As Rarity and Applejack came off of Spike's cocks, they panted and laid down next to Twilight in exhaustion from the best sex they've had in years. As they did, Spike said, "I'll be gentle with you if you want me to Fluttershy."

Fluttershy smiled, but stuttered, "Well... if it's not too much trouble, I'd like to wait until Rainbow and Pinkie have had their turn... I'm... still a virgin..."

Spike smiled and stood up to kiss her, "Agreed. Pinkie, I've heard rumors that you taste like cotton candy. Mind if I see if those rumors are true?"

Pinkie giggled and said, "Don't mind at all captain." before pulling Spike back onto the bed.

As Pinkie positioned herself over Spike's head, Rainbow Dash stroked his cocks and said, "Still hard as ever. I'm going to enjoy having these babies up my ass at the same time. I used to be a tight end on our high school football team. Looks like I'm going to become a wide receiver." before slipping both of Spike's cocks into her ass and moaning, "Oh fuck! They feel even bigger when they're both in!"

Spike started licking Pinkie's pussy and smiled, "Huh, I guess the rumors are true, it tastes just as sugary and sweet as strawberry cotton candy."

As he licked her pussy, Pinkie moaned in pleasure, "Jeepers! Twilight was right about dragon tongues, it's amazing! It feels so thick and rubs my clit so roughly! Keep going Spike!"

Spike chuckled, "Is a dragon's tongue really that much better than a pony's?"

Pinkie nodded quickly as she panted, "Yeah, so much better! Even Big Mac can't compare!"

Meanwhile, Rainbow Dash moaned deeper and louder as she found herself getting closer to orgasm, and said, "Hey Pinkie, are you getting close too?"

Pinkie nodded, "I don't think I can last much longer, Spike's the best lover I've ever had."

Spike smiled, "Well, you girls are great lovers too, don't sell yourselves short on that."

As the girls came, they screamed out, "I'm cumming!" before collapsing from exhaustion and pleasure.

Spike looked over to Fluttershy as he sat up, "Are you ready Flutters? You're last, but certainly not least. You've got a beautiful body, and I'd be honored to take your virginity."

Fluttershy walked over to him and smiled, "You're so sweet captain. Let me pleasure you first though. I want you to cum in my mouth before I lose my virginity." before kneeling down and starting to suck on both cocks as she squeezed them between her breasts.

Spike moaned, "Your mouth is so warm, and your tongue is so soft, it's like getting head from a pillow. And your breasts are so soft, you could easily use them as plush pillows. You may be new to this Fluttershy, but you're sure acting like a pro."

Fluttershy felt Spike's seed dripping out of his cocks and shoved both cocks all the way down her throat, causing him to cum and she gulped down every last drop. As she stood up, she asked, "You'll be gentle, right?"

Spike nodded as he drank another stamina potion, "Of course, I made a promise, and I'm a man of my word." before lifting her up and slowly positioning her onto only one cock.

As Fluttershy felt Spike's cock poke at her hymen, she moaned, and squealed out a bit as she felt him penetrate her, holding him close as he popped her cherry, "Oh Spike, this is heavenly! Thank you for being my first, and please, I want you as my only."

Spike kissed her passionately, and said, "You're welcome Fluttershy, and I'd be honored to be the lover to such a beautiful and gentle girl."

Fluttershy moaned as she kissed Spike back, biting his bottom lip as she pulled away. As she felt herself coming close to her orgasm, she grabbed onto Spike's second cock and gave him a quick paced handjob.

Spike moaned, "If you keep that up, I won't last much longer..."

Soon enough, Fluttershy said, "S-Spike... I'm cumming!" before pulling herself into Spike's arms as she made one final thrust, and both of Spike's cocks erupted in the largest orgasm of the night, covering Fluttershy in his seed from head to toe.

Spike collapsed, not even having enough energy to reach for another stamina potion, and soon passed out.

The next morning...

Spike awoke from his sleep to see the girls cuddling him and said, "Girls, that was the best night of my life. Thank you, all of you for that great night."

The girls all kissed Spike's cheek, Twilight saying, "You shouldn't sell yourself short captain, you gave us the best night of our lives too."

Pinkie nodded, "Yep! No pony back home could ever give me such a great lay!"

Rainbow Dash ruffled his hair, "I knew you were good in bed, but that was even better than our first time."

Rarity stroked Spike's chest with her finger, "Indeed, you were simply heavenly Spikey-wikey."

Applejack stretched out and smiled, "Oh yeah, big time. I haven't had such great sex since the time Rainbow Dash spiked the punch at the prom."

Fluttershy snuggled up to Spike, "And I'm so happy I was able to lose my virginity so you Spike, I wouldn't have wanted it any other way."

Spike smiled, "Thanks girls, you're all great." before getting up, "I think you girls might want to get back to your quarters before anyone else wakes up, for all they know, you went to bed later than them."

The girls nodded and got dressed before hurrying back to their quarters, while the rest of the crew were still sleeping. Twilight asked Pinkie, "You think he knows we drugged him?"

Rainbow Dash told them, "If he doesn't, we're in for a great night if he decides to 'punish us' when he finds out."

The girls giggled before getting into their beds and pretended to wake up with the rest of the crew.

Next Chapter: The Treasure Hunt (Part 1) Estimated time remaining: 2 Hours, 58 Minutes