That Night...

A purple colt with short white hair, and wearing a shirt with a video game controller printed on it, opened the cash register of his game shop. After checking the money he closed the drawer with a smile and headed to the back office. Grabbing his coat he headed out to the main room to lock up when he heard a game case fall off a shelf in one of the back shelves.

The colt's ears perked and he turned around to look. "Hello?" he asked. "Someone in here?"

When there was no answer he slowly began moving to the source of the noise. Looking around, he saw nothing out of the ordinary. When he got to the shelf he went around to the other side to find a game case on the floor. Tilting his head in cconfusion he knelt down and picked it up, setting it back on the shelf. He then then began making his way back to the front when he heard the cash register open. When he turned around, he saw a cloaked red mare standing at the register. She was staring at the machine as she pushed in the money drawer with a finger before pushing the eject button again.

"Can I help you, ma'am?" he asked cautiously, stepping towards her.

"What is this?" the mare asked, pushing the drawer in again.

"A... cash register?" the colt said questioningly. stepping up to the counter as the mare opened the drawer once more. "Could you maybe not do that?" he asked, reaching around to the front and closing the drawer. "And, could you please leave? I'm closed."

"Leave?" asked the mare. "But, I just got here."

"Please, ma'am. I just wanna go home..."

The cloaked mare smiled before ducking down out of sight. The colt stared for a moment before sighing and heading around to look behind the counter.

"Ma'am, this is getting..." he said, stopping when he didn't see her. "Where'd you go?" he asked, looking around. He then heard movement from up above and looked up. Letting out a gasp he saw the mare sitting like a frog, upside-down, on the ceiling. "What the fu--" he began before he was tackled to the floor. After letting out a grunt, he looked the mare in the eyes. "What are you?"

"Me?" asked the mare, pulling her hood off and smiling at him. "I'm Ruby." She then leaned in and placed kisses on the colt's neck.

"What the hell are you doing?" he asked, trying to push her off.

Ruby then sat up and tilted her head. "You don't like?" she asked. She then stood up and pulled her cloak open, letting it fall to the floor and exposing her slim body. "Like this?" she asked, pulling her panties down and bending over the counter.

The colt blushed and bit his lip, knowing he shouldn't and yet his body was deceiving him. He slowly got to his feet as Ruby moved her hips side-to-side as she watched him move closer. The colt then placed his hands on the mare's butt and shuddered lightly at the feel.

"You like?" Ruby asked.

The colt nodded. "Yeah... I like..."

The mare giggled and pushed back into the colt's crotch. "Don't keep me waiting..."

The colt let out a sharp gasp as he felt the mare's ass press to his hard-on. He then unzipped his pants and quickly pulled them down before gripping his dick. He then aligned it with her pussy and pushed it in with a grunt, both of them moaning when the colt's rod entered the mare.

"Mmm, that's it..." Ruby moaned out with a smile. "Fuck me, big boy..." The colt grabbed her butt again and began to move his hips back and forth quickly, letting out moans of his own. "And, you can cum inside..."

The colt gasped softly as he kept going. "Are you sure?"

"Yes," Ruby replied. "Cum inside."

"A-Alright," the colt moaned as he kept going, now slamming his hips into hers as he moaned out. "Shit! Here I cum!" he moaned out as he blew his load deep inside the mare's pussy.

Ruby smiled and licked her lips beforepushing the colt backwards with her butt. She then turned around to face him before kneeling down. After gripping his cock she wrapped her lips around it and began sucking the cum off as well as whatever else squirted out.

"That was amazing..." the colt moaned.

Ruby giggled and stood up. "Cummed quickly but... it will have to do..."

"What do you mean?" the colt asked, sounding confused. Just then, wings popped out of Ruby's back and a tail grew from just above her butt. "What the fuck?!" the colt yelled in surprise.

Ruby then tackled him and smiled before opening her mouth, revealing her razor sharp teeth, before diving in for the kill.

Luna entered Fluttershy's bedroom to find the mare in bed, both mares wearing their nightgown. The only light in the room came from the lamp on the bedside table.

"Hello, Fluttershy," Luna said with a smile as she approached the bed.

Shy smiled back and scooted over, giving the alicorn room so she could climb in with her. Luna then scooted up to the shy mare and smiled, putting an arm around her.

"You said you wanted to try something new tonight?" Luna asked with a smile.

Fluttershy looked away slightly. "Um... Well, yes, but... Um... W-Well, you see..."

"What is it?" Luna asked gently, placing a hand on Shy's cheek, rubbing gently. "You can ask me anything..."

"W-Well..." Shy began, blushing heavily. "Y-You see, I started liking the fake you when were... having... You know..."

The alicorn thought for a second before smiling. "You would like to... have sex? To know if your feelings are true?"

Shy blushed more and felt her body heat up. She was so nervous about asking the sub-leader of their group to have sex simply for the reason of finding out whether or not she truly loved her. "I-I know it's selfish to ask this of you, Luna... Especially since it's just to find out if I really have feelings for you... B-But, I... I-I have to know..."

"I understand, Fluttershy," Luna said with a smile as she leaned in close to the pegasus. "If you would like to have sex, then we can... It is alright..."

"A-Are you sure?" asked Shy. "I-I mean, we--"

She was cut off as Luna leaned in and kissed her on the lips. Shy went wide-eyed briefly before closing her eyes and melting into he kiss. The alicorn then slowly climbed atop the mare, their breasts squishing together as Luna felt Shy's hard-on against her crotch. Luna slowly broke the kiss and smiled as she wiggled her hips a little.

"Ready, sweetie?" asked Luna, smiling.

Shy put the tip of her thumb into her mouth and nibbled on her fingernail, looking nervous and cute. She then nodded hesitantly as the alicorn smiled, reaching down and gripping the bottom of Shy's gown. Luna began pulling up the mare's gown as she leaned in and kissed her on the lips. Once she had pulled the gown up and over Shy's huge breasts she broke the kiss.

"Arms up, sweetie..." she cooed.

Shy hesitated before raising her arms, letting Luna pull the gown off, and setting it on the bedside table. She then sat up and pulled her own gown off, tossing it onto Shy's gown. Fluttershy blushed as she looked over Luna's body. Now, she knew what it looked like since she had seen it before but this was the real Luna's body.

The alicorn then slid back a bit over the shy mare's cock, letting it spring back into an upright position. Luna smiled and gripped it, stroking the tool with a smile. "Like this?"

Fluttershy shuddered and let out a cute moan. "U-Uh-huh..."

Luna smiled wider and scooted back a bit more before leaning in, giving the head a kiss. Hearing the pegasus let out a cute gasp of pleasure, she giggled and wrapped her lips around the tip, before bobbing her head.

"O-Oh, Luna..." Shy moaned out, feeling the alicorn move lower on her cock, bobbing her head up and down the whole length.

Once the cock was wet enough, Luna pulled away and smiled, scooting back up. She then raised her hips, her pussy lips kissing the dick's tip. She then let out a grunt and a moan as she pushed downwards. As Fluttershy felt her cock penetrate the alicorn's pussy she let out a loud moan, reaching out and gripping the mare's hips as Luna moved up and down.

"Mmm... So big..." the alicorn moaned, licking her lips.

Shy moaned and shuddered, feeling her cock twitch inside Luna's wet insides. After a moment she felt her orgasm approaach. "L-Luna, I... I'm about to c-cum..."

The alicorn smiled and slid off the meaty tool, before leaning in and wrapping ehr lips around the tip. She then began stroking it quickly before she heard the pegasus moan loudly and felt a flood of cum shoot into her mouth. Luna closed her eyes as she felt some cum shoot from her nose as a bit exploded from her mouth and splattered over her mouth and upper part of her breasts. Once she felt the shy mare's orgasm end she pulled away and swallowed, giving the tip one more lick.

"Did you like that?" Luna asked with a smile, licking some cum from her lips.

Shy smiled and nodded hesitantly. "I-I did, but... I never... put it in the other you... In Chryaslis... She always put hers... in me..."

Luna chuckled briefly and nodded. "I understand..." She then lit up her horn as there was a flash of light between her legs.

When the light cleared, Shy found herself staring at a familiar-looking blue cock. "Th-That's more like it..." Shy said as she stared at the tool.

Luna smiled and let her cock rest on Shy's chest. "Care to wet it first?"

"Sh-She usually just... p-puts it in..."

Luna nodded. "I see... Which hole did she do?"

"Well... Um... Both?" Shy said questioningly and nervously, her blush deepening.

The alicorn nodded and aligned it with her butt,, before pushing the head in, making Shy gasp.

"Did I hurt you?" Luna asked, receiving a head shake from the pegasus.

Smiling back at her, she continued pushing inwards until she was at a comfortable depth. She then began moving back and forth, anally fucking the shy mare who bit on her knuckle to keep from moaning too loudly. It soon became too much for her and she let out a loud squeal of pleasure and began gasping and panting constantly.

Luna smiled as she kept going, moving back and forth at a speed in which she was sure she wasn't hurting the mare. After a few minutes she let out a gasp.

"I-I'm close," Luna moaned, biting her lip. "G-Get ready..."

Shy nodded and moaned out before feeling a rush of warm cum in her ass, making her moan loudly. Luna pushed ehr whole cock inside the mare's ass as she fired off more cum. A lot shot back out and covered Shy's ass and Luna's crotch until the alicorn's orgasm ended.

Luna panted heavily before laying atop Shy with a smile. "W-Well, sweetie? What do you think?"

Shy bit her trembling lip, before covering her eyes with her palms. "No..." she whimpered, before crying softly. "I'm sorry..."

"What?" asked Luna. "What is it?"

"I-It didn't feel... right..." she whimpered, sniffling. "Oh, Luna, I'm sorry to have made you have sex with me for nothing!"

The alicorn then watched as Shy broke down crying, tears streaming her face. She was clearly embarrassed and ashamed by what she had done.

Luna then smiled and gently took Shy's hands, moving them from her eyes. "It was not for nothing, Fluttershy..." she said, looking into the sobbing mare's wet eyes. "You realized who you truly love. Just because it is not me does not make this experience worthless... And, you were smart to try and recreate the moments which led to your feelings. And, now you know who you really love."

Shy calmed a little but she still had leaky eyes. "B-But, it's impossible!" she cried out. "C-Chrysalis would never... I-I mean, I'm just... It's impossible..."

"Nothing is impossible, Fluttershy..." Luna said with a smile, leaning in and kissing Shy's cheek. "You just have to work at it."

The shy mare sniffled and smiled, wiping her tears away. "Thanks, Luna..."

"Of course..." the alicorn replied with a smile.

The pegasus smiled a little wider. "Could you... um... possibly... still spend the night with me? Just for comfort?"

Luna smiled and nodded, reaching for the bedside lamp before turning it off.

Ruby used her long, foot-long fingernails to tear into the colt's chest, splattering blood all over the game shelves and front glass door. She then began pulling out chunks of meat, eating it before diving her face into the wound and drinking the blood. She had lusty eyes and moaned a little as she enjoyed her meal, her face and chest covered in blood.

"Mmm... Tasty..." she moaned.