Login

Alternate Beginnings: Behind Closed Doors

by Doug Graves

Chapter 5: DA, AJ, RA, RD; One; Depression (17.5)

Previous Chapter Next Chapter

“Well,” Applejack gives Doug a sultry grin. She gets up slowly and is joined by Rainbow and Rarity, “I think you might need to make this official… with each of us.” She gives an exaggerated wink at Doug as she walks away, swaying her hips and flicking her tail as the other two mares follow suit, giggling among themselves.

Doug smiles, still a little winded from the sprint with Rainbow. He gets up, following the three mares to Applejack's bedroom. He stops in the doorway, the three mares looking at the bed that he and Applejack share. Doug immediately realizes the problem - there is just enough space in the bed for two of them, and barely enough at that. He asks, "So, um, how does this work, exactly?"

Applejack tentatively offers, "Well, um, Ah suppose we could take turns?"

Rarity and Rainbow shake their heads, Rarity saying, "One at a time? Please, darling, I would like to be more than just an observer. We are in a herd, after all!"

Rainbow nods, "Yeah! I mean, I watched when Doug and Rarity were together, and that was really tough. To, you know, control myself."

"Oh, Rainbow, you weren't controlling yourself then, not at all." Rarity smirks at Rainbow's pout, moving over to nuzzle the pegasus, "And I certainly hope you don't control yourself when we get started." Rainbow's frown turns to a smile, her nuzzle with Rarity quickly turning to a kiss.

Applejack smiles at the two before turning around; she winks at Doug while walking back out of the room. Rarity and Rainbow grin, the three following Applejack to a door that had been unused in the two months Doug had been there, and had gone unopened for longer than that. She hesitates, her hoof over the horseshoe shaped doorknob. She pushes the door open, looking at the larger bed, dresser, and mirror in the master bedroom.

Doug moves next to Applejack, a brief scratch of her mane as he looks around the room. "This was your parents?" He moves over to the bed, easily able to accommodate four ponies. The solid apple wood construction, very little bounce in the frame but made up for by the mattress. The comforter and the sheets look and smell clean, just a bit dusty.

Applejack nods, a wetness in her eye, as Rarity and Rainbow quietly walk into the room. "It was, and Ah think... Ah think they'd understand, and approve." She grips a corner of the quilt and sheets in her mouth, drawing it back to the foot of the bed. She hops on the bed, settling down into the 'pony loaf' configuration, four legs tucked under her. Rarity and Rainbow follow shortly after, turning and looking around; Rarity seems to be waiting for something, looking at Rainbow, while the pegasus seems unsure of what exactly happens next. Rarity shakes her head as Doug moves towards the bed; the human stops, resting a hand on the sheets.

"So, what happens next?" Doug asks, looking at the three mares.

Applejack and Rainbow both look towards Rarity, who looks at Applejack. The earth pony says, "Um, Ah guess you mate with each of us?" Rarity rolls her eyes, Applejack huffing and saying, "Ah'm sorry, Rarity, Ah haven't exactly studied the intricacies of herding. Is there a way this is supposed to go?"

Rarity nods, turning to Doug, "Well, it wouldn't hurt to have a bit of class, a guise of mystique about it. As far as the, ahem, mating goes, it depends on whether or not you have already mated with the new members of the herd. If you haven't, then they would get exclusive use of you for that night, with the more senior of the new members having their night first. After that, or when a new member joins that you have already mated with, as part of the dating and selection process of course, then you will mate with each pony in turn, starting with the new member, the most junior, and ending with the lead mare. But, and this is important, you don't ejaculate until you get to the last mare, and you try to pace yourself to spend the same amount of time with each mare. Later nights you keep the same order but start with the mare you finished with last night."

Doug nods, "Okay, but that sounds like I'll be leaving two of you wanting more."

Rarity nods, a forced smile, "Well, yes, that is the unfortunate reality, as most stallions are only able to release but once a night. However, it helps solidify the herd, let each mare know that they are desired, that they have a place with the other members. And, while they might not be fully satisfied every time, there is an unfortunate biological reality that the stallion might not last long enough with each of them for them to orgasm every time they want. There are potions and spells that purport to remedy this; but, I've heard, they make things very uncomfortable for the stallion. And, it is just the first few nights that each mare is included like this; whom the stallion spends later nights would be determined to the satisfaction of each mare, generally just the one mare per night. However, with you, you should be able to condense the three nights to just one session."

"Condense the nights? What do you mean?"

"Well, so, the first night you would start with Rainbow, then myself, then finish in Applejack. The second night, you start with Applejack, then Rainbow, then finish in me. The third night, you start with me, then Applejack, finishing in Rainbow. However, with your ability to finish more than once a day, you should be able to finish with each of us. I mean, I am speaking in generalities of course; if we wish to do something different, it is our choice. But we do have a bit of time before we each need to go back to work."

Rainbow licks her lips, "Mm, I kind of like how that sounds," as Doug nods, the human slowly climbing up onto the bed. Each mare watches him with anticipation, their eyes drifting down to his half-erect penis. His left hand goes to Applejack's head, his right to Rainbow's, petting both mares around the ears. He pushes against Rainbow while releasing Applejack, taking the earth pony's hat with him and tossing it to the side.

Rainbow turns around before rolling over, his hand playfully tracing a line along her body with her the entire time. He slides his fingers up and down her belly, brief tickles in the soft hair; Rainbow smiles at the brief squeeze above her teats where her foal is growing. She squirms, his hand moves down, briefly playing with each teat before moving further, dancing along her outer lips. She blushes as he parts the hair, exposing her marehood for everypony to see, a finger lingering on the inner lips before plunging in, helping spread her juices in preparation for him entering her.

His left hand moves to Rarity's head, a brief scratch against her ear, pulling her head slightly towards his penis, now fully erect. She realizes his intention, and she grins, her mouth opening and tongue sticking out, moving her head closer to Doug's. She licks along the bottom, his hand resting against her head as he shudders. She turns to the side, her tongue dancing around the sides before focusing on the head. She gasps as his hand lightly pulls her, encouraging her to open her mouth and accept him. She complies, first taking in the head, drawing her tongue across the tip, swallowing in anticipation.

She grimaces a little internally; his hand is messing with her perfectly coiffed mane, though it likely would not have survived the night intact regardless. The position he is asking for, while not unheard of, is a little low class and dirty, normally requiring the mare to push her body against the ground in order to do so. However, at least he looks and smells clean, just the expected hint of urine, and his upright posture is allowing her to remain comfortably against the sheets. She will still need to do something about her mane, and probably tail, though.

He winces, and she looks up, her large eyes raising in confusion, her mouth still around his head; he smiles down, lightly scratching her ear as he whispers, "Watch the teeth." Rarity nods, Doug exhaling contentedly at the movement, and Rarity opens her jaw a fraction more, trying to keep her lips wrapped around him. Her eyes open a little as he pushes his hips forward, another two inches disappear inside her, her tongue dancing over and around him. She sighs in relief as he slowly pulls out; she isn't sure how much more he wanted to go, and she should definitely practice that if it is an activity he wants to repeat. And, judging by his face, he will.

Doug's left hand briefly scratches Rarity as he pulls away, first kneeling then laying down on top of Rainbow. His right hand has her fully excited, ready and willing to accept him. Rainbow grunts as he enters her, his lubricated member hilting with little difficulty. Her hooves reach forward, wrapping around his neck as he begins thrusting, their chests rubbing up against each other as their mouths meet. Rainbow whines as he pushes in and out, already lasting longer than the other time they were together. He goes agonizingly slow, Rainbow wanting to tell him to speed up, to hurry up and finish. Sooner than she would have liked, but longer than she had heard stallions lasted for, he breaks away, one hand brushing away her mane from her eyes as he smiles down. Another quick kiss and he pulls out, a soft whimper from the mare as he motions to Rarity.

Applejack and Rarity watch as Rainbow gets penetrated; Rarity shifts slightly back, her hoof slowly moving to her marehood. Applejack nudges her, the unicorn looking back to see Applejack making a circular motion with her head. The unicorn gleefully rolls over, spreading her legs as Applejack moves down; the earth pony pauses, looking first at Rarity's marehood then back up at her head. Applejack whispers, "So, uh, you done this before?"

Rarity shakes her head, "Just read about it,." At Applejack's stern look she appends, "Extensively." Applejack shrugs, her hoof touching Rarity's, slow moving to part the hair around her marehood while her head moves down. She stops, her tongue dipping down to locate the slit, slowly drawing up and down. A brief glance to the side as Applejack hears a soft pop, watching Doug pull out of Rainbow, his cock dripping with her juices.

Doug slides over, grabbing onto Rarity's hind legs and sliding her closer to him. The unicorn giggles as he lines himself up, quickly penetrating her, a few thrusts before he picks up his pace. Rarity coos, "Mm, this feels much better," as Doug's hand moves to her head, finding her ear to twist and stroke as his other hand holds him up. He continues pumping in and out of her, his hand gripping her ear as she moans.

Rainbow watches from her back, trying to catch her breath as she watches Rarity. The position, the same as the one he had used with her before, but at a much slower, unhurried pace. He had definitely rushed things before, but this is much more awesome, even if she hadn't been able to get him for long enough. But, she grins to herself, she had two more shots with him. Tonight. And then, other nights she would get him just to herself, and if he could go this long with three of them, then she might find herself the exhausted one!

Applejack grunts as she lays back, twisting her neck to continue watching her stallion. She smiles to herself; thank Celestia, they had found a way. Hopefully the farm didn't suffer too much, or maybe they could borrow a bit of Rainbow's income to stay afloat. But, they would make this work. Her stallion hadn't run off, scared at the prospect of raising three foals. She idly rubs her belly as Doug pulls out of Rarity, the mare looking with sorrowful eyes at the withdrawing member.

Applejack spreads her legs wide as Doug easily slips into her, their practiced motions quickly bringing Doug close. He smiles, locking eyes with Applejack as he grunts, ejaculating into his mare. No, he corrects himself, his lead mare. Applejack leans forward, the two locking lips as she exhales, not long enough to bring her to orgasm but still feeling amazing. He rests inside her, Applejack lightly rubbing her hooves along his back as his hand strokes her ear, the other hand moving above her teats to the slight bulge on her sides, rubbing her growing belly.

"So," Doug says as he pulls out, smirking at the three, "You're saying I get to do that two more times?"

"Mm," moans Applejack, "Ah sure hope you do." She glances down, a streak of white slowly spilling out of her; she moves a hoof down, trying to contain it, keep the sheets clean. Well, cleaner, they would probably need a wash after they are done regardless of how careful they are.

Rarity moves closer to Applejack, "Here, darling, allow me." She bends down, pushing Applejack's hoof away with her muzzle, her tongue starting at the bottom drop and slowly making its way up. Applejack shudders as Rarity reaches her entrance, the tongue parting her lips, trying to find more of the sweet liquid. Rarity purrs as she laps it up, her tongue darting inside.

"Oh sweet Celestia," Applejack moans. Rainbow moves over, her mouth hanging open as she watches her herdmates. She glances over; Doug is completely engrossed in their action, his erection quickly returning, a few more drops emerging from the tip of his already soaked cock. Rainbow smirks, moving over and startling her stallion as her lips wrap around him. She savors the sweet taste, reminding herself to keep her teeth apart as she swallows, her tongue wrapping around him, trying to find as many of the deposits as she can.

Doug relaxes as he leans back, one hand going to Rainbow's head to scratch her ear, keeping her head in place as she bobs up and down. Rarity pulls back, watching Rainbow as Applejack gets to her hooves. She moves over, bumping her flank against Rainbow's barrel. The pegasus gives a mock pout as she pulls her mouth off with a pop, moving over to allow Applejack to take her favorite position.

Doug moves a hand down, briefly supporting himself as he lays down against the sheets. One hand holds him member upright and guiding into Applejack's folds as she takes the lead, her hips shifting up and down; the mattress is a bit softer than the one she is used to, her motions becoming a bit more exaggerated. She can feel the cum still inside her, lubricating her walls; along with Rarity's help, the earth pony quickly comes to a climax, her marehood clamping down. As she recovers from her orgasm she starts moving up and down again, stopping only when Doug puts a hand on her chest. She looks down in confusion, her stallion saying, "Sorry, love, but we have to leave some for the others; I'm getting close pretty fast."

Rainbow watches Applejack mount Doug, a little disappointed at her muzzlejob being interrupted. Rarity slips behind her, the unicorn whispering, "So, Rainbow, how do you taste?" The pegasus gasps as Rarity's tongue invades her vagina, looking back with wide eyes as Rarity probes deeper into Rainbow. "Mm," comes the disappointed tone, "Not nearly enough to test. We'll have to fix that, now won't we?" Rainbow spreads her legs slightly, Rarity taking advantage to push further inside. Rainbow squirms, a little uncomfortable at the mare's tongue lapping back and forth in her.

Rainbow pulls away as Doug pushes Applejack, gladly taking her position above the human. She looks down, a hint of confusion as to how exactly he will fit in her, as his penis is currently aimed at her teats. Doug grabs hold of her forelegs, walking her forward a few inches, a brief 'Ah' from the pegasus as he finds her entrance. She moves down for a kiss, her hips awkwardly moving up and down as she tries to find a good rhythm. Her muzzle curls in frustration, a hand coming up to stroke her face. "Shh," Doug whispers, a brief kiss, "Take your time, Rainbow. No rush."

Rainbow starts again, a smile slowly forming on her face as she lowers herself. A longer kiss this time, her body shifting forwards and backwards, trying to find that sweet spot. Rainbow frowns as she starts to tire, the unfamiliar position more difficult than she imagined, especially after watching Applejack. She peels herself off, a heavy breath as she slumps to the side. Doug's hand finds Rainbow's head, pulling the mare close for a brief kiss and ear scratch. Rainbow smiles before her frown returns, a little disappointed that she wasn't able to perfect the position.

Rarity moves next to Applejack, letting the mare recover as they watch Rainbow move on top. Rarity whispers to Applejack as she notices Rainbow's difficulties, "So, um, how do you make that one work?"

"Um, one of two things," Applejack whispers back, "You have to move your hips a lot more than you think, and it takes some getting used to. Or, let him take the lead, and try to keep your legs in one place as he does his thing." Rarity considers; Doug had taken the lead on the last position. She wants to be in charge, at least some of the time, but she wants the first time he finishes in her with the rest of the herd to be more memorable than what is happening with Rainbow.

Rarity moves up, a slightly worried look on her face; Doug did not look like he is ready to go off immediately, like he was with Applejack, and she hopes he doesn't tire himself out too badly. Well, if he does, there is always tomorrow. She settles down on top of him, drawing close for a kiss as she whispers, "You may need to take the reins on this one." Doug nods, one hand moving to her head and mane, keeping her close as his other hand helps him shift downwards. He lines himself up, Rarity feeling herself driven forward as he penetrates her.

Rarity tries to keep her legs steady, gasping as he drives deeper into her. She quickly loses herself in the motion, her mouth having to strain forward just a little to find his. He accepts whenever she tries, but backs off if she doesn't continue the effort, focusing on pumping his hips up and down. She can hear his breath becoming a little harder, his penis seeming to swell, enlarging inside of her as he continues. Rarity groans at the increased pressure, her own orgasm quickly approaching. She shudders, her mind going blank as he grunts; a few pumps later and he finishes, Rarity letting go a long breath as she slumps over.

Applejack bends over, Rarity's eyes unfocused as she leaks onto Doug's belly; she whispers, "Mm, Ah think you need a little help there, partner." She slinks around to the side, her muzzle brushing past Doug's knee to find Rarity's marehood. She takes a long lick of the liquid dripping out, smiling at the taste. She glances down, watching Rainbow lick the pool of cum off of Doug's belly before going to his shaft; Applejack gives Rarity another lick before backing off. Doug isn't hardening as quickly this time, Rainbow able to get more and more into her fellatio.

Rarity turns, watching Rainbow get faster and faster, Doug wincing a little at the roughness but still enjoying himself. Rarity moves over, her head next to Rainbow's, and whispers, "Now, dear, I'm more than happy to give up my turn to you, but are you sure you want it in that end?" Rainbow slows as she considers, her head bobbing up and down on the tip. Rarity purrs, "It does feel great, but I assure you, it'll feel even better in the other side." Rainbow pulls off, smirking as Rarity considers what position to take.

Rarity moves over to Doug, motioning with her head to the head of the bed. She levitates a few of the pillows, setting them up against the headboard, Doug moving to a seated position against them. She moves next to him, carefully setting one hind leg across his body and lowering herself, her back against his chest. Doug grunts as she rests on top of him, his arms trying to lift her back up. She looks back, confused as he continues pushing, a strained look on his face. She sits back up, a look of relief on his face, "Dear, whats wrong?"

"Just a lot of weight on me, against my hips. Try putting more on your legs, maybe kneeling next to me." Rarity bends one leg, then the other, her rump pressed against his belly. "Mm, much better," Doug says, Rarity smiling back before taking a hoof, guiding him into her. She smiles as the head disappears, slowly lowering herself to completely engulf him.

"Enjoying yourself, darling?" Rarity asks, bobbing her hips up and down. She feels her mane pressing against his chest and face, one of his hands moving through her curls against her head, trying to keep the offending hair away from him. She sighs to herself; yup, will definitely need to redo her mane. Her tail at least is laying to the side, the style keeping it out of the way and away from those grasping, style-destroying paws he calls hands.

His hands move to her flanks, rubbing into the soft flesh, slowly making their way up her back. She smiles, slowly arching her back, cautiously moving her head back. She tilts her head to the side as his hands move to her sides, rubbing along her ribs, going down, twisting along her belly until both are grasping her teats. Her mouth finds his lips, a light nibble before a long sigh, pushing forward with her legs and hips as she slips away. She looks back, a coy smile on her mouth as she winks, her mind decrying her actions as she lays down.

Applejack moves over, a brief pause as she lines herself up. She remarks, "This position seems a little familiar, partner," as she begins moving up and down, "But Ah can't quite put my hoof on it."

Doug nods, his hands lightly holding onto her flanks, "I think I called it reverse cowgirl, except I'd be lying down."

Applejack gets more into it, moving her hips faster, "Ah, right," as she thinks to herself, 'Ah like that one more, but better not spoil Rarity's choice.'

Rainbow moves over to Applejack, still feeling a little depressed that her last position with Doug hadn't gone very well. She whispers to Rarity, "That position, um, was it hard? It didn't look bad, but I really don't want to screw this up."

Rarity whispers back, "Here, line up with me." Rainbow spins around, trying to mimic the position Rarity took. "Okay, remember to sit up on your hind hooves a bit more. Bend a lot at the knees, try to rest them on the bed. You'll be moving your hips a lot, not bending at the knees, or you'll tire out too quickly, and not be able to go as fast." Rarity sees Rainbow's smirk, "And I bet you like going fast." She winks as Applejack gives a long sigh of her own, pushing Rainbow towards Doug.

Rainbow confidently struts up to Doug, placing her left hoof on his left side, an awkward configuration at first. She puts her forelegs on his shoulders, a long, forceful kiss against his mouth. He moves his arms past her barrel, briefly touching her wings before moving past, gripping her and pressing her closer. Rainbow looks over at Rarity, giving the unicorn a wink as she slowly rotates her body, keeping her lips locked on his, the arms around her loosening and allowing her to spin, planting her right hoof next to his right hip as she lowers her body. One of his hands moves down, positioning himself to enter her, her lips slowly parting his as she realizes she is a little too tall to comfortably keep in this position, especially if she needs to get her knees on the bed and is resting on his hips. She ends the kiss with a heavy smack, a coy smile as she bends down.

Rainbow slides forward, then back as she rests down, a contented sigh as he hilts inside her. He grips her flanks as she starts rocking her hips up and down, a pleased groan coming from behind her. She grins, beginning to pick up her pace, his hands starting to relax, now resting on her back as his head goes to the ceiling, eyes closed and mouth open in ecstasy. Rainbow speeds up again, her hips starting to burn as she feels him swell inside her. She pants as she orgasms, feeling the spurts inside her, relishing the proximity as she rests as close to him as she can.

Rainbow pouts as she pulls off of him, quickly spinning around and joining her mouth to his. She sighs as she breaks away, going for a second kiss as Rarity moves next to her. The unicorn receives a kiss, followed by Applejack. The three mares glance at each other, sharing a quick nuzzle with each other.

Rainbow glances outside, "That was... that was awesome, you girls." She moves over to Applejack and then Doug, sharing a quick kiss with both, "I really want to keep going, I think we all do, but I have to get back to work."

Rarity nods, "And I as well. Applejack, I will get back to you, but I am okay with the two nights at the Boutique. Maybe every seventh day we can get together to do something, the three of us, and I would like to have at least a little time spent with Doug every day, even if it is just a half hour conversation over lunch."

Doug gets up, stroking Rarity and Rainbow, "I think that will work out. You might need to make the trip over here, though, on some days." They share a smile, the two mares walking out. Doug looks to Applejack, "I guess we have a bit more work to catch up on too, huh?" Applejack nods, a wry smile as they tidy up the sheets, the mare taking a long sniff of the various puddles.

Next Chapter: DA, RD; One; Weather Blues (20.5) Estimated time remaining: 58 Minutes
Return to Story Description
Alternate Beginnings: Behind Closed Doors

Mature Rated Fiction

This story has been marked as having adult content. Please click below to confirm you are of legal age to view adult material in your area.

Confirm
Back to Safety

Login

Facebook
Login with
Facebook:
FiMFetch