Login

Old Flames and New Sparks

by GentlemanJ

Chapter 10

Previous Chapter

Chapter 10

By the time Graves finished his story, sweat dripped from his brow and down a face with a pallor to match the marble around. Legs, usually so sturdy and strong, trembled like a newborn foal’s as a man who’d fought off gigantic arachnids and demonic beast melds without so much as batting an eye looked ready to keel over at the next gust of wind. In all her days, Rarity had never seen the marshal so unsteady on his feet.

But then again, he’d never done anything quite like this.

“Anyway, that’s how we met.” Graves rasped as he pulled an already damp sleeve across his forehead. “What next…? Right. So–”

Rarity would not let him speak. Grabbing his arm, the violet-haired beauty bodily tossed him towards one of the simple, polished benches. As he fell into the seat, she pulled out both wand and handkerchief, summoned a small trickle of water from the cool, evening air, and wetted the square of linen before thrusting it into the marshal’s hand. Needing no instruction beyond the demand in her sapphire eyes, Graves wearily wiped his face and heaved a shuddering sigh.

“Feeling better?” Rarity asked softly once he was done. Once she confirmed a small nod of his head, all gentleness faded away as her eyes flashed with blue fire.

“Good. In that case, would you mind telling me what the hay were you doing?!”

“I thought–”

“No, you obviously weren’t thinking,” Rarity interjected as she seized the handkerchief back. “If you were, then you most certainly wouldn’t have worked yourself into such a sorry state!”

“Sorry?” Graves blinked.

“Yes, sorry,” Rarity confirmed as she began to furiously pat at the marshal’s face and neck in his stead. “Honestly, just look at you, sweating as if you were struck with withershanks fever. What could possibly possess you to push yourself so hard?”

Though her words were still hot and miffed, it was a sort of warm, comfortable anger that matched the firmly gentle pressure laid out by her slender hands. She was obviously still upset with the marshal, but only because she was practically beside herself with worry. Maybe it shouldn’t have, but the scene brought a crinkle to the corner of the marshal’s mouth.

“Same reason I organized today, really,” he shrugged.

“And that would be?” Rarity asked, still patting, still with a frown on her fair brow.

“I needed proof.”

Suddenly, the cool dabs stopped as Rarity’s hand froze in midair. She looked Graves as the heat slowly cooled to a tremble of concern.

“Graves, you have–”

“Nothing to prove?” he interjected, a satisfied smirk appearing as Rarity’s face lit up with surprise at his undoubtedly accurate prediction. “Sure I do.”

“You… you do?” Rarity blinked.

“Don’t you think?” Graves asked, still grinning like a sober Cheshire cat. “Like you said, you got mad because you were jealous. You wanted to be, oh, how’d you put it… ‘speshul’, was it?” The flush of crimson that bloomed in Rarity’s cheeks confirmed the marshal’s suspicions.

“But… but why this?” Rarity asked, hesitant as she made a small gesture towards the monument before them. “Why tell me about them?” Though she didn’t ask them aloud, the real questions rang out loud and clear in her silence. Rarity knew that of all the things Graves did, speaking of the past was not one of them. For all the suffering those memories had caused him, reminiscing was more akin to grabbing an open coal than anything else. Why then, would he choose this path over any other?

Graves didn’t answer when the smile slid from his face. He didn’t reply when his eyes grew cloudy with thought. But when those gunmetal greys hardened with piercing intent, the marshal finally spoke.

“You, Miss Rarity, have got a lot of nerve,” Graves called out as he raised an accusatory finger. Needless to say, the Miss Rarity in question was rather shocked.

“I… I do?” she blinked.

“Yes, yes you do,” Graves firmly nodded. “You recall when you came to visit me in the Changeling camp? You left, but I chased you back down, remember?”

How could she forget? He’d blown out the engine of a Stallion-class transport with a well-placed blast of lightning, snuck past a hull of crewman, and taken multiple beatings from her friends for his troubles.

“After I tracked you down, we had a little talk, you and I,” Graves continued, his voice a gravelly rumble that sounded of a looming avalanche. “Then at the end, I made you a promise. You remember what that was?”

Of course she remembered. Each and every word of his was engraved on her heart as the promise of a man who’d given everything he had to her. Just remembering those words brought tears to Rarity’s eyes to glisten and shimmer in the pale moonlight.

“Yeah, I thought that’d be enough,” Graves sighed. “I mean, I figured that a promise like that would be enough to make you realize just how important you were. I was wrong.”

“Graves–”

“I was wrong,” Grave interjected with hand raised for pause, “because that wasn’t fair to you.”

“It… wasn’t?” Rarity blinked once more.

“How could it be?” Graves shrugged. “Making promises is easy. It’s the follow through that trips people up. That’s why we needed today. All of it.”

Though his eyes were still focused and sharp, the steely hue of the marshal’s eyes softened as he took Rarity’s hand into his.

“I didn’t expect this to be easy,” Graves frowned as he held Rarity’s gaze with unwavering intent. “Fact is, it should be anything but. You’re a fancy lady who throws hissy fits at the drop of a hat and I’m a gunslinger with issues. Lots of issues. We go together about as… well… everything I just said.”

The marshal’s eloquence brought forth a small bubble of laughter from the lady’s lips. With a knowing smile, Graves continued.

“We knew it’d be hard. But I made that promise because I knew it’d be worth it. You’re afraid we’re too different? I can handle a full day of fancy living and the bucking opera. Think that’s a one off? A day of croquet and tomorrow’s ballet says nothing, but nothing can keep me down.”

Laughter came again, much louder and stronger despite the tears that once again welled in sapphire eyes. Graves raised a calloused finger to wipe a stray drop aside as he continued once more.

“You also said that you didn’t feel special. You said I was too nice to Neida and that made you feel… replaced?”

“Graves–”

A finger pressed to her lips silenced her protests as a grimace came to his face.

“Yeah, about that. Maybe… you were right,” Graves sighed. “I’ve saved your life before, but I’ve also saved hers. We’ve gone on adventures, but Neida and I have more. Looking at that, it sort of makes sense how you’d think she was special. I didn’t want you to, but I didn’t know any way to change that, except… well… except for this.”

Even as he spoke, a faint sheen of perspiration came to the brow as the recollection of his ordeals burned at his mind once more. Rarity’s hand squeezed his till her knuckles turned white.

“So,” Graves continued once he finished swallowing the lump in his throat. “Right now, you’re the only one I’ve ever told that story to. There are others, and I’ll… get to them. Eventually. But I want you to know that those stories? Every last one of them is yours because no one could ever, ever replace you. Got it?”

Rarity merely nodded.

What more needed to be said?

*****

Far out of earshot, just close enough to see, a blonde-headed woman turned and began walking away.

“Seen enough?” Shining Armor asked as he fell into step behind her. Quietly, she nodded.

“Take care of him, yes? He is now… open.”

“You say that as if it’s a bad thing.”

“I fear for him. The heart can drive any to madness, even wolf.”

“He’ll be fine,” the captain shrugged. “Right now, I’m more worried about you.”

“Because I failed, yes?”

“I… tried to warn, you,” Shining Armor answered, bringing a hand to his navy hair as he awkwardly scratched his head. “Rarity and Graves have something special. You weren’t going to get between that.”

As she passed beneath the now unguarded archway, the woman paused in the shroud of shadows cast.

“Your Cadance. If she was in arms of other man, would you not fight, even against impossible odds?”

“I… would,” the captain admitted. “But why like this? Why not another way?”

Out from the darkness, laughter came.

“Perhaps is only way I know how.”

As the steps resumed to carry the woman away, the soft peals laughter slowly faded into the night. Or maybe they were something else. It was honestly hard to say.

*****

Beneath the moon’s soft light, Rarity and Graves sat together, her head resting lightly on his shoulder as his arm held her close.

“So that’s really why you organized today?” Rarity smiled. “A personal test?”

“Eh, mostly,” Graves smiled. “Plus, having you in a good mood never hurts.”

“Oh, it may,” the young lady laughed. “Now that I know you’re so comfortable in Canterlot, I may just expect you to join me more often.

Graves blinked.

“… That was not my intent.”

Rarity laughed aloud once more as a weight sitting on her shoulder for days was now free and lifted. However, she paused as a thought transformed her smile into something less.

“Graves,” she began, “I know you probably don’t want to talk about it anymore, but there is one last question I have. About us.”

“Shoot.”

“Do I…” Rarity paused to gather the courage needed to speak, “do I make you weak?”

Slowly, the marshal turned meet her gaze.

“Rarity… I nearly passed out telling you about them because I wanted you to feel special. If anything, you give me a reason to be stronger.”

Those words sent a warm tingle to the very core of her inmost parts.

“… Funny you ask though,” Graves frowned. “Neida said something like that too. You guys talk about that, or something?”

And here, Rarity paused. They had, in fact, discussed the issue, though it was more of Miss Roamanov lambasting her for being a liability over her own inability to protest. She could tell the marshal that of course and let him know just how harshly the visiting woman had been. Knowing Graves and his protective nature, the next meeting between them would be decidedly cooler.

“... We did,” Rarity nodded. “She thought I was bad for you because I might end up distracting you from the fight. She was worried.”

And surprisingly, Rarity found that she believed it. Though Araneida had wielded words with a skill to rival the dressmaker’s own, even all of that cleverness could not help the lady spy hide one simple fact: she cared about Graves. A lot. Whether or not Rarity agreed with her cause, she could understand that feeling. So whether it was because of concern for one of the marshal's few friends, or a simple act of solidarity for one who loved the one she herself loved, Rarity left her words at merely that.

“Heh, that’s Neida,” Graves replied with a fond smile. “Sometimes I think the fight’s all she thinks about.”

“But is she right?” Rarity pressed.

Graves paused.

“Ironside had a saying. ‘Only thing more deadly than a man with nothing to lose is a man with everything to lose.’ You, Rarity,” he grinned, “are way too much to lose.”

And surprisingly, Graves found that he believed it. For years, he’d thrown himself into battle because there was no reason not to. Now that he had Rarity, things were different. He had a place to come back to, a person to welcome him home after the battle was over. He’d always fought knowing that duty was something to die for, but Rarity was finally something he wanted to live for.

So he would fight. Demons may come and devils may block his path, but the marshal would press on. He would complete his mission, survive the ordeal, and live to come back to the woman at his side.

Survival had always had a cost, but now? Now Graves was finally willing to pay the price.

**********

To Be Continued

The Journey of Graves concludes in the final story: Journey's End.

Return to Story Description

Other Titles in this Series:

  1. When the Man Comes Around

    by GentlemanJ
    52 Dislikes, 32,511 Views

    As Ponyville prepares for arriving royal marshals, a new traveler quietly slips into town.

    Teen
    Complete
    Adventure
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    8 Chapters, 22,211 words: Estimated 1 Hour, 29 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Feb 19th, 2012
    Last Update Mar 3rd, 2012
  2. So... What Happens Next?

    by GentlemanJ
    23 Dislikes, 15,100 Views

    Ordered to stay in Ponyville, Graves finds that his new life will take some getting used to.

    Teen
    Complete
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    4 Chapters, 7,070 words: Estimated 29 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Mar 2nd, 2012
    Last Update Mar 8th, 2012
  3. Trouble Meets Disaster

    by GentlemanJ
    21 Dislikes, 13,230 Views

    Marshal Graves gets settled in, but is called away on duty. Oddly enough, Sweetie Belle tags along.

    Teen
    Complete
    Adventure
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    6 Chapters, 13,521 words: Estimated 55 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Mar 10th, 2012
    Last Update Jul 19th, 2012
  4. Two Kinds of Complications

    by GentlemanJ
    25 Dislikes, 13,228 Views

    Rarity wants a date. Sweetie Belle wants a brother. Lucky Graves just wants a day without headaches.

    Teen
    Complete
    Romance
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    7 Chapters, 14,433 words: Estimated 58 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Mar 26th, 2012
    Last Update Apr 7th, 2012
  5. Untangling the Knot

    by GentlemanJ
    21 Dislikes, 12,010 Views

    The fifth story in The Journey of Graves. A week has passed since the ill-fated events in Rarity's boutique. The encounter has left a deep impression on Graves as he grows colder and more distant than ever before. Rarity, feeling responsible, wants

    Teen
    Complete
    Adventure
    Romance
    Comedy
    Slice of Life
    Sad

    11 Chapters, 21,467 words: Estimated 1 Hour, 26 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Apr 14th, 2012
    Last Update May 6th, 2012
  6. Lazy Summer Days

    by GentlemanJ
    18 Dislikes, 11,005 Views

    Life's not just for adventures. Sometimes, the best stories happen on lazy summer days.

    Teen
    Complete
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    8 Chapters, 19,013 words: Estimated 1 Hour, 17 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Jun 9th, 2012
    Last Update Jul 18th, 2012
  7. Return to the Gala

    by GentlemanJ
    23 Dislikes, 12,935 Views

    We can all remember how the "best night ever" turned out. Well, looks like it's time for

    Teen
    Complete
    Romance
    Random
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    12 Chapters, 38,713 words: Estimated 2 Hours, 35 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Jul 24th, 2012
    Last Update Oct 20th, 2012
  8. Happily Ever After

    by GentlemanJ
    25 Dislikes, 11,203 Views

    One day, even the hardest of soldiers hangs up his gun to find a chance at happiness.

    Teen
    Complete
    Romance
    Slice of Life

    9 Chapters, 23,040 words: Estimated 1 Hour, 33 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Oct 27th, 2012
    Last Update Dec 16th, 2012
  9. A Long, Winding Road

    by GentlemanJ
    24 Dislikes, 7,529 Views

    The marshal's gone, cutting all ties and making clear his intent never to return. Why? What compels the grey eyed soldier to leave? To find the truth, Rarity and the girls start down a long, winding road that will hopefully bring him back. Hopef

    Teen
    Complete
    Adventure
    Romance

    16 Chapters, 60,190 words: Estimated 4 Hours, 1 Minute to read: Cached
    Published Mar 2nd, 2013
    Last Update Jun 9th, 2013
  10. There's a Reason They Call it a Crush

    by GentlemanJ
    22 Dislikes, 7,138 Views

    Spike is definitely looking forward to the Ponyville girls coming home. Only... what's he to do when the object of his deepest affections turns out to be taken?

    Teen
    Complete
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    3 Chapters, 9,720 words: Estimated 39 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Jul 21st, 2013
    Last Update Aug 5th, 2013
  11. Dating is Hard

    by GentlemanJ
    17 Dislikes, 5,677 Views

    A short story in the Journey of Graves. Join our favorite grey eyed soldier as he navigates the new and treacherous minefield known as dating.

    Teen
    Complete
    Romance
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    3 Chapters, 6,744 words: Estimated 27 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Aug 22nd, 2013
  12. Nightmare Night 2: Halloweening Harder

    by GentlemanJ
    15 Dislikes, 6,348 Views

    Nightmare Night is back once more, which means a night chock full of hilarity, hi-jinks, and near apocalyptic obliteration. Need I say more?

    Teen
    Complete
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    1 Chapter, 3,201 words: Estimated 13 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Sep 14th, 2013
  13. Casino Battle Royale

    by GentlemanJ
    13 Dislikes, 6,306 Views

    In which a night of glitz and glamour becomes a bit more interesting for a couple of Equestria's finest.

    Teen
    Complete
    Adventure
    Romance
    Comedy

    1 Chapter, 4,459 words: Estimated 18 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Oct 6th, 2013
  14. The Ugly Side of Right

    by GentlemanJ
    13 Dislikes, 3,808 Views

    Though the world sees the Equestrian Royal marshals as a band of heroes, Graves goes on a new mission that shows just how ugly doing right can be.

    Mature
    Complete
    Adventure
    Dark

    1 Chapter, 7,365 words: Estimated 30 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Nov 3rd, 2013
  15. Be a Man

    by GentlemanJ
    24 Dislikes, 6,877 Views

    With his crush on Rarity going the way of the dodo, Spike begins to wonder just what it means to be a man.

    Teen
    Complete
    Romance
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    1 Chapter, 5,140 words: Estimated 21 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Dec 1st, 2013
  16. Delivery Directive: Do NOT Be Late

    by GentlemanJ
    7 Dislikes, 7,061 Views

    Marshal Graves has simple orders: take the package and deliver it on time. Of course, simple orders never mean a simple time.

    Teen
    Complete
    Adventure

    1 Chapter, 6,755 words: Estimated 28 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Dec 24th, 2013
  17. Winter Wonders, Winter Worries

    by GentlemanJ
    16 Dislikes, 5,208 Views

    Winter's a wonderful time full of fun and festive frolicking. Just be sure not to catch the sniffles.

    Teen
    Complete
    Romance
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    1 Chapter, 2,901 words: Estimated 12 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Jan 19th, 2014
  18. Marshals: The Next Generation

    by GentlemanJ
    13 Dislikes, 5,309 Views

    Four of Equestria's finest military cadets seek entry into the elite branch of the marshal. However, in order to qualify, they have to pass the test of none other than Gunmetal Graves himself.

    Teen
    Complete
    Adventure
    Comedy

    4 Chapters, 12,090 words: Estimated 49 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Feb 23rd, 2014
    Last Update Mar 16th, 2014
  19. Marshmallows and Cotton Candy

    by GentlemanJ
    15 Dislikes, 5,062 Views

    A collection of fluffy tales around Graves and the best sisters in Ponyville. We start with Sweetie Belle doing business. Serious business.

    Everyone
    Complete
    Romance
    Comedy
    Slice of Life

    6 Chapters, 12,102 words: Estimated 49 Minutes to read: Cached
    Published Apr 13th, 2014
    Last Update Jun 15th, 2014
  20. Old Flames and New Sparks

    by GentlemanJ
    15 Dislikes, 4,126 Views

    When a piece of the marshal's colorful past comes back to town, Rarity starts to wonder whether some things just weren't meant to be.

Login

Facebook
Login with
Facebook:
FiMFetch