For about an hour and a half, you've given the CMC the ride of a lifetime, pleasuring and fucking them nonstop and taking turns in giving each other a good time. Eventually, they soon became nothing more than three hot messes, completely passed out on the floor of their clubhouse. But, being the gentleman you were, you wiped off the cum from their faces and covered their bodies with a spare blanket they had stashed in their clubhouse in case they spent the night here.

Afterwards, you threw your clothes back on and walked out of the clubhouse to let the Cutie Mark Crusaders sleep in peace while you went out to get some fresh air. To be honest with yourself, you were only a little bit fatigued after all that, but you still had enough strength left inside you.

"Well, at least now they'll be able to take a break, but man, they are out of control!" you said, "Twilight and I are going to have a long talk after this is all done." At first, you couldn't say no when Twilight first persuaded you to drink that potion she made for the first time, and after that whole experience with the Mane 6, you thought you'd be a goner for sure, but at the end of that day, you won 6 girlfriends.

Only now, you've got 9 girlfriends. You were relieved that Twilight mentioned how there's no limit to how many mares you add to your harem as long as you showed how faithful you are to them. All these thoughts ran through your mind right as you entered the town again without noticing.

You got a very bad feeling when you noticed that most of the town was completely empty. You couldn't hear anything other than the sound of the wind, blowing against your skin. Just then, the sound of a door creaking open was heard behind you, but you were too scared to look.

"Psst! Psst! Hey!" whispered a familiar female voice. You slowly turned to see that it was Pinkie Pie, peeking out from the opened door to Sugar Cube Corner. "Come with me if you want to live!" she whispered again, signalling you to walk inside, like something was wrong.

With that look in her eyes, it was clear she wasn't overtaken by the heat spell. You sighed in relief and followed her inside the bakery before she closed the door behind you two. "Pinkie, what the heck is going on and why are you so frightened right now?" you asked. She rushed up to you and covered your mouth with her hand and moved you up the stairs to her bedroom where the curtains were down and lights were off, as if she was trying to keep something out.

"Did you drink Twilight's potion again?!" Pinkie whispered. You removed her hand.

"Actually, she went so low as to sneak a drop into my breakfast this morning." you said, frowning.

Pinkie's jaw literally dropped down to the ground with an audible thud.

"I can't believe she did that! Well, did it happen before you left or after you left? If it happened before you left and you ended up banging her again... WITHOUT ME..." she shouted.

"Calm down, Pinkie. The potion took effect after I left Twilight's castle." you reassured.

Pinkie's smile had soon returned and gave you a big hug. "Okay, I was just checking. But you gotta be careful, every single mare in Ponyville's looking for a good bucking. And just remember, no matter how many mares you bring into our special relationship, I still love you." Pinkie said, nuzzling you cheek to cheek.

"I love you, too, my cute little pony." you replied. Pinkie giggled and pressed her lips onto you for only a few seconds before pulling away with her usual adorable smile. "And don't you worry a thing about me, my tender groins haven't burned up one bit... unless you want to give me another Pinkie "Cream" Pie." she asks, teasing you with her half-lidded eyes.

"Now now, Pinkie, you've already had your fun with me last week. Anyways, I've got to head back to the castle and talk to Twilight about this. See ya, Pinkie." you said before walking down the stairs. You then walked outside of the bakery and strolled down the streets of Ponyville. As usual, the quiet atmosphere was making you feel nervous, as Pinkie explained that the potion somehow ended up affecting every other mare in Ponyville, and you hoped that it didn't include the rest of the Mane 6.

About 15 seconds of walking, keeping your eye out for any mare that might be looking for you, the sound of wings flapping could be heard, but you're not sure which direction it's coming from. The sounds of wings flapping grew closer and louder until suddenly...

*BAM*

Your vision was blank and your head felt like it was hit by a freight train. You slowly opened up your eyes, instantly noticing that you weren't outside anymore. Instead, you were in a bedroom with a window on you left hand side and a nightstand on your right, but this wasn't your room. The floor boards were all wood and the walls were made of plaster.

"W-Wha-- What the hell am I doing here and how did I get here, anyways?" you asked yourself. The back of your head felt a little cold. You looked at the pillow you were resting on and saw an ice pack, which meant, someone, or somepony, brought you into their house and treated that bruise on the back of your head, but somehow, you didn't want to stick around to find out who it was that brought you here. But it was only natural for you to thank whoever it was that helped you.

Suddenly, the bedroom door opened up, revealing a grey pegasus mare with golden wall-eyes and blonde hair, wearing a white T-shirt that showed black straps from her bra. She wore tight, blue jeans and was carrying a basket of muffins in one arm and holding a cup of water in her other hand.

The moment she sees that you're awake, she gasped and flew over to you. "Oh, you're up. I'm so sorry, I lost control when I was flying home and ended up crashing down onto you." she says with a sad smile. She puts the cup of water on top of the nightstand before reaching into her basket. "Here, have a muffin. I baked them myself as a way of saying I'm sorry and that I hope you'll forgive me."

You knew she was being sincere and you were a forgiving kind of guy at heart. Besides, even if you weren't forgiving, you just couldn't stay mad at a cute face like hers. You reached for the muffin and grabbed it, smiling at the mare and chuckling. "Thank you very much, miss... uhh."

"Oh right, of course, how silly of me." she said, her smile looking more happy. "My name is Derpy Hooves, I'm a mailmare and muffin lover." she giggled. By Celestia's name, she sounded so adorable. "So what's the name your friends call you by?" She asks, before you tell her your name. "Ooh, that's a nice name. And again, I'm really sorry I crashed into you, is there anything else I can do for you?"

"Umm, nothing else comes to mind, but thanks for the muffin and water." you reply, before taking a bite out of your muffin and a sip of your water. Derpy puts her basket down on her nightstand and crawls on top of the bed, sitting on the right hand side, looking down at you with her cute, wall-eyes.

"Are you sure? I really don't mind." She persisted. Was she trying to get into your pants? If she was, you wanted to make sure that she wouldn't be taken advantage of. You remembered that Rainbow Dash told you about Derpy being picked on by other ponies because of her wall-eyed condition and that she hardly has anyone Ponyville she would see as a friend, even though she tries.

"W-Well, what exactly did you have in mind, Derpy?" you asked, sitting up straight and looking at her. She didn't even sound like she was affect by the heat potion Twilight secretly gave you.

"Umm, w-would it be okay if I... gave you... a... a kiss?" she asked, blushing with a smile. Dear Celestia, she just doesn't know how to stop being cute, but to be honest, you don't mind it at all.

"Oh, a kiss. Okay sure." you said with a smile. Her smile grew happier with a squee.

You scooched yourself closer to Derpy, staring into her cute, golden wall-eyes. She leans in closer to you while you got closer to her until both of your lips mashed together. Right as you kissed Derpy, her wings spread out and soon, what she does next takes you by surprise. She pushes herself onto you even more, deepening the kiss and laying you back down on the pillow. She started to moan and thrust her tongue into your mouth, easily push past your teeth and pinning your tongue down.

There was no other choice other than to wrap your arms around her, continuing the kiss. You soon realized that she tasted like blueberries. Must have been from all the muffins she ate. Even if she is a muffin lover, she still managed to keep her gorgeous figure.

After a while, Derpy retracted her tongue and broke the kiss, breathing heavily with you. She never broke eye contact with you with her golden eyes, half-lidded and a noticeable blush on her face. She sits herself back up on her knees and grabs the hem of her shirt and pulls it off, showing off her breasts, covered by her black bra, probably a D cup like the CMC or an E cup like Twilight. You watched them bounce beautifully.

"D-Derpy... I thought you only wanted a kiss." you said.

"I can't help it, my loins are burning up so badly, I want them to stop! Please, I need you." she pleaded. Derpy grabs one of your hands and locks it with one of hers. "Please, if you do this for me, I'll never ask for you to do this ever again, I promise." But to you, didn't seem right to leave her hanging like this, she's such a sweetheart, and besides, it wouldn't be right for you to ditch her after just one fuck.

"Hey, come on don't say that." you reply, sitting up and rubbing her cheek gently. You gave her a warm hug, earning a hug from her back.

"Derpy, if you want to do this, I'd be more than happy to help you, but I'm not going to abandon you. You're too precious for me to leave, not to mention you're so adorable and beautiful at the same time. So, here's what I found out from a good friend of mine: They said that here in Equestria, it's not uncommon for a man or stallion to be seen with multiple mares. To be more specific, a harem."

"A harem?" she asked.

"That's right, if you want to, you're more than welcome to join my harem. You have my word that I'll always be faithful to you, no matter what. It's all up to you in the end. For me, all I want to do is make you happy, I don't care what I have to do to prove it." you tell her genuinely.

"Can you give me another kiss, please?" she asked. You look straight into her eyes and plunged in for another warm and passionate kiss on the lips.

You gently stroked her beautiful, blonde hair and danced your tongue with hers. Derpy began to grind her hips on your lap, bringing out a bulge from your pants. Derpy's wings wrapped around you like a blanket. She breaks the kiss for air and then reaches behind her back, unclipping her bra and letting it fall on the bed, presenting her huge cleavage to you. You didn't want to leave her hanging, so you took off your shirt, leaving your upper body exposed for her eyes to see.

"Oh wow, you look so handsome." she says, placing her hands on your upper torso. Derpy gets off the bed and grabs the hem of her blue jeans and black panties. "Do you like what you see?" she asked, staring at you with her half-lidded eyes, smiling at you.

"Sweet Celestia, you look hot!" you say, taking off your pants and boxers. Derpy giggled adorably and climbed back onto the bed and this time, she had her swollen, wet pussy facing you directly while she had her eyes on your big, meaty member. "I guess you want to do the ol' 69, huh?" you asked.

"Mmhmm, it's been a long time since I've tasted a big, meaty cock."

"Seriously? When was the last time that happened?" you asked.

Derpy turns around to gaze at you with her beautiful golden eyes. She also had a seductive smile on her face while biting her lower lip. "Oh, that's not important right now. You just keep on giving mommy some sugar and I'll give you some some sugar, too, okay?" she asks, pushing her butt against your face.

Her ass was just way too mesmorizing for you to say "no." You grab both of her plump butt cheeks and swirl your tongue around her pussy lips. You feel the taste of blueberries hit your taste buds every time the tip of your tongue reaches the inside of Derpy's love tunnel. Derpy moaned uncontrollably and starts sucking on your cock, deep-throating you right from the start. You moaned inside her pussy. You were even curious of whether or not she was young and talented, or if she just looks young, but is a skilled mare who's learned how to please other stallions from years of experience, if so, who was her previous sweetheart?

Before you could start overthinking any further, Derpy's soft, furry hands start massaging your balls. The pleasure would then travel up your spine as you continued to lick her pussy. However, her skills in pleasuring a stallion, or in your case, pleasuring a man were proving to be extremely good. At any poiny you could cum inside her mouth from the pleasure.

However, you refused to be outbested by this cute mare. In an attempt to match up to her, you thrusted your tongue a lot deeper inside her pussy. Derpy's whole body began to shake as she felt you slurping up the mare's juices inside her love tunnel like a wild animal. She moaned and kept on deep throating you like the pro she was. Thrusting your tongue inside her just wasn't enough to send her over the edge. Your other strategy you used was to flick your tongue on her clit while kneading her plump ass like it was a made of dough.

Derpy's wings stiffened outwards as she let out an even louder moan and took your shaft out of her mouth, obviously this was her weak spot and you aimed for it everytime.

"More! More! Oh, sweet Celestia, eat my pussy more! Oh yes! I'm gonna cum!" she shouted. You kept up the pace, trying to get her to climax. Derpy was barely hanging on by a thread. Her hands gripped the bed sheets and began panting heavily. "I'm gonna- I- I- can't...!" she couldn't finish her sentence and at that moment, Derpy screamed from the top of her lungs, spraying you with her sweet honey. You drank up every last drop that leaked into your mouth, trying to avoid choking. When she ran on empty, you gave her vaginal lips a good licking to get any excess cum off of her. Derpy moaned more softly than before.

After you were done, Derpy turned herself around and straddled your body, looking down at you with her beautiful golden half-lidded eyes and cute smile. She leans down, pinning her breasts against your chest and nuzzled herself against your cheek ever so adorably.

"Are you ready for this?" Derpy asked, earning a nod from you. She giggled and leaned her lower body upwards and guided it back down on your shaft. "Mmmm, so big!" she said, as her body shuddered. Her entrance felt so tight and warm, you threw your head back slowly and moaned. The wall-eyed mare on top of you began to ride your cock, moving her hips slowly, gradually gaining speed and momentum.

Derpy would constantly let out cute moans, riding your cock like the horny mare in heat she was. 'There should be a law that limits how cute a mare should be, but man, she rides so well!' you thought.

Your hands start traveling all over Derpy's gorgeous body and started to grope her beautiful breasts. Derpy gasped with an adorable smile and her eyes still closed. You moved her breasts in circles, causing her to ride your cock faster and lay her whole body on top of yours. Your hands were pinned between her boobs and your bare chest, and she smirked seductively at you like she was waiting for this to happen.

"You're all mine now, cutie pie." she said before mashing her lips with yours. Her tongue pinned yours down with effortless ease, leaving you under her control. Her pussy would then squeeze your shaft as she moved her hips back and forth, still holding the kiss.

Having such a cute, sexy mare dominate you like this was unlike anything you could ever imagine. The more she rid on you, the closer your climax was reaching you. However, you weren't going to let her do all the work and get the better of you, so you lifted her upper body off of you a little and then move your hands towards her hips before Derpy pressed herself back down on you, resuming your little make-out session. With both of your hands firmly locked on her hips, you thrusted upwards, ramming your thick cock inside her love tunnel, hitting her most deepest spots that couldn't even touch herself.

Derpy's muffled moans were a good sign that she was enjoying it as much as you were. Derpy kept her eyes locked on yours and you noticed how she began to blush intensely. You moved your hands up to her wings and caressed them, making her shudder.

She swirls her tongue around yours in circles while you both kept on pleasuring each other with your hard thrusts and her quick bouncing on your cock. Suddenly, her movements got even quicker, her breathing was getting heavy and her moans became louder and throaty.

"Oh, buck me! I'm gonna cum!" she nearly screamed.

"So am I!" you grunted. You weren't gonna lie, Derpy's movements were gradually increasing to the point where you could barely hold in your climax. Derpy sits herself up and bounces violently on your cock, letting out loud and throaty moans, letting her breasts bounce beautifully. You moaned alongside with her, grabbing her hips while thrusting upwards inside her pussy. None of you could hold in your climaxes any further and soon, both of you came at the exact same time.

Derpy screamed out loud and stiffened out her wings, throwing her head back while you groaned and shot huge ropes of your semen inside her love tunnel. Derpy's love nectar sprayed all over your crotch and splattered all over her clean bed sheets, leaving huge stains.

It took both you and Derpy 10 seconds to finally calm down. The two of you were still panting, but not as heavily as before, and yet, even after all that, you still felt a little energetic. Derpy gets off of your shaft and lays herself down next to you and starts striking up a conversation.

"How was that, did you feel good?" she asks.

You looked at her and gave her a hug and a boop on the nose, making her giggle. "It was amazing, I didn't know you could ride like that. You're a natural." you replied. She giggles again and hugs you back.

"Sorry if I came on too strong, it's just been so long since I last felt something to blissful as that."

"Really, why do you say that, Derpy? You're one of the most beautiful and cutest pegasi mares I've ever met, not only that, but you're so kind."

"Well, when I first lost my virginity to a stallion I loved, I felt so happy, but then after that, no pony in town would take my feelings seriously and thought I was just a silly mare with an eye problem. You're the first person I've ever had the pleasure of experiencing this amazing feeling in years."

"Aww, that's so sweet, Derpy. Look, forget what all those other ponies say about you, they don't know what they're missing out on. They say you're a silly mare with an eye problem, I say you're a gifted and talented mare with an honest job and a gift to all ponykind. No matter what, you'll always be my special muffin."

Those last three words were enough to make her gasp and beam with joy. She wraps you in a tight hug and smothers your face with kisses. Derpy lands one last kiss on your lips, but holds it for a few seconds without adding in her tongue before pulling away.

Afterwards, her lustful stare returns, which means she's ready for round two. But this time, she lays down on her back and lifts her legs up using her arms. You knew what she wanted, and by the almighty powerful sunbutt, you were going to give it to Derpy. Without saying anything and in a swift sit-up, you crawled on top of the adorable wall eyed mare in front of you, gazing down at her sexy naked cuteness. She stares back at you with her lustfilled eyes, rubbing your arms with her soft, fluffy hands.

"Take me again, my love." she whispered, seductively. You lean down and lined up your cock with her swollen flower and thrust it inside her. Derpy lets out a cute moan, holding onto your shoulders. It was amazing how she went from dominant alpha female to submissive cutie in such a short time.

Though, you were in control, you didn't let your urges get the best of you. While you kept fucking your lovely muffin lover, you added a few circular inward thrusts, just to increase the pleasure a little more and also to get a reaction from her, which was a goofy smile and adorable moaning. "You feel good?" you whispered.

"It's the best sex I've ever had! Oh yeah! I love you so much, baby! Even more than muffins!" she moans, keeping her grip on your shoulders.

Her inner walls soon clamped down onto your shaft tightly. You grunted, feeling like there was no way you could ever exit out of her, unless you filled her up like the CMC. Your eyes quickly drifted down to her bouncing boobs, which looked like they needed some loving. Derpy nodded with an adorable blush. That was the "go ahead" signal she gave you to have as much of her breasts as you want. You lean down and latch your mouth onto her left nipple and fondled her right breast with your left hand.

"Mmm, oh yes! Suck on my nipples, my love! They're all yours, drink as much as you want!" she moaned again, while you gladly continued to suck on your boobsicle. You switched breasts to help give them both equal amount of pleasure, all while you kept pumping your dick inside her pussy. "Oh sweet bucking Celestia, your dick is so huge, I'm gonna go crazy!"

'Too late for that.' you thought. While sucking on her breast, you picked up speed and power in your thrusts, driving Derpy into a sex-crazed state of pleasure. Her legs locked around your waist and her wings had stiffened once again, giving you the opportunity to go into town with those beauties. You moved both of your hands towards each of her wings and gave them a good rubbing.

Derpy could only blab out pleasurable gibberish. Her body was turned into putty in your hands, much to yours and her liking and it only got better from there.

She pulls your face deeper into her bosom as if she's trying to breast feed you like a mother. You got so horny, you drilled your cock deeper inside Derpy to the point where it was touching the entrance of her womb, driving her even more crazy for your cock. After some time, you let go of Derpy's bountiful cleavage and gazed at her beautiful lust-filled eyes with your own lust-filled gaze.

"I'm gonna cum again, my love! Release your semen inside me, please!" she begged. Luckily, she didn't have to wait for you that long, as you felt your climax getting closer by the second.

Her climax was definitely reaching its peak, too. Whether she knew it or not, you were about to finish up inside her, even as she tightened her legs around your waist. Finally, you buried your cock deep inside her warm pussy and painted Derpy's inner walls with your hot love cream. Derpy screamed out loud, holding you tight with her arms and legs while you grunted, feeling your balls being emptied out inside her. She soon sprayed her juices all over your crotch like she did before when she was on top of you.

You kept pumping so much thick ropes of cum inside her womb, her belly bulged slightly. 20 seconds later, her grip on you loosened up, which causes you to fall next to Derpy, panting heavily. Your cock immediately gets pulled out of her pussy, allowing the stored up cum to flow out of her like a stream.

"Oh fuck!" you panted. "I... I don't think... I can go... another round..." But sadly, you couldn't catch a break for two reasons, one of which is that the potion was still lingering inside you, giving you unlimited stamina, and another reason was because a certain "muffin fanatic" wasn't finished with you just yet. Your fears couldn't have never been more right when Derpy got on top of you in a reverse cowgirl style. "N-No, you wouldn't..." you said, in a slight panicked tone.

"Mmm, oh yes, I want more... much more." she says, looking at you with her seductive stare.

In that very moment, you let out the most deafening scream inside your head that if it were done out loud, it would have left a very pissed off Luna.

A whole hour went by and you went at it with Derpy for at least 6 rounds. By the time you had finished, she had a bloated belly making her look 7 months pregnant.

Her heat had finally calmed down, but you decided to stay a while and talk with her a bit longer. As of right now, you were laying down on the bed with her, both of you were still naked.

"Derpy, I know I've said this before, but sweet Celestia, you were amazing." you said.

"You were so wonderful, too. I think I might actually fall in love with you. Out of all the stallions in Equestria, and trust me, there's not enough of them, you're the only one who's ever been nice to me. If it's alright with you, I want to be a part of your life so I can always be close to you." Derpy confesses.

"If you feel that strongly about me, how about I tell you something that'll make your day." you said, making her nod rapidly with a smile.

"You see, Derpy, my friend, Twilight, told me about this thing called "herding," which practices a stallion going out with not just one mare, but multiple mares. There are no limits to how many a stallion can have, but the catch is that the stallion has to be faithful to all the mares he has in his herd. Now, I want to know something about you, Derpy, do you want to joing my herd, if you do, you have my word that I will love you just as equally as I love the other girls, if not, then I understand."

Derpy gasped with her hand over her mouth. "Y-You want me... to be a part of...?" she asks.

"If you're okay with it." you reply. Derpy thought long and hard about it and finally, she looked at you and gave you a great big hug and a peck on the cheek.

"Then this is exactly what I want, if it means being with you." she whispers. After confessing, she lets out a yawn and let the fatigue get to her as she finally conked out.

"Well then, welcome to the herd, my beautiful muffin." you whispered back. She didn't hear you, but that's alright, she deserves a little break. Now that she was out cold, you got off her bed and covered her up in her blankets before grabbing your clothes and putting the back on. You soon left her bedroom and closed the door behind you quietly so you wouldn't wake her up. You made your way to the living room downstairs and exited out the front door and closed it behind you before letting out a sigh. "Derpy, no matter what others may think about you, I think you're a sight for sore eyes." you say, looking at the front door. With Derpy now a part of the herd, it was time to give Twilight a good scolding for "spiking" your food this morning.