After much fun having, the party eventually wound down as the mares and man took stock of themselves as they lay out on Luna’s bed. Silver was sitting in Moonlight’s lap, giggling in a drunken stupor as her rear was hot dogged by the unicorn’s lingering phallus. Thomas, finally free of his scout uniform, hummed in contentment as he sat in Surprise’s lap while she hugged him from behind and rested her chin over his head. This left Honey and Luna sitting side by side as they leaned on one another, enjoying the pressure and warmth of the other’s body.

Surprise gave a mighty, room shaking belch and tapped her fist to her sternum. “Oops. My bad.”

“Gross,” Thomas laughed as the mare shifted around him, savoring the feel of her soft breasts against his back.

“Ah don’t mean ta break the mood ‘n’ sound ungrateful,” Honey began.

“But?” Luna asked.

“But ain’t this our induction party?” Honey inquired. “Shouldn’t we be buckin’?”

Luna chuckled good-naturedly and wrapped an arm around the earth mare’s shoulder, pulling her close. “Anxious, are we?”

Honey shivered as her ear was nuzzled. “Ya gotta ask?”

“Ooh!” Surprise chirped. “How about we pair off and rotate?”

“Ngh, I like that,” Silver moaned as she began rotating her hips in Moonlight’s lap. She shot the larger mare a half lidded smirk over her shoulder, which was returned with a purr.

“Hold!” Luna proclaimed with an outstretched hand. “Before we begin, I propose we make things interesting.”

“An alicorn, a mare from each tribe, and a naked alien aren’t interesting enough for you?” Thomas deadpanned.

Luna smirked and lit her horn. At the foot of the bed appeared a choice wheel with a dial and more than a hundred sticks indicating their options. Above the wheel a title blared to life on bright, neon lights. “The Wheel of Kamasutra,” the alicorn read. “Spin the wheel and attempt the position depicted.”

“I stand corrected,” Thomas conceded flatly. He then looked over at the others after feeling the silence had gone on for a little too long. “So who’s first?”

“I volunteer,” Silver announced and hopped from Moonlight’s lap. She frowned at the loss of warmth against her back and backside, but decided to hurry to the wheel so she could get back all the quicker.

“But first,” Luna announced and snapped her fingers.

Thomas shook his head as the lingering buzz from the alcohol all but evaporated from his head. He looked around and confirmed, by the looks on the others’ faces, that Luna’s spell had sobered them up, too. Probably for the best.

Once she’d adjusted to her new sobriety, Silver gave the wheel a spin and the dial made its selection. “The Bridge?” Silver asked as she read.

In answer, a screen manifested directly beside the wheel. It blinked on and depicted a still image of a generic looking mare and stallion. The two nodded in greeting and proceeded to assume the position.

“Oh wow,” Silver awed.

“Glad that’s not me,” Thomas admitted. “I’m not that flexible or strong.”

“Ah think Plow might like ta try that,” Honey offered.

“Oh boy,” Moonlight breathed anxiously as she studied the image. “I-I’ve never done it like a stallion, before, let alone like that.”

“Do you need a moment to…” Silver trailed off as she searched for the right words.

“No, no. It’s fine,” Moonlight assured as she slid along the bed until she was positioned between the wheel and the audience. Lying flat on her back, the unicorn braced her hands behind her shoulders and propped her middle up, forming a vague arc with her spine. Her stallionhood, still agitated from Silver’s touch, stood high and proud overhead, twitching in anticipation of what was to come.

Silver laughed giddily as she fluttered her wings and hovered a few feet above the bed. She then gently alighted down onto Moonlight’s waist, pressing the mare’s cock against her belly. Her legs hung down to either side of the unicorn, too high up to touch the ground. “Oh my,” she said with a shudder as she looked down at Moonlight’s heaving breasts. “This is certainly… new.”

“T-tell me about it,” Moonlight giggled nervously as she experimentally flexed her penis.

“I’m not too heavy, am I?” Silver asked in concern.

“Not at all,” Moonlight declared proudly. “Though I think you’re the only mare I could have done this with.”

“Naturally,” Luna stated. “The selections are random, but are enchanted to make sure those participating are actually capable of carrying out the act. Though I must admit I had not expected our game to begin with something so advanced.”

“Oh well,” Moonlight said with a shrug. “Shall we start?”

“We shall.”

Bending down until she was belly-to-belly with Moonlight, Silver slid forward a short distance, using her wings for balance. Then, feeling the tip of Moonlight’s stallionhood prod at her entrance, the little bat pushed back. Both mares moaned in delight as their sexes became intertwined. Moonlight was taking this the hardest, dealing with not only supporting herself in the odd position, but also to all the strange new sensations of her stallion appendage.

As such, Silver made sure to move carefully, sliding back slowly and giving the orange mare time to adjust. She smiled happily as she moved, savoring the control she exerted over the mare beneath her. Once fully hilted, Silver gave her wings another flap and pulled herself up. When she did, she noticed a certain something beneath her hooves. Surprised, she gazed down from her seat to find a clump of sheets elevated upwards, encased in Luna’s magic.

“Thank you,” Moonlight offered, having also noticed the elevated sheets.

“It was my, ngh, pleasure,” Luna replied. Her and Honey’s fingers had disappeared between the other’s thighs. At the same time, Surprise was carefully studying the intricate texture of Thomas’ testicles, all while keeping his dong untouched.

With her newfound leverage, Silver lifted herself up a few short inches before slowly descending back down. “Goodness!”

Moonlight had given up on thrusting after a single, admittedly pitiful, attempt, so she decided to let Silver set the pace, which was just fine with her. The bat mare was being much more tender than usual, mindful not to jostle the unicorn too much as she moved. All of this allowed Moonlight to focus entirely on the sensations running through her stallionhood.

“H-how is it?” Silver managed to ask as she gently bounced herself along the shaft.

Moonlight panted heavily. “I can barely think straight. It’s like this, ugh, amazing tingling all along the, oh Faust! Your marehood feels wonderful,” she moaned. “So warm and tight. I love it!”

“What else?” Luna asked insistently as her fingering of Honey became more intense.

“I’m still winking,” Moonlight said as she felt Silver’s own marehood wink around her dick. “M-my body… it wants a penis, but it also wants Silver’s marehood.” She panted with a flushed face.

“You’re big,” panted Silver. She had placed one hand to her abdomen to add a little extra pressure as she bounced with her hooves. “I can feel your heart beat. It’s beating so strongly.” She gave a long, whining moan as she quickened her pace. “It’s pulsing. I feel you twitching inside me.”

“More!” Luna demanded. “We want to cum together. We want to feel thy climax from our passionate acts of love!” She and Honey were now working their fingers to near numbness, sinking deep into the other’s wetness while remembering to pay attention to one another’s clits. At the same time, Thomas was coaxing moans out of Surprise while the white mare showed a remarkable level of restraint by only juggling his balls.

“It’s different,” answered Silver breathlessly. She was getting a real kick out of this feeling of being in control, deciding when and with what intensity her marehood would be filled, all while the ‘stallion’ was entirely at her mercy. “Her penis is… I’m not sure.” She’d begun rotating her hips while the hand that wasn’t massaging Moonlight’s breast had migrated down to her little bat clit. “It’s not as big as yours,” she said to Luna, “and it doesn’t have that unique shape that gives me that special tingle,” she added, shooting a look at Thomas. “I… I don’t know if I can even describe it,” she confessed while rocking her hips back and forward. “She’s twitching inside me. I’m so close!”

“Try to describe it anyway,” Luna urged. “Tell me what’s going through your mind!”

“Moonlight!” Silver answered quickly. “I feel her. Nnngh! I feel her inside of me.” As she finally made sense of the vague sensations being transmitted into her head, trying her best to find some way to communicate what was asked of her, she laughed at the absurdity of what she was about to say. “I see her doing push ups,” she chuckled. “Many of her muscles are rippling with each movement. And her abs…” she trailed off as her tongue extended forth and was limply suspended from her mouth.

“I… I’m cumming!” Moonlight announced.

Silver brought her body back down to Moonlights, wrapping her arms around the unicorn’s back and holding on for dear life. Moonlight’s balls quivered beneath the bat mare’s ass and fired her load. Silver’s entire body shudders as she feels the liquid warmth fill her up. At the same time, Moonlight’s limbs gave way as the alien climax overwhelmed her. Thankfully, a tingle of familiar magic spreads beneath her back and slowly levitates her back down to the bed. Silver and Moonlight clung to one another in a desperate cuddle, smiling in the afterglow as they rub cheeks. Their genitals remained interlocked and Moonlight fires a few additional salvos into Silver’s waiting warmth.

“Damn, that’s hot,” Thomas muttered. Watching the mare who was basically his wife give a good dicking to another mare he cared for had been amazing. However the sheer size of the tool had left him feeling a little inadequate. It was hard not to compare. Below average for ponies would always be bigger than him, and Moonlight was definitely above average. At the same time, the feeling of emasculation only added to his already peaking arousal.

“And the round continues,” Luna proclaimed joyously as she set a hand on Honey’s back and pushed her up. “Onwards, my juicy apple. Let us not let ourselves be outmatched!”

Honey, her competitive side switched on, gave an affirming nod. She walked up to the wheel with a considerable sway in her step, loving the idea of so many of those whom she was coming to care for watching her backside with lust. She spun it and read the selection. “Crouching Tiger?”

As before, the screen lit up and the same generic ponies from before bowed and demonstrated.

“Now that looks fun,” the apple mare giggled.

“Verily,” Luna proclaimed as she all too excitedly scooted down to the side of the bed, past the still recovering Moonlight and Silver, and slid even further until her legs fell off the bed at the knee. The Princess made herself comfortable, breathing deeply of the smell of fresh sex, and patted her thighs for Honey to take her seat as she laid down on her back. It was still important for the audience to have a clear view.

“Whoo whee!” Honey cheered as she hurried over to Luna, her breasts bouncing exuberantly, only for the Princess to hold up her hand in halting. “What?”

Luna pointed back at the screen.

“Oh…” Embarrassed from her over exuberance, Honey turned her back on her alicorn, gave her ass a modest twerk, lifted her hoof across to her Princess’ opposite hip, and squatted down low. “Uh, Luna?”

“Yes, my juicy little apple,” Luna cooed, licking her lips as she eyed Honey’s delectable backside. She couldn’t help but reach out and grab those succulent cheeks, squeezing and exploring their lightly fuzzy texture. Next she pulled them apart, wanting a clear view of the earth mare’s quivering pucker and winking, dripping marehood.

“Ain’t you, uh forgettin’ somethin’?” Honey asked between squeaks.

“Am I now?” Gripping Honey’s bottom more tightly, Luna adjusted the mare’s position further down, forcing her to adjust her hoofing to keep up. “What might I be forgetting?” she asked as she slid a thumb over Honey’s winking sex.

Honey had no words, but she did offer a beastlike growl of lust.

“Oh, did you mean this?” Luna’s stallionhood erupted upward, narrowly missing Honey’s sex as it climbed to its maximum size of roughly eighteen inches long and three inches in diameter.

After a brief period of stunned silence, a grin quickly grew across Honey’s face as she turned around and gazed down at her new plaything. “Aw yeah. Now we’re talkin’!”

Thomas tensed in Surprise’s grip, and not just because the mare was nibbling at his neck. While the male anatomy of the common pony wasn’t nearly the big deal that it used to be, especially since most guys walked around with it tucked away in their sheaths, the lingering compulsion to compare himself still left Thomas feeling strange. It was only made worse when he saw the towering spire between Luna’s legs. Even so, he could not tear his eyes away from the sight of such large, beautiful women about to fornicate as much for his enjoyment as their own.

“Alright, sugar,” Honey cooed as she squatted down between Luna’s legs, grabbed onto the spire, and gave it a tentative lick. “Mmh, nice.” She then parted her lips and sank her maw down, consuming a good fourth of the spire on her first go.

Luna flung her head back as her hips jerked upwards, driving more of her length into Honey’s throat. Pony bodies were flexible enough to handle a lot, but Luna knew only a mare of exceptional size could handle her girth when she grew her phallus out like this, at least not without magical aid. Honey’s throat undulated as she swallowed more and more of Luna’s meat, sinking down to the medial ring and causing the alicorn’s hips to jerk. The earth mare grinned around her mouthful and sank even lower, feeling the burning piece of meat curve back to slide down her esophagus.

“Herna heen hor hrrrmy,” Honey said through her mouthful. Growing up, the proud earth mare had never imagined she’d ever be able to taste a Princess’ penis. Now that she had, it was hard not to compare to her own stallion’s member. Luna was bigger than Plow by a solid several inches. It stretched her throat in ways she’d never expected, no doubt foreshadowing its other abilities in the moments to come. The texture was a lot smoother and the musk wasn’t nearly as masculine as she’d hoped. Yet there was no trace of disappointment in the apple farmer’s heart as she listened to the sweet melody of sounds her lavish affections were bringing from Luna’s mouth.

“What was that?”

Slowly Honey lifted herself up, sliding the cock out of her slick maw with a wet slurping sound. When it was free, the cock bobbed back and forth like a bobble toy, but one that shined with a fresh polish. “Ah said Ah think you’re ready.”

Still squatting, Honey turned around and lifted herself a considerable height to rest above the flat end of Luna’s dick. She unconsciously licked her lips in memory of the taste as her eyes zeroed in on the bead of pre that was forming. Honey lined herself up with the flat head and, bracing one hand on her knee and using the other to pull one ass cheek back, slowly lowered herself down. Both mares tensed from the contact, but Honey recovered quickly enough to resume her descent as Luna once more grabbed her rear.

The feeling of fullness was something all mares knew came to know and appreciate. To envelope, to be penetrated by a long, thick, and burning piece of stallion meat was a sensation without compare. Coolers did a serviceable job, but every mare knew that the real thing was leagues better, no matter the size. Being a large earth mare, Honey was accustomed to the much larger penis sizes which were typical of the stallions of her tribe. Yet no stallion, not even Big Plow, compared to the absolute monster burying itself within her depths and threatening to rip her apart. She was still in the process of sinking down when she felt the tip of Luna’s cock kiss the entrance to her womb, followed seconds later by the medial ring passing over her clit, sending shivers through the earth mare.

Honey’s mind screamed out in awe and ecstasy when she realized that Luna’s monster, despite its size, had almost fully hilted itself within her in one fell swoop. She had, after weeks of training and unorthodox courtship, become one with the Princess of the Night.

Luna was roughly digging her fingers into Honey’s plot, savoring the sounds the mare made just as much as the textures of her inner walls. The feel of her medial ring brushing Honey’s clit caused her to involuntarily thrust upward, sinking another several inches into Honey’s depths.

“So smooth,” Luna purred as she massaged Honey’s plot. “Thou art tight, but mine stallionhood enters so smoothly. Might thou be accustomed to phalluses of such size?”

“O yeah!” Even with her back turned to the Princess, the smile in her voice was more than apparent. “My stallion’s big, like real big, but he ain’t got nothin’ on you, Moonbutt.”

Luna growled as she yanked Honey down several more inches, penetrating past the mare’s womb as startling a joyous squeak from her lips. “Is that so?”

“Yeah,” Honey panted. “He’s gonna flip when Ah tell ‘im.”

She’s not worried about him feeling insecure or jealous, Thomas managed to note, even as he was thrusting into Surprise’s hand. It was reassuring to see everyone acting so casual about all this. Even now, he still took comfort at these signs of normalcy, which helped to ease his lingering uncertainties.

Luna made a growling moan as she sank the final few inches into Honey’s depths, only to let out a contented sigh at the feel of finally being fully hilted. “We leave the reigns to you.”

Nodding rapidly, Honey channeled all power into her legs. It was an uphill battle trying to pull her incredibly tight and clingy snatch off of Luna’s wondrous length. But with a snarl of defiance, the earth mare managed to pull it off, or out as the case may be. The feel of Luna’s stallionhood sliding all along her vaginal cavity was almost as good as when it had first entered, sending continuous jolts of pleasure throughout her body. She had just slid the medial ring out of her when her body’s craving proved too much and she slammed her plot back down.

“Oh Faust, this is awesome,” Surprise whimpered in want as she watched, her body shaking from the excitement of watching an alicorn, her alicorn, bucking such a sexy mare. The feel of Thomas’ smooth skin against her belly and breasts was like icing on a cake she couldn’t wait to taste.

Silver and Moonlight had also recovered enough to watch the show. Although they said nothing, they continued to hold onto one another as Silver would occasionally rotate her hips around Moonlight’s still embedded phallus.

After a few more test rounds, Honey found her rhythm as she repeatedly lifted herself up and slammed back down. Her movements quickly grew more and more rapid, losing all traces of refinement or patience as she fell into wild bucking. Luna only encouraged this by yanking on Honey’s tail with one hand and sinking the other’s middle and trigger finger into Honey’s tight anus.

“Oh yeah, bucker!” Honey cried. “Give it to me!”

“As thou wish,” Luna growled threateningly as she began finger fucking the mare’s ass with just as much reckless abandon.

Both mares let out a tremendous cry of ecstasy as they came, spraying their juices over one another’s thighs as the remaining mares and man had to cover their ears. Unseen was the sheer intensity of the load firing directly into Honey’s womb, filling her belly with a warmth that quickly spread throughout her entire body.

Honey craned her neck back to meet the alicorn’s eyes. Both mares wore flushed looks on their faces, along with smiles that looked like they might never fade. The earth mare lightly twisted her hips in Luna’s lap, finding the alicorn still hard. “Ready for round two?” she asked with a girlish giggle.

“Momentarily,” Luna purred throatily as she lifted herself up. Pressing her chest into Honey’s back, she wrapped her arms around the earth mare’s middle and gently nibbled at her ear. “We must wait our turn.” She gestured with her eyes at the others. Silver and Moonlight had retaken their earlier position against the pillows as they contentedly cuddled and nuzzled. By contrast, Surprise looked about ready to bounce out of her fur as she anxiously eyed the alicorn. Thomas’ chest was rising and falling with his heavy breaths as he humped into Surprise’s hand. Keeping herself wedged firmly within Honey, Luna managed to shuffle her way back to the head of the bed before nodding at the white mare.

The pegasus sprung forth for the wheel, wrapping an arm around Thomas’ middle and carrying him with her the entire time.

“Someone’s excited,” he commented dryly as his head was wedged into the bottom of the mare’s breasts, obscuring his vision. However, Surprise gave no sign she’d heard him as she gave the wheel a spin.

“The Rowing Boat? Oooooh!” Surprise cooed as she held Thomas out from her, spinning him around to face her and gave his body a hungered look. “Ready, little colt?” It still felt amazingly kinky and deliciously taboo to imagine Thomas as a colt.

Grinning back at her as he glanced briefly back at the screen, Thomas nodded. “Bring it, marshmallow!”

Surprise gently laid Thomas down on the bed, belly up, just like the stallion on the screen had done. She angled him horizontally across the bed before checking with her audience. “Everypony see, alright?” They all confirmed and she nodded excitedly. After all, everypony else had been considerate of the audience’s needs.

Sitting down on her knees, she shuffled her way over the human’s pelvis, humming excitedly as their genitals brushed against one another. She took a moment to savor the look on his face as she cast a shadow over him. It was that same nervous anticipation he always got whenever a mare was about to dominate him, sexually or otherwise. It made Surprise’s heart flutter to know that, this time, that mare would be her. She placed her hand down over his chest and took stock of his pulse. Surprise then spread her wings out experimentally and gave a short laugh when she felt his heart rate quicken. “You like big mares, don’t you little colt,” she teased as she rocked her hips back and forth, teasing the tip of his cock with the edges of her lips.

Thomas could only smile and nod as he stared up past Surprise’s massive breasts and into her lascivious purple eyes.

“You want this?” Surprise trailed her hands down her body before grabbing a handful of her own breast and lifted it up to her face. Angling her body to ensure maximum visibility, she gave her nipple the briefest of licks.

“Oh Luna, yes,” Thomas said without thinking.

Honey tensed and writhed in Luna’s lap, uncertain if what she felt was the mare’s cock simply twitching in excitement, or magically widening a few centimeters.

At the same time, Moonlight felt Silver’s snatch tighten around her fingers while the bat felt the unicorn’s half-mast dick twitch with new life in her hand. They shared a lascivious look before returning their attention on the scene at hand.

Surprise sank herself down until her nether lips were just above his erection and she felt herself wink around his round tip. “Sure hope you’re up for this, little boy,” she added experimentally. Based on the giddy and expectant noise that came from the human’s throat, she considered it a success.

Grinning lustfully, Surprise sank herself slowly down Thomas’ length. It was hard not to make the comparison with Thomas’ length and what she’d seen coming out of Luna and going into Honey. And as much as Surprise couldn’t wait for her turn with that monster of a cock, she was equally antsy to once more feel Thomas’ unique shape and foalish features within and against her.

It took mere seconds for the pegasus’ wide rump to meet Thomas’ thighs and balls, where upon her plump assets spread out around his bony frame, holding him in place. The two shared a contented moan at becoming one as Surprise helped the human to sit up. His head poked between the bottom of his breasts, tickling them with his hair and breath. They smiled at one another, but Surprise donned a more determined look as she glanced back at the screen. The ponies there were able to be face to face, but that was unfortunately impossible given the massive size differences between the pegasus and man. Another challenge came from just how big Surprise’s plot was.

“Maybe you should, uh,” Thomas stammered and gestured downward.

“Right,” Surprise agreed as she almost completely lifted herself off of Thomas’ length in order to free his legs.

“And then I…” Thomas trailed off as he tried to focus. The sheer width of Surprise’s rump meant he had to extract one leg at a time out from under her. Surprise’s thighs also proved too much of an obstacle for the man to successfully loop his legs over as depicted on the screen.

Instead, Surprise brought her own legs up, pinning Thomas’ shoulders between her knees while her hooves pressed down directly behind his tailbone. At the same time, Thomas pressed his knees up against her thighs. From there they locked their hands beneath the other’s knees as best as they could before locking fingers. It was their best attempt at mimicking the image on the screen, and it felt awesome. Both mare and man moaned as they rubbed their legs against the other’s bodies, enjoying the feel of smooth skin and soft, plush fur respectively.

Their position did not allow for heavy thrusting like they were both used to. They could only rotate their hips and make slow, shallow strokes. It was far more intimate and even a bit casual as the mare and man looked into one another’s eyes.

“This is nice,” Surprise cooed as she rotated her hips against Thomas’. The texture of his shaft rubbing along her insides in short, shallow strokes was blissful. “Like relaxed, uh,” she trailed off in search of the desired word, never ceasing her movements.

“Intimate?”

“That’s it!”

Thomas leaned forward until his vision and the top of his head were completely consumed by Surprise’s soft, warm bosoms. He hummed into the breast flesh and smiled at the sound of the mare’s giggle. Surprise gently stroked the back of Thomas’ head, enjoying the feel of his short hair. The two stayed like this for several minutes, moving only a little as they simply reveled in one another’s touch. Even so, tension still built in their loins as their audience watched a notable if gradual increase in hip movement. They held tightly to one another, using the other’s bodies for leverage as they pushed and pulled apart.

“Such a sweet colt,” Surprise purred as she nosed the top of his head. “You know exactly what a mare needs before a good orgy.”

Thomas’ earlier feelings of inadequacy were all but forgotten as he allowed the warmth and smell of the mare to drown his senses. The voice of his inner skeptic telling him that the mare’s moans of delight were all fake was drowned out by the sound of her quickening pulse reverberating all around him. She was happy, excited, in a state of bliss, and the one responsible for bringing these feeling to her was none other than himself. Surprise wanted him, his body, his dick, his gentleness, and everything else that made him who and what he was. “I love you,” he whispered into the mare’s breasts, uncertain if she could hear.

Surprise’s expression of gentle bliss quickly morphed into a crazed grin as she snapped to face her audience. She silently mouthed the words ‘he loves me’ and earned many silent cheers from the others, especially Moonlight. Thomas was always careful and reserved with his words. It was neigh unthinkable for him to make such an admission without meaning it. Driven by this fact, Surprise tightened her grip around the man’s form and quickened her pace.

The pair groaned as both of them achieved their climax, faces looking only marginally flushed as they pulled apart far enough to look at one another. They smiled and brought their lips together in a modest kiss.

Thus ended round 1.

It can be tricky thinking up ways to keep sex scenes and orgies (of which this story as many) interesting and inventive. Audiences can only read the exact same sequence of events so many times before it gets dull and repetitive, after all. And given that my primary objective for the conclusion to this ark was to make sure everyone got a turn, a roulette just seemed like the most natural conclusion. Also it gives me an excuse to use more kama sutra poses.

Big thanks to my Patrons.
Tier 1: Nobody at this time
Tier 2: Arthur Daniel Caro, Cerberi, and Josh
Tier 3: Jonathan Applewhaite, kent, Nakey Jakey, and AuthorGenesis