“Oof! Oo-S-Sonata,” Fluttershy struggled to wheeze, though notably smiling from the welcomed display of affection from her roommate. A girl who was currently in the midst of wrapping her arms in a snake-like hug around Fluttershy’s entire body from the side, lifting her off the ground with a shocking amount of strength.

“I’m soooooooOOOOOOooooooo glad you’re okay!! And not just okay, you passed your initiation! Against Rising Star of all guys! You’re one of us now! I’m so happy I could cry!!” Sonata wailed.

“Ummmm, you are crying,” Fluttershy noted, giving a small comforting pat to the girl’s hip. That being all she could manage seeing as her arms were locked in place by the siren’s embrace.

“N-no I’m not!” Sonata cried, finally breaking her hug to wipe the tears from her eyes. Fluttershy gave a relieved sigh of relief as circulation finally returned to her lower arms. “I swear, from here on out, bestie, it’s going to be nothing but smooth sailing for you… And Rarity too! You’re both part of our family now. Now and forever. Forever until the end of time!”

“I’m not going to lie… it does kind of excite me more and more,” Fluttershy replied with a thrilled smile and flushed cheeks. To her, this one mansion was an endless supply of possibilities. There were new friends to make, new friendships to flourish, and new sexual life lessons to learn. “And… thank you for believing in me, Sonata. I don’t think I would have made it if you didn’t give me your support…”

Sonata didn’t respond. Sonata couldn’t respond. Fluttershy could see the girl was merely getting a grip on herself until her comment, which caused the siren’s face to break down into free flowing tears again, collapsing to her knees on the floor. Opps. Thankfully for Sonata, a knocking was heard at the door. “A d-d-distraction! Perfect!” Sonata garbled out. She swung open the door, while at the same time, using it to wedge herself between it and the corner of the room, giving her something resembling privacy as she let her tears of joy flow freely.

This left Fluttershy alone to face who entered. It was girls. And a lot of them at that. Considering the blindfold she had worn whenever she left the room, Fluttershy hadn’t seen any of them here before! But that wasn’t to say they hadn’t seen her. All of them stood front and center, smiling warmly at their new sister, clad in nothing more than their sheer bras, panties, and individual pet collars. Their complete lack of clothing and readiness to leave little to the imagination made it readily obvious of the similar body types they shared. Skinny, slender, lithe, petite… with even the smallest of their breast sizes still being fairly above average. All of the school girls would easily be able to be classified from cute to hot to even beautiful. Fluttershy wasn’t really surprised, seeing as the mansion did set rather high standards on who they asked to join.

“Welcome, Fluttershy,” none other than Fleur De Lis greeted warmly, extending her arms out wide and embracing their newest member in a full hug. Fluttershy was taken aback for a second before she returned it as warmly as it was given, having a stark feeling she was going to be hugged out by the end of the day. While Fluttershy might not have gone to the same school as her, she was already quite familiar with Fleur. The up and coming Crystal Prep beauty was an idol in the modeling business, having made several front page features in a number of trendy magazines. It was almost humbling to be in the presence of a real life super model. “A little birdie told us you passed your initiation. So we just wanted to stop by to officially welcome you to the family.” Sonata was heard squeaking out a soft “yay” from behind the door before going right back to sobbing. The others didn't react to the sound of crying. Apparently they knew Sonata quite well.

“We’re all in this together,” Octavia added, with a hug of her own. “If you need anything, don’t be afraid to ask any of us.”

“T-thank you!” Fluttershy beamed with her trademarked heart warming smile. As if she needed anymore reinforcement to her decision on living here. “I wasn’t expecting something like this.”

“Oh yeah, and I already added your number to our group chat,” Juniper Montage said, the Crystal Prepper tapping into her phone. “We talk in there sometimes, but it’s mostly used to share all of the pics and vids of us to everyone else living here. Just remember to keep it to yourself. We don’t really want everyone at our schools knowing we exist if we didn’t invite them.”

“I mean, yeah,” Cloudy Kicks added with an annoyed grimace as she imagined the situation. “If they all knew, we would have to board this place up like the world outside was a zombie apocalypse. Everyone we know would probably be tearing down the door to try and get some action with us.”

“But... speaking of getting some action…” another spoke seductively as Fluttershy felt two pairs of hands slowly sliding up her arms from behind. Lighthoof and Shimmy Shake… the twin cheer leading sisters of Crystal Prep. They were here together?!

“You slept with him! Tell us!” Shimmy Shake begged, her personal specialty. “What was he like in bed?!?!?!” she spoke as if too afraid to utter the man’s name.

“You mean… Rising Star? My master?” Fluttershy asked innocently. Shimmy Shake and Lighthoof both flinched, but swallowed their fear and nodded.

“Personally, I’d rather deal with all of my classmates trying to break down our front door to get at us than spend an hour in a locked room with Rising Star,” Octavia muttered, the others nodding in agreement. “Do tell… how ever did you survive such an ordeal?”

“And in one piece too!” Juniper added, noticing that Fluttershy was still standing firmly on her own two slender legs. Along with her mind seeming perfectly intact, not rendered in a vegetable-like or insane state after suffering more orgasmic pleasure than any human should be able to endure at one time.

Sonata too, poked her tear-stained eyes out from behind the door, curious as to how her best friend beat the impossible odds.

“W-welllllll….” Fluttershy stammered slowly with a nervous blush. The other underwear-clad pet girls leaned in closer, rife with anticipation. She remembered the predicament Rising Star had confessed to her. How his status as a living Sex God was all a fabrication crafted by rumors that had been spread by his collective peers. All of them adding to the myth and legends of his sexual deeds, but not a single one of them knowing enough to see through the lies. She didn’t want to be the one to spoil the secret her master desperately wanted kept… but she didn’t want to lie either. “He was… he was… very gentle with me. He knew it was my first time, after all. He seemed to know exactly what I wanted and he-”

“Holy crap!! He can hear your thoughts!?!” Lighthoof exclaimed out loud.

“Well, ummm, I don’t think-” Fluttershy added before being interrupted again.

“Ordinarily I wouldn’t think it’s possible to perform such a feat… but he is no ordinary man. It is certainly a possibility he can read our minds,” Fleur noted, stroking her chin in deep thought. “Though likely it is an ability that Rising Star can only perform on women. After all, he is the man to who knows our bodies better than we do ourselves…”

“It would certainly explain how he manages the upper hand on every girl he beds,” Octavia nodded. “All of his partner’s lusts or desires are easily obtained by him and taken full advantage of. As if his cock wasn’t dangerous enough on its own.”

“This is incredible…” Juniper spoke, wasting no time as she texted the juicy details of gossip to every girl friend she knew.

“What else can you tell us, Fluttershy!” Lighthoof urged, shaking the new joiner. “Spill the details!”

“Yeah! How many gallons of cum did he pump out?” Shimmy Shake asked desperately. “Did your stomach bloat up like a balloon? Did you almost drown?”

“Were you pushed to the brink of death by his cock then brought back to life by the same cock?!?” Octavia added.

“And how long was Bitch-Tamer?!” Cloudy Kicks asked. “I can get a conversion table because I know you can only answer in metric units…”

“G-girls…” Fluttershy fearfully stammered as her new family of horny school girls slowly closed in on her, bombarding her with an endless array of perverted questions. “I-I don’t think he would want me to tell you everything about him.”

“Oh pish posh!” Octavia scoffed. “We are perfectly capable of keeping secrets. How would he ever know you said anything?”

The room of girls instantly came to a halting silence as a sudden realization hit them like a load of bricks. Rising Star… the female mind reader. Was there a range to this power? Was the fabled man in another room listening in on their gossip?! They could picture him, smirking to himself as he wrote each of their names down after showing such interest in his sexual reputation. His next targets and conquests. Girls who had fallen for his trap hook, line, and sinker.

“Y-y-you’re right. He’s a-actually pretty ugly now that I think about it. Probably not that impressive downstairs either.” Cloudy Kick stammered as the others ran from the room in a fearful skip. “Alright bye!”

“Yeah, probably! I don't know who would want to sleep with him! See ya, Fluttershy!”

“Later!”

“Buh bye!”

“Au revoir!” Fleur panickedly spilled out as she too left in a hurry.

“Wait-what?” Fluttershy replied, but her room was empty once more.

“That was weird…” Sonata pouted, peeking out from behind the door as she watched the bubbly butts bounce away as the girls dramatically ran for their very lives. She stepped back over to her friend, noticing that Fluttershy seemed to be struck with a solemn silence of sort as she stared at the floor. “Uhhh, is everything okay, bestie?”

“N-no…” Fluttershy muttered while shaking before looking up at her sternly. She needed to get something off of her chest. “Do you think…. you could keep a big secret?”

Ordinarily Sonata would have jumped for joy upon hearing that, knowing Fluttershy was willing to trust her with something so important just proved how close they really were. But she held herself back, seeing her friend seemed rather serious in the moment. They would be a time for celebrations later. Well additional celebrations to the ones she already had planned.

“S-Sure!” Sonata replied with struggled casualness, her heart not being able to stop itself from racing. “Well… I mean, I guess I could keep one from anyone besides Rising Star. If he really can read our minds!”

“A-actually… it is about him” Fluttershy admitted timidly. This only sweetened the pot for Sonata, in more ways than one.

“Okay, fine. Dish already!” Sonata gushed, bouncing on her heels.

Fluttershy did a quick double take around the room, making sure they were alone. “W-wait here…” she whispered before slipping outside. Leaving a puzzled Sonata to tilt her head in confusion.

A few minutes had passed, leaving Sonata to do nothing but pace circles around the bedroom as she waited, wondering what big secret Fluttershy had about a living sex god. Was he secretly immortal? And if so, did his sperm share the gift of immortality? It would certainly be an ironic twist of fate, sleeping with one as dangerous as Rising Star would, in turn, allow one a longer life. But at what cost? Maybe Rising was just that kind of twisted god. Still, even with that benefit given, it didn’t mean Sonata was willing to be one to sleep with him. In fact, she didn’t want to be anywhere near him!

Suddenly, she heard the bedroom door close and lock behind her. Sonata pivoted to find Fluttershy had returned... only to learn… she wasn’t quite alone.

She was with………………………. HIM!

Rising Star… the man of legend himself, holding the hand of her best friend. He stared directly at her scantily-clad body. For the first time in her life, Sonata was the sole focus of a God’s attention…

No…

No!

NO!

NO!!

This was bad! This was really really bad! Sonata wanted to slap herself. Of course Rising Star’s legendary lust hadn’t yet been sated! He had just lulled them into a fall sense of security to make them drop their guard! He was back for another round! The second of many! And there was no way her bestie could survive another go with him!

Before either the master or his pet could speak up, Fluttershy was pushed to the wall in a sudden surge of motion. Rising Star was likewise shoved at the bunk bed with a surprising amount of strength, falling onto the mattress.

“RUN!! Get out of here, Fluttershy!!!” Sonata yelled. With swiftness that could only match that of a lewd ninja Sonata unhooked and slipped her bra off in a flash, pouncing atop Rising Star before he could push himself up. “I’ll hold him off!!! Don’t look back! Just run!” she growled fiercely while cupping the underside of her breasts and mashing the pillowy titflesh directly into Rising’s startled face. “Come on, big guy! I’m the one you want! Not her!” She grit her teeth as she attempted to pull attention off her attractive friend. Her skin had already been in direct contact with him for a few seconds! It was only a matter of time before the tremors of her first orgasm started to whittle away at her precious sanity. He wasn’t even making a move to unsheathe his Bitch-Tamer. As if taunting her that he didn’t even need his cock to reduce her to a trembling moaning mess of flesh on the floor. He could probably do so with as little as the tip of his pinkie finger.

“Ummmmmm… Sonata…?” Fluttershy was heard asking, tapping on her shoulder from behind. Not appearing to share the smallest amount of panic and fear Sonata held.

“W-Wha-why are you still here? Run! Go!!” Sonata exclaimed, frantically waving her off. Was her sacrifice doomed from the start? Was Fluttershy already enamored by Rising’s sexual presence?! Had she already been rendered a mindless thrall?!

“I-I don’t really know how to say this…” Fluttershy started, pushing her two index fingers together shamefully, “but… everything everyone is saying about Rising Star are all made up rumors.”

…

…

…

…

…

Sonata turned back to face the high school student, of which, her bare tits were still currently smothering. Double taking back to Fluttershy then back to Rising Star again.

…

…

…

…

…

“Whhhhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat?” Sonata spoke finally.

“He’s actually just a sweet guy!” Fluttershy confessed. “He was actually brand new to sex like I was, and so, I guess, we ummmm, kind of… just hit it off.”

“So… ummmph, is this how all of the girls in this mansion greet guys?” Rising Star asked in a muffled voice, still covered with a faceful of Sonatatits.

Sonata withdrew her breasts from Rising’s face as she sat up on the bed. “No way… I could have sworn I saw him do something… Or at least do something to someone… I heard it from everyone.”

“Yeah-yeah, it’s all fake,” Rising sighed. “But please don’t tell everyone because I’m so deep into it it would ruin my life if this truth actually got out now. So you have to keep it a secret, alright? Fluttershy told me we could trust you and you could help her with that. Deal?” he asked, holding out his hand for her to shake.

“Y-you really aren’t a sex god,” Sonata pouted as she saw his extended hand. Not just that, he really was a rookie to everything! She quickly grabbed his wrist as she prepared a lecture. “First of all, mister, you’re a guy in this mansion. Don’t ask a pet to do something! Tell me too! And no serious hand shakeys either! Just pet my head!” She plopped his hand down atop her hair as she adorably braced herself up on her two arms. Sonata released a soft shudder of excitement. Both from being pet but also from talking down to Rising Star in such a manner. Sure, he may have been a fake, but it still felt so naughty!

Meanwhile Rising was only left wondering if every girl here were so ridiculously stacked like this blue haired one. It was practically a surreal dream! This place was just one beautifully busty girl willing to fuck after the other. Well, maybe not so much fuck him, in particular. Fluttershy clapped excitedly seeing that her roomie and her master were hitting it off. Sonata was bound to help her keep her master’s secret safe. Plus, it just felt wrong keeping such a secret from her friend. And now her lover had one more adorable pet to play with!

“Let me go find Rarity next,” Fluttershy pondered, turning to the door. “She might have a better idea of how to handle this if we let her in on the secret…” She slipped outside, Sonata and Rising both watching her go.

“You know… I guess it was kind of a good thing you weren’t the sex god everyone said you were, heeheh,” Sonata giggled gleefully, turning back to face him. Still not even bothering to conceal her chest from his gaze. “I mean, for your sake and all.”

“For my sake? Ummm, what do you mean by that exactly?” Rising asked.

“Oh, I just mean if you actually had hurt my best friend in the entire world, I was like, totally planning on killing you,” she chuckled.

“Hah-w-wait… a-are you being serious?”

Sonata didn’t hear or didn’t answer him as she continued to giggle and skip over to the bedroom door, slipping outside to follow Fluttershy.

Okay, maybe it was seeming a bit less like a dream now...

It wasn’t hard to find Rarity. One only needed to follow the sound. The heated sound of love, lust, and debauchery, or something at least in between of all of those.

In yet another of the mansion’s many hallways gathered a group of girls around the open door of a certain bedroom. The same scantily-clad girls that had officially welcomed Fluttershy earlier ago. Though even with what little they were wearing, it wasn’t little enough for the mood they were currently in.

Octavia was gently cooing with Lighthoof’s arms wrapped around her from behind, her fingers tracing circles underneath her panties. Fleur was also seen gently moaning as Cloudy’s needy hands clung on her chest. Having pushed up the schoolgirl’s lacy bra as she played and teased her friend’s bare breasts from behind. All of them half desperate to concentrate on something else so that the suspected mind reader in the mansion didn’t think to reward their perverted thoughts of him with a lay.

It was none other than Rarity who was the sole focus of everyone in the vicinity. The set of alluring lingerie the fashionista had crafted for herself? It was gone. Torn from her slender figure and lying forgotten off the side of a rather large bed. On the bed itself was Rarity, her pristine body completely exposed from head to toe, save the collar indicating her place as an animal in the mansion. Considering it was Fluttershy’s first time seeing her fashion-oriented friend fully naked, it was even more of a shock to the timid girl seeing her current predicament.

Rarity wore a matching set of cuffs to each of her wrists, binding them firmly to the respective bedposts behind her. Her face was beat red in an uncontrollable blush, moaning happily as she sweated in exertion. Her plump ass and voluptuous breasts, on the other hand, were a different shade of red as they showed all the telltale signs of a recent rough manhandling. Her legs were bent backwards, showing a marveling amount of flexibility Fluttershy did not know her friend to possess as her ankles were held behind her head. Crystal Prep’s own Royal Pin was grinning madly at her while he held her legs back, jackhammering his thick manhood into the fashionista’s womanhood with reckless abandon. The reverberating clap of flesh on flesh contact was like a chorus of delight for the many pets listening in. From the still present sight of Rarity’s blindfold, it was almost safe to say that she was not even currently aware of who exactly was rigorously pounding away at her deepest spots, but from the wanton moans that escaped her lips she didn’t seem to care.

Also present on the bed was Coco Pommel, another honor roll student from Crystal Prep Academy, in a similar state of undress. The little vixen was smiling gleefully as she aided her master in enjoying his newest pet. As he worked Coco crawled behind the pair, taking a small rope she had held in her mouth and expertly fastening the fashionista’s ankles to her respective wrists with practiced precision. Once done, Rarity was left even more immobilized and vulnerable to the unending onslaught of thrusts, completely powerless to stop what was coming to her, not that she wanted to.

Rarity moaned with no control on volume, revealing a full display of her uncontrolled lust, completely unaware of the small crowd of female voyeurs watching her closely from the bedroom door. Or for that matter, the tripod camera to the side, aimed directly at her profile as it recorded the entire scandalous session.

Bringing an abrupt and cruel pause to his thrusts, Royal Pin spoke, “Who am I to you, pet…? Say it!” Coco quickly capitalized on the brief respite by swooping in and aggressively sucking on one of Rarity’s now non-bouncing breasts while roughly groping the other. It seemed like the two were quite an effective tag team.

“M-master! Master!!” Rarity begged. Uttering the only word she was allowed to say using the same voice as when she was being overdramatic. Though this time, she seemed a tad more serious and desperate.

“Good little slut,” Royal Pin proudly grinned at his fast learning pet, resuming his thrusts at an even quicker tempo, content on fucking the bound CHS schoolgirl into his ideal obedience. Rarity groaned lustfully in pleasure once more as the positive reinforcement lesson sank into her sex-addled mind. Sure, she was a tad disobedient to start, but most newcomers were a little rough around the edges. Now it was obvious to all she had improved her behavior compared to her first night, but there was still a ways to go. Luckily it wasn’t Royal's first time putting a high school nympho in her place. He knew exactly how to deal with girls like her.

Fluttershy was rendered utterly speechless. Her eyes wide in shock, unable to relax or look away. She thought she knew everything there was to know about Rarity. They had been extremely close friends for years! But this… it was a whole new side of her friend she didn’t even suspect existed! It was like, she was an entirely different girl!

“Wow…. props to Rarity,” Cloudy Kicks commented from the sidelines, resting her chin on Fleur’s shoulder, finding some new found respect for her fellow classmate. “I always knew she was like this deep down. Good on her for being so open with it on her first lay.”

“Not her first actually. She already passed her initiation a while ago,” Shimmy Shake giggled, “but she wanted to pass a few more times just to be sure. I bet she’s lost track of how many times she’s cum.”

“Good! I’m glad! She definitely belongs here with us,” Lighthood smirked proudly.

“Still probably nothing compared to what Rising Star put you through though, right?” Juniper playfully nudged Fluttershy’s arm with a wink.

“Ooooo, we’re finally seeing it?!” Sonata cooed, the bare-chested girl having just caught up to Fluttershy in the hall as she placed both hands on her friend’s shoulders from behind, jumping up and down with excitement. “The real Rarity coming out to play! Hehheh,” she giggled gleefully.

‘The “real” Rarity…?’ Fluttershy was left to ponder that phrase, unable to banish it from her mind.

Before she could say anything else, all eyes immediately shot to Royal Pin’s royal cock as he released a beastial grunt. His hips, once a blur of motion, now came to a sudden stop as he hilted himself inside his new human pet’s pussy. He gave out a low growl, his cock twitching madly as he unloaded a load of fresh cum directly into Rarity’s nethers. The school girl cooing and purring like a true animal in heat as her passage was pumped full of the potent rich seed. The sound of heavy breathing was all that was heard as her master kept himself in her for a while, ensuring everything he had to give was completely expelled within his pet’s depths. Only then, with a whimpering whine from his mate, did he pull out. Coco Pommel was already busy releasing the rope holding Rarity’s legs back as the mood was slowly dying down, allowing the girl to finally move them back to their normal unbent position. No sooner had she done that did Royal Pin scoot on up over her body, positioning his groin mere inches in front of her face. Gripping the base of his member he slapped it twice against the fashionista’s cheek. With her mind still reeling, it was as if she acted solely on her womanly instincts as Rarity’s lips parted, allowing her new master to push his cock past them as she diligently licked him clean. Royal Pin grinned again in perverted joy as his pet so eagerly worked with a desire to please. He planted a single hand atop her lavish purple hair, half petting and half bobbing her head along his length. Without even being told, Coco was likewise busy putting her tongue to good use, shooting between Rarity’s legs and lapping away at the delicious treat her master had so kindly deposited into her new sister pet’s gaping pussy.

All three of them seemed more than happy with their current arrangement. It seemed as though Evil had worked her magic again, knowing exactly who to pair up.

Fluttershy swallowed hard. Maybe the truth about Rising could wait for now...

Ultimately, it was up to each respective master in the mansion whether or not each new pet passed their initiation. And out of all of the girls tested that night, every single one of them was deemed to have passed.

After much due celebration and congratulations between the new members and their new families there was the usual shift in room assignments. Sleeping arrangements were generally flexible, but left to the men’s decision when it came to deciding who occupied their beds. Some preferred their pets in bed with them during the night. Useful for those seeking to have someone to cuddle and fondle as they drifted off. Also having them in the most ideal position upon awakening to deal with any and all morning wood that usually arose. Other men in the mansion were different. Holding nothing against their pets, they simply preferred a bed to themselves. Royal Pin was one of those people with a different arrangement for his pets...

It wasn’t long after her blindfold was removed did Rarity set her eyes on a peculiar large metal cage innocently residing next to her new master’s bed. Coco Pommel already lay inside, shooting the new pet an eager ‘come hither’ look while she lodged atop of a comfy cushion. Inside she could see plenty of blankets to keep the two of them warm, and even a water bottle attached to the side they could suck on whenever they needed a drink.

Her lingerie had not been returned to her, neither was she permitted to speak even though their love-making was over. From her sitting position, Rarity could only glance hesitantly at her warmly smiling master, gently urging her inside the cage with some small taps on her bare back. It was completely degrading how they treated girls here… but Rarity consistently found herself more intrigued and excited by the treatment, rather than off-put. Girls really were just animals in this house. Powerless, told only to obey as their bodies were to be used in any which way for the enjoyment of their masters.

Slowly but surely Rarity accepted her position as a collared pet, crawling into the cage. Coco Pommel was more than excited to have a bunk mate now, not even wasting a moment before embracing the nude fashionista friend in her arms.

As Coco cuddled up against her, Rarity released a pleasured shudder as she heard the door to the cage not only close but lock. Royal Pin grinning down at his two secured sex pets as he pocketed the only key. Whipping out his phone, he aimed it directly at the pair, quickly capturing several images of the two beautiful intertwined bodies before Coco could cover them with their blankets and quilts.

“Nighty night, girls,” Royal Pin spoke softly as he sent the pictures out to the group chat, briefly scrolling up and enjoying a few quick peeks at the other explicit images the others had littered into the chat of the new girls. He had always wondered what his cute classmate, Sunny Flare, was hiding under that pesky school uniform. Thankfully, it was a mystery no longer. “Get a good night’s sleep now. You’re going to need plenty of energy for tomorrow.”

As the lights were flipped off, Coco purred softly as she drew herself closer into Rarity’s embrace, preparing to sleep. Rarity, on the other hand, already felt as if she were in a dream.

As it turned out there were actually more female members in the mansion than there were guys. So a single male student being master to two separate girls at the same time was not uncommon. Apparently, according to Sonata at least, there were a lot more submissive girls in the world compared to dominant men, so Fluttershy supposed it made sense. That, or the members were just a lot more picky when it came to letting guys join.

Either way, it was enough of an excuse for Sonata to join Fluttershy as Rising Star’s pets during the normal living arrangement shift. Both of them moved out of their bunk bed and into the bedroom Rising had been given. It was rather empty, like a new college dorm room one could expect moving into. The only objects of note inside were a simple desk, closet, dresser, a lockable human sized pet door, and a rather large sized bed.

As the night as already nearing bedtime for the mansion’s occupants, Rising Star was faced with the task of deciding sleeping arrangements. He didn’t seem too keen on housing either Fluttershy or Sonata in a metal cage each night, either because he didn’t quite get it or was afraid of the girls disliking the practice. So the only sensible place for them to sleep in the single bed bedroom was right next to him.

Fluttershy had no complaints and was thankful even, feeling as though she had made a real connection with both of her roommates and felt compelled to explore it further. And if going to bed each night in her underwear, nestled between a siren and a sex god was how that happened, she was all for it.

Originally, she had thought that Rising would be in the center, but it mattered little to her. Fluttershy mewed softly as she snuggled into the embrace. To the left of her was Sonata, positioned on her side as close as she could possibly be to her bestie. Currently facing her with her eyes already closed, smiling contently as she snoozed. Thinking back upon her first night here Fluttershy remembered how she had caught Sonata crying in her sleep. She didn’t know if that was because of her friend remembering something from her past, or that she and Rarity had elected to both sleep on the top bunk without her. It didn’t feel right to ask her either way. However, it thankfully seemed like those sad nights were gone for good.

Rising Star spooning her from behind though was an entirely new sort of closeness she felt, not the same as the intimate moment she and him had shared, but at the same time, not entirely different either. For the strangest reason, it just felt nice to feel his constant presence. The sheets didn’t keep her as warm as the ones in her old bed at her parent’s house and sleeping in her underwear certainly didn’t help, but being the little spoon to Rising more than made up for it. It was a warm tingly sensation the coursed through her, which led her to feel the urge to push as much of her body into him as possible to strengthen and intensify that feeling.

Rising was practically taken aback by his pet’s display of willingness to be so close. Surprised, but not off put. He was more than willing to show the contact was not unwanted. Snaking his arm over slowly, he wrapped a single arm of his over the beautiful girl’s hourglass waist, resting it on her bare stomach.

Fluttershy released a soft gasp as she felt her master’s touch on her tummy. The same heat she had felt before returning, making her madly blush. Regrettably, as much as she would have liked to explore those feelings again, she felt like her friends would simply prefer sleeping for now. Not just her, but the rest of the mansion probably wanted it quiet too! For now, she simply placed her own hand atop his, holding it in to keep him there. She was happy like this as she closed her eyes and drifted off to sleep with a smile on her face.

“Hmph…” Evil was heard pouting, her face scrunched up as she sat with her arms crossed.

“She passed fair and square, what can you do?” Fleur cooed, planting a gentle trail of kisses up her friend’s side.

“Hmph!” Evil pouted louder, and seemingly, angrier.

“Even against the impossible odds you pitted her against, she prevailed. Everyone likes her, she seems like she belongs here, she has a positive attitude, I haven’t seen Snuggles happier since she moved in with her, and sleeping with Rising Star only proved that she must really want to stay, isn’t that reason enough to let her, Eevee?” Fleur went on, tugging her friend closer, nibbling at her ear. She also recalled Fluttershy helped save the world, but that didn’t seem quite worth mentioning. Neither did the fact that surviving a sleep session with Rising likely meant Evil herself could stand to learn a few things from Fluttershy.

“HMPH!” Evil pouted again, but her friend was used to her stubbornness.

“I suppose, if you really wanted to, you could break the protocol you yourself put in place, pull rank, and kick Fluttershy out,” Fleur mused, “this is your house, after all. You pay the bills,” Evil was seen smiling briefly as she imagined doing so. Literally doing so. “But have you considered what happens after that? Rising Star, whom you invited to live here, would then be left without the only girl here who managed to sleep with him and survive… Do you want to be the one to take Fluttershy’s place under that role? To be his go to pet for all his ball draining needs?”

Evil’s smile instantly vanished as the girl’s face turned as white as Rarity’s. Dread coursing through her veins.

“Then I’d imagine him and his Bitch-Tamer will be coming after all of us. I’d imagine you can see Fluttershy wouldn’t be the only girl leaving the mansion, should that scenario come to pass…”

"M-maybe Fluttershy can stay... for now," Evil finally admitted, in a voice so quiet Fleur could barely hear. Whatever. It wasn't like she was going to last long with Rising giving her a dicking everyday...