Silver awoke slowly to the gentle embrace of the softest and warmest bedding she had ever felt. It didn’t feel like there were sheets, but the mattress and pillows more than made up for it, keeping her warm and cozy. She snuggled into the pillows, cooing softly as she became aware of a soft thumping coming from beneath the bedding. It was a steady beating rhythm, like a pulse, and it threatened to coax her back into unconsciousness.

“Are you awake?”

Silver’s ears stood sharp, recognizing the voice as her Princess. She tried bolting up, only to find a pair of large and powerful bands held her in place. She tried putting more force into her efforts, but her fingers merely sank deeper into the bedding, earning a giggle from the Princess. Realizing that her eyes were open despite the pervading darkness, she focused her efforts on extracting her face from whatever held it in place. When she did, her heart practically melted.

Princess Luna was gazing down at her little Silver. The smaller mare was held tightly against the alicorn’s naked belly while her face had recently been extracted from her bare breasts. Luna could only titter further at the way the smaller mare squirmed against her, especially in light of what they had been doing not so long ago.

“I- You- That is to-” Silver stammered incoherently. Images of what had happened before her loss of consciousness flooded her mind. She wanted to just crawl into a hole and die after the terrible things she’d done to her Princess, but said Princess refused to let her look away. Instead, Luna held her chin in place as the alicorn’s eyes fluttered sweetly.

“Silver Bell,” Luna hummed contently.

“Pr-Mis-Lu-” Silver stammered to find the right words.

“You did well.”

Silver blinked, flushing as her inner turmoil seemed to melt away in the alicorn’s grip. “I… did?”

Luna nodded gently. “You performed wonderfully.” She tittered. “I can tell you have a real knack for giving orders.”

It was Silver’s turn to flush, but her mind remained functional as she processed Luna’s words. “You w-wanted me to d-d-do that?” It was a near incomprehensible prospect, but one that needed urgent clarification.

Luna leaned forward and lightly touched noses with Silver. “I am, as modern ponies say, a switch.” She rubbed her hand along Silver’s back, soothingly petting her beneath her wings as she explained. “In my many years, I have partaken of virtually every manner of carnal delight this world has to offer. I feel the cravings of their variety no differently than other ponies crave food.”

This much Silver knew as she nodded along, squirming a little to make herself comfortable in the alicorn’s grip. It wasn’t hard.

“Given my size and position, most assume I enjoy being dominant in bed as much as on the throne,” Luna said as she began nuzzling Silver’s ear. “And while that is fun, one could say even my rightful place, I still find myself wanting for variety,” she purred, now taking nips of the bat mare’s ear and earning several soft squeaks of delight. “I love playing games, pretending to be somepony I am not. I want a pony who can be more than an equal.” Her hand slid further down until it stopped just above Silver’s tail. “I want a pony who can take charge, to play the role of putting me in my place now and then.”

Silver whinnied as she felt Luna’s fingers weave through her tail, wrapping around the strands of hair until she had a solid grip. Without warning, Luna gave a swift yank of Silver’s tail, causing the bat mare to cry out in joy as her wings sprung out.

“My my,” Luna giggle as she felt a dab of wetness against her stomach. “Sensitive, aren’t we?”

“N-no fair,” Silver whined. “Y-you cheated.” Despite her mini orgasm, the bat mare was finally feeling her thoughts grow more coherent.

“And how, pray tell, did I do that?”

Silver nuzzled into Luna’s touch. “Because you’re you,” she said meaningfully. “How could I resist?”

Luna felt her voice catch in her throat as her eyes threatened to water. Those hadn’t been the words of a blind zealot or servant, but a true lover. “All’s fair in love and war, my little bat,” Luna teased happily.

Silver leaned forward, trying in vain to climb through Luna’s cleavage to those coveted lips. The Princess, her Princess, met her halfway and they shared a kiss. It was neither platonic, nor was there tongue. Their lips pressed together with a passion, saying more than words could ever manage. In time they parted and Silver looked up contentedly at Luna.

“Now what?” the bat mare asked with a silly grin, unable to imagine anything bringing down the mood for how happy she was. It had happened. She’d done it, achieving her lifelong fantasy and her family’s legacy. She, Silver Bell, was now lover to Princess Luna. All was well in the world.

Luna pulled herself up against the pillows, holding Silver close until she sat cross-legged with the little bat on her knee. Once settled, with a hand on the bat mare’s back to hold her in place, she gave a dower sigh as she stared at her new lover. “Before we go further, there is something important we need to discuss.”

Silver nodded with a serious urgency. Luna was upset and this was not something Silver saw fit to suffer any longer than necessary. “Anything!” she asserted. Whatever it was, she would meet whatever was making her Luna look upset and take it away.

“It is a matter I have been considering for some time,” Luna admitted somberly. “None know of this, not even my sister. So when I tell you, I want you to think long and hard before you answer. Understand?”

Silver paused as she contemplated the severity of what she was about to hear. Something so serious that not even Celestia knows? Her mind raced with all the possibilities this could entail, from espionage to the Princess revealing her deepest, darkest fetish. No matter what it was, Silver knew she could not falter after coming so far. The bat mare straightened up and gave a swift nod. “Whatever it is, I’m here for you… Luna.” She had to restrain the urge to giggle. It still felt so naughty to say her name like that.

Luna took a breath, steeling herself before making her confession. “Do you hate me?”

Once more Silver’s brain performed a full reboot. “What?”

Luna grimaced. “It shames me to say, but the bat ponies have suffered terribly in my absence; most fleeing from the cities to Nocternia, or the wandering tribes, isolating themselves from the rest of Equestria. I have read of the hardships your tribe had to endure, alone, without my help.” Tears of sorrow welled in the alicorn’s eyes. “You loved me, you and all bat ponies, and I turned my back on you.”

“No!” Silver insisted. Luna was wrong. It felt blasphemous to even think, but emotion overrode reason and drove Silver on. Luna should not, could not, be allowed to blame herself. Somepony else had to be at fault. “We failed you. It was us. We should have-” but Luna cut her off.

“You did everything right,” Luna said through a sorrowful smile. “You loved me, devoted yourselves to me, yet I still gave into jealousy and became Nightmare Moon.” She ignored Silver’s flinch at the cursed name, caught up in the moment. “I turned into a monster, doing terrible things until I forced my sister to do something almost as bad. I failed!”

Silver flinched again as she felt her own eyes starting to water in anger and sorrow. Each word Luna spoke stoked the fires within the bat. She would never tolerate anypony to speak ill of her Princess, making it all the more frustrating that such words were coming from said Princess. It was infuriating, heartbreaking, and all so confusing the way the feelings clashed inside her.

“I failed the bat ponies. I failed my sister. I even failed myself as a Princess.” Luna snorted back her anger. “And then I come back to find most of Equestria has dismissed me as a legend, a monstrous story to scare foals into going to bed on time. How could you not-”

It was Luna’s turn to be cut off as Silver lunged up, wrapping her arms around the alicorn’s neck and squeezing tightly. “It’s alright,” Silver sobbed as she gently stroked Luna’s mane. “It’s okay.”

Luna returned the embrace, pulling Silver close as she cried into the mare’s shoulder. Amidst her muffled sobs, Silver choked down her own tears as best she could and endeavored to speak. This was something that needed to be said.

“We,” Silver sobbed. “We don’t hate you. We never did.” There was a pause in Luna’s crying as she listened. “We always loved you, Luna. When you went away, we were sad, but that didn’t change how we truly felt. We never stopped believing in you, praying to Faust for your swift return. I’ve spoken to many bat ponies over the years,” she tittered softly, “so trust me when I say they feel the same.” She tightened her grip, never wanting to let go, never wanting her Princess, her alicorn, her Luna to ever feel alone or unloved again.

“T-truly?” Luna whispered softly, keeping her face in Silver’s tear and snot coated shoulder.

Silver nodded against Luna’s cheek. “We heard about your return and your formal apology, the same as any other pony, and we were beside ourselves with joy. Our Princess had come back to us!” She laughed loudly, recalling the joy of time. “My sisters screamed and danced all over the house. When we got noise complaints, my dam told the complainer to shove it up her skinny flank,” she laughed through the tears. “My sire wept as he wrote correspondence to the nomadic tribes to give them the good news. And I,” she choked down a sob, “I cried. I cried until my tears ran out. We all did, and we just embraced and reveled in the moment for the rest of the day. For us, my Princess, there was never anything to forgive.”

Luna very nearly flexed her earth pony strength around the lithe bat mare, but managed to keep control. Instead she extracted herself from her lover’s messy shoulder, while Silver did the same, until they were eye to eye. With both their faces marred with tear stained fur and barely contained snot, The Princess of the Night kissed Silver with an aggressive passion. The alicorn devoured the smaller mare’s lips, desperate to convey her feelings of gratitude. Silver had to know, needed to know just how thankful her Princess was. Deep down Luna knew that it wouldn’t be that simple; that she still owed her bat ponies a proper apology, but that would come later. For now, the love and forgiveness of this one bat mare was enough.

Silver struggled against the larger mare’s advances. Luna was kissing her with a painful intensity and her lungs were starting to burn for a lack of air. The bat mare now found herself on her back. It was fortunate that there was a soft mattress against her, lest she be crushed by the alicorn’s immense bulk. Her hands groped impotently over the alicorn’s body, searching for anything to grab onto. Her finger’s glided across the immensity of Luna’s breasts, but the mammaries were squished too tightly against her own for her to get any kind of grip.

Finally Luna ceased her assault and stared down the bat mare. As her massive breasts eclipsed the bat’s tiny frame, the alicorn stared down with a hungry gaze and held Silvers face with her palms, the tips of her fingers teasing the tufted ears. “Silver Bell.”

“Luna,” Silver heard herself reply as her wings fluttered meekly. The scent of arousal hit her nose like a pillow to the face, adding to her already heightened sensitivity.

“Thou art our new lover,” she said with a throaty lust. Beneath the desire lay an air of command, an order so absolute that not even the craftiest lawyer would dare overturn it. Luna’s word was law. “Doth thou know what this means?”

Silver needed a few moments to think. “We’re going to rut?” she asked with a mixture of hope and fear. Now that the moment was finally upon her, to do what she was born to do, Silver could not deny her anxiety. Little strings of fear throated through her mind, every lingering doubt and insecurity she’d ever imagined suddenly climbed to the forefront of her mind. Do I know what to do? Am I strong enough? Will she break me? Can I truly handle her? Do I… deserve to?.

“No,” Luna growled, leaning close as Silver’s eyes widened in shock and horror. “It means I’m going to fuck you until you can’t walk anymore.”

“Okay,” Silver squeaked as her lips curled into a grin. Luna’s words, her absolute declaration, had erased roughly 75% of her worries. She was wanted, and she knew it. However, that still left the little mare questioning if she was up to the task. Luna was a goddess, after all.

Luna sat up, straddling the smaller mare as she stared into Silver’s eyes. That look of fear blended with excitement was one the alicorn always savored. It was the look of a virgin experiencing their first time. While cases like Thomas were rare, where she could take a pony’s virginity good and proper, she and her sister had found a more than adequate replacement. ‘Alicorn virginity’, as Celestia had dubbed it, was the look on a pony’s face when being with an alicorn for the first time. No matter how much experience, or how many partners they might have had before, it all paled in comparison to the realization that they were about to be with an alicorn for the first time.

Deciding she’d drawn out this moment long enough, Luna clapped her hands. The main doors opened and in walked Moonlight and Thomas. Their bodies fidgeted in anxiety as they waited to hear what had happened in their absence, eyes darting between Luna and the mare between her legs. Luna gave them an eager grin. “She said yes,” she gasped in elation. “Phase Three is on.”

“That’s great!” Thomas shook his fists in cheer.

“I’m so happy,” Moonlight said, bouncing giddily in excitement, not unlike a filly who had gotten the doll house she’d wanted for Hearth’s Warming.

“Three?” Silver asked as she watched the other concubines over Luna’s leg.

Moonlight wrapped an arm around Thomas’ shoulder and pulled him close, her breast pressing against his cheek. “Thanks largely to my stallion,” she bragged proudly, “the three of us came up with a three part plan for your final test. The first was dressing Luna as a maid to help you see her as a mare.”

“Second part,” Thomas chimed in, “was the apology.” He beamed at Luna, proud of her for going through with something so hard. “Again, really glad that worked out.”

“Told you it would,” Moonlight chuckled.

“And the third,” Luna purred, rotating her hips around the bat mare’s waist, “is your initiation.”

As if on cue, Thomas and Moonlight made for the bed with purpose in their eyes. Luna grabbed Silver by the waist and lifted her up into the air. Despite being a natural flyer, the bat mare still found the action disorienting as her wings impotently flapped about to hold her balance. The Princess and bat stared at each other for only a moment before Silver was lowered back down, but not onto the bed. Feeling the folded legs beneath her loincloth covered butt, Silver looked back to see Moonlight smiling down at her. The bat mare couldn’t even open her mouth before the unicorn grabbed her stomach and began fondling her breasts.

“Do you like that?” Luna asked seductively.

Silver moaned her approval as Moonlight kneaded her breasts, testing which actions earned the strongest reaction.

“Good. You should know just how much debate went into discussing positions. We wanted to make your initiation a night to remember,” Luna purred, lowering her head while keeping her rump up.

Silver blinked when she saw Thomas standing behind Luna. He grinned excitedly, gave her a salute, and finally set his hands over Luna’s bountiful plot where Silver couldn’t see. “She seems to like me in this position,” he explained, as if him being in the traditional mounting position needed to be rationalized.

Luna coughed, eyeing him over her shoulder.

“I mean,” he corrected. “She likes being fucked like a real mare,” he laughed nervously.

At Silver’s confusion, Moonlight rested her chin on the bat pony’s shoulder and held out a piece of paper for her to see. “Humans have a very… colorful vernacular,” she tittered. “Try to work in a few of these phrases. Luna’s in the mood to experiment.”

Even with Moonlight’s hands on her breasts, Silver’s flush deepened as she read over the list. Some of the words were alien, but they were accompanied with a context that made their meaning all too clear, not to mention she recognized more than a few from conversations with Thomas. “You want me to,” she gulped, “say this!?”

“Mistress,” Luna pleaded, drawing attention to her place on eye level with Silver’s winking slit.

Silver straightened as her face hardened, not even flinching as Moonlight pinched her nipples. Her Princess needed her and she would not shirk her duties, even if said duties involved the Princess’ hot breath pelting her already burning marehood. Quickly she skimmed the paper for an appropriate starter. “D-does my little pet want to get f-fucked?” Somehow the words felt fitting on her lips.

“Mistress,” Luna growled throatily as her grin widened. “Pet wants to get fucked sooooo hard!”

Silver gulped, but maintained character as she glanced over at Thomas. “Is he,” she checked the paper, “going to f-fuck your P-Princess pussy?”

“No, mistress,” Luna tittered as she waved her rump back and forth. She was inching her way forward, feeling the soft fur of Silver’s thighs brush past her cheeks, and causing the bat mare’s marehood to wink even faster. “Pet’s pussy is being saved for later.”

“Moonlight!” Silver snapped at the unicorn, only to give her an apologetic look. Moonlight smiled acceptingly, understanding full well how overwhelming this must be, much to Silver’s relief. Silver flexed her wing in unspoken command and Moonlight moved her hands to the bat mare’s leathery appendages. She shuddered in delight, but kept her composure as she double-checked the list. “Then he’s…” Her eyes widened. “He’s… going to play with your… ass pussy?”

While Luna had been crouching like a cat, her left arm moved beneath her belly and between her legs, unable to help herself at the name calling. She’d been willing to abandon this element if human words didn’t have the desired effect, but the sticky stream falling from her marehood left no doubt that this was a good idea. “Pet likes having her ass played with. Pet loves getting it donkey style, and her pet loves giving it.” It felt so wrong to degrade herself like this, especially in front of one who venerated her so dearly, but that just made it more exciting. It was the ability to move past preconceptions, to break out of your role, which made these moments shared between lovers so treasured. Here, now, they were nothing more or less than themselves. “Shall pet begin pleasing mistress?”

Silver glanced at the paper once more. Besides vocabulary, there were also suggestions for other phrases. “Eat me out you little, um, slut. Suck my cunt and drink my cum?” she asked, though she tried to stay stoic. To say such things to the Princess, her family might disown her. But the look in Luna’s eyes made it clear that she was liking it. “Hurry, or else mistress will be displeased,” she emphasized with a stern look.

“As mistress commands,” were Luna’s last words before diving for Silver’s flower. The bat mare cried out as the alicorn lapped at her moist folds, drinking in her strawberry flavor. Luna’s tongue plunged deep, past Silver’s winking lips into her core. The alicorn grabbed the bat mare’s hips to stop her from squirming too much as she whimpered with ecstasy.

Removing her hand from her pussy, Luna snaked around Moonlight’s side until she grabbed the surprised mare’s flanks. This in turn caused the unicorn to tighten her grip on Silver’s wings, exciting the bat mare further. Moonlight eased into the new sensation as Luna’s powerful fingers kneaded her butt flesh until they found her winking slit. Luna grinned into Silver’s lips as she felt Moonlight’s anus and pussy tense at her touch, before finally relaxing and granting the entry of her fingers.

Thomas, who had been massaging Luna’s ample rear since the start, figured it was time to do his part. He gently pressed his finger into her puckered star, pushing it all the way in before removing it and a thin strand of sticky fluids, causing her already flagged tail to twitch. Glad to see her anus had already been lubed, Thomas set his hands back on her rump and pulled her cheeks apart, giving him unobstructed access to her enticing tail hole as it quivered in anticipation. He leaned forward and inhaled deeply, eyes rolling to the back of his head as his nostrils filled with Luna’s arousal.

“Jesus, Luna!” He gasped. Gently blowing against her twitching hole, Thomas chuckled as the onset of cool air seemed to excite her ponut even further. “You like that don’t you,” he teased. He was uncertain if Luna was even listening as the only sounds he heard were muffled moans of delight made between Silver’s legs, the succulent moisture dripping onto her fingers from Moonlight’s nethers, as well as the wet squelching on Luna’s tongue within the bat mare’s folds.

But Luna did hear. Her ears stood proud as all of her senses were geared into maximum awareness. The juicy flavor on her tongue, the depraved moans of her mares playing with one another, and the burning tool filling her ass were absolutely divine. Invisible tendrils of magic shot out around her body, desperate for more sensory input. The soft fur of Silver’s stomach, the look of bliss and control in Moonlight’s eyes, the clenching of Thomas’ own butt as he pounded into hers, and even the way her own winking marehood looked from between Thomas’ legs; all of it was at her disposal and then some. She was everywhere, enjoying her fucking from every angle.

At long last, Thomas lined up the tip with her entrance and pressed forward.

The lube worked better than expected as his cock effortlessly entered her pucker, causing Luna to whine even louder into Silver’s folds. That, he thought, and we’ve done it so much back here that she’s probably fully adjusted. Still, she was no less tight than the first time they did it as he hilted himself inside her until his balls tapped against her dripping folds. Her ass was warm around his stomach and sides. Her colon was almost burning as it clenched hungrily around his cock, trying to pull him in deeper.

Grinning to himself, Thomas looked up past the bountiful landscape that was Luna’s ass until his eyes met Silver’s. She’d been watching him, and he couldn’t deny the sight of his mares working on her wasn’t also stimulating. Using Luna’s plump cheeks for leverage, he pulled out until only the tip remained. Nodding at Silver, he slammed his hips against Luna’s rear, hilting himself once more as he heard Luna’s muffled cries into Silver’s pussy.

Silver’s hands found their way to Luna’s horn where they gripped tightly around the shaft. Luna shot her a needy look and the bat mare knew what she had to do. Leaning forward, Silver gave the tip a teasing lick, earning a shudder from the alicorn. Grinning, she wrapped her lips around the base of the horn, licking around where the appendage met the skull before sliding her tongue up along the shaft. Imagining the horn like a dick, she wrapped her lips around the tip and sank her mouth down, fellating it. Luna’s horn wasn’t as hot as Thomas’ penis, but it was hard and the texture felt good in her mouth. The tip felt almost blunted as it grazed the roof of her mouth, sliding to the back of her throat. Silver’s lips sunk further down, the tip tickling the back of her tongue as she reached for Luna’s ears, experimenting with different levels of pressure until she found one the alicorn liked.

In response, Luna began paying special attention to Silver’s clit, nipping and lapping at it between dives down into her folds. Her massive wings reached out and intertwined with the bat’s, feathers stroking enticingly across membrane, stimulating both mares. The Princess clenched around Thomas’ cock between thrusts, catching him off guard; her large dexterous fingers plunged deep into both Moonlight’s holes, causing her to bite and pull at Silver’s mane just to keep from crying out; and as she ate out Silver, she dominated the smaller mare’s wings. A lesser mare might fumble with having to pay attention to three lovers at once, but Luna was far from lesser, stimulating all three and bringing them painfully close.

Silver threw back her head, crying in orgasm. Her voice was echoed by groans and moans from her fellow concubines. Luna eagerly drank up Silver’s sweet nectar as her ass swallowed every spurt of salty cum. Each concubine collapsed forward, with Luna turning to the side in time to avoid impaling Silver on her horn.

After drinking the last of the bat’s juices and licking her vulva clean, the grinning Princess sat up to her full height, letting Moonlight fall atop Silver as Thomas was pinned beneath her massive backside. Despite being the only one to not orgasm, she sighed contentedly as she took in the sight around her. It was a welcomed sight, of lovers brought to the exhaustion of bliss thanks to her, but it was not enough to satisfy her just yet. She lit her horn and cast the spell.

The three concubines all shot up, suddenly full of energy, save for Thomas who was still pinned, but no less raring to go as his cock came back to life in Luna’s anus.

“Mistress,” Luna purred seductively, earning the attention of the other mares. She crouched forward, ears folded back submissively as her tail flagged high. “What do you want to do?”

“I…” Silver’s mind raced with the possibilities. Princess Luna had just given her the reigns, granting her permission to take the lead and do as she liked. Straightening stoically, the weight of this responsibility slowly became clear. “I’m in charge… of making everypony happy?”

“If that’s what you want,” Luna grinned as she nuzzled Silver’s breast. “I grant you full access to my body and well of magic. Both are yours to do with as you see fit, mistress.”

Something snapped in Silver’s brain. Her wings flared imposingly as she pointed a commanding finger at Luna. “Pet. I order you to release Sir Thomas, this instant.”

Luna obliged, lifting her rump enough for Thomas to wiggle his way free as his cock extracted with a soft pop.

Heart thudding in the thrill of her actions, of commanding her goddess, Silver’s head swiveled around the room until she spied the ponyquin from earlier and grinned nefariously. “If you are to be my pet, then it’s only fitting for you to wear the appropriate attire.”

Luna didn’t need to see what Silver had to know what the bat pony had in mind. Panting eagerly, she levitated the collar over to the bed where she gently handed it over to her mistress. Nodding in approval, Silver unbuckled the collar before eyeing the slender beauty of Luna’s presented neck. She licked her lips as she reached out, caressing the taut skin with her palms as she fastened the lock and pulled back. The sight of the Princess-turned-Pet, the mighty alicorn reduced to a humble servant, caused her to grind her thighs together.

Silver stood in the bed, wobbling a little as her extended wings adjusted to compensate and keep balance. She folded her arms, trying to look as domineering as possible. “Pet! Mistress commands you to bark.”

“Arf!” Luna answered. Her tail wagged as she panted like a real mutt. “Arf, arf!”

Thomas and Moonlight stared in stunned silence at the display. Their minds boggled at how easily Luna had given into the command and the eagerness with which she carried it out. Had this really been something she’d been craving all this time?

Moonlight cleared her throat, drawing all eyes on her. Batting her eyes playfully, she beamed up at Silver. “Will the mistress be needing a throne?” She accented with a lick of her lips as she eyed the bat’s plot.

Silver’s eyes widened, but she kept her face frozen and gave a soft nod. She crouched, sticking her rump out as she slowly descended to the sheets below. Moonlight quickly scrambled into place in an act reminiscent of the Dukes of Hazzard jumping feet first through the open window of their car. She slid her body between Silver’s legs, her own legs shooting past the bowing Luna’s face. She eyed the approaching plot with a hungry lust. Grabbing for her cutie marks, Moonlight gently guided the bat’s rear down onto her face, the tight ass cheeks wrapping around her muzzle as her lips softly kissed Silver’s vulva in greeting, tasting the juices from her earlier climax. She kept her hands on the cutie marks, kneading them gently and earning some welcomed moans from Silver, or rather mistress.

“Jesus, that’s hot,” Thomas blurted. Now it was his turn to feel the weight of all eyes in the room. Only they weren’t looking at him, so much as the hand masturbating his cock. He froze, eyes widened in shock as he hadn’t even realized what he’d been doing. He almost pulled his hand away, only to hesitate.

“What’s the matter, Sir Thomas?” Silver was still trying to sound in charge.

Thomas chuckled, looking up from his cock to face her. “I’ve got nothing to be embarrassed about.” He chortled his epiphany as he resumed pumping at his cock. “I… I love you girls.”

“Awwwww!” The mares cooed, even Moonlight.

Thomas chortled more, finding the sight far too endearing as he decided to play along. “What would mistress have of me?” he bowed gracefully, never ceasing his pumps. “Do I look as silly as I feel?”

“Probably,” Silver said, her face flushed as Moonlight began her advance between her folds. She smirked as a new thought occurred. “Thomas,” she said to his masturbating penis. “Do you recall the story I told about my father and my mother’s wing?”

Thomas smiled and nodded. “I do. Why?”

Silver smiled deviously. “You may not have a wing, but I’d like to see you recreate the story with pet.”

Once filled in on the story, Luna could not sit up fast enough. She leaned back, pushing out her hips as her legs spread wide, leaving nothing to the imagination. “Like this, mistress?”

Now it was Silver’s turn to pant, and not just because Moonlight’s tongue had stopped teasingly short of her G-spot. “V-very good,” she panted and motioned to Thomas.

The human had stopped masturbating, looking between the mares for direction on exactly how this was supposed to work.

“We’ll start simple,” Silver instructed. “Use your fingers and we’ll go from there.”

Deciding he was far too horny and curious to resist, Thomas nodded and bent down in front of Luna’s slit, crouching beside Moonlight and unknowingly giving Silver an eyeful of his own delectable rear. All his focus was on Luna’s winking marehood as he set his hands on her inner thighs, their size dwarfing him and making him feel small. Without hesitation he dove in with a kiss, paying special attention to Luna’s clit. The mare bucked and writhed at first, but soon calmed.

Thomas frowned in disappointment. It wasn’t that long ago that Luna’s self-control wasn’t nearly so strong, that his touch could drive her absolutely wild. He’d prided himself on that, but such results had been growing harder and harder to achieve. Intellectually he understood, that Luna’s alicorn body had powerful needs that could only be satiated with powerful actions, but it still saddened him that he’d lost the power to make her happy on his own. These thoughts were quickly pushed aside as Thomas remembered he had a mission to carry out, to make his mare squirm and moan as his other mare had commanded.

Flexing his fingers before his face, Thomas flattened his hand into roughly the shape of a spear and poked at Luna’s entrance. She squeaked, and Thomas smiled, scooting over to allow Silver a clear view. He’d never really cared to think about all that had been here before, all that Luna’s hungry cunt had taken before him. But now, as he sank his fingers all the way to their bases, he had to wonder exactly how much of himself she’d be able to take. At the same time, a faint voice in the back of his head wondered if he had enough to give.

“I can handle it,” Luna grunted, fixing Thomas with a look of determination from between her massive boobs. “There’s no need to fret, my little human. I promise you won’t hurt me.”

Thomas let the truth of Luna’s words fill him, only to look down and realize how far his hand had sunk in. There’d been no resistance, save for the occasional wink, as Thomas marveled at what he saw. His hand had been consumed all the way to the wrist. “Wow.”

“Ai’ll say,” Silver agreed idly, her eyes roaming over the delicious sight of Luna’s spread body to Thomas’ pert little butt, balls, and cock.

Thomas chuckled nervously and looked back over his shoulder. “How much can a mare take, exactly?”

“As much as ‘er stallion can give,” Silver tittered through her accent.

“Challenge accepted,” Thomas smirked. Aligning his arm, he sunk his hand in further. The occasional wink forced him to pause, but otherwise his progress was unimpeded. Two inches. Three inches. It wasn’t long before Thomas was down to his elbow. “Ya know, I remember you being a lot tighter,” he commented.

“Do ‘uman mares note adjust to zeir partner’s size?” Silver asked. “Alzou, zis goes far beyond anyzing Ai ‘ave seen before.”

“Alicorns,” Luna purred as her horn lit, as if the one word was enough of an answer. There came a noise from beneath Silver’s rear as Moonlight began to cry out into her plot. It wasn’t long before the others spotted the tingle of magic around the unicorn’s sex. “We are a gifted lot.”

“Pet!” Silver snapped, reminding Luna of her place. “Iou vill only speak vhen spoken to.”

“Mistress,” Luna bowed, cheeks bright red. It had been so long since she’d gotten a proper scolding.

Silver rapidly listed out a series of instructions, all in Prench. Thomas had no time to inquire before he felt himself wrapped up in Luna’s magic. His arm remained in place, two inches past the elbow, as the rest of him levitated into the air. He turned back to find Silver and Moonlight also levitating, and coming closer. Moonlight’s hooves slipped beneath the human; the left detouring around and over Luna’s hip while the right prodded at the alicorn’s entrance, just below Thomas’ arm.

Despite the logical part of his brain screaming that what he was seeing was impossible, Thomas nevertheless bore witness to Moonlight’s magically encased hoof sinking into Luna’s snatch. That same logical portion tried to latch onto the magic, using it to argue that Luna was bending reality to make what his vision was seeing possible. He didn’t even notice the way his rear raised into the air until he felt Silver’s arms grab around his hips. Surprised, Thomas looked back to find his butt in Silver’s face, her breath hot against his taint.

“Finally,” Silver gasped before pressing her nose to the human’s taint. He tried to squirm, but the magic held him fast. “Iou’ve been teasing me vhith zis plot zense ve met,” she accused. “Now, ite’s mine!” She inhaled sharply through her nose as her broad tongue scooped up his testicles, sucking them into her mouth.

Thomas made a number of incoherent noises as his mind tried to catch up with what had happened. The feeling of Silver’s tongue lapping hungrily at his rear felt strange, but not uncomfortable. His efforts to comprehend were cut short as Silver gripped his cock and began jerking him off.

“Luna above!” Thomas looked down to find the newly freed Moonlight, her cum-stained face in awe as she took in the sight that had previously been denied. Thomas’ ass was being eaten by a mare she had considered a rival not terribly long ago, all while he was elbow deep and she up to her ankle in Luna’s love tunnel. The whole scene was mind boggling, and something the mare was fairly certain no pony had ever even written about before. She moved, startling her back to reality as Luna’s active magic continued to pull the unicorn’s leg down deep past her knee. Her body writhed in ecstasy as Luna’s pussy massaged her leg and her magic worked the rest of her. “Is this a dream?”

Thomas grinned wryly as he hung upside down, his arm still sinking into Luna’s lower mouth as Silver gargled his balls and ate his ass. “Considering who we’re with, it might just be.”

“Then let’s make it a good one,” Moonlight declared as she leaned up and kissed Thomas fiercely. She shot her tongue into his mouth, feeling driven to share the lingering taste of Silver’s juices in her mouth, which he accepted with hungry moans. Alas, it could not last as the continuing sinking soon left their position too awkward for the unicorn to maintain. Her leg had been fully consumed by Luna’s sex. Thomas and Silver had both been moved out of her reach, but she didn’t have long to feel left out before she saw Luna’s hand snake down, sliding past the unicorn’s marehood as it did something beneath the alicorns. “What are you…” Her words were cut short as she felt something poke at her lips.

Thomas was now shoulder deep in Luna’s pussy, granting little choice but to look down at Moonlight’s sex. As such, he had front row seats as Luna removed her hand, revealing the alicorn’s cock. It was small at first, but in no time it grew unimpeded into Moonlight’s sex. They cried out as unicorn and alicorn became one, all while Thomas could not take his eyes from the bulge that grew in Moonlight’s abdomen all the way to her stomach.

It was only after hilting herself fully that Luna began thrusting. It was slow at first, easing Moonlight into the motions as the smaller mare acclimated to her girth. Using her magic, she pulled the unicorn back, unsheathing her cock from the mare’s snatch, as well as the mare’s leg from her own, before pulling them back together, sending ripples of pleasure through both her sex organs. The alicorn cock was not something Silver had ordered, but Luna felt her mistress, had she not had her mouth full of Thomas’ ass, would have approved. Another slow dual extraction followed by a swift double penetration, and both mares moaned with want.

Not wanting to be nothing but a passive fuck toy, Thomas began spinning his sheathed arm within Luna’s sex, fighting against the friction of Moonlight’s leg as he strived to touch every part of the alicorn’s soft insides. With his free hand he reached down, past Moonlight’s cutie mark until he found her puckered star. It twitched at his touch, parting shortly after in anticipation. At this angle, he could do little but insert a couple fingers, his hand moving with the mares’ thrusting, but it seemed enough for Moonlight as she looked at him through tear-filled eyes. She’d never felt so full in her life. It hurt a little to be so stretched out, but it was a divine kind of hurt that made her feel complete inside.

Silver ran her tongue across the crack of Thomas’ plot, her lips smacking hungrily against his smooth skin. She was only vaguely aware that, in her pursuit of human ass, she had lost control. The thought mattered little, as everypony seemed to be enjoying themselves. There would be time to learn to be a proper mistress later, roughly sometime after she found a way to eat both human and alicorn plots at the same time.

At this thought, Silver felt Luna’s hand cup her backside. As the Princess’ digits squeezed her plot, she felt a prodding of her back door. Unlike Thomas’ anus, which had remained stubbornly closed no matter how she had prodded, her own trained plot hole opened graciously for its guest. The bat pony pressed her muzzle tightly between Thomas’ ass cheeks as the warm appendage sunk deeper into her cave, allowing her to share in the same sense of fullness as Moonlight. Astoundingly, like Thomas’, the cock growing from Luna’s palm also had a pulse, causing Silver’s insides to reverberate with its steady thrum. She could take it no more and finally called out her feelings. “I love alicorns!”

Minds hazy with lust, it did not take long before the others made their own declarations.

“I love humans!” Moonlight cried happily.

“I love mares!” Thomas beamed excitedly.

“WE LOVE YOU ALL!” Luna boomed in the Royal Canterlot voice, shaking the entire room and the people within it.

It was the final straw as the foursome climaxed at once. Silver into Luna’s hand, Thomas into Silver’s hand and down on Moonlight’s face, and Moonlight and Luna into each other, the excess bursting out onto Thomas’ face. The mares and man fell lifelessly into the alicorn’s magical grip. She lowered them into the sheets, panting contentedly as she relished in the afterglow. It was only one orgasm, but it had been a mighty one, more than enough for her alicorn cravings, at least for the moment.

Luna scooped up her lovers, crossing her legs as she laid them neatly in her lap. She sighed blissfully as her eyes roamed over their sweat stained exhausted bodies. The room reeked with sex as Luna set a hand over her heart, feeling it beat with love for those who had made her so happy. Running the night’s events through her mind, she performed a silent evaluation of everypony’s performance, including her own.

Thomas was as dutiful as ever, his love and commitment easily compensating for any lack of physical ability. His masturbation in front of Silver, she reasoned, had been a sort of milestone in its own way, showing his trust and security with all parties present. Moonlight’s participation, Luna felt, left room for improvement. Sure she’d acted, but there was little she’d initiated on her own. Perhaps that was her thing? Perhaps she needed to be trained in obedience, just as Silver needed training in dominance. Everypony had their place, strengths and weaknesses, as well as preferences. If the guard could find a place as an obedient follower, or anything else for that matter, Luna would be happy.

Next was Silver, the star of the hour. Luna nodded in approval as she ran a finger through the mare’s mane. She’d had Silver pinned as a potential dom since the moment they met, despite all her rough edges. Like a sculptor pulling a masterpiece out of a marble block, Silver only needed somepony to help bring it out. However, while being a dom didn’t come as naturally as Luna would have hoped, she certainly got a kick out of playing the part. For a first try, the little bat performed admirably, pushing past her compulsion to worship to put her Princess in her place, if only for a little while.

As for herself, Luna’s chest puffed in pride as she beamed at nothing in particular. She’d exercised a few of her favorite kinky spells with ease, delighted at not being rusty. In particular, the Princess giggled at the glistening sight of Thomas’ arm and Moonlight’s leg. They’d stopped short of where she’d liked, but that was fine for now. Luna knew that Thomas especially might not be comfortable with such an experience, despite his own preferences. Ancient as they were, alicorns were nothing if not patient, at least most of the time. She would wait and ease them into the more elaborate perversions, building their trust in her and each other until the achieved the full ideal of the family herd.

Luna’s lovers stirred in her lap, bodies rubbing against one another. The mares were clearly the most conscious as Thomas moved with the least energy. Luna watched in elation as their eyes fell upon one another and grins grew upon their faces. Pleasantries and congratulations were exchanged, followed by Silver farting while the others tickled her in righteous retribution.

At a gurgle from Luna’s stomach, the alicorn used her magic to activate the bell marked for food. The maid arrived shortly after to take their orders, but was not allowed in the room. Besides sparing everypony embarrassment, Luna did not care to open the door and unleash the combination of alicorn, pony, and human sex odors onto unsuspecting staff, at least not right now. Orders were given through the door, only to be teleported inside when the maid knocked again. The foursome ate their fill, speaking little but saying much as they exchanged contented smiles.

There were still matters, serious ones, that needed to be addressed, but that could wait for later. For now, the newly initiated Silver had recovered enough for another round.

You know what? This chapter was pretty hard to write. Threesomes are one thing, but it can get pretty tricky trying to give everyone a position with a foursome. And with the premise of this story meaning the harem is only going to grow from here, I’m hesitant about doing any more of these. Of course there’ll still be clop, but I personally prefer love making to be more, well, intimate, and that’s just not easily done with larger groups.

Logistics aside, this was a fun addition to the story. Luna got a bit of catharsis from Silver’s forgiveness, most of which had been a segment written months ago but postponed until I could find a better place to put it. And you guys got to enjoy my longest and most elaborate clop yet. Alicorn magic is a handy plot device to allow for pretty much anything I can imagine, which is a lot.