J slammed forward into Pinkie causing her to moan loudly. While doing so he tossed the bottle of rum into the air and caught it with his other hand. He poured some out into the glass and flipped it back up.

Pinkie wasn’t willing to wait for him to start again and grabbed his shoulders. J lost his balance and stumbled back taking her with him onto the floor in a loud crash.

-----------------

My eyes snap open, scanning the room.

“Pinkie! What was that for?!?” A voice yelled.

“I want to go again!” Pinkie responded.

I stand up, tip-toeing to the sound of the voice.

“Gods if your that ready then who am I to say no?” The voice quickly responded.

“No one silly! Oh wait… yes you are…” Pinkie said. She quickly turned around to see me, “OH! Hiya Star! You’re finally awake!”

“I can see that..” I said, glancing between the two.

“Oh hey Star. I got home like an hour ago! You all were so peacefully asleep too. It’s so nice to walk in twice in the same week to the aftermath of an orgy! I just had to get in on it too for once!” J stated.

“Uh huh..” I said, scratching my chin.

“Wait… Pinkie it’s time…” J said with an evil smile.

“OH it is?!?!” Pinkie said as she quickly dismounted J and pushed me onto the table, “Now Star… be a good boy and take your medicine!”

J got up and grabbed a partially filled glass.

“Should I ask?” I said, raising an eyebrow.

“It’s just a little birthday present from me…” J said as he stepped beside me, “Now just drink it. The rest of today’s going to be fun for you!”

“Well… Bottoms up!” I said, chugging the glass down, “Yep…” I grunted, “That hit the spot..”

“Give it about a minute to kick in. You’ll be hornier than they’ll ever see you again!” J said as he helped me up, “Now… where were we?”

“Uh uh Jj! Today’s Star’s birthday! You have to wait!” Pinkie said as she hauled me away and back into the living room.

“Hey uh… What was.. In that..” I sighed heavily, stumbling backwards as I grabbed onto the kitchen counter.

“Rum and a very potent aphrodisiac. Specially formulated to shove any werewolf into a rut! Enjoy the effects I’m sure… the four of them will… Now… I feel it’s time for a show of dominance!” J said as he walked into the living room behind us.

I rush up behind J, wrapping my arms around him as I rest my head on his shoulder, “Hey… J.”

“Oh… god… wrong bottle of rum… fuck my life…” J said quietly.

“I just have one thing to say..” I say, feeling my dick prodding him.

“Not… going to… move… don’t… want… to… get… raped…” He stammered.

“Shh… It’ll be okay… Just listen.” I whispered, rubbing his cheek softly. “There’s one thing I want to ask.. Well.. Tell you.”

“Please… at least get some lube…”

“You see Fluttershy over there?” I asked, glancing across the room.

He nodded weakly, “Yes… I do…”

“Good.. Now..” I said soothingly, “If you touch her… I will make you feel pain in places you didn’t even know existed… Are we clear buddy?”

He nodded weakly again, “Yes… yes we are…”

“Just making it clear.” I said with a smile, planting a soft kiss on his cheek as I moved away, smacking him on the ass.

“Twilight..” I said quietly, shaking her. She yawned, looking up at me with a smile.

“Morning..” She said.

“Come with me Twilight. We are going to have a little fun.” I said, hoisting her into my arms.

“Where are we going?” She asked, seeing something in my eyes that slightly worried her as I stared straight ahead.

“The basement.” I said bluntly.

“Why are we going into the basement…” She asked concerned.

“Science.” I say, slamming the door behind us.

-------------------

I walked over to the couch still a little shaken by Star’s threat. “Dear God… Never again… Never again…”

I saw the mare I didn’t recognize and sat down beside her.

She yawned as she woke up, “Oh… I didn’t…”

I smiled a little, “Don’t worry. I know you’re here with Star. The name’s J Dog.”

She smiled and laid her head on my shoulder, “So you’re the hero who rescued my sister? I can’t think of how to thank you…”

I smirked, “Oh I can…”

“Then why don’t…” She began until Dash got down in front of me.

“So… why don’t I help out a little?” Dash questioned. She started stroking my now soft dick.

“Why not? Come on I got a much more comfortable place that all three of us could share upstairs…” I said as I slowly got up.

“No you don’t… Right here’s just fine. Sit back and let the both of us thank you for saving those three fillies…” Dash said, “So Rarity are you gonna be taking him first or can I?”

Ha… taking me? I think not. I grabbed Rarity’s ass and began fondling her, “Sorry but unlike Star I’m more… dominating…” I forced Dash’s head down and she deep throated me almost instantly. I slurred, “Gooood girl…”

I knew I’d have hell to pay when she snapped out of this but I didn’t care.

Rarity was forcing my fingers in and out of her, “Mmm so forward…”

I leaned over and kissed her deeply.

From the basement I could hear muffled screams of pain and pleasure.. Mostly pain.

“What the fuck?” I questioned as I shot straight up almost knocking Dash out with my dick.

Rarity was laying flat on her face on the floor.

“Shi… Sorry sorry… Um… I really need to make sure he isn’t pulling some fucked up shit or worse… I’m hoping he didn’t fucking turn.” I said as I walked over to the basement door. As I reached for the door, it slowly cracked open, and I was met with Star’s blank stare as he looked me in the eyes.

“Hello..” He said.

“Oh god… What the hell have I created?” I questioned as I backed away. He stared at me for a moment before his attention was caught elsewhere, looking behind me.

“Fluttershy… Can we talk?” He asked.

Two things raced through my mind. I could let her go down there with him and most likely let her suffer through some horrible crisis, or save my anus from being torn in half. “I’m… just going to go over there.” My ass is more important right now.

“Oh.. And J.” He said, his sight snapping back to me.

“What…” I said back.

“If you ever open this door…. Have fun!” He said with a smile as Fluttershy walked in and the door shut. It quickly opened again, “Oh.. And if i call you down.. Please don’t make me wait. I hate waiting.”

“Oh god…” I ran over and checked the bottle. I tasted a tiny drop. Mint. “FUCK ME I GRABBED THE WRONG ONE!”

“What… you grabbed…” Dash began to question.

“Fuck… fuck fuck! I need…” I began as I looked over where my cellphone was, “How the fuck did he smash it? Oh god… Um… Um…” I glanced around, “I know! I’ll…”

From the basement, I continued to hear the muffled screams of pleasure from Twilight, not hearing a peep from Fluttershy.

“Shit…” I said.

“I’m going down. I’m not going to..” Dash began.

“I commend your bravery but HELL NO! HE’S HYPED UP ON LIQUID RAPE! There is no fucking way I’m letting…” I began.

“NO! YOU LISTEN TO ME! I’M NOT LETTING FLUTTERSHY GET RAPED BY HIM!” She screamed back as she grabbed the door handle.

She turned it and entered the basement. The door slammed shut as soon as she was away from it.

“Oh… god… I hope none of them remember it…” I said quietly.

I looked over at Rarity and Pinkie. Both looked scared. After the door closes, silence fills the basement. We wait there as a minute passes. Then finally.. I began to hear footsteps, climbing the stairs, a slow, menacing pace.

“Both of you… whatever happens this was my fault. DO NOT BLAME STAR!” I said as I glanced at the door.

The door cracked open, Star peeked out at us. “Hey J..” He said, a whisper that filled my very soul with terror.

“What…” I answered.

“We’re having a lot of fun down here.. I’m glad Rainbow Dash came. She’s with us now though.. Don’t worry. And remember… If i call..” He said, slowly shutting the door.

“... No.” I stated calmly as a small bit of rage burned in me. No. I’m not letting you be the only one to have a little fun around here. All fear rushed from me and I grabbed both Pinkie and Rarity, “Upstairs now.” I ordered.

I walked upstairs with them Pinkie backed off into my bathroom and closed the door quietly.

“J… what… what’s going on down there?” Rarity questioned.

“I don’t know.” I said.

“Can… can you…” She began to ask.

“Lay down now.” I ordered.

She complied and laid down on my bed.

I got over top of her.

“J… please… don’t let him…” Rarity began.

“I won’t… I won’t.” I said quietly as I kissed her. She grabbed my dick and moved it towards her pussy. When I was lined up I thrust in.

---------------------

Rarity gasped as J thrust in.

J growled in pleasure as her interior although recently ravaged by Star was quite tight and gripped his shaft.

Rarity moaned as he pulled out, only to gasp when he thrust in again. He pushed in and out in a slow pattern.

Rarity broke the kiss and moaned loudly, “J… ah… why… why does it feel so different… why…”

J groaned as he pulled out slowly. He bent further over top of her and got into a better position, “Now… let’s turn up the heat…”

He quickly sheathed most of his length in her warm depths and proceeded to pound into her. The kissed again and got lost in their own passions.

---------------

“Oh Pinkie!” I shouted out as I opened the door, Waiting patiently at the entrance to the basement.

I heard a loud thump upstairs and she came rushing down almost instantly.

“Good girl.. Now I have something i want to ask you.” I said, circling her, a hand running across her skin.

“O… okay Star what is it?” She questioned.

“You remember how much I hate alcohol right?” I said, placing my head on her shoulder as i stood behind her.

Her eyes went wide, “Y… yes I do…”

“And you recall the night you spike the cider… At my.. ‘Party’ as I recall?” I said.

Pinkie nodded but didn’t utter a word. Her hair drooped a little bit.

“Well.. After Fluttershy got drunk.. It made me think of how much I really cared about her. I couldn’t stand to see her like that.. So in a way, you helped me.” I said, gently rubbing my hand through her hair.

She perked back up, “I… I did?” She thought about it for a few moments, “I… I’m happy for you then…”

“I am happy for me too.. And after everything you have done for us.. I would like to.. ‘Repay’.... The favor.” I whisper into her ear, slowly kissing her neck.

“Okay!” Pinkie said happily, “You really don’t have to though… I just enjoy helping my friends!”

“Nonsense.. What kind of friend would I be?” I said, leading her to the stairs.

She followed me forward although she seemed a little reluctant, “Um… I wanted to ask what did J mean when he said liquid rape?”

“Oh him..” I said with a small laugh, “He exaggerates. I just want to make everyone happy. You can understand that right?”

“Of course I can!” She said as she seemingly forgot all about J’s protests and warnings.

“I’m glad.” I said as she began descending down the stairs. Half way down she stopped, seeing Twilight, Fluttershy, and Rainbow Dash. She quickly glanced up at me as i stared down at her, closing the door behind us.

“Now… I want to see you smile..”

-------------------------------

J and Rarity didn’t notice Pinkie leave and continued making love.

“J… I’m… *moan* so… close…” Rarity stammered as he pushed even deeper into her.

He groaned, “So am I…”

“P… please… don’t… pull out…” She said as he leaned down again.

“I won’t then.” He responded as he thrust into her again.

They kissed one last time before she came. With another few thrust J climaxed as well pouring his cum into Rarity.

J pulled out and reached into his drawer. He pulled out a small candle and an incense stick.

“J… what are those for?” Rarity questioned.

“These will help you relax…” J lied as he lit the candle first. He held his breath as the fumes wafter through the air. Within a few seconds Rarity was out cold. J doused the wick and took a deep breath as the candles fumes faded away. Next he lit the stick and waved it in front of Rarity’s nose. “There… that should save Star’s ass from any retribution… Now. Pinkie? Are you still in there?”

He waited a few seconds and she didn’t respond so he went into the bathroom to check.

He looked around frantically and stepped out, “No…” J rushed down stairs and prepared to open the basement door, “Ready or not… here I come…”

The sounds of whatever was going on down there continued. J stepped back. He needed something to make sure he wouldn’t remember what had happened.

“Well… as a wiseman once said. To fight a demon you have to become the demon.” J grabbed the bottle and his glass of vodka. He poured a little into the glass and downed it in one gulp. “Here goes nothing…”

J stepped towards the door as the drink began to take hold over him. He had watered it down significantly more than he had done to Star’s so it didn’t take as much a hold on him. But it did awaken something deep inside J’s soul.

J grabbed the door handle and silently opened the door. He knew the stairs creaked to much so as he closed the door just as silently he climbed onto the wall and slowly made his way down into the basement.

-------------------------------

As I make my way down, I see something unexpected. I look down to see a dark figure, whom I can presume is Star, sitting in a chair naked in the middle of the room. He has his head in his hands, looking almost bored. About 5 feet in front of him is Twilight and Rainbow Dash, who are chained up against the wall. Twilight looks almost emotionless, staring straight ahead as Fluttershy ate her out, giving an occasional twitch.

“I think she’s ready.” Star said, motioning to the key. Fluttershy moved and unlocked Twilight, she fell to her hands and knees, crawling forward to Star as she curled up around his leg. I could see Rainbow Dash muzzled, sweat pouring down her as i could see she had just recovered from an orgasm.

I heard a strong and very evil voice speak inside of me, ‘Do it… kill him...’

I shook it off and my hands shook. I knew he knew I was here. He’s been waiting. I took a deep breath and stepped forward. “I’m ending the mistake I caused right here…” I was intending to get him down and out cold. Maybe then I could unfuck this all. Then it hit me. Where’s Pinkie?

“Hello.” Pinkie said, stepping out of the shadows. I could tell instantly there was something different about her. Her hair was… Straight, not puffy like her usual self.

I scoffed the horror of what Star was doing kicked in, “What… the hell…” I stepped back. No there isn’t any turning back right now I was in the lair of an Apex Predator there wasn’t any escape for me. “Star… is this really how you want it to continue?” I questioned trying to pick at what ever sanity was in him at the moment. While I said that my own sanity was slipping away. I wanted to find out what happens next… I want to know… My breathing became heavy as I felt the drug take full effect on me. “You… really thought… I would… let this go?”

Star doesn’t even glance over to me. He simply watches as Fluttershy and Twilight move on to pleasing Rainbow Dash. Pinkie approached me, running her hands across my back.

“Come on J.. Relax. Have some fun..” She said.

I smiled and laughed, “Fun… No no… I’ve come to take what’s mine…” I grabbed her hand and pulled her against my body, “And he thought that I’d let this go unabated… At least invite me…”

“Mmm..” She said, “So assertive..”

Just as I stepped forward the door upstairs in the living room crashed down.

“Oh… how did they find out?” I questioned.

The second door opened up and Pupa rushed down. She stared at me wide eyed.

I glanced over at Star with a smirk, “Ready for a little fun brother?”

Star just sat there and glanced at me with a returned smirk, looking back at Rainbow Dash.

“Hmmm… Let me deal with the intruder you have fun with breaking her in…” I said as I approached Pupa. She attempted to back away but Pinkamena grabbed her and held her for me, “So you want to help? Then… let’s start now…”