Back at the North Pole, Twilight is still trying to get things organized with the presents and the lights on the globe. But, she's also very stressed out about it.

It doesn't help either when Pitch showed up on top of the globe with victory. "Oh no." Twilight muttered. Pitch laughed at her and said, "You won't be needing any Christmas presents anymore. Thank you. Nor ever again." "Let me guess. You want to destroy anything that deals with Christmas like you did to Easter." said Twilight. "That's exactly what I'm going to do right now." said Pitch as he uses his black sand to destroy all of the presents and the cookies.

The destruction causes Applejack, Rarity, and Fluttershy to fly all over the place until they landed next to Twilight. "Guys, are you ok?" Twilight asked. "Ugh, what happened?" Applejack asked. "Yes! I have finally destroyed everything that deals with the Guardians!" Pitch laughed evilly. "You monster! Why are you so cruel?!" Fluttershy shouted in fear. "Because it's who I am, Fluttershy. And there's nothing you can do to change it." Pitch replied.

He turned around to see the globe, and smiled when all of the lights are out except for six. "Well, it looks like most of Equestria has stopped believing in the Guardians. And you ladies are the only ones that still do." he said. "No." Twilight muttered. "Yes, yes, yes! I've won!" Pitch shouted in joy. "No, you didn't. Jack Frost can still beat you." said Rarity. "Oh, Jack Frost? You don't have to worry about him anymore, because I got rid of him. Also, your other friends were beaten too." Pitch replied. Twilight gasped in shock and shouted, "No! Not Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie!" "Yes. Those two were in the way and they were completely obnoxious." said Pitch.

"What are you going to do to us?" Fluttershy asked in fear. "The same thing I did to your friends. Prepare to not see the light of day ever again!" Pitch replied as he prepares to attack Twilight and her friends, but she blocked the attack and made an escape. "Let's get out of here!" Twilight shouted. The girls ran for their lives as Pitch chases after them. "He's onto us!" Fluttershy shouted. "We have to get North and Tooth." said Applejack.

"I'll go get Tooth, you guys get North." said Rarity as she went to the other direction to get the Tooth Fairy. When she did, Tooth was already weak and could no longer fly. "Rarity?" Tooth asked. "Oh, Tooth. You look awful. Come on, let's get out of here. Pitch is here at the North Pole, and he won't stop at nothing until we're all dead." Rarity replied as she uses her magic to lift up the Fairy and took her to the sleigh. "But, there's nothing left. I'm done for." said Tooth. "Don't say that. There's still a way to save you." Rarity replied as she ran faster.

When Twilight, Fluttershy, and Applejack got North and took him to the sleigh, there was no time to lose because Pitch is still right behind them. "We better hurry up!" Applejack shouted. Rarity ran towards them with Tooth and jumped into the sleigh. "Perfect timing, Rarity." said Twilight. "Thanks. Tooth is getting weaker by the minute." Rarity replied. "And so is North. We have to go to Ponyville, and we need everyone there to believe in the Guardians again." said Twilight. "Then let's go before Pitch gets us." said Applejack. "Right." said Twilight as she took the wheel of the sleigh and started flying it.

Now, they are off to Ponyville.

...

When they got there, all of Ponyville is covered with pure darkness.

"Oh my Celestia. Our home is covered with darkness. I can't even bear with it." Applejack said in despair. "It's dreadful. Absolutely dreadful." said Rarity. But suddenly, the sleigh crash landed and the reindeer ran off. "Come back!" North shouted. "Aw, the sleigh is broken." said Twilight. "It's hopeless. Everything I have is gone." said North. Fluttershy looked up in the air and shouted, "Hey, look up there!"

It was Rainbow Dash, Pinkie, and Jack Frost coming to the rescue and they are safe and sound. "Rainbow Dash! Pinkie Pie! Oh, I'm so glad you two are safe." Twilight shouted as she hugged her friends. "We're fine, Twilight. Really." said Rainbow Dash. "We almost got killed though." said Pinkie. "Jack. You came back." said Tooth. "I'm sorry that I left you. I promise that I will never leave the Guardians again." said Jack. "That's my boy. You act like a true Guardian." said North.

"Thanks. But, where's Bunny?" Jack asked. "Losing Easter and Christmas took effect on all of us. Bunny, most of all." said North as he shows everyone what happened to Bunny. He shrunk down into an actual bunny rabbit. "Oh no." Jack muttered. Rainbow Dash started to laugh really loud when she saw Bunny's new appearance. "Laugh all you want, Rainbow Dash. Because it ain't gonna help." said Bunny. "Aw, look you cute you are. You look like an actual bunny." said Fluttershy as she begins to scratch him behind the ears, which he really loves.

But, he stopped when he saw Jack and walked towards him to say he's sorry. "Look, Jack. I just wanna say I'm sorry for yelling at you earlier. This is what I get for giving up hope." he said. Jack picks him up and said, "Well, apology accepted kangaroo." Bunny laughed on what he said. "It's about time you two are getting along." said Fluttershy.

Then all of the sudden, thunder was heard and Pitch showed up with thousands of his nightmare horses. "It's Pitch!" Twilight shouted. "And he wants us dead!" Rarity shouted. "Get the Guardians out of here. Find a good place to hide." Jack ordered as he flew into the sky to face Pitch. "Be careful, Jack." said Fluttershy as she picks up Bunny and flies away. "Oh, I have a bad feeling that he's not going to make it." Applejack said in worrisome.

When Jack reached to the Boogeyman, Pitch was surprised to see him alive. "Jack Frost? You're still alive? Well, let's end this. Shall we?" he asked as he charged at the boy. Jack shot some frost at him, but he defended it and has is more powerful than ever. "That trick doesn't work on me anymore!" Pitch shouted as he shoots black sand at Jack, causing him to fall out of the sky.

As the mane six try to find a hiding place, they saw Jack fall straight to the ground hard. "Jack!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "I knew this would happen." said Applejack. "Are you alright?" Twilight asked. "I can't beat him. He's stronger." said Jack as he feels pain from the fall. "Now, what do we do?" Pinkie asked.

Pitch has finally have the mane six and the Guardians cornered by surrounding them with himself and his nightmare horses. "All this fuss for being believed again? And these six girls still believe? They should be filled with complete fear by now." he said. Bunny tried to defend them and said, "You have to go through me, first." Pitch teased him by scratching him behind the ear and said, "Oh, look how fluffy you are. You like being scratched by the ear?" Bunny hid behind Fluttershy and shouted, "Don't you think about it!"

"You know how happy I am to see you like this. You look awful." said Pitch as his shadows grew closer towards the mane six, making them more frightened than ever before. "He's going to kill us!" Rarity shouted as she closed her eyes. "This is it, we're done for." said Applejack. Twilight holds onto Jack and said, "Jack, I'm scared." "We're all scared." said Rainbow Dash.

As Jack was about to comfort them, he remembers what he said to his sister when she got scared. "I know, girls. You're going to be alright. We're going to have a little fun instead." he said. And then, something clicked in his mind. Jack has finally found his center. "That's it. I've found my center." he said. "Beg your pardon?" Applejack asked in confusion. "Fun. Your center is fun." said Twilight.

"Now, girls. Do you have complete fear in you?" Pitch asked as he was hit by a snowball by Jack, making everyone laugh. "That was funny. Do it again." said Pinkie. Jack threw another snowball at Pitch, and then the mane six joined in. "Take that, Pitch!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "Hey, what we just did took away our fear." said Fluttershy.

"I've got an idea. We need everyone in Ponyville to help us." said Jack. "Everyone?" Twilight asked. "Yep. If they all believe in the Guardians again, they'll be saved." Jack replied. "Alright, let's do it." said Twilight. "Come on! Woo hoo!" Jack shouted as he made an ice trail for the mane six and the Guardians, just to make it more fun.

And it actually is. It's like a roller coaster for them with the high speed and the excitement. "I really like sled rides now." said Applejack. "Well, you've had it in you all along Applejack." said Jack as he makes more ice to make the trail more fun. He even made a huge loop. "Whoa, that was so awesome!" Rainbow Dash shouted.

During the sled ride, everyone in Ponyville saw them having fun which makes them feel better. "Hey, look. We've got an audience." said Pinkie. "Perfect." said Jack. "Everyone! We're here to help you believe in the Guardians again! But, we need your help fighting the Boogeyman! I promise that all of your fears will go away!" Twilight shouted to the ponies. "And say hello to Jack Frost! The new Guardian, and make sure you believe in him!" Pinkie shouted. The ponies agreed and began to believe in the Guardians again, and also started to believe in Jack Frost.

"They're beginning to see me." said Jack. And then, North regained his personal strength while Tooth has gotten her ability to fly again. "Yay! The Guardians are back!" Pinkie shouted. "Yee haw! I knew it would work!" Applejack shouted in excitement. "Oi! What about me?" Bunny asked. "Don't worry, Bunny. You'll grow back to your normal size right about now." said Pinkie as she uses a hat to cover him right when he grew back, making it more magical. "Now, that's more like it." said Bunny. "Ta da!" Pinkie shouted.

Then all of the sudden, Pitch showed up to make sure that the Guardians are dead, including Jack Frost. "It's the boogeyman!" a pony shouted. "Everyone, please calm down! He's nothing but a bad dream!" Jack shouted. "We'll protect y'all." said Bunny. "Oh really? You Guardians want to the ponies? But who will protect you?" Pitch asked.

"I will." said Twilight. "I will." said Rainbow Dash. "I will." said Pinkie. "I will." said Fluttershy. "And me." said Rarity. "Ditto on that one." said Applejack. "You see, Pitch? The mane six have always protected the Guardians from you. They even saved me from not being believed in. And they saved me from you." said Jack.

"Ha! Is that so? You all still think that there's no such thing as the boogeyman?!" Pitch shouted as he releases a massive force of black sand towards everyone. "I do believe in you. But, I'm not afraid of you." said Twilight. Just as when the black sand touched her horn, it immediately turned into golden sand. The mane six and the Guardians were shocked at this. "What just happened?" Twilight asked. "You conquered your fear of Pitch. Which destroys the fear inside you." North replied.

"Come on, every pony! Let's kick Pitch's butt!" Rainbow Dash shouted as she begins to fight off the nightmare horses. The rest of Ponyville joins her by touching each of the nightmare horses, turning them into golden sand. "Well, it looks like no one is afraid of Pitch anymore." said Jack. "Neither are you." said Twilight.

To make the battle more interesting, North brought out his yetis and elves to join in while Bunny summons his statue eggs. "Oh yeah!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "One set of confetti for you and another set of confetti for you!" Pinkie shouted as she shoots confetti at the nightmare horses, making them turn into golden sand. Applejack keeps bucking on the nightmare horses without a sweat while Twilight and Rarity zap them with their magic.

During the fight, Jack sees Pitch trying to escape and chases after him. "Guys, Pitch is getting away!" he shouted. "Then, let's get him!" Bunny shouted as he follows Jack. "Right behind you!" North shouted as he joins Bunny. "Oh, come on. Give me a break." said Pitch as he defends himself with his black sand. But, he was stopped when Twilight zaps him with her magic.

"Good job, Twilight. Now, let's finish him!" Rainbow Dash shouted as she joins the fight. Pitch keeps throwing black sand at them, but they defended themselves with it while the Guardians were fighting him. "Ho Ho Ho!" Bunny shouted as he threw his boomerangs at the boogeyman. "Take that, you bully!" Pinkie shouted as she shoots confetti at him with his party cannon.

As Pitch tries to run away from them, Twilight tackles him to the ground and uses her magic to keep him still. "Now, we've got him." she said. "You think this is over?" Pitch asked as he breaks free and backs away. "It is over, Pitch. And there's no place to hide." said Jack. Pitch actually did hide in the shadows and appears right behind Jack, holding him hostage by covering his mouth and bonding his wrists.

"Jack!" North shouted. "Let him go, Pitch!" Twilight shouted. "Nobody move. Or the boy dies." Pitch warned. But suddenly, a rope of golden sand grabs the boogeyman and drags him away from Jack. "Jack, are you ok?" Rainbow Dash asked. "Yeah, I'm fine." Jack replied. The figure that saves Jack from Pitch was none other than Sandy. "Is that who I think it is?" Applejack asked in awe. "It's Sandy! He's come back to us." said Rarity.

Sandy easily defeated Pitch by punching him and knocking him unconscious with his sweet dreams. The mane six and the Guardians rushed to The Sandman to reunite with him. "Oh, Sandy. We missed you so much." said Fluttershy as she hugs him. "Now, we're going to get good dreams from now on." said Applejack. Rainbow Dash saw what happened to Pitch and was laughing out loud. "Look at Pitch! He's out like a light!" she laughed. Jack laughed with her.

Everyone in Ponyville cheered for the Guardians and the mane six for defeating Pitch. "Look, Jack! Everyone loves you!" Pinkie shouted. "They sure do, and I've found my center." said Jack. "Indeed you did, Jack. And it suits you." said Twilight. "Yes, fun is a pretty good center for a Guardian." said North. "Well, speaking of fun. Think fast!" Rainbow Dash shouted as she threw a snowball at Jack. "Oh, its on!" Jack shouted as he threw a snowball at Rainbow Dash.

And then, everyone else joins in the snowball fight. While Sandy begins to create anything beautiful with his golden sand like rays, butterflies, and dinosaurs. "Whoa, that is cool." said Applejack. Sandy made an apple tree made out of golden sand just for her. "Aw, thanks Sandy." said Applejack.

When Pitch woke up, he was furious that everyone is happy instead of being scared. "No! No! You all need to be feared! I am the boogeyman! Fear me!" he shouted. But, the ponies don't see him anymore as they ran right through him. "No!" Pitch shouted as he holds himself.

The mane six and the Guardians confronted him once again as he make a run for it. But, Applejack stopped him with her rope. "Where do you think you're going?" she asked. "Leaving the party so soon?" North asked. "And you didn't even say goodbye." said Tooth as she gives Pitch a quarter. "A quarter?" Pitch asked. "Pinkie, will you do the honors?" Tooth asked. "Certainly." Pinkie replied as she punches the boogeyman in the face, knocking his tooth out. Pitch held his mouth in pain. "That's for kidnapping me!" Pinkie shouted. "And this is for trying to kill Jack!" Rainbow Dash shouted as she kicks Pitch in the stomach.

"There will always be fear." said Pitch. "So what? As long as one pony believes, we will always be there to protect that pony." said North. "Even if it's more than one." said Rarity. "And even if it's the mane six." said Bunny.

"Oh really? Then, what are they doing here?" Pitch asked as he gestures the nightmare horses. "Don't look at me, I'm not afraid." said Rainbow Dash. "Not me." said Applejack. "Me either." said Fluttershy. "It's your fear they're smelling." said Jack. "You better run for your life!" Pinkie shouted.

Soon after, the nightmare horses chased after Pitch and dragged him all the way down to his lair. "Oh my Celestia." Twilight muttered. "NOOOOOO!" Pitch shouted as he was locked away in his lair forever.

Pitch Black will no longer harm anyone in Equestria ever again.