Luigi and Fluttershy decided to go back to the mansion. First they went to the rooms they were already at to catch the boos. But while they were in the Area 2 hall they saw a floating candle stick which scared both of them. But then they went back to trying to capture the boos, each of which were teamed up with a shadowbolt. Then they actually went to the rooms they haven’t been in yet. First they went by the place they first met the grabbing ghosts. Luigi went to the room next to it while Fluttershy waited.

While Luigi was in there there was a toad that was sitting on the floor crying.

“Toad what’s wrong?” Luigi asked

Toad sniffled and answered “I, uh… dropped a REALLY important thing in the toilet. I didn’t mean to!”

“Don’t worry about it, Toad” Luigi said.

“Hey... you’re right!” Toad said “No point crying over spilled milk! I suppose I’ll just flush that old worry away. Yup, I’ll just let it swirl on down to the depths and let happiness refill my life!”

Then the lights turned on suddenly, and then Luigi decided to see what toad dropped. It was a key. Luigi picked it up, trying to barely touch it while still picking it up, and washed the key but had to take his gloves off first, then washed his hands, then put his gloves back on, then actually put the key away.

Then he left the bathroom and he and Fluttershy went to the room the key led to, which had a fortune teller in it. They walked up to her, but unlike the other ghosts, she didn’t disappear. When they walked up to her she asked “What... do you seek of me?”

“Wh-who are you?” Luigi asked.

“I am Madame Clairvoya, seer of dropped items. Possessions of other people awaken vibrations in my spirit. If you find someone’s dropped items, you should bring them to me. I will show you the extent of my vision… Also if you’re looking for multiple people, then I need two; one from each person. It works better if it’s at the same time, too.”

Fluttershy had found some things earlier and picked them up; a hair clip shaped like a diamond, a cupcake (though she didn’t eat it), and a book, but didn’t end up giving them to Madame Clairvoya.

Luigi and Fluttershy went to the next room. It had a mirror. Then ghosts grabbed each of them, and they shook the ghosts off. But neither of them saw the ghosts until they saw the mirror. They gasped at the same time. But then they caught them. Then more appeared and they caught them.

After they caught all the ghosts, the lights turned on and a chest appeared. After catching the boo in the room, and Fluttershy caught the shadowbolt, Luigi opened the chest. It was a strange red medallion with a fire ball on it.

Then Luigi’s Game Boy Horror went off. “Hey guys! What have you found there? Let’s take a look at that.” Professor E. Gadd said. Luigi held up the medallion, and E. Gadd continued. “It’s… a Fire Element Medal! Now you can use the Fire Element! Yes sir, with that, you can catch Fire Elemental Ghosts! Of course, if you only have one, only one of you can use it.”

“What’s a ‘fire elemental ghost?’” Luigi asked.

“Hm? What’s a fire elemental ghost, you ask? Why, they show up wherever you see fire! They’re ghosts of fire itself, if you will. If you approach a flame, they’ll be surprised by your presence and leap out into the air. Then you vacuum ‘em up right away! After that, you can expel fire at stuff. You can melt ice, light candles, do all kinds of stuff. The meter on your Poltergust will actually tell you how much of an element you have left, so keep an I on it! You may have to use the fire element to defeat some ghosts… Keep that in mind! Don’t say I never warned you!”

Then they left the room, and also found a key. They went to where the key went, and it was some kind of laundry room. After he and Fluttershy caught all the ghosts, Luigi checked the washing machine and saw… Mario’s hat! Then they go a chest and when it opened there was 20 coins, 25 bills, and 2 gold bars. Then after that, they caught the boo and shadowbolt.

Then they went to Madame Clairvoya’s room, and Luigi gave her the hat and Fluttershy mentions how she found some stuff earlier, and then, as Madame Clairvoya could not read more than two items at a time, Fluttershy only gave her Pinkie’s cupcake.

“What objects do you two have here?” Madame Clairvoya said. “Show them, please, to Madame Clairvoya. This is.. a cupcake, and Mario’s hat. Why, it’s so clean as if... SOMEONE JUST WASHED IT! ...Sorry, sometimes I like to add a little drama, you know. Hm? Just one moment… Did I just say Mario? But what about the cupcake?”

“It’s probably my friend Pinkie Pie’s. I would wrap it in plastic, but there is none.”

“Well, I have some random stuff that I keep because who knows!” Then she wrapped it up. “So anyway… how many are we looking for, exactly?”

“Well I already found Applejack, so that leaves Twilight, Pinkie Pie, Rarity, Rainbow Dash, and his brother.”

“Well anyway, I need to show you my vision. And Luigi, you’re the younger brother of the famous Mario, and you have come to this place to find him! And Fluttershy for her friends! Anyway, let’s get to reading that fortune! Ahh! They come! Now the spirits come!! Come spirits of power, come spirits of sight! Show me the awful things occurring here tonight! Crystal orb, symbol of my clan, use your darkling powers to show us all you could, I mean CAN! Show us all you can! Show us these five still trapped in the mansion! The light of the spirits comes! Show us what we seek!! Ohhhh… Harummm… I see that these five live… none of the five are in the spirit world, but one cannot say they are alive… haaackth ha ha hork! (Excuse me, sorry.) Where are they? Where is at least one of them? ...Ah, the spirits fall silent! Uuuh… This is all I can tell you for now! Bring to me more dropped items, and I will show you where they are! These clues no longer speak to us…”

Then Luigi and Fluttershy went to the hall and walked around for a bit, and saw a floating candlestick! Luigi scanned it, and it said “Ah, the beautiful Melody will not even give me the time of day... What must I do to win her? Passion! Yes! That's it! I will show her I burn for her! My unbridled passion will scorch her soul!” Luigi was confused by that, but thought maybe he should light the candles the ghost was holding. Then the ghost appeared and made really strange noises. They followed him anyway, and then they went to a room full of tools for lots of stuff, and caught him.

Then they got a key, and caught the boo and shadowbolt in the room.

Then Luigi noticed a mouse hole. He scanned it, and somehow it made him go through the mouse hole. There was a room, full of treasure chests, but Luigi still was freaked out by the mouse hole and tried to make sure he could get back, but when he tried to, the Game Boy Horror gave him an error message that said he couldn’t teleport out until the room was lit up, he had opened all the chests, and caught the boo. He sighed, and first caught the ghost bats, and then opened the chests, and managed to find all the ghosts, which he needed to use the fire element on, and also got 48, coins, 48 bills, and a red gem, a blue gem, and a green gem. Then he got the boo, and shadowbolt, in the room. Then he scanned the mouse hole, and went through it. Since he kinda fell out of it, Fluttershy asked if he was okay and he said he was fine.

Then they went to where the key went, and it was a room full of instruments. They played them, (and guess what was playing) and then a ghost appeared.

“My name is Melody.” the ghost said. “People call me the spectral beauty of the ivory keys! What a stirring performance! I haven’t been so charmed by a piece for ages! One of you, or maybe both of you, have delicate ears for music. Would you two like to listen to my piano sonata? Well, here I go.” Then Melody started playing a song. Luigi recognized it.

“Wasn’t that song in Super Mario Bros. 3? In that game, just like the first game in the first game in the series I was only playable in multiplayer.” Luigi said after Melody finished playing.

“Yes, you got it! Oh, and sorry you got to be player 2 in that game.” Melody said. “Anyway, very impressive! I guess I needn’t hold back with you! Would you or your friend care to do battle with my musical sheets?”

Before either of them could say anything, music sheets came out of the piano, but Luigi and Fluttershy vacuumed them up, and then Fluttershy captured Melody and the lights came on.

Then a chest appeared and in it was a key, and then they caught the boo and the shadowbolt of the room.

Then they went to a dining room, and found a ghost that they caught and got 20 coins, 5 bills, and a green jewel. Then after that, Luigi scanned it’s heart and  it said “No one can see me in this darkness! No one no one no one noooooooooo-one!” Then Luigi thought maybe to light the candles, and then he had to vacuum up the food, and then caught the waiters, and then he and Fluttershy had to avoid him spitting fireballs at them, but then he got tired and Luigi and Fluttershy caught him. Then they got a chest with 20 coins, 20 bills, 2 gold bars, and a silver diamond. Then they caught the boo and shadowbolt and went to the next room, which was a kitchen. They caught the speedy spirit in the room (from now on I am just going to call it that even if they never actually find out what they’re called) which rewarded them with 20 coins, 5 bills, and a blue jewel. Then they found another frozen ghost, and Luigi caught it. Then a blue chest appeared, and they found a medallion similar to the fire medallion, but it was blue and had a drop of water on it. Then Professor E. Gadd messaged Luigi on his Game Boy Horror.

“Hey now, guys! What have you stumbled across? ...Ohh… This time… it’s… a Water Element Medal! Now you can use the water element! My research shows that these particular elemental ghosts leave their watery dwellings whenever you approach. You know the drill… vacuum ‘em up! Then expel ‘em the same way as the fire. I hear there are some ghosts who can be defeated only by water, actually… Also, remember that water has purifying properties, so use it well…”

Luigi gave it to Fluttershy, who hosed down the flaming door. Then they caught the boo and shadowbolt, and then went through the door.

They were outside, but there was a dog house. Fluttershy filled the dog’s water dish with water and suddenly the dog appeared and woke up. Then he walked up to Fluttershy and licked her face.

“Down boy.” she said laughing, but then a skeleton ghost appeared.

“Fer the luvva dirt, make that yappy dog be QUIET!” the ghost said but then they caught him.

“Okay, now, I really don’t want to do this, but I think I need to catch you.”

The dog whined a little bit but let them catch him.

Then Luigi scanned the dog house, and teleported through it, but this time Fluttershy went too. There were in a graveyard. Then three ghost skeletons appeared, and Luigi and Fluttershy caught them. Then the biggest grave started glowing. They reluctantly walked towards it, and when they did, lightning a strange ghost appeared! He, or she, or it was purplish pink, and blobish, and even its, erm, arms had goo coming off of them! Both Luigi and Fluttershy screamed when it appeared! Then they were in someplace that was surrounded by an iron fence. Then the ghost appeared and they screamed, and then Luigi vacuumed it up, but then he realized that it wasn’t actually the ghost, but then saw the shadow and shot the goo ball it, and vacuumed up some of the ghost’s health, then Fluttershy did it, then they kept switching until they caught the ghost. Then they were teleported back to the graveyard, and they saw a chest. They opened it, and a key and a painting of Rainbow Dash was in it.

Then Luigi’s Game Boy Horror went off. “Luigi, can you hear me?” E Gadd. said. “Good to hear you and Fluttershy are still okay! I lost your signal when that lightning struck. Hmmm that was some battle, or battles if you each fought a different ghost, that you had there.”

“We both fought the ghost.” Fluttershy said.

“Okay, well, why don’t you two come back to the lab?” E. Gadd said.

“What if one of the Poltergusts are damaged?’ Luigi said.

“What? You think the lightning damaged one of the Poltergusts?” E. Gadd said. “Don’t worry about it! Even if that lightning had cooked your goose, the Poltergust 3000 wouldn’t even have a scratch! Heh heh!”

Luigi and Fluttershy went to the lab, and Professor E. Gadd had them turn the ghosts into painting, then Fluttershy put the painting of Rainbow Dash on the opposite end of the machine, and turned her back to normal.

“What happened?” Rainbow Dash said, and Fluttershy explained everything. Then Rainbow Dash said “Woah. Fluttershy, how did you become so brave?”

“I did it for you, Applejack, Rarity, Twilight, and Pinkie Pie.” Fluttershy said.

“This is a strange painting.” Professor E. Gadd said. “It says Bogmire, but I really don’t remember this one.”

Luigi and Fluttershy were surprised by that, but still went back to the mansion.