Author's Notes:

OC Credits
Lava played by and owned by: KittyLava

Later...

Slowly awakening, Lava rubbed her head first, soon brushing closely by her eyes. Light purrs escaped out of her muzzle as she had no idea where she was.

"Oh, you're awake," came a voice that wasn't Twilight's. The black mare soon realized she was laying on a couch as a dark purple mare was knelt beside her, leaning forward and looking down at her with a smile.

Several yelps escaped her muzzle as she glanced up at the other mare. Her wings still resting around her body as she flustered-ly skimmed the mare over with her eyes to try and get some idea who she was. Then there was the unfamiliarity of where she was currently at.

"N-Nyaaa? Who are you?" She asked.

"Diamond..." the mare said. "One of Twilight's newest pets. Are you a new playmate, too?" She asked with a smile as she sat upright, giving the mare some space.

"One of Twilight's pets? How many does she have?" Lava asked, purring softly and nervously glancing around the room.

Looking around, she saw a few other mares. There was a green mare making out with a white mare, both nude. There was also a blue mare laying on her back on the floor wearing sexy, skimpy bra and panties. The purple mare, herself, was wearing a white tube top and panties.

"More than a couple," the mare answered with a smile.

A blush formed as Lava's eyes looked around. From what she could tell about her new Mistress; that mare had a longing or desire to gather other mares. Given their mostly skimpy, or lack of clothing, wasn't too hard to guess what exactly they might be for. Deciding to examine herself, she'd quickly note how clean her body was. She then noticed that all she wore was a pink thong, immediately blushing quite harder.

"Why so shy?" Diamond asked, gently rubbing Lava's bare belly. "You're among friends now... Relax..." she cooed gently.

"N-Not entirely used to waking up like this," Lava purred softly, unaware her tail changed into something more feline-like. "I-it's quite flustering, to be fair, waking up to all this. D-Does this sort of wake up happen often?"

"You mean do most pets feel like you do? Not sure. Me and my sister... That green mare, Emerald, over there... We're the newest additions. But, we owe Mistress Twilight so much. She saved us from the streets. From being raped. Did she save you from the streets, too?"

"W-Well she did pull me off the streets, though is it normally this mischievous around her room? Or home?" Tail shifting around, Lava glanced around at the mares again.

Diamond smiled. "It's usually like this for her pets. Her girlfriend sometimes plays with us, though she seems to wanna be with her lover more. Which is fine by me because Mistress plays with us enough..."

Looking partly surprised, attention drew back to Diamond whilst her kitty ears started to pop out. "M-Mistress has a girlfriend? She didn't mention that at the time, though she did get me partly flustered, though."

"I heard from Aqua that Midnight, the girlfriend, had sex with her to see what Mistress found so enjoyable in having sex pets... She then became okay with the idea and let us all stay here... And, like I said, sometimes plays with us..." Diamond then slowly moved her hand up to Lava's left breast and gently rubbed it. "You'll like it here. Trust me. We all do. Much better than being out there."

"S-Sounds like Midnight goes to inspect us at times," Lava purred softly, before one moan escaped outward. A blush formed across her cheeks... and both her kitty ears poked upward in surprise. She then shifted her hands upward in an attempt to hold them down, wanting to keep them hidden in her mane. "N-Nyaa?"

Diamond went wide-eyed. "Um... You have... cat ears?" She asked, not sounding as surprised as she should but sounding surprised enough.

"U-Ummm, might just be part of a costume?" She hesitantly replied, hoping the mare would buy it. Then again, she's probably stuck with it out of the bag. "Are they really that unusual?"

Diamond smiled and reached out, poking the ears. "It's not the strangest thing to happen in the city..." she said. "Changelings... A Succubus... Vampires... a werewolf... But... why do you have cat ears?"

Lava blinked a few times, both ears twitching. Changelings weren't that unusual to her, having played with a few before. But when it comes to everything else mentioned, one would wonder what the heck kind of city they were in.. "U-Ummm, do I have to answer that?"

Diamond leaned in close and slipped her hand in the cat mare's panties, rubbing. "Mmm... What if I asked you nicely?" She asked. "I'm really curious..." she cooed.

Lava shivered lightly as soft "eeps" escaped outward, her chicks bright red with her hands shifting into that of black furred kitty paws. She quickly pressed them against her muzzle to try and cover her moans. This was embarrassing enough, but now she was growing damper between her legs.

"So, you're a cat?" Asked Diamond, noticing the paws as she kept rubbing. "A cute kitty?" She cooed.

"N-nyaaa? N-Not exactly?" Lava purred softly, more moans escaping from her mouth.

Diamond then slid her fingers inside and wiggled them around as she kissed Lava's cheek. "I wanna see how much of a kitty you become..."

Lava eeped as she became fully exposed just as the mare desired. Two full sets of kitty paws were present, tail, her ears, and one very red pair of cheeks. "N-Nyaa... A-Are you s-satisfied now?"

Diamond nodded. "But, now I want some fun with the kitty..." she cooed, moving her left hand to the kitty's tail. "Sit up, please..." she said with a smile.

"Wh-What are you planning?" She asked nervously, eeping this time from something brushing up against her tail. "P-Please tell me she isn't going to find out about this?"

"Who, Twilight?" Asked the mare. "Why don't you want her finding out? Also, sit up, please," she repeated with a smile, biting her lip.

"U-Umm, she doesn't really know about this?" She replied before nervously sitting up.

Diamond gently pulled the Kitty's panties off before sitting beside her and pulling her into her lap. "But, why don't you want her to know? Are you... embarrassed?" She asked, looking the cute kitty in the eyes as she rubbed her butt.

"M-Maybe... I'd just rather not have everyone know I'm Cheshire-- U-Umm... Forget I said that?" She said, sounding rather nervous.

Diamond nodded and kissed her neck. "I love this look, though... You're so cute," she said, rubbing her butt before her right hand lightly stroked the tail.

Yelping softly, moans trailed outward as Lava attempted to avoid eye contact. "G-Get the feeling you or her might keep me this exposed with vibrators and chastity..."

"That how it works?" Asked the mare, using her hand to grip the cat's breast. "When you're aroused, you turn into a cat?"

"N-Not exactly, b-but a few things can make me lose control o-of which is revealed or hidden. O-Oh, buck," She moaned out, glancing nervously back at the mare.

Diamond smiled and kissed Lava's cheek, rubbing her breast. "I see... Well, I like it..." the mare cooed as she then kissed the black mare on the lips..

Releasing flustered moans, Lava gave into her situation as she likely wasn't going to be getting out of this one. At least she didn't have to worry about Twilight discovering her secret. "N-nnyaaa..."

Diamond smiled and laid Lava down on the couch before climbing atop her. Pressing her breasts to the kitty's, she smiled. "Mmm... Giving in, are we?" She asked, leaning in and kissing the mare's neck some more.

"N-Nnngh... D-Don't have much choice, do I?" She replied with soft purrs whilst tilting her head towards the side and tail swishing excitedly. "N-Nyaaa... W-What are you plotting to do with... K-Kitty?"

"Plotting?" Asked Diamond with a chuckle. "That sounds like I'm... the bad guy, or something... I'm simply having fun with Twilight's new pet... Her new... kitty..." The mare then slid lower and began to lick the black mare's nipples.

"N-Nyaaaa... S-Seems like it's train the kitty, instead," Lava moaned out, squirming weakly whilst letting the mare have her way.

Diamond smiled and gripped both breasts, squishing them together. "Did mistress use her thick cock on you?" Diamond asked with a smirk as she moved lower and kissed the kitty's belly.

Squealing softly, she nodded, rather embarrassed yet not desiring to outright say it.

"Did you like it?" Diamond asked as she moved lower and gave the kitty's pussy a few kisses.

"N-Nyaaa... D-Do I really have to answer this in front of the others?" She moaned, blushing hard but likely answering it indirectly.

Diamond chuckled and nodded. "One of the things Mistress' pets have to learn is to be open... Look around as the others have sex right on the floor. They don't care who sees or hears them. I don't. Neither should you. Now, moan it out for me. What do you think of Mistress' cock?" She asked again before giving the kitty's wet lower lips a lick.

Just then, Lava could hear Twilight's voice coming down the hall. Once she was close enough, the rest of the girls heard her as Diamond smiled. "Looks like she's gonna find out..." she cooed.

"N-Nyaaa, d-do I really have to b-be revealed th-this way to h-her?" Lava gulped as she squirmed cutely, light moans escaping outward as it seemed her fate was sealed.

Diamond sat upright, pulling Lava up with her. "Doesn't matter how you appear. You don't have time to hide your cat traits," she said as Lava could hear Twilight step up to the door.

The kitty yelped cutely as she was too distracted to hide her feline features.

Just then the door opened up and in stepped Twilight, her eyes falling on the black mare. "Um..." she said, before walking towards her. "Lava?" She asked. "Something you're not telling me?"

"U-Ummm... K-Kitty costume?" She quickly stuttered, quite noticeably tense and nervous as sweat began forming.

The purple mare stepped up to her and looked her over. She then turned and headed to the ouch before sitting down. "Sit," she said, patting her lap. "Facing me..."

Lava gulped as she nervously get up slowly, crawling on the couch before sitting upon her Mistress's lap, facing her. Her tail swished as her kitty ears lightly twitched.

Twi then put her arms around her. "What's really going on?" She asked. "You can tell me," she said, gently rubbing her hand up and down the kitty-mare's back.

"N-Nyaaa... D-Do I really have to say i-it?" She purred softly, body shuddering and her ears occasionally twitching.

"Well, you're clearly not normal. Seems you're part cat. What, exactly, are you?" She asked, still only rubbing the mare's back as she looked her in the eyes.

"N-Nyaaa... D-Does Kitty really have to answer that question?"

Twilight frowned. "Still need some training, huh?" She asked before pushing Lava onto her stomach on the couch, before unzipping her pants and pulling out her dick. She then climbed atop the black mare and leaned in close to her ear. "This will go on until you tell me..." she said, before pushing her way inside of the kitty's ass with a grunt, forcing several yelping moans from the mare.

Diamond casually stepped up next to Twilight and bent over 90-degrees, whispering into her ear. The purple mare nodded and gave her a brief kiss in the lips before looking at Lava again. She continued her thrusts into the kitty-mare's ass as she leaned in once more. "Diamond here... said you started to... say something earlier," she said between groans. "Chesh-something... Care to explain?"

Squealing under continuing thrusts by her Mistress' desire for answers, two minutes passed before answering when it was harder to resist or think. "A-Ahhh! Ch-Cheshire... I-I'm a C-Cheshire..." She spoke in escaping moans with cheeks cherry red, her folds leaking all over Twilight's couch.

Twilight smiled and pulled out, waving her hand over hr cock to clean it before grabbing the mare beneath her. After flipping the cat onto her back, she gently pushed into her pussy. "Mmm... Much better..." she cooed, leaning in and kissing Lava's cheek. "So, you're a Cheshire Cat, huh? I'll have to add that to the list of new species I've encountered..."

Humiliated by her confusion without any idea how this may go, she soon figured it out when Twilight flipped her around for another session, letting out a yelp of embarrassment. "N-Nyaaa... K-Kitty's kind of ,umm..... A-A little bit u-unique, M-Mistress..."

"I'll say," Twilight cooed, before lifting her head to look he mare in the eyes as she slowly rocked her hips into Lava's.

"N-Nyaaaa!!! D-Does K-Kitty have to c-confess another one of h-her secrets?" Lava spoke up between panting and moaning, both wings pomfed opened within her flustered state.

"Why?" Asked Twilight with a smile. "Do you have any other secrets?" She then slowed her thrusts as she leaned in again and kissed the mare on the neck.

"U-Ummm, K-Kitty is somewhat of a... m-mean... shot with a sniper rifle... O-Occasionally hired before you, umm.... Well, you probably know, Mistress," Lava gulped as those words escaped outwards rom her mouth.

Twilight's ears twitched before she stopped her thrusts. "You took jobs for Kronos?"

"U-Ummm, y-yes..." She replied as she was still uncertain about whether she was in trouble or not.

The purple mare hesitated for what seemed like forever before she slowly began moving her hips again. "Well... I'd say it's a good thing Kronos is with the Elementals now... But, in a way, we cut off your funds and... caused you to live in the alley, huh?" She asked, sounding like she felt bad as she moved her hips very slowly.

"I-It was more along the lines of... me being hired occasionally by them, and other groups at times. S-Somepony really didn't like the Elementals... And Kitty sometimes was permitted to have a bit of... fun at times with captives before turning them over..."

"You're saying you... raped Elementals before sending them to their death?" Twi asked, stopping her thrusting and leaning in close.

"N-Not to their deaths... At least, I don't think so... Well, except for a few they wanted Kitty to snipe in the field..." She then gulped nervously.

Twilight scowled before pulling out of the kitty with a growl and standing up, quickly moving to her coat on the coat rack and pulling out her gun, ejecting the mag to check the ammo before sliding it back in and cocking the gun.

Diamond went wide-eyed and walked over to her. "Twilight, what are you doing?"

"She's the enemy," the unicorn said, using her gun to point at the black mare. "She's a rapist and a murderer... The very kind I rescued you from, lest you forget."

"We haven't forgotten..." Diamond replied quickly, almost cutting Twilight off. "But, she's not the same..."

Pants escaped outward from Lava's muzzle, leaving her vulnerable. She was quick to gulp from nevousness and fright as she stared at the pistol's barrel, knowing how this may end.

Twilight eyed Diamond and then Lava again before pushing passed the mare in front of her. She then climbed atop the black mare and pressed the gun to her head. "What do you know about the Apocalypse?!" She yelled. "This mystery gang! Know anything about them, huh?!"

Blinking a few times, it appeared the name wasn't familiar to the mare as she was both terrified and confused at the same time. "U-Ummm, who? K-Kitty may be f-freelance a-and mischievous at times, but never h-heard of them before."

Twilight was breathing heavily before she took a deep breath.

"Sh-She doesn't know anything, m-mistress..." Cauliflower said as she spoke up, sounding nervous as she was new to this as well. "I've never seen her before..."

Twilight eyed the white mare before looking at Lava again. Diamond stepped up to her and tapped her shoulder.

"You don't need that anymore..." she said, holding out her hand.

Twilight eyed the gun and sighed, placing it in Diamond's hand, who went to put it back in her coat pocket. The unicorn then looked down at Lava again. Fear not yet fading as the pistol was eventually removed, Lava's body was tense like she was about to pass out on the spot.

Twilight sighed and nuzzled her cheek. "You can relax now..." she cooed. "I'm not gonna hurt you... You are with me now, after all... Right?" She asked, kissing Lava's neck.

Either by mixture of fright and exhaustion, or just mostly fear itself, the charcoal colored pegasus mare passed out before Twilight.

The unicorn let out a sigh and stood up. "She sure is an unstable one."

"Unstable's putting it mildly," Diamond said as she looked down at the black kitty-mare. "What'll you do with her?"

Twilight shrugged. "Train her like I trained Cauliflower."

"You used my full name," the white mare said with a smile, sitting up and looking at her.

Twi looked over at her and nodded. "You earned it."

Blushing, Cauliflower smiled wider before Emerald wrapped her arms around her neck.

"Come back here," the green mare said before pulling the white mare back down into a kiss.

The lavender mare then stretched. "Well, it's getting late. I'll see you girls in the morning," she said, heading towards her bedroom. AS she passed by Aqua she stopped and smiled. "You may sleep with us again if you'd like," she said, before entering the bedroom.

Aqua gasped happily and ran in after her.