Why is Fluttershy So Shy?
Chapter 8: Chapter Eight. Deceit, Fear and Unexpected Turn of Events
Previous Chapter Next ChapterThe sun shined brightly this autumn morning as cold crisp breeze blew through the city, causing the early morning people to wear warm clothes to work. But for two people, a cold breeze is the least of their worry. Anon wakes up to the sound of an alarm clock ringing loudly, causing him to wake up without thinking and smack the clock off and falling back into the pillow. But seconds later Anon's eyes open wide as he notices that he doesn't own an alarm clock, leading him to sit up straight. Anon looks the room over and he's not in his bedroom, suddenly he feels movement next to him, making him look over. As he looks over to the side of him he finds a naked Sunset Shimmer sleeping peacefully. he instantly looks away from her and looks down at himself and finds himself naked also. And all he's memories of last night come flooding back to him along with a feeling of guilty and fear for his girlfriend. He couldn't keep this secret from shy and he didn't want to lie to her, she deserved better then that.
Quickly Anon got up to put his pants and trousers on, Sunset turned over to see his bat wings sticking out of his back and she could see that they were real making her gasp. This scared Anon causing him to look round in horror, Sunset had found out he's secret and he didn't know what to do.
"W-What are you?" Sunset asks her fear clear in her voice
"I......er..." Anon didn't know what to say.
"Are you from Equestria?" Sunset asks smiling calming down.
There was only one thing Anon could think to do at this time being and that was to bring her to Fluttershy to which he was not going to like. "Get dressed and ill show you." Anon grabbed his shirt, waistcoat, trench coat and left the house and Waited in his car for Sunset.
Minutes which felt like hours later Sunset left her house dressed and got into the car. "So where are we going?"
"You'll see." Anon replied, there was no joy in his voice only regret.
The drive was mostly silent until Sunset spoke up once more " Anon, About last night-" Anon lifted his hand to cut sunset off.
"I don't feel like talking right now. We'll talk about last night later, And just so you know im going to be completely honest to Fluttershy." Anon says keeping his eyes on the road, not even looking at Sunset.
"Do you regret it?"
"Sunset!"
"Do you?"
"..."
"Well?"
Anon sighed sadly "I would be lying if yes."
That seem to keep Sunset quite for the rest of the drive. But Anon's thoughts went wild and he knew that Fluttershy already knew about him sleeping with Sunset he didn't know, but he just knew that she did. Soon they arrived at Fluttershy's house and Sunset immediately became scared of what was about to happen next. Anon didn't say anything as he left the car and she knew better then to say anything that wasn't going to be given a proper response. Sunset followed Anon to Fluttershy's door, he could of unlocked it with the spare key she gave him but he didn't feel right doing that to day instead he just knocked and they didn't have to wait long before she answered.
Fluttershy opened the door with angry frown seeing Anon look sad and Sunset look fearful. "You've had sex haven't you?"
Anon stared her right in the eyes. "Yes."
Fluttershy bit her to hold back the tears. "Let me guess she saw your back and worked out the rest?"
"Yes."
"And you didn't know what to do so you brought her back to me?"
"Yes."
Fluttershy looked over to Sunset who looked confused and scared. "Its okay Sunset go sit in the front room." Sunset did say anything and just did as she was told, she scooted past Fluttershy and entered the front room. Shy looked back at Anon "I'll talk to you later." And that was it Fluttershy closed the door behind her, leaving Anon on his own.
Without knowing what to do Anon head back home in his car and sat down on the sofa and began to watch some YouTube. But as he sat there his thoughts began to wonder, wonder about what Fluttershy and Sunset are talking about, wonder about his future with Fluttershy and Sunset. His thought began to become to much for him so he called out to Buddy, Molly and grabbed their leashes to take them out on walks. Anon took the dogs to their local dog park and let them of the leashes to let them run around. As Anon walks around while the dogs play, Anon notice a familiar pink girl sitting alone looking upset.
"Pinkie?"
Pinkie instantly looks up still frowning "Anon!"
"What's wrong you look sad and you never look sad. I didn't even think it was possible." Anon jokes forgetting his trouble for a little while.
"Its Nothing really." Pinkie continued to stare at her shoes.
"Nothing! Pinkie your upset, Its clearly not nothing. Come on tell me what's bothering you?" Anon asks giving pinkie a playful punch on the shoulder making her giggle.
"Do you think im embarrassing to be around?" Pinkie asks looking up Anon.
"No I don't. Why do you think that?" Anon asks clearly seeing there was something she was holding back.
"Well when I tried to meet Gilda, Rainbow's friend, they barely noticed I was there. And they kept running off together without me." Pinkie explains sounding so upset.
Anon smiled at pinkie and wished he had her problems right now. "They were probably just so excited to see each other from being apart for so long. Dash must of accidently forgot about you without meaning to. Give her a text and you'll see that everything is okay."
"Yeah your probably right." Pinkie says cheering up smiling brightly.
"I know I am." Anon says with confident smirk.
"So why are you upset?" Pinkie asks as her bright and colourful personality had seemed to come back in full strength.
Anon faked a confused look that could fool the police if he was on trial. "Im okay. Im take my dog's out for walks." Anon points out to Buddy and Molly.
"Yeah but your on your own. Where's Fluttershy?" Pinkie asks looking out for her.
"She busy at the pet store and she said that was nothing I could do, so I decided to take the dogs out for walks. " Anon felt bad about lying but he couldn't tell her the truth.
Pinkie nodded her accepting the lie. "Well since you've got nothing to do, do you wanna go to cinema and catch a film?"
"Yeah alright. Let me just get Buddy and Molly, ill take them home and we can go." Anon stands up to See buddy and molly. "BUDDY! MOLLY! COME ON!"
They come running over as soon as Anon calls and he attaches the leads and begin to walk them back home. After take Dogs back home, they take the car and drive down to the Cinema and look at the list of films that are on to day. Having decided on The Power Girls: Age of Maneiac, they buy their tickets, snacks and enter the screen to sit down and watch the film. But halfway through the film Anon's thoughts turn back to Fluttershy And Sunset it had been awhile now and nothing. No Phone call. No text. Nothing, but suddenly everyone starts laughing at the antics between Split-Second and Zapp, Causing Anon to focus back on the film and forget his problems for th time being. Once the film was done and they had watched the end credit scene Anon and Pinkie began speculation over the film and the Squeal to come.
"Its about time Sombra did something then just sit on his ass." Anon says with all the excitement of six year old hype up with sugar.
"I know and we finally got to see the Eternity Gauntlet!" Pinkie squealed with excitement.
"The Power Girls: Eternity War is gonna be the most amazing film." Anon announces as they make their way into the car park.
"Don't forget we've got Mistress Marvellous Civil War next." Pinkie says reminding him.
"Mistress Marvellous team vs Masked Matters team. I cant believe we have to wait a year!" Anon says as gets out he's car keys to open the car doors
"Its gonna be worth the wait!" Pinkie smiles as she gets into the car.
"I know. Whose team are you on? Im team Masked Matter." Anon asks he starts driving away from the Cinema.
"Oh no team Mistress Marvellous makes the most sense." Pinkie argues back.
The Argument carry's on for the entire car ride, both of them trying to get the other to see sense in their opinion. Anon drops Pinkie off at Sugar Cube Corner and they both agree the conversation isn't over and that they would continue it over text. But as soon as Anon drives away a notification sound goes of making Anon pull out his phone and look at it. It was text from Fluttershy, he opened up his phone as quickly as he could.
"We need to talk now."
And with that Anon turned the car around and head towards Fluttershy. This time surprisingly he's head was silent on the way down to Shy. No shouting, no over thinking, it was bliss and at the same time it was worrying. Maybe he had accepted his fate and what ever happens, happens, he just hoped for the best outcome possible. he arrived at Fluttershy's house and he thought it best open the door with his own key this time.
"Fluttershy?" he calls out, unsure of where she was.
"In the front room." Fluttershy answers back.
Anon found Fluttershy dressed her vampire clothes, sitting one of the two arm chairs, she has a table was between them with tea ready for them to discus what happened this morning. There's no expression on her face as she stands up and walks towards Anon and he didn't know what to expect. But suddenly her expression gets and she slaps Anon hard across the cheek.
"That was for making me scared by not coming back." Flutters slapped him harder a second time on the other cheek. "And that was for sleeping with Sunset." Fluttershy started to burst into tears as she suddenly grips Anon tightly in hugging him as he hugs her tightly back.
A couple of minutes late Fluttershy pulled away drying her from all the tears. "Feel better?" He asks smiling gently.
"Yeah, I just needed to get out all of my emotions. Sorry." Fluttershy apologies having dried her eyes.
"You don't need to say sorry. im sorry, I never meant to hurt you." Anon apologies as tears started to escape he dried them quickly and held them back.
"Come on we need to talk." Fluttershy took hold Anon's hand she led him to the arm chairs to sit down. "I want you to answers these questions honestly and I don't want you to lie. okay?"
"Okay." he nods show he understood.
"Do you love her?" It hurt Fluttershy to ask that but she needed to.
Anon thought it over deeply all of he's thoughts were on Sunset and how he felt. "Yes I do."
"Do you love me?" She somewhat feared this question.
Anon didn't even have to spend a second thinking of his answer. "Yes of course I do."
Fluttershy sighed a sigh of relief know he still loved her. "Okay well I had a chat with Sunset she now knows what we are and with a little talking she understood and accepted us. ...Im happy with you dating both of us, I tried to see if I could have feelings for her and form a herd, but I couldn't, she's a great friend, I just didn't feel anything like that for her."
"Are you sure your okay with me dating you and Sunset?" Anon asked shocked.
Fluttershy put on her serious voice. "Just make sure you make time for me and remember. If you feel that strongly for Sunset then you might want to give her the option to change like I did with you. Or do you think you could bare to live with out her and watch her grow old?"
She was right and Anon had thought it that way and now he had to ask her the question and he didn't know if he could handle watch sunset grow old as he stayed young.
Next Chapter: Chapter Nine. New girls, New problems. Estimated time remaining: 5 Hours, 25 MinutesAuthor's Notes:
I had fun coming up with the power ponies/equestria girls/marvel cross up.
I also I have an idea and I want you guy's and girls opinion on it. Im thinking of making a villain up for Fluttershy and Anon to fight. what do you guys think?
Im still going to be doing the films aka rainbow rocks, friendship games and legends of the everfree so don't worry on that front.