It'd been comfortable sex—curious sex. Whenever Fluttershy's shaft started to flag, I'd give it a few more gentle licks to keep him a little chubby. I adored the way his hips twitched each time I did it.

"Why'd I agree to all this?" Fluttershy asked. "Why did I go through with it?"

"Because it was fun? Because I promised you'd be safe, and I wouldn't hurt you?" I gave him another lick just to hear his sigh turn into a giggle.

"That's hedonism."

The word wasn't exactly true, if we didn't do what we do we wouldn't survive. "You know we have to do this for food?"

"But you chose to do this for food. It's the choice that makes it hedonism." Fluttershy returned the favor now, licking and nuzzling at my sheath. "But you're right—it is fun. Why didn't you feed?"

"You could tell I didn't?"

Fluttershy seemed distracted by my sheath, but finally she paused long enough to say, "I'm awake. I've read enough about sirens to know they typically feed from a pony to the point of either being a thrall or unconscious."

I let out a chuckle, enjoying the verbal sparring with an old (and new) friend. "And yet you saw Rarity up and walking around after I fed from her."

"Then you didn't feed from her." Fluttershy nuzzled a bit lower, kissing my balls and playing with them gently.

It was impossible to stop the groan his efforts bestowed upon me. "But I did. I drank so deeply she should have been wandering around doe-eyed for a day."

"I wish Applejack was here."

I gasped in mock surprise. "Fluttershy! She's my sister! Pick somepony else if you want to suggest a three-some—you know I won't say no to that."

Fluttershy left off nuzzling my nuts. "N-No. I m-mean she could tell if you're l-lying."

"Well that's easy to solve. I'm not lying." Opening my mouth, I sucked up and down Fluttershy's shaft just once—enough that his hips bucked.

It took him a while to get his head clear, it seemed. When Fluttershy finally spoke, his tone was laden with curiosity. "Is there something special about Rarity?"

"At a guess, I'd say it's all the Element bearers." I licked him again to energize his flagging shaft.

"So you could have fed on me just now?"

"I could have, certainly. You felt plenty enough adoration of me." Returning the favor, I nuzzled his plump balls. "But I didn't."

"Why didn't you? If you go and feed on somepony else, they might not be able to take it." The concern in Fluttershy's deep voice made me want to please him more. Shifting a little, I nuzzled his balls one last time before squirming to get further down.

"What are you do—?" Fluttershy's words cut short as my tongue found his anus.

Nuzzling and nibbling tenderly, I explored slowly to give him time to get used to the new sensation. Our first period together had never involved much more than straight sex and a little bit of oral work on each other's genitals. In my time away from Ponyville, however, I'd learned a lot of new ways to please a pony.

"That is—Oh my g—What are y—"

My licking seemed to rob Fluttershy of his words each time my tongue delved into him. Pressing my lips tight around his bulging ponut, I worked my tongue in as deep as I could get it.

"Waaaaait!" Fluttershy's cry made me stop and ease back. "What are you doing?"

Pulling away from his wonderful rump, I licked my lips. "You don't like it?"

"It feels—It feels odd. Not bad-odd, just odd."

"Want some more?" I asked.

"I don't think so. Maybe when I'm more in the mood. I want to talk more." Fluttershy rolled over and then around so we were both heading the same way, but facing each other. "You're going to go out hunting now?"

"Nope," I said, taking care not to put my old pronunciation on the word. "I'm not sure if you noticed, but we don't hunt, we offer."

Fluttershy frowned a little. "Calling it something else doesn't make it any different. You find a pony you like and then manipulated them to feed you."

"Want me to tell you the secret about how we feed so well?" I used one wing to lift Fluttershy's left forehoof to my mouth and nibbled on the edge of it a little.

Unable to hold back a giggle as I masticated one of his more ticklish spots, Fluttershy nodded.

"We make it well known we are available." I tried to go back to nibbling his hoof, but Fluttershy pulled it away from me. "You really think we have to chase down ponies? Fluttershy, there's plenty of ponies who are happy for a little consequence-free fun."

"But there are consequences, Mac! You drain their—their…"

"Adoration," I said.

"Right. You drain their adoration!"

"We don't drain it. We leave them a little in the tank. I try not to drink anypony into a stupor, but Rarity was just so into me I couldn't stop. And then there's what Mrs. Cake did. Fluttershy, if you ever want some great and freaky fun, make a pass at Mr. Cake." I reached out and grabbed his hoof to nibble, and this time Fluttershy didn't fight me.

Fluttershy giggled again in his deep voice, the sound like hot butter melting down my spine. "Everything I've read about sirens is wrong?"

"No. Every other siren I've met was everything you're afraid of. We just don't work like that. We prefer to care for ponies and move on before our feeding does any harm." I began nuzzling his hoof, working my snout around it and decorating it with little nibbles and kisses.

"You've encountered other sirens?"

I nodded while I worked my tongue into the groove of his frog.

"What happened? What are they like?" Despite his earlier protests, Fluttershy didn't try to dislodge his hoof from my care.

Giving up the hoof only to collect its twin, I let out a sigh. "Their names were Rock and Grunge, and they fed on helplessness. I didn't realize it was them at first, but when they revealed what they were, I played along to give—to give my master time enough to reach me."

"What did they do to you?" Fluttershy wasn't looking at me, but rather at his hoof as I heaped attention upon it.

Kissing the soft flesh of his sole, I let out a little sigh. "They were not nice fish, Fluttershy. They wanted to do much worse things than that other siren did to you. They fed on a mare's helplessness, toyed with her, and almost left her a hollow shell. Her name was Summercrisp Pear."

"Oh. A cousin?"

I just nodded to him and tried to forget what the two monstrous sirens had done to Snuggles. "Or near enough. She's okay now, I left her with all the Bits I could."

"Wait," Fluttershy tugged on his hoof and pulled it from my grip. "Are you saying you patrol Equestria?"

"If you ever want to see my master not be the easy-going stallion he mostly is, show him something hurting ponies. I thought he was going to rip them in half—and I think they thought that too." I rolled to my belly and squirmed a bit. "Do you want to test that thing out properly before we go to Zecora to get you changed back?"

"Change back?" Fluttershy jerked up and off the bed, standing beside it. "But I—" He looked at me. I was laying as provocatively as I could with my belly down, which meant stretching one leg back to show off my thigh and flagging my tail in open invitation.

"I promise you I'm loose enough, and unless you cleaned yourself off, you're definitely slick enough. If you want, I'll even feed." I might be a hedonist, but I didn't have to use an ounce of magic to persuade Fluttershy to advance on me again.

"It—It won't hurt you?" He walked around behind me and looked under my tail.

Glancing back over my shoulder, I could see hunger in his eyes, and the hefty tool hanging under his belly. "Sirens are amazingly robust. You can do whatever you want, and I'll probably moan all the louder for it."

"You're a lot lewder than you were, Mac." Fluttershy stepped forward and put his forehooves on the bed on each side of me.

When he slid forward far enough that his flared tip kissed my ponut, I arched my spine. "Me? Lewd? I'm not the one who's buggering their first lover."

Pushing forward, Fluttershy parted my body around his length and drilled his way deep into me. Stretching and pressing his snout into the back of my mane, Fluttershy's said, "You weren't my first, Mac."

I opened my mouth to ask for more details, but Fluttershy picked that moment to shove deeper, and all that came from my throat was a happy moan. He was definitely a big stallion—bigger than I'd had for a while—but that only served to stir my arousal more.

The sex was awkward after that. Fluttershy bucked well enough, but his aim was far from perfect, and he slipped out of me twice. By the time he finally unloaded in me, we were both giggling almost as much as we were moaning.

Despite it all, I still had plenty of opportunity to bask in the fullness and heat. "You didn't answer my question."

"What question?" Fluttershy's deep voice was breathless, and it made it sound all the cuter.

"Can I feed from you?" I asked.

"You're really serious about asking?" Fluttershy sounded perplexed. "Does it hurt? No. Of course it wouldn't. You wouldn't hurt anypony. What does it feel like?"

I wanted to hug and kiss him forever for realizing his mistake and showing how much he still trusts me. Remembering back to when Feather had eaten up my adoration, I shivered in excitement. "It feels good. I remember wanting Feather to do anything to me, and what he did was made me want that more and more until all I could feel was happy."

"That—That siren I fed before, I think he fed on lust." He sounded embarrassed. "I liked it more than I—I really liked it."

"It's up to you, Fluttershy." Truth be told, he could have asked me anything right then and I would have agreed to his terms—there was something about having a big stallion you trust inside you that makes the world better.

"Okay. Go ahead." Fluttershy shifted a little, and when I looked back he was braced.

"Uh, Fluttershy?" I asked.

"What?"

"I don't mean now. Next time we—"

"You want a next time?" Fluttershy's tension broke and he leaned forward, which stirred a latent sigh of pleasure from my throat. "Oh, right, penis. Hold on." Then he pulled back.

The whole world seemed to explode with colors I'd never seen before. I felt amazing, but empty. All my muscles seemed to go limp, and I completely missed Fluttershy's gasp of shock and ensuing run to his bathroom.

I lay on his bed, my mind twirling in circles at the implications of his answer and how adventurous this new Fluttershy was. Clenching down, I tried to keep all his seed inside—at least until he was done in the bathroom.

When Fluttershy walked back into the room, I turned my head to look at him. "You look magnificent. Do you want to go to Zecora's now?" I jumped to my hooves and quick-walked through to his bathroom.

"I-I-It's getting late. We shouldn't go into the Everfree Forest after dark." His words betrayed him, though I was certainly not going to punish Fluttershy for passing my test.

"Well," I said, "What about we go into town and you can talk to my master?"

"M-M-Maybe we could go into the Everfree Forest after dark. I'm sure it's safe!"

"Fluttershy, he doesn't bite." Done, I washed my hooves and walked out of his bathroom. "Not unless you ask him really nice, anyway."

Author's Notes:

Rarity: what did you think of Fluttershy poaching your current model?

"To be honest, darling, I quite like the pluck she showed. He's definitely pretty enough that they could make some wonderful foals together, not that I'd put pressure on her to those ends, but have you seen where she lives?" Rarity seemed ready to slide into full-gossip mode. "I'd had high hopes for her when she and Big Mac Apple were sneaking around everywhere, but that never went anywhere before he went somewhere."

---

So I do this "Ask X" thing. X can be any pony within the story. You can ask them anything and they will definitely, hopefully reply. Keep the questions appropriate to the age-rating of the stories, and they will answer the best question in the author notes of the next chapter. The more votes a comment has the more likely I will get it to the right pony to answer. Try to keep it to one question per post! They will pick one question per chapter.

Support me on Patreon or fuel my writing on Ko-Fi!

Join me on Discord. Please use your FimFic name as an alias. Warning, said chat may contain NSFW material and should be considered adult in nature.

Awesome ponies who are already helping to keep me in keyboards and rum:
A.P.O.N.I.
Boulder
Canary in the Coal Mine
Daremo
Dio-Drogynous
KFS Crimson
Nils
Sirion123

And special thanks to the following, for careful eyes and friendly words:
Lab