Chapter 34

The three of us decided to go to that restaurant close to Sunset’s apartment...the one we had breakfast at the day after the bar incident. Sunset had put on some of her normal clothes, a pair of jeans and the red t-shirt with the sun on the chest…and of course, her leather jacket.

Fluttershy had brushed her hair to tidy herself up a little bit after our little session in Sunset’s bedroom.

We got seated quickly, even though the place was pretty busy. It was no surprise it was open surprisingly late on weeknights with this kind of traffic, which is the reason we went there…as well as the fact that they had nachos.

Sunset wanted us to stay with her so that we could see what happens when she turns. Neither Fluttershy or Rarity got to see what happened because they weren’t expecting it to happen, so they weren’t paying any attention.

They put us in a booth that was along one of the inner divider walls this time. The ambiance there at night was even nicer than during the day, the big pot lights with dark green shades that hung just over the table were dimly lit, lighting the two girls’ faces nicely, making their eyes sparkle.

They were both very beautiful in this light, even though the small amount of make-up that Sunset wore had run while she was sweating, then got wiped away thoughtlessly by her hands while she was in the heat of the action.

“You really should have showered, Sunset…” Fluttershy said, showing a bit of self-consciousness on her friend’s behalf.

“Bah…” Sunset waved her off. “I couldn’t wait. I’m fuckin starving…”

I chuckled at Sunset’s attitude. She was a lot of fun when she was loosened up. Her hair was still pretty messy around her face, some of it had that previously-wet look, like it had been stuck in sweat that had now dried. I’d be willing to bet she didn’t smell the greatest under her arms anymore either.

“I wonder how long it will take…” Fluttershy said softly.

“I dunno…” Sunset replied, chewing her lip as she started staring at the table top. She was probably getting tired, it was after 11pm after all. I was curious as well about what was going to happen when she changed. Would she just stop being tired? Would her hunger just disappear?...these thoughts made me realize why she was probably so antsy to go eat…it was likely going to be the last time she would experience the satisfaction of fulfilling a specific food craving while being really hungry.

Fluttershy had been on her phone off-and-on since we left Sunset’s place, making me wonder who she was texting…

Just as I was thinking about that, a familiar face appeared at the end of our table.

“Good evening, darlings…”

Sunset looked up, then smiled when she saw who it was. “Hey, Rare! What are you doing here?” She said, shifting over to let Rarity sit next to her.

Rarity slid onto the bench across from me, giving me and Fluttershy a little smile. She turned to answer Sunset’s question. “Fluttershy texted me, inviting me to join you guys for a late night dinner, which sounded delightful! How could I refuse?”

“Ah.” Sunset nodded.

Rarity stopped, looking more closely at Sunset’s face. “My word, Sunset! You look atrocious!” she said, putting on a half grin. ”I take it that means you enjoyed yourself…”

Sunset froze, then blushed a little. “What do you mean?” she said, trying in vain to hide what had happened, unaware that Rarity already knew everything.

Rarity looked at her with a smirk, then glanced at me for a second before returning her eyes to Sunset.

Sunset knew what that meant. She groaned, turning her face towards Fluttershy, who shrugged innocently.

“Sorry, Sunset. She was going to find out eventually anyway…” Fluttershy said timidly, hiding behind her hair.

Sunset shook her head. “It’s Ok…you’re right. Rarity should know anyway…I mean, it’s just the four of us who are like this, right?”

“Precisely, darling.” Rarity said. “So…” she said, nudging Sunset’s shoulder with her own.

Sunset looked her. “So…what?”

“Come on Sunset, surely you can spare some juicy details…” the gossipy fashionista said. “How was it?”

Sunset nodded. “It was, uh…pretty OK.”

Rarity cocked an eyebrow. “OK?”

Sunset looked awkwardly at Rarity for a second, then rolled her eyes. “OK, it was pretty good.” She said. “Better than I expected. Happy?”

Rarity put on a satisfied grin. “Now that sounds more like the Golden Arrow that I know,” she said, winking at me.

I smirked and shook my head, then turned to look up at the server who was approaching the table.

“Hi guys, how’s it going tonight?” she said in a friendly tone.

We all nodded, mumbling words like ‘good’ and so on, except for Rarity who perked her head up.

“Simply wonderful, darling!” she replied with a little flip of her bangs.

“Great.” The server replied. “Your server for this evening will be right with you, but until then, can I get you started with some drinks?”

“I will have a sparking Perrier with one lemon wedge and one-half lime wedge.” Rarity said, quite impressively.

“Wow, very specific.” The server laughed, then she looked at Sunset.

“I’ll have a Pepsi.” She said with a smile. I noticed right then how disheveled she actually looked. She probably should have showered…I should have as well, technically…since I had gotten covered in her sweat too. In fact I think I could smell it on me…

“Is coke OK?” the server asked Sunset as I pulled my shirt collar over my nose to take a whiff.

“Sure.” Sunset nodded.

The server looked at Fluttershy.

“Just a water.” She said quietly.

The server leaned forward, turning her head to bring her ear closer. “S-sorry?” she asked, squinting.

“Um, water…” Fluttershy said, even quieter.

“You-…water?” the server repeated, to which my girlfriend nodded as the rest of us snickered.

“Sure.” The server said, standing up straight again. She turned to me next.

“Pepsi, please.” I said.

“Is Co- hey!” the server laughed.

I smiled back. “OK, do you have Coke?”

The server smiled as shook her head. “Smarty. We’re gonna keep an eye on you.” She turned to the rest of us. “OK, coming right up.” she said as she turned to walk away.

Rarity folded her little white hands on the table. “OK then, darling. Let’s hear it.” She said to Sunset.

Sunset rolled her eyes. “I told you, it was good.”

Rarity shook her head. “No no, I need details.”

“Why?” Sunset asked, “You know what he’s like, you already had a turn with him.”

“Two, actually,” Rarity snapped back without thinking, before slapping her hand over her mouth.

Sunset looked wide-eyed at Rarity. “What?”

“Nevermind, darling. I…I must have miscounted,” Rarity quickly replied, struggling to come up with a decent recovery.

“Miss-“ Sunset shook her head, scowling. “How the fuck do you miscount between one and two?”

I had a good chuckle at the exchange. “Rare can say the dumbest shit when she’s flustered...”

Rarity put her nose up. “Just forget it, darling.”

I smiled at them for a few seconds, then I looked at Sunset. “Do you feel any different yet?”

Sunset sighed, then started fondling her wrist that was injured a few weeks ago with her other hand as she looked up at the ceiling. “It still hurts when I bend my wrist.” She said, looking disappointed.

“Don’t worry, darling. Just give it time.” Rarity assured her. “It should work as long as you, um…” Rarity tapped her chin, looking up at the pot light above us. “Hmmm, what was that you had to do again?” she teased.

Sunset groaned. “Fuck, Rarity…you wanna know? Fine.” she said, starting to raise her voice. “We were in my room, me and Flutters both gave him head, then I rode him…” Sunset pointed at Fluttershy, “Then she rode him…” she pointed back at herself, “Then I rode him til he popped.”

I was fairly certain that Sunset said that whole thing louder than she had intended, and I started looking around the restaurant as she and Rarity continued to talk. I met eyes with the people in the booth across the aisle from us, who were glaring over in our direction after hearing the entirety of Sunset’s recap of the evening.

I quickly turned back to Fluttershy, who had her head down, hiding her beet-red face behind her hair, then I looked back at Rarity and Sunset, who were still gossiping loudly with graphic detail.

“Hey! Guys, keep your fuckin voices down…” I whispered loudly.

The two girls looked at me, then over at the people in the other booth. Rarity blushed as she and Sunset looked back at each other, then snorted…snickering quietly at each other with embarrassment.

“OK.” Rarity composed herself, leaning her head down closer to the table. The rest of us followed suit, now speaking in closer quarters.

I was enjoying myself. I really liked these girls…and they were now all just like me...well, almost…Sunset wasn’t quite there yet. They will always be around with me now…I still had a hard time grasping this fact after being the only one for so many centuries. Spending time with them made me forget about my unusually long life. They made me feel normal…I couldn’t possibly love them more, just for that single reason.

“I’ll say this…” Sunset was saying. “Flutters is literally THE MOST FUN person to be in bed with…she was awesome.”

“Oh, I can imagine…” Rarity said, grinning at the shy girl, who was beaming with pride at the compliment, but still blushing at the fact that we were talking about sex in public. “What kind of things did she do this time?” Rarity asked.

Sunset chuckled. “Actually, it was me who kind of went a little crazy…” She nodded towards me, “I thought Golds was going to smash my face a couple times.” she laughed.

Rarity looked stunned as she glared at me, then back at Sunset. “I beg your pardon?” she asked with a high tone.

“Well…” Sunset started. “I got a little too deep into it and I kind of…started role playing.”

Rarity dipped her head as her eyebrows went up. “Really? What did you do?”

Sunset scratched her temple, looking down at the table. “Well…I bullied them. Like back in high school…”

Rarity snapped her head back. “You bullied both of them? Golds too?”

“Yeah, well…actually no.” Sunset said. “What I did to him…I never did in high school.”

“I hope not…” I chuckled as Rarity glanced at me.

“What did you do, Sunset?” Rarity demanded an answer.

“Well, I started talking mean to Flutters, just like in school...” Sunset said, turning to Fluttershy. “And she was great, she knew what I was doing right away and started playing along.”

Rarity looked at her shy friend in disbelief.

“It was kind of scary at first…” Fluttershy said softly, finally joining the conversation. “But once I knew she wasn’t serious, I thought it was kind of exciting…it was actually a lot of fun…”

“Hmm…” Rarity thought out loud, cocking an eyebrow.

Sunset tipped her head towards me next. “Then this guy ruined it…”

“What?” I scowled. “No I didn’t!”

Sunset chuckled. “Just kidding.” she said, turning to Rarity as she started to laugh. “You should have seen his face, Rare…when I said I was gonna bully him…” she started laughing harder, struggling to finish the sentence. “It was fucking priceless…haha…”

“It would be a bit out-of-the-blue, I would think.” Rarity chuckled, giving her hair a flip with her fingertips.

I spoke up. “I legitimately thought you’d lost your fuckin mind…” I said, folding my arms.

Sunset shook her head with a grin. “Whatever…as if you weren’t gonna fuck me anyway…”

“Oh…well, yeah, I was still gonna do it…” I admitted.

The red-head sighed…looking at me for a moment. Then she shook her head. “You sure made things difficult for me.”

Rarity scowled. “What do you mean by that, darling?”

Sunset glanced over at her friend. “My plan for how I was gonna bully wasn’t really working out…”

The purple-haired girl rolled her eyes. “Well, I should think not…he’s not exactly someone you can intimidate very easily.”

“No,” Sunset said, knowing that Rarity had misunderstood. “I didn’t bully him like I did Fluttershy…remember, I said it was something I never did in high school.”

Rarity cocked her eyebrow at Sunset. “Sunset Shimmer…what did you do to him? Or try to do, I should say.”

“Oh, I did eventually do it…” Sunset said, with a look of satisfaction on her face.

“Did what??” Rarity asked impatiently.

Sunset grinned. “I edged him.”

“You mean…?” Rarity leaned in closer.

“I wouldn’t let him cum…” Sunset said. “I kept stopping.”

Rarity gave me a sympathetic look. “You poor thing,” she whimpered, before turning back to Sunset. “Well, it’s no wonder he wanted to smash you, darling; you don’t withhold pleasure from someone like that!”

I shrugged. “Too bad she couldn’t do it by herself…”

“What?” Rarity looked back at me.

Sunset rolled her eyes. “Well…I had a little trouble getting him there…that’s when the role playing kind of got screwed up and I kept breaking character…”

“Why? What happened, darling?” Rarity asked.

Sunset tipped her head at me. “He kept making me cum first before I could get him there…I had to keep stopping.”

Rarity looked at me and smiled. She cocked an eyebrow as she turned back to Sunset. “Oh… well, I know all about that. I have had exactly the same problem with him…”

“Me too…” Fluttershy interjected.

Just then, we heard someone loudly clear their throat at the end of the table. All four of us quickly turned our heads to face the person standing there.

It was our official server. She was a petite girl, but she had obvious muscle tone, similar to Rainbow Dash. She was in her early twenties, with orange skin and fairly short, fuchsia hair. She had big eyes, with large pupils and violet irises.

She was standing there with the tray of drinks, her eyes wide open as she stared at us.

After an awkward pause, Rarity started laughing nervously. “Oh, uh…heh heh…Hi Scootaloo…I didn’t know you worked here…”

She nodded slowly. “Yup…this is my second week here.” She said, her eyes still darting around at the four of us.

I looked down at the table, unable to face her. I was positive she had heard everything we were saying.

After an awkward pause, Rarity suddenly pointed a finger at Scootaloo. “Not one word of this to Sweetie Belle! Understand?”

“Sure, whatever.” The girl said. “My lips are sealed, unlike yours…”

I quickly looked away from the young server to hide my reaction. “Wow, get some ointment for that burn! I like this chick.”

“Um, so here are your drinks, guys…Water?” she said, holding up the glass.

Fluttershy put her hand up, her face as red as a tomato. Scootaloo reached out to set the drink down in front of her.

“Perrier?...oh, that would be you, Rarity.” She said, setting the sparkling beverage down in front of the fashionista.

“Good guess, darling. Thank you.” Rarity replied.

“And two Cokes…” Scootaloo said, reaching out to set Sunset’s drink down, then she set mine down in front of me.

I looked up at her. “I ordered a Pepsi…”

“Nice try.” Scootaloo smiled at me as I raised an eyebrow at her. “Yeah, she told me all about you…”

I chuckled and picked up the drink to take a sip.

“Didn’t you guys get menus yet?” the young server asked, looking around the table.

We shook our heads.

She sighed. “Sorry guys, it’s just been crazy here tonight. I’ll get you some, one sec…”

“No, it’s OK!” Sunset stopped her. “We don’t need menus.”

“What desserts do you have?” Rarity asked.

Scootaloo pointed at the back of the booth with her pen. “There’s a dessert menu there.”

Fluttershy passed the small book to her friend while Sunset ordered.

“I’ll have the buffalo chicken nachos.” Sunset said.

“OK, sour cream and salsa on the side?” Scootaloo asked.

“I don’t care, just pile it on…I’m friggin starving…” Sunset replied.

“OK then,” Scootaloo chuckled. “You’re hungry, eh?”

“Oh yeah…” Sunset said, rubbing her hands together.

“Worked up an appetite, did ya?” Scootaloo asked again.

“Yea-“ Sunset stopped, realizing she’d been trapped.

Scootaloo chuckled, then pointed to the corner of her eye with the back of her pen. “Your make-up’s a little, uh…”

Sunset blushed, touching her fingertips to the corner of her eye, finally realizing how obvious it looked that she’d had a rough night. She then looked over at me.

“Don’t look at me!” I thought as I looked back at her for a second. I glanced up at the young server girl, who looked down at me with a raised eyebrow. I lowered my eyes again and took a sip of my drink, knowing that Scootaloo was fully aware that I was the one who banged the ass off of Sunset Shimmer that night.

Rarity, who missed the whole thing, suddenly perked up. “OOH! I’ll have that triple chocolate crunch sundae...doesn’t it look amazing, Fluttershy?” she said as she held up the picture to her friend.

Fluttershy nodded.

“Shall I make it two?” Rarity asked.

Fluttershy nodded again. “Sure, Rare.”

“Make it three.” I said, not really caring what I was going to have.

“OK. Great. I’ll get those out to you as soon as I can.” Scootaloo said as she turned to walk away.

The four of us looked at each other in silence for a moment, then at the same time we all started laughing together at what just happened.

“That girl is such a sass-pot…” Rarity snickered as she gave her hair another flip with her fingertips.

After the giggling died down, Fluttershy looked at the fashionista. “Um, does Sweetie Belle know?”

Rarity stopped, suddenly looking very serious. “No…she doesn’t. I haven’t told any of my family yet. I’m not sure how I would tell my little sister that she is going to get old and pass on while I stay this way forever…” Rarity said, starting to look remorseful.

“Oh…I’m sorry, Rarity.” Fluttershy said quietly. “I didn’t mean to bring that up…”

Rarity shook her head. “No no, darling. We will all have to face these things at some point. There’s simply no avoiding it.”

“What about you, Flutters?” Sunset asked.

Fluttershy shook her head. “I haven’t even talked to them.”

Fluttershy had a small falling-out with her family a few years back when her younger brother had been obsessed with becoming some kind of hair stylist in Paris. He had begged their parents for months to move to Europe with him so he could get his foot in the door there and despite Fluttershy’s advice not to go, they allowed her brother to convince them, like the pushovers that they were, to pack up and move to France. Then, not surprisingly, her brother gave up on it when he didn’t accomplish his dream within a week and now he’s still living in their parents’ flat, freeloading off of them as always. They could barely afford to keep living there, and didn’t have the money to move back home, so they’re stuck in Europe with their turd of a son.

They never would have done something like that for Fluttershy. She never understood why they did it for Zephyr…maybe because they thought Fluttershy was going to be fine on her own?

Fluttershy had grown tired of trying to convince her parents not to let her brother use them as doormats, and Paris was the last straw. Fluttershy knew the whole thing was ridiculous and that it was never going to work out, but they didn’t listen to her and went anyway. It frustrated Fluttershy to the point where she stopped talking to them…it broke her heart to do it, but they caused her too much unnecessary stress in her life that she didn’t need.

“It’s too bad we can’t make everyone we know immortal…” Sunset said.

Rarity glared at Sunset. “That’s my little sister!”

“Whoa!” Sunset put her hands up. “I mean, without having to have Golds fuck them.”

“Sweetie Belle doesn’t have magic anyway.” Fluttershy said quietly.

“Oh yeah…” Sunset said, rubbing her chin. “Good point. I guess the only people Golds can turn immortal is the seven of us…”

Rarity tapped her chin for a moment. “I wonder if Gloriosa has any magic left in her?”

Sunset laughed. “Gloriosa Daisy? Could you imagine fucking her? She’d be all like: ‘I GOT THIS!’… except you won’t be able understand her with Golds’ cock in her mouth.”

The three of them giggled together. I didn’t know who's mouth they were talking about so I had a look around the restaurant.

Eventually our food came and we ate while we talked. Sunset was still working on her nachos long after the three of us had finished our ice cream.

Rarity had her hands folded on the table, watching Sunset pick at the now cold and soggy chips.

“Um, Sunset?” Flutterhsy asked.

“Yeah, Flutters?” she responded.

“I noticed, um…that you took my advice…” Fluttershy said quietly.

Sunset frowned a bit with confusion as she put another chip in her mouth. “What advice?” she asked with her mouth full, which muffled her words.

“About, you know…down there.” Fluttershy replied, pointing down at her own crotch.

“Mm.” Sunset nodded, then swallowed her food. “Yup.” She said as she swiped her hand over the table in a slicing motion. “I took it all off. You were right, if feels so much better like this.”

Fluttershy giggled. “See? I told you…”

Sunset rolled her eyes. “Yeah, yeah.”

Rarity hadn’t been paying attention and was now looking at the both of them. “What are we talking about, darlings?”

“Fluttershy convinced me to shave my pussy.” Sunset said rather abruptly as she rifled through her plate, looking for a chip that was still crispy.

Rarity’s eyebrows went up. “Oh! Well, that was probably a good decision, darling. If you’re going to be stuck a certain way forever, that’s probably a good choice to go with.”

“How about you, Rare? What did you do with yours?” Sunset asked, picking up a chip.

“I have a lovely little landing strip.” Rarity bragged. “I happened to be trying it at the time…I feel that it adds a certain level of sophistication down there, especially given my colour scheme.”

Sunset looked at her sideways as she sipped her drink through the straw. Then she replied. “You don’t really like it, but you’re stuck with it now. Is that right?”

Rarity looked blankly down at the table. “Yes.”

Sunset chuckled as she picked up another soggy chip.

“I thought it looked good…” I said, trying to cheer up the fashionista.

Rarity gave me a half smile. “Why thank you, darling. It’s always lovely receiving compliments on one’s clam…” she said sarcastically as Sunset and Fluttershy giggled.

I shrugged. “I was just…ah, forget it.” I said, waving her off.

Rarity looked back at Sunset for a moment, then changed the subject. “So, how did you do it?” she asked.

“Do what?” Sunset asked with her mouth full as she quickly glanced at the indigo-haired girl.

“How did you get to edge him?” Rarity asked.

Sunset looked up with her eyes at the pot light, her mouth slightly open as she used her tongue to dig a piece of nacho chip from one of her molars. “Oh, yeah…” she said. “I had to get Flutters to take over until he got close.”

Rarity raised her chin at the realization. “Ahh…yes, that would do it. She clearly knows how to work him better than we do.”

“Well, it’s not just that…” Sunset said as she crammed another chip in her mouth, then continued to speak with her mouth full. “She doesn’t stop when she’s cumming…” Sunset turned to Fluttershy, pointing her finger at her. “Which, by the way Flutters, you owe me some new bedsheets…”

Fluttershy blushed while rubbing her right arm with the other. “Yeah…sorry about that.”

“My word…” Rarity said, looking back at Sunset. “Is she not the most stunning thing you’ve ever seen when she’s making love?”

Sunset nodded. “Yeah, totally.” She replied, looking at the shy girl. “You’ve got moves, Flutters. I’ll give ya that.”

I put my arm around Fluttershy as she smiled, but continued to blush. She rested her head on my shoulder as we listened to the conversation.

“So, anyway…” Sunset continued. “After Flutters got him close, I got back on and did my thing. It felt kind of lame getting back into the bully character after I had to get her to help me, but whatever. I just rolled with it. It was good times.”

“Well, that’s the main thing.” Rarity said.

Sunset chuckled. “It’s funny…now that I think about it. I was trying to bully him, and I couldn’t…so I had to get the girl that I actually used to bully to help me do it…” she shook her head. “Oh, the irony…”

“It’s all good, Sunset.” Fluttershy said quietly with a smile.

Sunset smiled back at her.

“Well…I, for one, am delighted to welcome you to our little club, darling.” Rarity said proudly. “Especially now that you’ve paid the small ‘entry fee’…” she said, snickering at her own double-entendre.

Sunset snorted. “There was nothing small about it, Rare.” She said, winking at me as she wiped her hands with a napkin.

“Oh, stop…get your fuckin minds out of the gutter.” I said, shaking my head as Fluttershy giggled against me.

Rarity giggled for a moment, before continuing. “Well Sunset, I suppose this means we’ll be seeing more of each other in the near future…you won’t believe all the extra time you will have on your hands when you don’t sleep.”

Sunset slid her plate away and folded her arms on the table. “I can’t wait.” She said with a smile.

We finished up at the restaurant, paid and left to go back to Sunset’s place. All four of us were curious to see how it happens now that we knew to watch for it, so we planned to hang out at Sunset’s to spend time with her and see what was going to happen.

We headed up the elevator to her floor. As we walked down the hall to Sunset’s door, Rarity and Fluttershy were chatting as I walked behind the two of them. Their conversation was suddenly cut off by Sunset’s voice behind us.

“Uh, guys…”

We stopped and turned around. Sunset was about forty feet behind us, obviously she'd stopped walking long before we noticed. She was holding her wrist, moving her fist back and forth as she stared at the floor with wide eyes.

We watched her as she slowly raised her eyes towards us to speak.

“My wrist doesn’t hurt anymore…”