Chapter 65*

2-28-15, 8:42 P.M.

It was a few hours before Celestia walked in, smiling as soon as she spotted them.

“Goodness, I hope this isn’t the aftermath – Luna, didn’t I say to wait?” she chided.

“Nay, sister, we have not started,” Luna sleepily mumbled.

Celestia lightly chuckled. “In that case, I’ll join you,” she decided, using her magic to expand the bed outward.

With that done, she curled up on the other side of Jeremy, and Jeremy gave a content smile as he leaned into her warmth as well.

“Shouldn’t we… call Chrysalis… get her in on this?” he muttered, sounding half-asleep.

Celestia gave a hum of thought. “Yes… she’s on her way,” she informed him.

Jeremy mumbled a barely audible ‘thanks’ and curled up between the two of them as Celestia gazed down at him with utmost adoration.

“I must say… your new form is absolutely adorable, I could cuddle you all day,” Celestia whispered.

“How do you think… I feel about you girls?” Jeremy whispered back.

Just a few minutes later, Chrysalis arrived. “Heard there was intense cuddling going on and good gracious it stinks of love in here,” she declared.

Jeremy waved a hoof for her to come join them, and Chrysalis gingerly stepped over the piles of books and texts that adorned Luna’s room. Finally making her way to the bed, she took her position right on top of Jeremy, her chitinous body surprisingly warm.

“Mmm… forget the sex, we should just do this all the time,” Chrysalis remarked. Jeremy chuckled slightly.

Moments later, Jeremy became aware of a distinctly uncomfortable pressure on his lower thigh. Initially unwilling to disturb the peace of the other three, he let it be until it became too annoying to ignore. Curiously, he lifted his head up and looked over – Luna’s ‘second horn’ had been poking him. Luna was looking at him with a guilty expression.

“Er…” she mumbled, blushing furiously.

“Need some help?” Jeremy asked seductively.

Luna laughed a little, and spread her legs wider, looking away with a grin on her face. Jeremy leaned over and licked the tip, causing Luna to shiver with excitement and Chrysalis to move off of him.

“Well, I guess we’re getting started, then,” Chrysalis announced, and immediately kissed Celestia on the lips.

Jeremy looked over in some surprise – he guessed he should’ve known that his wives would share the love amongst themselves as well, but it came as a bit of a shock nonetheless. Celestia, for her part, immediately returned the kiss, her forelegs wrapping around Chrysalis as the latter proceeded to forcefully invade her mouth.

After a few seconds of watching this, Jeremy went back to Luna, lowering his mouth and breathing slightly on her quivering shaft – Luna gave a small squeak at this, and he grinned as he began licking and sucking at her tip.

“Yesss… just like that…” Luna hissed as she began making slow thrusting motions into his mouth, her hooves on his head. Jeremy sucked deeper, his tongue making its way around her medial ring as he bobbed his head up and down.

“Keep… going…” Luna panted, seemingly restraining herself from thrusting deeper into his mouth. Jeremy smiled around her cock, and in one swift motion plunged down to the hilt, taking all 7 inches into his maw. Luna cried out in shock, and came, her fluids coating the inside of his mouth white as she held his head in place. Jeremy’s eyes widened as his air supply was cut off by the influx of fluids, but didn’t say anything – he could hold his breath for pretty long, after all. Finally, Luna rode out her orgasm and released him, panting with happiness and exhaustion.

“Ooh… that was… wonderful,” she declared, slumping back onto the bed. Jeremy swallowed, and grinned once more.

“I hope you’re ready for my turn,” he reminded her, before taking a moment to check on Celestia and Chrysalis. They were hard at it, licking at each other in the classic ‘69’ position, and Chrysalis caught his staring eye before lifting her head off and grinning.

“Like what you see?” she asked, and Jeremy nodded. “Hmm, that reminds me,” Chrysalis noted, before craning her neck over and biting him on the foreleg. Jeremy stiffened for a moment, but quickly relaxed as Chrysalis unlatched her fangs and went back to her ministrations.

“Oh boy, it’s that time of the night again – nothing but drugs and sex. God, we’re like the 70’s,” Jeremy muttered jokingly.

Luna giggled, and he positioned himself over her, already hard and ready to go.

“Huh, it’s the same size, too…” Jeremy noted, comparing his and hers curiously.

While hers was slightly wider, the overall difference wasn’t too noticeable, and Jeremy prodded the entrance to her marehood.

“Ready?” he asked, and Luna eagerly nodded.

“Rut me, you stallion,” she pleaded, and Jeremy happily obliged, slowly but surely hilting her as she breathed a long, drawn-out sigh of pleasure.

“Say, you three can get pregnant tonight, right? You don’t need to be in heat?” Jeremy asked.

Luna nodded. “We used a... rather unusual spell of Princess Cadance's design in order to enter our estrus a little early. That shall last for a month,” she informed him, and Jeremy nodded appreciatively. He began moving in and out of her, slowly at first but with a building rhythm.

As he looked down at Luna, he could tell she was enjoying it – but not as much as she could be. Jeremy decided to change that, leaning over and nibbling on one of her wings. Luna gave a renewed cry of pleasure, and Jeremy continued his assault on her senses, reaching a hoof over to circle one of her teats.

“Ah – it’s too much! We just came, we can’t - !” Luna exclaimed, but Jeremy was having precisely none of it, continuing to thrust, rub and bite until Luna could only gasp in pleasure.

Finally, he felt his orgasm building up, and with a primal cry he unloosed himself inside her. The amount of fluids that made their way out shocked him, and they quickly formed a puddle underneath Luna’s tail. Luna came as well, her walls clenching down on him and forcing out the excess liquid. Once done, she slumped down on the bed, unmoving. Jeremy, coming down from his own earth-shattering orgasm, placed a hoof to her chest in concern – her heartbeat was wild, but she seemed to be breathing just fine.

“Not… dead… just… wow…” Luna breathed, barely able to speak.

“I wasn’t too rough… was I?” Jeremy asked, still somewhat concerned – he wasn’t normally that aggressive.

“Pegasi have a reputation for being more aggressive than other ponies – good choice, by the way,” Celestia informed him before going back to her position below Chrysalis’ dripping pussy.

Jeremy, after taking a few seconds to process this, shrugged. He decided to help Luna recover while Celestia and Chrysalis finished their thing, and snuggled back up next to her, as she immediately brought him into a kiss.

“Best one yet,” she declared as she pulled away, and Jeremy gave an embarrassed smile.

“Why did I give so much?” he asked, referring to the puddle of fluid that was currently staining the sheets.

“It’s a lot less… ‘concentrated’… than the human variety,” Luna answered.

“Quantity over quality, huh?” Jeremy muttered, and she gave him a semi-indignant gentle smack with her wing.

Jeremy chuckled, and pulled her back into the kiss. They continued to lay there as Chrysalis’ and Celestia’s moans got louder and louder, and Jeremy was relieved to remember that Luna had soundproofed the room some hours ago. Celestia came first, wings once again flaring out and knocking Jeremy off of Luna and onto the ground. She didn’t even look over as she tensed and came, coating Chrysalis’ muzzle with her fluids. Chrysalis, for her part, was much quieter about her orgasm, and had finished by the time Jeremy poked his head above bed level again.

“You okay?” Celestia asked.

“Good as ever,” Jeremy answered, and hopped back onto the bed.

With that, Celestia assumed her position, dominating the bed with her sheer size. Jeremy was reminded of his new body’s diminutive stature as he climbed over her – while Luna was comparatively manageable, Celestia was now over twice his size.

“God, I’m tiny,” Jeremy muttered as he rubbed himself against her, slowly getting aroused once more.

“How many times do we have to tell you, your size is acceptable,” Chrysalis remarked irritably as she moved over beside Luna, who had by now recovered enough to lift her head from the pillow to watch.

Jeremy, after processing this, stopped what he was doing to double over in laughter. “The one time I didn’t mean it that way… I was referring to my height,” he replied. With that comment made, he leaned down and began suckling on Celestia’s teats, paying special attention to the nipples as Celestia hummed in satisfaction.

As he continued his foreplay, he noticed Chrysalis licking Luna’s rod, which had somehow managed to get hard again. “What is this, a square dance? ‘Everybody change partners, here we go’?” Jeremy commented.

Chrysalis laughed. “Might as well – you’re not the only one getting bitten tonight,” she declared ominously.

Luna laughed nervously, and she and Jeremy exchanged glances.

“You get used to it,” Jeremy assured her, and Chrysalis kissed her on the forehead to make her point.

“Relax, Moonbutt, it’s like a shot, you’ll barely feel it,” she remarked, and gently bit Luna on the foreleg. Luna had closed her eyes in dread, but quickly opened them again in surprise as Chrysalis pulled away.

“That was all? Hmm,” Luna thought aloud.

“Oh, that’s not nearly all,” Chrysalis darkly chuckled as she returned to pleasing Luna’s shaft.

Jeremy realized he’d been forgetting about Celestia, and turned back to find her gazing at him with half-lidded eyes.

“What are you waiting for? Make me your mare,” she whispered, and a blush crept across Jeremy’s cheeks.

“As you wish,” he replied simply, and thrust into her, forgoing gentleness – over the months, he had learned that Celestia liked it hard.

To his satisfaction, she gave a gasp of pleasure, and he grinned wildly as he thrust into her, the aphrodisiacs coursing through his system compensating for any exhaustion he might have otherwise been feeling.

“Yes! Right there!” Celestia cried out, and Jeremy figured he had found her G-spot. Aiming carefully, he continued to pound her senseless, hips slapping against her much larger ones as she began shouting out her pleasure.

Just a few minutes later, he felt the familiar sensation of a tightening in his chest.

“Celestia, I’m about to cum!” he warned.

“Do it! Inside!” Celestia half-shouted.

Jeremy gave one final thrust, burying himself to the hilt as his juices once again shot out like a fire hose. Celestia shuddered and spasmed as her walls clenched down upon him, and Jeremy collapsed on top of her a second later, out of breath and his heart racing.

“Not as long as last time… but how was it?” Jeremy haltingly asked.

“Amazing,” Celestia moaned, tail flicking in satisfaction.

Luna had already orgasmed again some time ago from the looks of things, so Jeremy moved on to the last mare of the night: Chrysalis. She gazed down at him with a sultry, indulgent grin as he moved in for a kiss, Celestia politely moving out of the way.

“Next time, I call first,” she got out before Jeremy’s lips locked with hers, Chrysalis instantly leaning into the kiss as her tongue reached into his mouth.

After a few moments of passionate making out, he unlatched from her, and sighed contentedly. “You three… are amazing, you know that?” he remarked. Chrysalis blushed green. Jeremy smiled – another thing he’d learned over the months was that Chrysalis responded very well to compliments.

“So, how would you like it?” he asked as they got into position.

“Nice and slow,” Chrysalis decided, surprising Jeremy.

“Sounds good,” he replied, and gave her a quick kiss on the lips again before making a trail of kisses down her body, Chrysalis shivering as he reached her nethers.

“Ooh… you stud, you know that turns me on,” she moaned. Jeremy smiled.

“Yeah? How ‘bout this?” he asked, and licked in a slow circle around her vagina, slowly centering in on her clit until he flicked it with his tongue. Chrysalis waved her hoof in a so-so motion, only her occasional twitch giving away her pleasure.

“Could be better… how about you put those new hooves of yours to work?”

Jeremy raised an eyebrow. “Care to elaborate?” he asked.

Chrysalis gave one of her trademark fanged grins. “Your entire hoof. Inside me,” she simply stated, and Jeremy blushed crimson.

“Whoa there. You sure it’ll fit?” he asked, and Chrysalis rolled her eyes.

“As if anything couldn’t – lest you forget, I can change my body as I please.”

Jeremy shrugged, and slowly prodded her entrance with his hoof. It slowly sank inside, taking in two, three, then four inches as the hole stretched to be nearly circular. “Ah! – Wait, wait. Take it out,” Chrysalis ordered, and Jeremy curiously complied.

“Are you okay?” he asked in concern.

Chrysalis sighed angrily. “I was trying to do it without changing – one of your human sites said couples enjoy this? No, it just hurts.”

Jeremy frowned, placing a consoling hoof on her shoulder. “Want to try something else?” he asked.

Chrysalis thought for a moment. “Let’s just go back to impregnation,” she decided, and Jeremy shrugged and complied once more, his tip lining up with her entrance.

He slowly pushed into her, being sure to be careful in case he hurt her again. Leaning down, he kissed her on the forehead as he began thrusting once more, and she moved her head up to kiss him on the lips again as he moved in and outside of her, their movements slow and coordinated in comparison to his earlier wild ride. For a moment, they said nothing, their eyes communicating all that was needed: I love you.

As much as Jeremy wanted to drag this out, he felt a familiar tingling in his pelvic region, and he looked down at Chrysalis.

“Going to finish soon,” he warned, and she gave a soft smile.

“Go ahead, I’m ready,” she replied. Jeremy picked up speed, and shot his seed into one of his wives for the last time that night.

They lay on the bed, all four having since showered and gotten ready for bed – or, in Luna’s case, her job. “Tomorrow’s Saturday, so… mind if I spend the weekend here?” Jeremy asked.

“Not at all,” Celestia chuckled.

“In fact, why don’t you just go ahead and spend the rest of your life here?” Chrysalis snarkily asked.

Jeremy pretended to think. “Hmmm… I’ll sleep on it,” he mockingly decided.

“Luna, quick, influence his dreams!” Celestia retorted, and Luna burst out laughing as Jeremy suppressed giggles.

Next Chapter: Chapter 66* Estimated time remaining: 1 Hour, 2 Minutes