"Hey everypony!" Pinkie Pie said, opening the basement door. "Look who I found." she said, pushing Fluttershy in.
"NO!" yelled Rainbow Dash and Rarity.
"Let her go!" Rainbow Dash yelled.
Fluttershy saw the state that Rainbow Dash was in and tears started to form in her eyes.
"Let her go?" asked Pinkie Pie. "So she can miss out on all the fun?"
Rarity looked at the straps that held her in place. Unlike Rainbow Dash's, hers were just plain rope. She pulled as she could. She could feel the rope starting to feel lose.
"I wonder how long Fluttershy will last." said Pinkie Pie, holding the scalpel in front of Fluttershy's face.
Fluttershy let out a whimper. Pinkie Pie movd the scalpel closer.
"Leave... her..." The ropes snapped. "ALONE!" Rarity leaped at Pinkie Pie and knocked her away from Fluttershy.
Pinkie Pie looked over Rarity. Her smile had faded and her eyes had narrowed. Her mane was also now hanging flat and not poofy like usual. Her skin tone also got a little darker.
"YOU!" Pinkie Pie (now Pinkamena) said.
Rarity looked at Fluttershy. "Run!"
Fluttershy started to move towards the door. Pinkamena brought her hoof to a button on the wall. She was waiting for the right moment to push it. Rainbow Dash saw what Pinkie was doing and thought about it for a second.
"Fluttershy! Wait!" Rainbow Dash yelled.
Fluttershy didn't hear her. She continued for the door. As she was almost out Pinkamena pressed the button. The door slammed shut and whacked Fluttershy in the face. She tumbled backwards and lay on the floor. She tried to stand up and saw a red puddle forming on the floor. She reached a hoof up to her nose and felt blood. She brought her hoof down and saw red. Her nose and all around her mouth was covered in blood.
"FLUTTERSHY!" yelled Rainbow Dash.
Rarity trotted over to her.
"Fluttershy?" asked Rarity. "You okay?"
Fluttershy said nothing. She just stared at the blood on the floor. Just then Rarity felt a knife in her hip, right by her cutie mark. She fell to the floor, pain shooting through her body. The knife was still inside her. She tried to stand but it hurt too much. Pinkamena stood in front of Fluttershy and held a knife up to her face.
"Don't try anything." said Pinkamena. "You behave and I MIGHT let you live."

Pinkamena lowered the knife and left the room. The ponies weren't going anywhere soon. Rainbow Dash was still strapped down, Rarity's hip was injured so she couldn't walk, and Fluttershy was too scared to move.