Login

Blind Chance - A Blind Date story

by Blind Writer

Chapter 2: Ch 2 - Penetration Preparation

Previous Chapter Next Chapter

Author's Notes:

Contains: unknowing incest, kissing, butt plug, brief deep throat, anal, anal creampie

So I decided to indulge a jump ahead with my schedule, just because. I won't change it up again though, so expect to have a day or two for anticipating the looming train wreck they're headed for in the middle of hot sex. Might even tease by having several days between. Yeah, I can be a mean tease like that, and it will be worth it. :trollestia:

Eh, a good period of buildup before getting to the big finish always makes it better anyway. Of course, with Ch 3 only being the halfway mark, there's plenty more of this to go... :trollestia:

At the sound of the lock turning into place, Twilight couldn’t help the giggle that escaped, nor the brief little dance she did at the chance to meet with her mystery stallion again. She recalled how their second meeting had been even better than the first, deciding not to change anything other than being able to talk and seeing where things went from there. She couldn’t even begin to put words to how much it thrilled her when he’d come out and said why he’d held so still for her the first time. It made her feel so special. Due to the custom sound control enchantment between their rooms, she had found herself frequently wondering what his real voice sounded like without magic changing it to keep them unidentified. With how things were progressing, she was unable to stop thinking about getting to find out in the hopefully near-ish future.

For now, they were meeting for an hour almost every couple of days whenever possible, and they both had the same time slot available. Today marked a full month since their first meeting. Expectations of what they wanted had grown once they started talking, and amazingly, her mystery stallion had happily relished a couple visits where all they did was kiss and talk. They were required to keep things vague about their lives, but she knew he was an officer now. He also came from a good upbringing right here in Canterlot, just like her. What drew her in most was his warm personality. I bet Shiny would approve of him, assuming things keep going so well and we end up giving up our masks. Then I can show him off to my BBBFF and the rest of my family. I think it’s still a little early, but I really think I’m falling for him.

Until today, she had actually been somewhat reluctant to change their planned activity, feeling like it might mess something up for a time when they were getting along so well. He had agreed to let her lead things at her pace, wanting her to be comfortable as a first priority. Due to Twilight’s inclination towards experimenting, he didn’t really have much to complain about anyway. She enjoyed the way he obeyed her every request to hold still or move a certain way as she tried new ways of stimulating him. It was their meeting just yesterday that she finally took his whole length in her throat and got him to cum directly into her stomach as she swallowed around him, her lips clamped around the his base as she felt him twitch with each spurt. And that was after she let him thrust slowly in her throat until he said he was close. With a touch of her hoof, she’d climaxed pretty hard to that feeling.

The memory of his warmth filling her belly made it a little hard to sleep last night, once she’d finished her planned reading amount for the night. Once again, she was really glad she had gotten the dildo two days prior to practice having something inside herself. She hadn’t been able to sleep until getting off to fantasizing about him making love to her. The idea was occupying her mind more with each meeting, but it wasn’t her plan for today.

No, she had an opportunity to make her first time with a stallion perfect, and she wasn’t going to rush that moment for anything. A full checklist of things she wanted to be done or in place first was already half complete, including the dildo to ensure she would feel nothing but pleasure from him thrusting inside her as much as he wanted until he burst. Hopefully, he could get the time off from his duties for what she was planning soon.

Panting in anticipation ever so slightly, Twilight licked her lips at the plan for today. A precursor of sorts that she’d also been preparing herself for. The faint sound of another drop of her own arousal hitting the floor was a quiet indication of how excited she was to meet with him today.

***

Shining Armor closed and locked the door behind himself before finally giving into his anticipation, his cock unsheathing beneath him. Guard training really did provide him some unexpected benefits at times. While there were some environments where it was of no consequence, like simple guard duty in most places. Unfortunately, most of the time that was only for enlisted stallions, and not him.

As an officer, and likely candidate as the next Captain of the Guard in the next year or two, he spent most of his time in places where an unwanted erection was anywhere from a bit rude to extremely insulting and inappropriate. Preventing one when surrounded by dignitaries and officials of all kinds could be a very important skill some days. Of course, it didn’t hurt that it also improved his staying power and recovery time in the process. The Royal Guard had a quietly famous reputation in the bedroom for a reason, after all.

Finally getting to relax the muscles he’d been giving a lot of exercise recently even released some tension in his back, unable to stop the smile at seeing the white light already lit up once he’d closed and locked his door. His mystery mare was usually waiting for him whenever they were able to meet. Another reason he was glad he was an officer was more flexibility outside of normal duty hours, but he couldn’t arrive early like she always seemed to.

He had learned she was a university-level magic student at one of the three schools in Canterlot, and that she had a pretty big reading habit. She had the cutest laughs and pleasure-induced squeals he felt he had ever heard, too. During their conversations, a couple times not even getting into oral at all for the whole visit, he had come to find she had a brilliant mind and was very sweet.

It still amazes me how I feel so much steadier because of her. I’ve been very careful about it so I don’t rush anything, but I’ve even felt confident enough to flirt back a little with Cadence. I can’t forget the look on her face the first time I shot back an easy quip when she gave me an opening, and then just walked away with a confident smirk on my face. She’s been a lot more playful ever since, although she’s been giving me a strange nervous look from time to time as well. If she can sense love in other ponies, could that be it? Could I really be slowly falling for my mystery mare when I don’t even know her face yet? Am I getting ready to tell her who I am? She seems really smart, but would Twiley like her?

Slipping his mask on, Shining shifted around on his hooves in anticipation. His mystery mare had promised a surprise change for today, but hadn’t said what. With both of them having indicated sufficient mutual trust for them to skip planning what they would do when they met, he was curious as heck to know what she wanted to do this time. Maybe she finally wanted to try actual sex for the first time.

For a moment, he frowned to himself that she might be wanting to stick something in his plot, but he dismissed the notion immediately. By this point, he felt they understood each other well enough not to make any particularly off the mark assumptions about what the other would be interested in trying.

His smile returning, he remembered one session where he got to experiment with his mouth and tongue on her, finding various ways to make her react. She had felt guilty for him not getting a turn, but a weary tongue and his thirst quenched by several of her orgasms was enough for him that day. Considering their next meeting after that was her deep throating him completely until he came straight into her stomach from her gulping down his length like she hadn’t had a drink in days more than made up for it.

Hearing the hole between their sides of the meeting room slide open, Shining carefully moved to the opening with a giddiness that had kept growing since the first meeting. The sound of her breathing and familiarity with each other led him right to her lips, their tongues wasting no time as they went all out for several seconds before pulling back to nuzzle a little and talk.

“Mmm… Still a tasty mare like always, sexy,” he said in a low voice. “How do I sound today?”

***

Twilight shivered as she nuzzled her mysterious stallion, licking the side of his mouth before she spoke. “Flatterer. Sounds like you’re a tenor this time, mister mystery. How about me?”

The sound of his warm chuckle gave her another quiver. “You sound like a one of those stereotypically deep-voiced mares from Stalliongrad. I bet you could do some really husky dirty talk with that.”

Humming to herself for a moment, she grinned in the darkness of their blindness, purposely dropping her voice a little. “Are you telling me you want to hear me talk about how I’m going to drag my tongue all over your penis until I get it all wet, then let it slowly slide into my throat until you can’t help but send cum straight into my needy body? To feel me swallowing you whole, knowing your mare thinks you taste delicious and needs another taste?”

She heard him let out a faint hiss before capturing her lips hungrily, simply enjoying the kiss for a bit before pulling back again, speaking in a somewhat pouty sing-song voice. “Too bad for you that I’m not letting you cum in my mouth today~.”

He laughed. “You’ve gotten so much better at dirty talk, sexy. Whatever do you plan to do with me today then?”

Pressing her nose against his, Twilight bit her bottom lip as she gathered up her courage for the step she was about to take, her voice a lot more nervous as she near whispered her intentions. “I-I want you… I want t-to…”

She almost melted when his lips pressed against hers for a tender kiss, her rising nerves snuffed out by his reminder he would never press her for more than she was ready for. A couple times, she’d gotten caught up in her nerves when she made a mistake trying to practice giving him a blowjob. Once, he even admitted a mistake really had hurt, but not once did he get upset with her. When they both had their faces at the hole, he’d taken up a habit of giving her a very gentle kiss when she started getting worked up. Every time, it calmed her.

“Hey now, no need for that. We’re at your pace.” He said in a soothing tone. She imagined him wearing a warm smile as his loving eyes stared into hers.

“I… My plot… I-I want to feel you in my plot today.” She got it out and the rest just rolled free from there. “I’ve been practicing with toys. Trying to get myself prepared so I could try it with you comfortably. I even made sure to clear everything out just before I came to see you. I-I need to feel you in me but I’m not ready to give you my real virginity yet. Please say you’ll be gentle and stay still for me again?”

Twilight panted in part from nerves, but also from the anticipation. She felt his breath on her muzzle, noticing his own breathing had sped up and it gave her a tremulous smile, even if he couldn’t see it. When she felt his lips press against hers with a hunger beneath the tenderness, she felt her excitement rise.

After he pulled back, he hummed to himself. “Let’s see… The sexy mare that’s been giving me amazing blowjobs and helping me learn how best to lick her to orgasm wants to try letting me slip inside her plot after taking time to prepare herself. And all I have to do is keep being gentle and let her control the pace? Is there a downside here? I’m not seeing one.”

She nipped at her mystery stallion’s nose before nuzzling against his warm face, unable to stop a bashful giggle from escaping. He had a fun sense of humor and always made it easy to relax around him.

Drawing back, she stopped holding back as her marehood quivered, her voice turning husky. “Produce that cock, stallion. I need to get you ready.”

Getting to her hooves, Twilight dipped her head around the side as he slipped his shaft through the hole for her. Like every previous time, she rubbed her face all over it before anything else, relishing the warmth even as she reached out with her magic in the dark and started getting herself ready for him as she removed the plug she didn’t tell him about. After they were done, she wasn’t letting any of his seed escape until she went to bed. A hefty squirt of lube she sent into her plot would have time to warm before she turned around to finally feel him in a variation of the penetration she was craving more every day.

As she worked on herself, her lips found his tip and wasted no time in letting him enter her mouth. Her tongue traveled all over the head, savoring his taste, before slowly sliding him in further. A deep breath first, she smoothly pushed herself forward so he slid down her throat, stopping once she reached his medial ring and gulping around him. The sound of his groaning voice above her only spurred her on, tempting her to make him feed her as fast as possible.

Instead, she drew back and let him escape her lips with a sucking pop. She then turned herself around on shaky hooves, the wet feeling of her properly prepared plot was one more sensation mixed into her anticipation. She flipped her tail out of the way, then stopped when she felt his tip press against her slippery back door. Proceeding to shift her body around in a teasing manner, Twilight pushed back until it felt like he was just about to slip inside her plot, then pulled away until she was barely touching, then finally pressing herself back until it felt like he was about to spread her open and go inside her.

Swallowing down her nervous energy over what she was about to do, she needed to hear his voice first and called out to him, knowing he could hear her easily through the thin metal wall between them. “Are you ready for me, my mysterious stallion?”

She heard him gasp as she teased him, his voice sounding strained. “You are such a tease. I’m more than ready.”

Licking her lips, Twilight began to slowly press her well lubed plot back against her mystery stallion’s cock, feeling the pressure climb and her ring spread wider until his flared tip overcame the resistance and slipped inside with a silent pop. The foreign warmth of him actually inside her made her let out a shuddery gasp as she squeezed her plot against the intruder for a moment. It was a strange feeling, being able to feel his twitching head inside of her that way, but her preparation with plugs seemed to have paid off. It felt different, but good enough to enjoy the sensation.

Hearing him groan like that because she made him feel good only made it better.

Biting her bottom lip, Twilight pressed herself back a little more, letting the stiff shaft now inside her sink a little further until the lube seemed to grow thin. Pulling herself forward, she let him slip out until she reached his flare again, keeping it firmly lodged in her plot. The lube she had squirted inside herself made her next push back sink a good deal more of him into her before starting to process again. Forward to let the lube spread again, then back to take a bit more.

Twilight gasped as his medial ring slipped into her body, unwilling to pull away as far now, needing more of him and feeling such a unique fullness. She was almost disappointed when she felt her flanks finally pressed against the wall, taking as much of his warm cock inside of her plot as possible through the hole in the wall. Her calculation on lube ratio seemed a bit high, but she had erred on the side of caution.

The extra only made him slip through her ring that much easier at least, and she pulled away to his medial ring, then slid herself back again, biting her bottom lip with a whimper. I need to feel him finish in me. My books said some mares had little feeling, and some had a lot during anal. I can’t believe I feel so much like this. I need to ask him my question about a joint room after this. How good would it feel if he could completely hilt inside me?

***

Shining gasped when he felt his mystery mare stop moving after bumping the wall a couple of times, his cock buried in her plot as far as she could get him. He could hardly believe how hot and tight it felt inside her. Before he could dwell much on it though, he heard her voice call up to him.

“Nnf, please. Please rut my plot my mystery stallion. I need to feel you claim me.”

He felt his cock twitch as he breathed a little harder. Part of him wanted to just start pounding, but staying at her pace was what he knew she wanted. Getting to his peak with slow thrusts would take longer, but it also tended to provide a stronger climax. Besides, there was always the possibility she’d ask him to go faster as she got used to it.

His previously stationary flanks began to pull back from the hole and her plot, drawing back until he felt his flare reach the inside of her back door, then slowly thrust his full length back inside. The lube she had used made it quite easy for him to move.

It wasn’t long before he heard her ask him to speed up and he readily thrust a little faster into her plot. Part of him wished he was directly on her back, holding her close with his forelegs. The wall prevented him from burying himself quite to the hilt inside his mysterious mare. Maybe she’d like to start meeting in joint rooms after this. Even if she just wanted to be held at first.

The inside of her plot was causing Shining to quiver a bit, still tempted to do what his instincts were telling him and pound her until he shot his cum right into her body. Instead, he took his pacing cues from her and the two of them soon fell into a rhythm together. After thrusting into her for a bit, she’d beg him to go a little faster, her whines and moans rising each time.

Soon, she seemed to struggle at forming words as she let him ravish her as fast as he wanted, letting out occasional utterances for more. Breaking the pattern of his thrusts from time to time in order to make his medial ring slip rapidly in and out of her plot would draw out one of her cute squeals.

There was one transition of going from ring thrusts back to deep when Shining felt himself nearing his end and she started moaning she was close. He told himself he’d make sure she started before he did, knowing his flare was starting to expand deep inside her as he held on, each thrust not letting his medial ring slip free so he could stay well inside her clenching plot.

“Nnnf, yes! Fill me! Cum inside my plot!” His mysterious mare cried out to him.

A deep groan escaped him as he tried to thrust faster, feeling her squeezing down on him as her body tensed up, knowing she was going to cum with him buried deep inside. The clenching, raw heat under her tail as he moved was eroding his ability to resist.

Even with his staying power, the dam had to break at some point and he finally rammed himself against the wall separating them and as far inside of her as he could just as his flare swelled to it’s widest. A snarl escaped him, gritting his teeth as the first rope of his cum sprayed deep into her bowels, causing her to squeal a moment later and her plot to clamp down on his cock as it appeared she came from his release shooting deep into her quivering form.

His cock sent several ropes of seed into her body, hearing and feeling her gasp and squeal and clench with every burst that hit the inner walls of her plot. By the time his orgasm had finished, he found himself slumped against the pad on his side of the wall, trying to catch his breath. He could feel her body trembling, the rhythmic clenches of her plot making his extra sensitive shaft twitch as the two of them tried to recover.

When enough strength returned to his legs after a minute or so, Shining slowly lifted himself back up, his still half erect shaft remained buried in his mystery mare’s plot. She let out a lazy moan as he shifted and slowly pulled himself free, slumping down on his haunches beside the hole in the wall between them. He could only lean against the wall for support as he heard her shuffling around.

The moment he knew she was there, he captured her lips with his own. It was a kiss born of deep satisfaction and she made a soft simper as she pressed into it, their tongues dancing together in an almost lethargic way. Heh, our first real post-coital kiss. No leftover mess to taste. No need for words. Just us and our afterglow. It feels… Good…

***

Twilight relished their kiss more than usual until they separated again. She knew she was smiling at him, knowing he wouldn’t be able to see it but needing to show him one anyway. It was one of those smiles that you just couldn’t help. Moving her head forward a little, she nuzzled the side of his muzzle before just going still and sitting with him like that.

Her plot felt a little sore, now that the intensity had faded. She felt it was a special sort of earned pleasant feeling of soreness though, the plug already back in place so she could keep all of his essence inside her until she went to bed. Possibly even all the way until morning. The warm feeling of it shooting into her had caught her right as her hoof on her clit had her on the brink and the feeling had sent her crashing over the line.

There was no question now about her upcoming plan. Her mystery stallion had given her every reason and she knew the perfect time was coming soon. Oh gosh, I hope he says yes…

“C-can I ask you something important, my mystery stallion?” Twilight started, part of her glad he couldn’t see her suddenly nervous look.

Even though his exact voice changed every time they met, she was familiar enough with his Guard-typical style of speech to hear more of him in his voice when he spoke, noting his tone was attentive, if still a bit playful. “My oh so sexy mystery mare, you can ask me anything you want. If you have something to say, I’m listening with open ears.”

Twilight bit her bottom lip again, took a breath, then told him her plan. “I… I want to get a joint room with you. Not just so I can feel your forelegs wrapped around me, but so there’s nothing between us. Y-you know I’ve never had sex before, and I-I’m g-going into estrus in two weeks. W-will you help make my first time absolutely perfect? T-to make love to me, and kiss me, and release your semen inside me while letting me look into the face of the stallion I love without the mask as you become one with me?”

She gasped and put her hooves over her mouth when she realized the word that slipped out. Remembering some of the psychology of love, she worried she might be getting carried away on a bunch of unsubstantiated hormones, pheromones and built up fantasies. It wasn’t that she had an actual reason for concern that she could see anywhere so far, but she struggled to believe he could be so perfect a gentlestallion all the time. Maybe it was like becoming Princess Celestia’s student, and her luck was just that good a second time.

Yet with the word slipping out, Twilight knew she was lost anyway and there was no turning back. She couldn’t bear the idea he could be too good to be true, but neither could she stand not looking into his eyes anymore. She needed him to hold her.

Much to her relief, she heard his relaxed tone convey no hesitation. “You really want to… Yes. I want to see you too. You only get one first time, so I’ll do whatever you need me to do in order to make it the best it can be. I…” He paused as if something came to mind, then he gave a warm chuckle. “I’ll even save a certain three words to say at that final moment too. Just to make it even better. So don’t worry about me not saying it back just yet...because I do too.”

A soft laugh that was more like a whimper escaped her throat as she pressed herself into his lips, happy tears threatening to escape as she kissed him. She felt like she was floating now, basking in the feel of his acceptance of her request and his own admission.

Twilight couldn’t stop smiling after their time ended and they had to depart. He said it shouldn’t be a problem to get a full day off. They would reserve a Reveal Room together for a few hours, just so they could take all the time they wanted for buildup, then make their way back to whomever’s home was closest once they finished their first time together, and then spend the rest of the day and much of the night making love until they couldn’t walk straight. From there they could stop meeting in secret and just enjoy being in love, doing all the simple everyday things that couples do together.

I can’t believe how well this has worked out. Princess Celestia always nudges me to be more social. What will she think when I bring my coltfriend with me? Oh gosh, I hope my mystery stallion doesn’t freak out when I take him to meet her… Hehe, and that she doesn’t tease him endlessly. It really feels like nothing could ever go wrong with him…

Next Chapter: Ch 3 - Perfect First Timing Estimated time remaining: 3 Hours, 20 Minutes
Return to Story Description
Blind Chance - A Blind Date story

Mature Rated Fiction

This story has been marked as having adult content. Please click below to confirm you are of legal age to view adult material in your area.

Confirm
Back to Safety

Login

Facebook
Login with
Facebook:
FiMFetch