Things have gotten worse for the mane six and the Guardians. Because Easter was ruined. They tried everything to keep every pony happy, but nothing worked due to the fear and darkness harming them. And worst of all, they stopped believing in Bunny.

"I'm still here, you guys. Here, I have some eggs. I know they're not the best, but they can do no good." Bunny pleaded. The ponies didn't listen to him nor could they hear him. "There's no such thing as the Easter Bunny." Lyra said as she walked through Bunny, meaning she doesn't see him. Bunny was in shock and dropped to his knees in grief. "She didn't see me. None of them could see me." he said in tears. "Bunny!" Fluttershy shouted as she reached towards him to comfort him.

"That was our last chance, and now it's gone!" said Twilight. "We still have Christmas to spread." said North. "But what if it doesn't work?" Twilight asked in worrisome. "Yeah. Pitch has destroyed everything we've made to keep you guys alive." said Applejack. "He even broke our spirits. It hurts so much." said Rarity as she holds herself.

And then, Jack Frost arrived and flew towards everyone to see what Pitch has done to them. "Jack, there you are. We were worried sick!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "I'm too late, aren't I?" Jack asked. "Oh, you should've seen it. Pitch's nightmares destroyed everything. The eggs have smashed, none of them made it to the surface." North explained. "And they destroyed every chocolate bunny Pinkie and I made." said Applejack.

"Speaking of Pinkie, where is she?" Twilight asked. Jack stammered at her question because he doesn't want to hurt her feelings. "Jack, where is Pinkie Pie? She was with you!" Twilight shouted. Jack sighed in grief and replied, "Pitch has her." The mane six and the Guardians gasped in shock at the answer. "You were with Pitch? Why?" Fluttershy asked. "Look, I'm sorry. He trapped me and Pinkie. I didn't know what to do. I'm sorry." said Jack.

"WE SHOULD NEVER HAVE TRUSTED YOU!" Bunny shouted. "Bunny!" Fluttershy pleaded. "No! Ever since Jack came with us, he made things worse! We're better off without him!" Bunny shouted. "You can't say that. Jack didn't do anything wrong, and it's not his fault that your holiday got destroyed." said Twilight. "She's right. Blame Pitch on all of this!" said Rainbow Dash. Bunny didn't listen to anything they said and left. "You know what? I'm done." he said as he leaves.

"Bunny, don't leave." said Fluttershy. "Oh no. What have I done?" Jack asked himself. "Jack, it wasn't your fault. We can fix this." Applejack promised. "It is my fault! And we can't fix it either! The Guardians are dying because of me! That's why I don't want to be a Guardian, because I mess things up! I ruin everything! And I ruined Equestria." Jack shouted in tears. "No, you didn't. Pitch did." said Applejack. "Pitch had always wanted me, and his obsession has been in the way ever since!" Jack shouted. "Its ok, Jack. Please, don't be hard on yourself." Applejack pleaded.

"I'm sorry, girls. I can't do this anymore." said Jack as he was about to leave. "Jack, don't leave! We need you!" Twilight pleaded. "You don't need me. You heard what Bunny said, I only made things worse." said Jack. "He didn't mean it. He was just upset that his holiday got ruined." said Fluttershy. "Goodbye, girls." said Jack as he flew away, never turning back. "Jack, come back! Jack! JACK!" Twilight shouted.

"Oh no, he ran off. I can't believe he blamed himself for what happened." said Tooth. "I wish that kangaroo was nicer to him, that way Jack would've felt more welcome to you guys!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "And I wish Pitch would never be obsessed with him." said Rarity. "Poor Jack. He was like a son to me." said North. "Now, what do we do? Christmas is our only option left." said Applejack. "The only thing we have to do now is to make presents and cookies. That's it." said North.

"But, what about Jack and Pinkie? They're still out there, scared and alone." Rainbow Dash asked. "Maybe you should go find them and bring them back safely. But, be very careful." said Twilight. "I will." Rainbow Dash promised as she flew off to find her missing friends.

The others went back to the North Pole in order to spread Christmas before it's too late.

...

When they got there, they immediately went straight to work with the presents and the cookies.

Fluttershy did the toy making with North, Rarity was wrapping presents, Applejack was making the cookies, and Twilight had to keep an eye on the globe and organize everything.

While doing this, Twilight noticed that most of the lights on the globe have gone out and she completely freaked out. "No! NO! NOOOO!" she yelled. North heard her shouting and came to her aid. "Twilight, what's wrong?" he asked. "The lights. Most of them are all out." Twilight replied. "Oh, I can feel it too." said North as he starts collapsing.

Twilight gasped in horror and shouted, "North!" "This is what happens when the ponies stop believing in us Guardians." said North. "Oh, North. I'm so sorry." Twilight said in tears. "Twilight, don't cry. You've got to be strong for the Guardians. I'll be fine. I'll regain my strength once Equestria starts believing again." said North.

Applejack and Rarity entered the room and saw what happened. "Oh no. Equestria has now fully turned into a living nightmare." said Applejack. "I feel so bad for everyone suffering from those dreadful dreams Pitch has given them." said Rarity. "I'll say. I couldn't even fall asleep ever since I saw that creep." said Applejack. "How's everything going, guys?" Twilight asked. "Well, the cookies are doing just fine. Made them with sugar, gingerbread, and snickerdoodle." Applejack replied. "And the presents are looking so divine with nice wrapping paper and glittering bows." Rarity replied.

"That's great. But, North is already getting weak." said Twilight. "Don't worry, I'm okay. I just need some rest." said North. "Oh no, that's dreadful. Tooth is suffering from the same thing. She couldn't fly properly and her feathers are coming off." said Rarity. "And I haven't seen Bunny ever since the ponies stopped believing in him. I hope Rainbow Dash finds Jack Frost soon, we really need him right now." said Applejack. "She's going to find Pinkie Pie too. I hope she doesn't get hurt." said Rarity.

"Oh, I hope they're ok." said Twilight as she watches the lights flickering on the globe.

...

Meanwhile, Rainbow Dash is searching for Jack Frost on a deserted land of ice and snow.

"Jack! Jack! Jack, where are you?!" she shouted. She looked everywhere, from the rocks, to the hills, and even in caves. While she was continuing her search, Rainbow Dash started to feel cold. Probably because she's been out in the snow too long without anything to keep herself warm. "I better hurry before I catch a cold." she said to herself.

Finally, Rainbow Dash has found Jack on the edge of a cliff still angry at himself. "Jack!" she called out. Jack heard her voice and turned around. "Rainbow Dash? What are you doing here?" he asked. "I came to find you. Come on, we've got to go home." Rainbow Dash replied. "Rainbow Dash, you have to leave." Jack warned. "Why? Jack, what's going on?" Rainbow Dash asked in worrisome.

Then all of the sudden, Pitch appeared right behind them. "I thought that this would happen. I never really believed in him. I was just trying to show him what it is like. But, I understand." he said. Jack immediately attacked Pitch with his staff and shouted, "You don't understand anything!" "I know what it's like to be casted out!" Pitch shouted as he defended himself with his black sand. Angered, Jack made a massive blow on the Boogeyman. Rainbow Dash ducked and covered during the fight.

Pitch defended himself with black sand once more and it caused some dust to be spread. "Jack!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "I'm okay, just stay there." said Jack. Pitch appeared behind him again and said, "To not be believed in. To long for a family." "Jack has a family, and he has very good friends to stand by his side!" Rainbow Dash shouted as she came out of her hiding. "Oh, he does? Well, what if his new family abandoned him all because he ruined Easter? But, don't worry. He has someone else to take care of him." said Pitch.

"And who would that be?" Rainbow Dash asked. "You're looking at him." said Pitch as he gestured himself. "No, you can't be my new family. Besides, all you do is scare people." said Jack. "I know. But together, we can do the impossible. Look what we can do." said Pitch as he shows the boy and Rainbow Dash a huge statue made out of black sand and frost. "Oh wow." Rainbow Dash muttered. "What goes together with cold and dark? And absolutely everything will be." said Pitch.

"Pitch Black?" Jack asked as he interpreted the Boogeyman. "And Jack Frost too. They'll believe in both of us." Pitch suggested. "No, they'll fear both of us. And that's not what I want." said Jack. "Yeah, that's right. All Jack wanted is friendship." said Rainbow Dash. "Well, I'm his friend. I'm the only friend he's ever had." said Pitch. "We're not friends, Pitch! Now, for the last time! Leave me alone!" Jack shouted as was about to leave with Rainbow Dash.

Pitch was stunned by the answer, and was angered by the fact Jack chose the mane six over him. "I've always liked you, Jack. Ever since I saw you wondering around, wanting to be seen. In fact, I was the first person to ever see you. But, you kept running away from me all because you don't like my nightmares! So, I continue to give you nightmares in order for you to join me. In conclusion, I've always wanted you to be mine." he said.

Jack stopped and turned around. "What you did all those years ago is wrong. You never gave me love or friendship. I chose the mane six for a reason. They are the ones that gave me what I need the most." he said as he stood by next to Rainbow Dash. "Fine, you want to be with the ponies. Done. But, first." said Pitch as he pulled out a familiar face in his grasp.

It was Pinkie Pie being strangled by the Boogeyman. "PINKIE PIE!" Jack and Rainbow Dash shouted as they tried to get to her. But, Pitch stopped them. "Let her go, Pitch!" Rainbow Dash shouted. Pitch saw her and uses his black sand to capture her by tying her up. "Rainbow Dash!" Jack shouted as he prepares to attack the Boogeyman with his staff, but was once again stopped. "The staff, Jack!" Pitch demanded. "Or what?" Jack asked. "If you do, I'll let them go." Pitch replied as he pets Pinkie's mane.

"Jack. Don't." Pinkie pleaded as she was still strangled. Pitch shook her violently to keep her quiet. "Stop it! No wonder why Jack doesn't want to join you!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "So, who do you like better Jack? Rainbow Dash or Pinkie Pie?" he teased. "Just let them go! They've had enough of you harming them!" Jack pleaded. "Give me the staff then." Pitch demanded.

Not wanting to lose his friends, Jack gave Pitch his staff. "Now, let them go!" Jack shouted. "No." Pitch replied coldly. "What?" Jack asked angrily. "You want to be alone. So, be alone!" Pitch shouted as he throws Pinkie into a deep ice hole. "No! Pinkie!" Jack shouted. But then, Pitch snapped his staff in half. Jack yelled in pain as he held himself because the staff was connected to him. "JACK!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "I've had enough of you getting in my way, Rainbow Dash." Pitch shouted as he throws her into the ice hole with Pinkie.

"No! Stop! You've done enough!" Jack pleaded. Pitch picks him up and held him in his arms. Then, he drops Jack into the ice hole along with Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie. He laughed evilly and threw away the staff at them before he left. Jack got very weak from the fall and the fact that his staff is broken. So much so that he couldn't stand up. "Jack." Pinkie called out. "Pinkie! Rainbow Dash! Are you two alright?" Jack asked. "Ugh, I've been through worse." Rainbow Dash replied as she rubs her head. "He gave me so many nightmares. They're not going away. They're not going away!" Pinkie cried.

"Oh, it's ok Pinkie. You're safe now." said Jack as he embraces his friend. Pinkie yelped at his touch and sneezed. "Bless you." said Rainbow Dash. "Sorry, all I do is to keep you cold." said Jack. "I'm cold too. Hopefully I won't get sick after this." said Rainbow Dash. "Pitch was right. I make a mess out of everything." said Jack. "No, he's wrong. Besides, he doesn't even know the real you." said Rainbow Dash.

But suddenly, Jack begins to feel pain and laid down on the cold floor. "Jack, are you ok?" Pinkie asked. "Pitch broke my staff. That's why I'm like this." Jack groaned in pain. "Oh no. I'm so sorry. I wish I wasn't afraid of Pitch." said Pinkie. "We were all afraid of Pitch. You should see Twilight, she's been getting panic attacks ever since he gave her nightmares." said Rainbow Dash. "Maybe you should get some rest, Jack. You'll feel much better." said Pinkie. "Ok, I'll do that." said Jack as he leans his head and closed his eyes. Pinkie and Rainbow Dash held each other to keep themselves warm.

A few hours later, Jack's tooth box began glowing and the familiar voice was heard once more. He woke up by the sound and pulled it out of his pocket. "Hey, is that your tooth box?" Rainbow Dash asked. "Yes, it is. But, why is it glowing like that?" Jack asked. "Maybe you should open it and see what's inside." Pinkie replied.

So, Jack opened his tooth box and saw his past memories with Pinkie and Rainbow Dash

...

(flashback)

It was when Jack was a human boy with brown hair and brown eyes, and he had a little sister.

He had always play tricks, make kids laugh, and knows how to have fun. One day, he took his sister out to go ice skating. But, the ice was too thin as it begins cracking underneath their feet.

"It's ok. It's ok. Don't look down, just look at me." said Jack. "Jack, I'm scared." his sister said as the ice starts cracking underneath her feet. "I know. I know. You're gonna be alright. We're gonna have a little fun instead." Jack promised. "No, we're not." his sister said. "Are you sure?" Jack asked. "Yes, you always play tricks." his sister said. "Not this time. I promise." said Jack.

"You wanna play a game? We'll play hopscotch. See? One. Two. Three." said Jack as he hops on one foot to get to safety. His sister was laughing the whole time. "Now, it's your turn. One. That's it. Two. You're getting there. Three." said Jack as he pulls his sister away from the cracked ice and into safety.

They both laughed until Jack had fallen into the ice and immediately drowned. "JACK!" his sister shouted. The Man in The Moon was there when it happened and decided to turn the boy into Jack Frost.

(end flashback)

...

Jack, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkie Pie were shocked about the flashback.

"Did you see that?" Jack asked. "I did. You used to be a human, but then you died saving that girl." said Rainbow Dash. "And The Man in The Moon brought you back to life." said Pinkie. "So what's why the moon chose me. I'm a Guardian. IM A GUARDIAN!" Jack shouted in happiness as he hugged Rainbow Dash and Pinkie. "I knew you have it in you." said Rainbow Dash.

"We have to get out of here." said Jack. "But, what about your staff?" Rainbow Dash asked. Jack noticed it and picks it up, trying to put it back together with his frost. And it worked. "Yeah, now you're talking!" Pinkie shouted. "Now, let's go help the Guardians!" Rainbow Dash shouted.

"Come on, girls. We have Equestria to save." said Jack as he flew out of the ice cave with Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie in excitement.