The episode begins with Fluttershy and Soarin sitting on the bed in the HOH room talking to Rarity and Lyra with rather concerned looks on their faces.

“Twilight wants Soarin gone” gasped Fluttershy “why can’t she just accept that I love him”

“She’s got it in her head that he’s just using you” said Rarity “and I’m afraid if we don’t eliminate her you’re going to have to say goodbye before the half way mark”

“I never thought” stuttered Fluttershy “I never thought I would have to turn on one of my friends, but I cannot and will not allow Twilight to get rid of him”

“Oh Fluttershy” sighed Soarin “I don’t want you to lose a friend over me”

“She’s brought this on herself” said Rarity not waiting for Fluttershy’s response “this game is bringing her paranoia to an all time high, she needs to be eliminated, being here can’t be good for her health”

“Well” sighed Fluttershy “I guess if it’s for her own good, at least now I have a better reason than just my own”

“Whatever you chose Fluttershy” said Soarin “I’m with you”

“Me to” said Lyra

“I’m also with you” stated Rarity “just tell us how to vote and you’ve got it”

The camera switched over to the kitchen where Twilight Sparkle was sitting grumbling to herself when Applejack walked in.

“Howdy Twilight” said the orange farm pony “uh, whatcha do’in”

“Trying to figure out where Rarity, Fluttershy, and Lyra are” Twilight responded an edge of annoyance pushing its way into her voice

“Is that all” said Applejack “they’re up in the HOH bedroom with that Wonderbolt who’s taken a liking to Fluttershy, what’s his name, uh Soarin”

“I should have known Lyra would betray me” mumbled Twilight “but Rarity, oh that Soarin may have them fooled but not me, Applejack will you promise me something?”

“Uh” said Applejack “What?”

“I need you to talk some sense into Fluttershy” said Twilight “make her see that Soarin is just using her the same way Fleetfoot was using Rainbow Dash”

“I’m sorry Twilight” said Applejack “can you repeat that, I could of swore you said something stupid just now”

“Oh no” gasped Twilight “He’s gotten to you to hasn’t he”

“What in the wide wide world of Equestria are you talking about?” asked Applejack “Twilight you need to calm down, you’re starting to scare me”

“You’re in on their plans” said Twilight “you need to go away”

Twilight’s horn glowed with a light purple aura and began to spark, while Applejack attempting to retreat vanished from the room reappearing in the HOH room upstairs.

“Twilight don’t!” shouted a frightened Applejack

“Applejack” said Fluttershy “are you ok?”

Applejack noticing that she had only been teleported to the HOH room sighed with relief that she still had all of her parts attached firmly to her body.

“Thank Celestia” said Applejack “she only teleported me”

“What did Twilight teleport you for” asked Rarity

“She thinks you’re out to get her” said Applejack pointing her hoof at Soarin “and she wanted me to get Fluttershy to put you on the block”

“There you go” said Rarity “just another example of why Twilight needs to go home”

“Well if you do put her up” said Applejack “you’ve got my vote”

“All right then” said Fluttershy “I’ll put her on the block, but who should I put up there with her?”

“Some pony, who no pony will vote for” said Lyra “how about Pinkie Pie”

“Well that might work” said Rarity

“Then it’s settled” said Fluttershy “Twilight and Pinkie Pie go up for eviction”

“All contestants report to the outside area” said Vinyl over the speaker system “while Fluttershy chooses her nominations for eviction”

All of the contestants headed to the outside area except Fluttershy who stayed in the living room quickly placing all of the keys in the roulette wheel with the exception of two which she placed in the bag on the table.

“All right come on in every pony” said Fluttershy “let’s get this over with”

All of the houseguests from outside headed into the living room and got themselves situated around the roulette wheel.

“Here we go” said Fluttershy pulling out the first key revealing the name Soarin.

After seeing his name Soarin reached for the next key.

“Rarity” said Soarin “you’re safe”

The next few keys were picked until only two keys and four houseguests remained and Sweetie Belle reaching for the next Key.

“Spitfire” called the little unicorn

Spitfire reached for the final key which would spare one of the three remaining contestants.

“And the final key says” said Spitfire “Rainbow Dash”

Fluttershy stood up to address the two houseguests she had selected for eviction: Twilight Sparkle, and Pinkie Pie.

“Twilight you’re on the block” said Fluttershy “becau”

“Because you’ve all been deceived!” shouted Twilight storming out of the room “why am I the only pony who realizes that Soarin and Spitfire are manipulating this game!”

“Uh, ok” said Fluttershy “Pinkie Pie, you’re up on the block because Twilight needs to go home, no one will vote for you to be evicted, I would like to call you all together to work towards evicting Twilight this week, because as you can see this game is simply not good for her”

“You’ve got a deal” said Spitfire “it’s rather obvious she’s been slipping down a rather bad slope since we arrived here”

“Ok then this nomination ceremony is done” said Fluttershy

The camera switched over to the studio next door where Vinyl was sitting on stage in front of a crowd of a couple hundred ponies.

“Well that was interesting, Twilight and Pinkie Pie up for eviction and I would say the only chance Twilight has is to win the upcoming veto, be sure to tune in next time for more thrills here on Big Brother”

The episode ends with All of the contestants except Pinkie Pie and the Cutie Mark Crusaders talking strategy in the HOH bedroom.