Holding in emotions is never good. Keep them buried for too long, and eventually they burst out at the wrong time. Both Rarity and Rainbow Dash have a secret they have been hiding from their friends, specifically from a certain shy, animal-loving pegasus mare. They've finally decided to come clean, but neither of them counted on the other revealing the truth, much less at the same time.
Now Fluttershy is stuck with an impossible choice between her two best friends. Can she choose one without risking her friendship with the other?
"Sex" tag due to innuendo and suggestive material. No actual sex happens in this story.
Author's Note: Many, many thanks to Steel Resolve and Karrakaz for pre-reading and letting me know when I screw up. Now with new cover art, courtesy of johnhilist over at deviantart.
33 Chapters:
-
Working Up Courage [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Jul 11th, 2013
5,076
-
The Shocking Truth [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Sep 29th, 2014
4,796
-
On the Fence [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Oct 28th, 2013
6,505
-
Rigging the Game [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Dec 26th, 2013
5,142
-
Hindsight [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
May 17th, 2013
1,753
-
The Grass is Always Greener... [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Dec 9th, 2013
4,963
-
...On the Other Side of the Fence [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Apr 3rd, 2013
5,064
-
Tough Decisions [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Apr 3rd, 2013
6,386
-
Coming Clean [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Nov 8th, 2013
2,257
-
Dressing Up [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Apr 3rd, 2013
2,493
-
Out on the Town [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Apr 3rd, 2013
5,240
-
Cheering Up [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Jan 25th, 2014
5,275
-
This Day is Going to Be Perfect [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Sep 29th, 2014
12,522
-
And Now, Back to Our Regularly Scheduled Programming [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Aug 23rd, 2013
8,062
-
Expected Confections [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Apr 3rd, 2013
8,106
-
The Cat's Out of the Bag [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Mar 2nd, 2014
4,700
-
A Comforting Touch [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Nov 8th, 2013
4,325
-
Getting Burned [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Jul 19th, 2013
4,514
-
Two of a Kind [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Apr 24th, 2013
6,155
-
Whiny Little Birch [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Nov 8th, 2013
5,240
-
Dressed for Success [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Nov 8th, 2013
5,211
-
Mending Fences [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Aug 14th, 2013
10,353
-
Blast From the Past [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Jul 31st, 2013
8,333
-
Making Up for Lost Time [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Jan 23rd, 2015
9,768
-
Fallen [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Sep 29th, 2014
8,410
-
The Mare of Her Dreams [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Oct 21st, 2013
10,843
-
The Forest for the Trees [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Sep 29th, 2014
9,742
-
Problem Solvent [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Sep 29th, 2014
8,858
-
Gone Clubbin' [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Feb 3rd, 2014
7,153
-
Making a Change [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Apr 15th, 2014
7,106
-
Test Drive [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
May 18th, 2014
10,647
-
I've Been Through the Dessert [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Feb 10th, 2015
6,835
-
Winding Down [Fimfiction.net] [Cache]
Jun 22nd, 2015
6,441