Rarity smiled as Spike drank another stamina potion, before pulling him to sit up and kissing him, wrapping her legs around his back, "I won't lie Spike, I've always liked you more than just a little brother, but I never knew how things would go with your mother if I told her about my feelings."

Spike smiled back as he kissed Rarity, "So, now that my mother's not here, should we have some fun with those feelings?"

Rarity nodded, before positioning both of Spike's cocks near her pussy, "I want every inch of you inside of my pussy, I want you Spike." before kissing him again as she lowered herself down onto his cocks, fitting both of them into her soaking wet pussy.

Spike moaned as both his cocks penetrated the love of his life and smiled, "I hope you can keep up, because I never go slow." before standing up with Rarity still on his cocks, plunging into her harder and faster with every thrust. He looked to the rest of the girls and said, "You know, you can join in if you want to, I'm sure Rarity would appreciate some more teasing."

As he said this, Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash moved to lick and squeeze Rarity's breasts, while Applejack moved down to lick up her pussy juices as Spike pounded her. Meanwhile, Pinkie made out with Rarity.

Applejack suddenly pushed Spike and Rarity back onto the bed and jumped up, "Hope you don't mind Rarity, but it's just so hard to wait my turn." before pulling one of Spike's cocks out of Rarity's cunt and slipping it into her ass.

Rarity rolled her eyes, "That's so rude Applejack, but I'm having too much of a good time to complain." before moving herself to face Applejack, while keeping Spike's cock in her cunt.

Spike moaned as Rarity moved herself, "F-Fuck! I never knew twisting a cunt around my cock would feel so good!"

Rarity giggled lightly, "In that case." before grinding her pussy around on Spike's cock.

As she did this, Applejack slammed her ass against Spike's second cock harder and harder every time.

Spike moaned, partially from pain, "Applejack, I know you're trying to enjoy yourself, but you're going to end up breaking my pelvis if you're that rough."

Applejack slowed down as Spike said this, "Sorry 'bout that Cap'n." before pulling Rarity into a deep kiss.

As the two girls kissed, Spike motioned his tail into Rarity's ass, causing her to yelp, but moan shortly afterwards, "Oh Spikey-wikey, your tail feels so good up my ass!"

Applejack panted as she came close to her own orgasm, but said, "Hey Rarity, think you can outlast me? How about a little bet? Whoever goes the longest without cumming gets to have both of Spike's cocks and his tail."

Rarity was also panting, but managed to say, "You and I both know we can't last much longer, even if one of us wins, we won't have the strength to go another round. Besides, while I could just as easily drink one of Spike's stamina potions, you have that personal rule that you never use potions to help with things that require good old hard work."

Applejack sighed as she panted, "Good point, but can we at least try to cum together?"

Spike continued to moan, "Don't think that's far from happening."

Rarity giggled, "Well, you heard him Applejack, let's both make our delightful captain cum." before kissing Applejack as the two of them sped up their thrusts as they rode Spike's cocks.

"F-Fuck! I'm cumming!" Spike yelled out before unleashing his third load of the night. He fell down on the bed exhausted, "You girls are really wearing me out. And I'm loving it!"

Rainbow Dash pulled a stamina potion out of Spike's nightstand, "You're not done yet, me and Fluttershy are next, right Flutters?" looking to her long-time friend.

Fluttershy said, "Well... what about Pinkie? She doesn't deserve to be the last one to have a turn."

Pinkie hugged Fluttershy, "Thanks Fluttershy, that's really nice of you. But can you keep up with all three of us Spike?"

Spike chuckled, "We'll just have to test my stamina and find out, won't we?"

Next Chapter: One Long Night (Part 3: Pinkie, Fluttershy, and Rainbow) Estimated time remaining: 3 Hours, 2 Minutes