Login

Some Secrets Are Better Left Untold 2...

by Deathsia

Chapter 6: A Faded Memory(Part 2)(FINISHED!)

Previous Chapter Next Chapter

Author's Notes:

And the chapter is finished! Hope you enjoy this chapter, I worked all night on it!XD

9k words...whoo!:rainbowkiss:

A FADED MEMORY

PART 2

Twilight opened the door to her home and immediately channeled magic into her horn in order to search for the book she was now seeking.

Many hours had passed now and the sun was starting to lower behind the hills as the Alicorn scanned book after book like a mare possessed.

“Yes, Twilight. You're Scootaloo's mother.”

These words echoed through the mare's mind over and over as she scanned every book. She couldn't believe it. No, she didn't want to believe it. She couldn't bring herself to believe that her mentor whom she trusted so much would be as vain as to separate a mother and a foal from each other and erase all evidence of such events happening in the first place.

Yet she continued to search for the book containing the spells needed for such things. Despite her not wanting to believe her friend's words, something inside her knew them to be true. Even so, she constantly denied this gut feeling and kept telling herself over and over that she wouldn't believe it until she found proof.

ALMOST A DAY LATER...

“Oh come now Spike, your still saying that? You don't need an excuse to sleep at my house you know.” Rarity remarked aloud with a giggle.

“But I'm telling you! She put a barrier around the house! I can't get inside!” Spike exclaimed with an annoyed glare.

“Oh come now, surgarcube. We all know what Fluttershy told her since she told us no sooner we went to see her but Ah doubt she would-”

SMACK!

The earth pony's face seemed to impact nose-first with an invisible surface just outside of the Alicorn's home. “What in tarnation?!” She blurted out as she rubbed her sore nose.

“Told you.” Spike remarked with a glare at the farm pony whom placed a hoof on the invisible surface in utter confusion.

“Oh my... I wouldn't have told her if I knew she was going to do this.” Fluttershy remarked with a worried expression as she placed a hoof on the invisible surface as well.

“Don't blame yourself for this one, Fluttershy. We all know that Twilight has had a history of pulling stunts like this.” Rainbow Dash remarked as she hovered in place near the yellow Pegasus.

“Rainbow Dash is correct, darling. Though I wonder why she would do such a thing? I would assume that at times like these, she would want the support of her friends more than anything.” Rarity remarked aloud in a concerned tone.

“Why is everypony standing outside of Twilight's house for?” came a voice all five immediately recognized at which point the color drained from their faces as they turned to look at the young Pegasus.

“Erm... well, you see...” Rarity began only to feel her words falter.

“I know it's a little early but I needed to ask Princess Twilight something before Sweetie Belle and Applebloom got here for Twilight Time.” Scootaloo said with a nervous expression.

“Sorry squirt but no pony is getting in here to see Twilight right now.” Rainbow Dash remarked in the calmest tone she could muster despite the unease in her voice as she spoke.

“Huh? Why?” Scootaloo asked with a look of utter confusion.

“Twilight cast a spell that prevented us from getting inside while she looks up some spells to find out why she can't remember being your-mmph!” Pinkie Pie began to say only for Applejack, Fluttershy, Rarity, and Rainbow Dash to slam their hooves over the party mares muzzle before the obvious words could escape her lips.

“Your-your teacher! Yes, that's right!” Rarity lied with a nervous expression as Pinkie Pie gave the unicorn a glare as she struggled to free her muzzle from her friends grip.

“Y-Yeah! See, Twilight's been forgetting a whole lot of stuff lately and she uh...” Rainbow Dash chimed in only to trail off as she found herself unable to continue the blatant lie.

“She's uh, tryin to find a spell to help her keep her lessons with y'all fillies in her head so she don't be forgettin them!” Applejack chimed in now as well only for her expression afterwards to display the trademark guilty expression she often wore when she lied.

“So she's doing all this just to prepare for Twilight Time?” Scootaloo asked and though she didn't look convinced, she seemed to be accepting the blatant lie by the three.

“Y-Yes. So could you, um, come back later? That is, if you want to.” Fluttershy replied this time meekly.

“O-Okay. I guess I could ask her after Twilight Time but I was really hoping she could give me an answer to the question I asked her a week ago before Sweetie Belle and Applebloom got here.” Scootaloo replied as her ears drooped, turned about-face and walked away from the five.

Once the four mares were sure that Scootaloo was well out of sight as well as earshot, they released their grip on the pink mare whom immediately took in a big gasp of air.

“Why'd you tell her a meanie-pants lie like that?! Her mommy is right there!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed as she pointed a hoof at Twilight's house.

“Ya don't use that there noggin ya have, do ya?” Applejack remarked with a glare at the pink mare.

“Twilight's already got enough on her mind as it stands Pinkie, we don't need Scootaloo adding to the stress she's obviously already under!” Rainbow Dash added also glaring at her.

“Besides, we don't even know if Twilight wants her to know the truth yet.” Rarity remarked with a worried expression towards the house.

“Um, why wouldn't she?” Fluttershy asked curiously.

“Naturally, Scootaloo would have a lot of questions. Many of which I believe, Twilight may be searching for the answers for at the moment.” Rarity explained casually as she looked at the yellow Pegasus.

“And some of which, she may not be so inclined to answer. If ya get my meanin.” Applejack added to which all five mares exchanged nervous glances.

“Still, getting knocked up by your brother... I don't even have a brother and I find that a little creepy.” Rainbow Dash remarked and gave an audible shudder.

“We all have secrets that we are not proud of, Rainbow Dash. Need we bring up the obvious?” Rarity censured with a glare.

Like you have any room to talk!” Rainbow Dash retorted angrily at which point the unicorn's face turned beat red.

Before the two could continue their squabble, Applejack wisely intervened and stood between the two. “Calm the hay down, both of ya! This ain't the time to be bashin one another for what they've been doin. We're all worried about Twilight so lets focus on our main concern at the moment, shall we?” Applejack remarked as she glared at her fillyfriend and Rarity.

The two glared at each other for a few moments longer, the tension between the two seemingly striking out at each other like a bolt of electrify which stopped half way to each mare that resulted in a standoff between the two before they looked away from one another and huffed in annoyance.

“Applejack's right. We need to figure out why Twilight would shut us off like she did.” Fluttershy remarked with a worried glance towards the house once again.

“Oh I wouldn't worry about it!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed as she leaned against the barrier with one hoof. “I'm sure she'll be coming out to greet us anytime now!” She finished and in the exact moment the pink mare finished saying what she had, the invisible surface she was leaning towards seemed to vanish as Pinkie Pie fell face forward to the ground with a comical thud. “Told ya!” She added as she ejected a hoof into the air with her face still implanted on the ground which muffled her voice as she spoke.

It was then that Twilight front door swung open and the lavender mare began to walk out only to realize her friends were standing there. This however only halted her for a moment as she continued to walk a few more feet farther and made a take off pose.

“Where are you going Twilight? You've had us worried sick about you!” Rainbow Dash exclaimed which halted the Alicorn's take off.

“To the Canterlot Archives. I couldn't find what I wanted to here so I'm looking there.” Twilight remarked calmly before she erupted to the skies without another word.

Rainbow Dash let out an annoyed sigh upon hearing these words and witnessing the Alicorn's take off. “Don't even bother to ask me to go after her because I don't feel like being zapped for sticking my nose any further into her business than I already have.” Rainbow Dash remarked with a mild glare at the five.

“Well, perhaps we can find out exactly what she was looking for by looking inside the library. I'm sure she's just fine. After all, she seemed calm enough when she spoke to us didn't she?” Rarity suggested calmly to which the other five plus Spike agreed.

The group however stopped dead in their tracks once they got inside and gawked at the site that beheld them. Nearly every single book in Twilight's library had been tossed about in a careless fashion as if her house had been ransacked by a burglar of some sort.

“So, what was that about her bein, just fine?” Applejack remarked smugly as she looked at the unicorn whom simply gave a nervous giggle in response.


-------------------------------------------------------


Evening now set upon Ponyville and Spike was once again staying with Rarity for the night due to the condition of Twilight and his house being in due to the Alicorn's frantic search. That wasn't the only reason for Spike staying the night however...

“Mmph!” Rarity exclaimed as Spike dug his claws into her haunches as he plowed her flower hard and fast.

“That's a good pretty pony, are you ready for your reward?” Spike asked between grunts as he felt him climax closing him now.

“Y-Yes! Fill me up! Eep!” Rarity exclaimed only to get a swift slap to her hindquarters from the young drake.

“Pretty ponies don't talk, Rarity.” Spike remarked with a coy smirk as he continued to plow her soaking wet love tunnel feeling it contract and squish as the unicorn came hard due to the pleasure she felt from being swatted by the dragon sending her over the edge of her sexual bliss.

Spike wanted to hold off his impending climax as a punishment to the mare for speaking out but the mare's slit was squeezing his member like a vice at the moment, milking it for the seed it desired so badly. Despite the drake's best efforts to hold off his orgasm, his cock exploded deep inside Rarity's flower, filling her with stream after stream of his dragon spunk until he could cum no more.

“G-Gemstone.” Rarity stuttered out breathlessly, both knowing this was the codeword to end their role-play.

Upon hearing this, Spike let go of Rarity's haunches and allowed his body to go lax as he laid over her hindquarters as a crutch to hold himself up. “I wasn't too rough was I?” He asked breathlessly between pants.

“N-Not at all darling.” Rarity remarked as she looked to her hindquarters and grimaced softly at the claw marks. She knew she was going to have to wear a dress for the next day or so to cover them up until they healed so she could avoid questions from her friends. Though she had a gut feeling they already knew, she didn't want to risk having to answer any embarrassing questions.

The two rested in their afterglow for a few minutes longer until Spike pulled his now flaccid member from the unicorn's flower which almost immediately began to seep with a combination of his seed and her juices due to his body no longer blocking the flow.

“If you'll excuse me darling, I must freshen up. As much as I enjoy our private time together, it would be unseemly if I were to allow our...ahem, fluids to stain my bed and carpet.

“Oh yeah, right.” Spike replied with a sheepish grin as the mare used her magic to seemingly plug the leak in her hindquarters and begin to walk towards the restroom. “I love you Rarity.” Spike added just before the mare left the room which halted her in her tracks and turn around to face the young drake.

“Oh,um.. I know.”Rarity added with a nervous smile before she turned about-face and left the room unknowing of the dragon's expression turning to a frown as he watched her leave the room.

Once he was sure that Rarity was out of earshot, he let out a depressed sigh. “She never says it back.” Spike remarked aloud in a saddened voice as he laid down on the bed and looked up at the ceiling.

With nothing to do but think, the young drake began to wonder if she loved him at all. After all, they had been doing this for the past month or so and never once had she said the words “I love you Spike”. Not even as an accidental outburst.

Before the drake knew it, Rarity was walking back into the bedroom, her mane and tail soaking wet from the shower water. Spike always loved this look she wore when she was soaking wet from head to tail but he knew it wouldn't last long as Rarity would dry herself off quickly.

Rarity however noticed Spike's saddened expression which halted her from grabbing the dryer from her vanity desk. “Is something the matter, Spikey-Wikey?” She asked with a concerned expression and tone to match it.

“No, it's nothing.” Spike lied as he forced a smile on his face.

“Oh? Very well then.” Rarity replied as she picked up the dryer, turned it on and began to use her magic to levitate it to dry her body off.

Spike watched the unicorn dry herself off until her mane,body, and tail were completely dry. Rarity then lifted up the brush to begin to brush her mane only for Spike to speak up which caused her to turn to look at him. “Actually, yeah something has been bugging me.” He began only to feel his words falter as he looked at her. “N-Never mind.” he added a few moments later though Rarity knew for sure that something was bugging the young drake now for sure and wasn't about to let this matter rest.

“Spike... if something is bothering you, its best to get it off your chest. If you let small things build up and don't talk about them, they can cause a problems later on.” Rarity remarked wisely as she placed the brush down, walked over the bed and sat down next to Spike.

“It's just that... forget it.” Spike began to say, trailed off once again and attempted to dismiss the topic once more.

Now Rarity was really concerned. It was clear to her now that he was afraid to talk about what was bothering him. “Darling... You can tell me anything, you know this right?” Rarity said in a comforting manner as she placed a hoof around him and held him close.

Spike took a deep breath through his nose, taking in the scent of the mare he loved so much and let out a sigh. “It's just that... of all the times I've said that I loved you...” Spike began to say only to trail off again. “You've never said it back” he finished and sighed once more as unknowingly to even him that tears began to form in his eyes.

Upon hearing this, Rarity bit her lower-lip guiltily. She had hopped he would never bring this topic up and now she was regretting asking the young drake was causing him so much grief now.

“Y-You do love me...don't you?” Spike asked as he looked up at her now tears freely streaming from his eyes now as he stared at her.

Seeing the young drake's face full of tears caused the proverbial guilt knife that was stabbing her in the gut at the moment to twist and grind further into her seemingly as she stared at his face. She had been using him for her own sexual fantasies for sometime now and she knew it. “Spike, I...” Rarity began to say only to feel her words falter followed by a sigh as she looked away from the young drake.

“You don't love me... do you?” Spike asked, his voice cracking as he spoke now.

A depressing silence ensued between the two now for what seemed to take forever to end until Rarity finally spoke. “No... I don't.” Rarity replied, her voice filled with regret,guilt, and sadness as she spoke.

“So... You've just been using me?” Spike asked as tears streamed down his cheeks and dripped to the floor now.

Another silence ensued between the two until the unicorn spoke once more. “Y-Yes...” Rarity stuttered out. As much as she wanted to, she couldn't bring herself to lie to him.

Spike, without warning, leaped off the bed and began to run out of the bedroom. “S-Spike! W-Wait!” Rarity exclaimed as she gestured out to him with her hoof as he darted out of the bedroom without another word but either Spike hadn't heard her or he had ignored her.

The sound of the front door being opened and slammed was the only thing that met the unicorn's ears which told her the obvious...

--------------------------------------

“Your highness, Princess Celestia wishes to speak with you.” A unicorn guard said calmly as Twilight scanned scroll after scroll, book after book, seemingly ignoring him. With no reply, the guard simply sighed and left the Canterlot archives for the fourth time today.

“This... isn't an overly thought out cruel joke by you and Discord... is it?” Twilight said shakily after a few moments.
“No, Twilight. I would never joke about such a thing.” Fluttershy replied as she looked at her.

These memories flashed through the Alicorn's mind as she scanned over a scroll for any sign of a possible memory alteration spell.

SEVERAL HOURS LATER...

Twilight had turned the Canterlot archives upside down and had found not one trace of a memory alteration spell. “How can this be?! If such a spell existed, it would exist here!” Twilight exclaimed as she looked over every single scroll and book that laid about. Twilight sat on her rump and placed a hoof on her chin in thought. “How could this be? Did I overlook something?” She thought to herself as she scanned her memory of every single book and scroll she read over.

It was then that something occurred to her. “What if... the spell is of Alicorn level magic? Naturally such spells wouldn't exist in the Archives since unicorns aren't strong enough to use them. But if that's the case, then where would Alicorn spells be stored?” She mused aloud thoughtfully.

This thought however didn't make her feel anymore relived though. In fact, it made her feel even worse since if this spell was indeed Alicorn level magic, it only further strengthened Fluttershy's story.

The Alicorn then stood up and began to search for a possible hidden wing which would contain the spell she looked for but as much as she looked, she couldn't find any trace. “Maybe there isn't a hidden wing for Alicorn spells after all.” Twilight remarked aloud as she placed a hoof on a wall and sighed. “Even if there was, I bet it would be locked with the highest encryption spell Princess Celestia could muster to prevent characters like Discord or other creatures with Alicorn level magic from getting a hold of them.” She remarked aloud until her eyes widened in realization as if she had an epiphany.

“An encryption...” She remarked out in a seemingly stunned tone as she looked over the countless scrolls and books that laid scattered throughout the floor thanks to her. Without another word, the Alicorn channeled magic into her horn, levitated every single scroll in the caterlot archives, and grave a loud grunt as she tapped into her inner Alicorn magic.

“I can do this...just concentrate Twilight!” Twilight thought to herself as she willed a decryption spell into her magic. If there was one thing Twilight knew, is was that she was the element of magic and had already once created new magic. Though she had merely finished the spell that Starswirl The Bearded had started, the fact remained that she had created a new spell on her own.

And if she could do it once... She could do it again.

Or at least, that's what she told herself as she concentrated with all her might as she continued to use all the willpower she had within her to create a decryption spell. Twilight's horn began to seemingly bubble with a black magic which was none other than her inner Alicorn magic rising to the surface.

Magical sparks began to spit and sputter from her horn now as she sweated profusely, not giving up in her attempt to create a new spell.

Many minutes passed now and the Alicorn was beginning to feel faint. However, just when she was just about to give up, her horn seemingly exploded with a burst of Alicorn magic which jetted towards all the books and scrolls she had been levitating.

Twilight watched in amazement as the books and scrolls she was once levitating began to swirl around the room coated in her Alicorn magic without her having to use her magic to levitate them any longer.

The swirling started out slow at first but gradually picked up speed, pages from the books being ripped from their bindings. Letters from some of the scrolls and pages began to seemingly look as if they were being ripped from the paper they had been written on and began to swirl around along with the scrolls and books as the speed of the swirling was picking up such speed and velocity that Twilight could feel the wind and pressure from the swirling began to whip against her which caused her mane and tail to flail wildly in the wake of the strong current.

Twilight soon began to panic however as the vortex of books,scrolls, and letters seemed to be picking up even more speed to the point that she had to channel magic into her hooves to root herself to the floor or risk being swept up in her own Alicorn spell. However, not even that was able to hold her in place for long. It was as if the spell was trying to draw her in as she felt her hooves begin to scrape along the floor as she edged closer and closer to the spinning vortex of books,letters, and scrolls.

Before Twilight knew was happened, her hooves left the ground and hr body flew straight into the heart of the vortex. Yet before she could so much as call out for help, the vortex suddenly and abruptly seemingly collapsed on itself and in a blinding flash of magic, Twilight vanished.

It was at this point that the same unicorn guard came back to tell her once again that Princess Celestia had requested her presence only to see the books, and scrolls fall to the floor with a collective sound of books and paper hitting cement. “Princess Twilight?” The guard asked curiously, having not seen the magic or the swirling vortex that was there moments before he walked into the room...

-------------------------------------


Twilight opened her eyes and hold her head with a loud groan before she stood up. “Ohh, what happened?” She asked aloud curiously before the scene that beheld her finally registered with her brain.

The Alicorn now stood in her brother's bedroom, her brother seemingly sound asleep in his bed. “Shining? You awake?” Twilight's voice asked only it didn't come from her mouth, rather from behind the door to her brother's bedroom.

“Yeah. What's up sis?” Shining Armor replied as he sat up in his bed as the door to his room swung wide open.

“How can I be there when I'm right here?!” Twilight blurted out in shock. The first thought that came to mind was that a changeling was invading her home and taking on her form but then another fact managed to catch her attention.

Her brother nor the Twilight that now stood in the bedroom seemed to have heard her outburst.

“Shining Armor, can't you hear me?” Twilight asked aloud but her brother made no motion to recognize her as she stood a crossed the room from him.

“Awake and bushy-tailed, good. Can't have you being a sleep while I give you your birthday gift now can we?” The Twilight in front of the door remarked with a coy smirk and tone to match it.

“Wait, this all looks familiar and did she say what I think she said?” Twilight thought to herself in a confused tone until it occurred to her. She was witnessing the night her and her brother had sex for the last time but something was off. “Wasn't my brother fast asleep when I walked in to his bedroom that night?” Twilight thought to herself curiously.

The unicorn then walked over to her brother's bed, channeled magic into her horn and closed the door to her brother's bedroom softly. She then climbed onto his bed and sat next to him. “So, are you ready for your birthday gift big brother?” The unicorn asked in a sultry voice as she used her magic to pull back the covers from her brother's body.

Are you sure this is such a good idea? In Canterlot, we had the privacy of your observatory and bedroom but here? What if our parents walk in?” Shining Armor asked apprehensively.

“Oh, I've got that covered.” Twilight replied with a smirk as she channeled magic into her horn at which point she quickly cast a sound damping spell on her brother's door and window.

Without another word, the unicorn channeled magic into her horn once again and focused it between her brother's hind legs which earned a soft moan from him.

Meanwhile the Twilight whom was standing a crossed from the two continued to stare as did her past self as her brother's length slowly grew and soon stood erect before the unicorn.

The unicorn slowly placed a single hoof on her brothers shaft and shivered uncontrollably. Her heart raced, her breathing quickened, the excitement was almost overwhelming for the mare. “It's been too long since I've touched this special part of you B-B-B-F-F. The part I've always adored the most.” Twilight remarked breathlessly as she placed her other front hoof on his shaft and began to stroke it up and down.

“I-It's only been two months.” Shining Armor replied between moans as the unicorn's hooves trailed up and down his shaft.

Twilight gave a soft giggle as she continued to stroke his length. “That's too long for me.” she replied with a smirk as she leaned down and licked the tip of her brother's member and shuddered at the taste. “You need to eat more fruit bro.” Twilight remarked as she looked up at her brother.

“Does it taste that bitter?” Shining Armor asked with a smirk.

Twilight looked up at her brother once again, leaned in close, and locked lips with him. “I'll deal with it since its your birthday.” She replied after she broke the kiss with her brother.

“Oh, how very considerate of you.” Shining Armor quipped with a smirk only to get a light smack upside the head from his sister's hoof. “Don't be such a jerk or I won't give you the second gift I have planned for you.” Twilight retorted with a coy grin before she lowered her mouth onto his shaft and began to bob her head up and down as she reached a hoof under herself and began to rub her clit with one hoof.

As much as Twilight tried, she couldn't help but be turned on at the sight of her past self giving her brother a blowjob. Despite being aroused by this incestuous act, one thing still lingered in the back of her mind. “Why am I seeing this? I was trying to cast a decryption spell, not a 'view my past' spell.” Twilight thought to herself but this event was transpiring a lot differently than she remembered it which prompted another question to come to mind.

“Could this be... what really happened all those years ago?” She asked herself aloud as she continued to watch her past self continue to bob her head up and down along her brother's shaft. “Maybe the spell I cast wasn't a decryption spell but rather a spell to tell me what really happened all those years ago?” Twilight mused aloud only to shake her head and groan. “I'll never understand Alicorn magic.” Twilight remarked dismally and sighed as she turned her attention back to her past self and her brother.

“Twiley... I'm gonna cum.” Shining Armor moaned out feeling his climax closing in fast.

Twilight watched her past self's eyes dart about the room as if looking for something and giggled aloud. “You're not going to find the box of tissues.” Twilight remarked aloud even though she knew her past self couldn't hear her, she knew was coming.

Shining Armor then let out a loud grunt and Twilight watched her past self's expression become shocked and surprised. The Alicorn couldn't help but laugh at this scene that beheld her now. Seeing it now from this perspective somehow made the scene hilarious to her. Twilight continued to watch as her past self reluctantly began to swallow her brother's seed or at least as much as she could as soft gulping sounds emitted throughout the room.

It was soon too much for the mare to handle and quickly channeled magic into her horn as she yanked her mouth off his still ejaculating member, coughing and gasping for breath as she did so but thanks to her quick thinking, the remaining streams were safely caught in her magic. “Why didn't I think of this before?” Twilight remarked aloud and sighed in announce as her brother's member ejaculated the remaining contents of his orgasm into the ball of magic she had conjured.

After she was sure that her brother had finished cumming, she quickly took the remaining contents of her brother's seed and discarded them out the bedroom window delicately so that the semen would not splash anywhere she didn't want it to.

“Wow Bro, you sure came a lot more than you used to. Also, you're getting a nice helping of strawberries and apple pies tomorrow for breakfast.” Twilight remarked aloud with a smirk at her sibling and looked downward towards his still erect cock.

“Your going to cook? In that case, I'll skip breakfast.” Shining Armor quipped once again with a cheesy grin only to get yet another playful swat from his sister as she gave him a playful glare.

“Unless you wanna miss out on getting some of this...” Twilight said trailing off as she turn around and flashed her soaking wet slit at him. “I suggest you be a little nicer to your little sister.” Twilight remarked with a coy grin as she turned her head around to look at him the best she could.”

Without warning, her brother leaned in and began to eat out his sister much to the latter's delight. “A-As much as I would love to cum hard to your tongue bro, we haven't got all night.” Twilight remarked between moans.

Upon hearing this, Shining Armor leaned back and chuckled. “Well, put it in then.” he remarked with a smirk.

“Oh I will, but first.” Twilight replied as she channeled magic into her horn and used it to clean off her brother's member. “Can't be too careful you know? Last thing I want is one of your swimmers getting me pregnant.” Twilight remarked aloud as she made sure not one drop of her brother's semen remained on his shaft.

Twilight knew what was coming next. The wetness in her hindquarters becoming even more apparent now as she felt it leak down from her flower to her inner leg before dripping to the floor. The urge to masturbate to her past self screwing her brother became stronger and stronger as her past self lowered herself onto her brother and began to thrust her hindquarters up and down along his shaft, moaning out in pure ecstasy.

She then leaned down and placed a hoof on his cheek. “I love you so much Shiny, it's good that you are awake to enjoy this. I wouldn't mind you having your way with me...” Twilight whispered into her brother's ear before she leaned in, closed her eyes, and kissed him deeply.

Twilight broke the kiss and flung her head up, her mane flailing in the wake of her swift gesture. “Dear Celestia! It's been too long since I've had you inside me B-B-B-F-F!” Twilight exclaimed a little too loudly.

Twilight watched as her past self gave a panicked glance to the door to her brother's room before she watched her expression become relieved and let out a sigh. She concluded that her past self must have forgotten she had cast the sound damping spell earlier and then remembered she had.

Twilight continued to watch her past self buck her brother. His shaft sliding in and out of his sister slit, the room slowly filling with the smell of sex.“I can't take it anymore!” Twilight blurted out abruptly, laid to the floor on her side, and resumed watching her past self buck her brother as she rubbed her clit furiously to the action that played out before her.

By now, Shining Armor's lower half was matted down and stained with Twilight's fluids, each thrust now causing soft squelching sounds to emit throughout the room, along with a soft wet slapping each time she slammed her sex onto his.

“Oh shiny, you're going to make your sister cum so hard...mmmph!” Twilight moaned out softly before slamming a hoof over her mouth to stifle her moans which were quickly becoming uncontrollable and louder with each passing minute.

“G-Go faster, Twiley.” Shining Armor managed to utter out between moans.

“You wanna cream your little sister's pie, don't you bro?” Twilight said as she continued to thrust her brother deeply into her slit as she stared at him.

“N-No! If I do that, you'll get pregnant.” Shining Armor stuttered out between moans as he felt his climax close in now.

“Shiny, I love you more than anything and...” Twilight replied only to trail off as she laned her head up to his ear and if not for the room being so quite aside from the wet slapping sounds, Twilight would have never heard her past self say the following words: “I'd gladly carry your foal.”

This statement snapped Twilight out of her sexual bliss and she blurted out: “SAY WHAT?!” as she stared in at her past self's words. She was glad that they couldn't hear her or anypony else in this past memory of hers for that matter. “Just how close were me and Shining Armor?” Twilight asked aloud curiously.

“I know you would but we've talked about this before, what would our parents think of us? What would princess Celestia say?” Shining Armor asked between grunts and moans as his sister continued to thrust his member into her.

“No pony has to know it was you who got me pregnant. It can be our little secret.” Twilight replied before she leaned in and kissed him. “I'll let you decide but you better decide soon though. You look like you're ready to pop.” She added with a smirk as she slowed her thrusts down in order to slow the pleasure her brother was receiving in order to buy him more time to decide.

A silence ensued now save for the soft squelching sounds as Twilight's past self continued to slowly thrust her brother in and out of her.

“A-Are you sure this is what you want? This will change out lives forever you know.” Shining Armor asked softly doing his best to stave off the impending climax he knew was closing in fast despite his sister slowing down.

“Shiny, I want to start a family with you. I've thought about this for nearly a year now and I decided that tonight, I would give you the chance to become a father as the ultimate birthday gift to you.” Twilight replied softly as she kissed him again.

Another silence ensued and Twilight noticed her brother looking deep in thought.

“O-Okay Twiley, let's make a foal.” Shining Armor finally said much to the delight of his sister who let out a squeal of delight as she resumed her previous pace with renewed vigor.

Shining Armor felt his climax close in now, the feeling in his member swelling to the brink with that familiar feeling that told any male he was ready to blow his load at any moment. “L-Last chance, sis. Pull off me now if you're having second thoughts.”

“Not a single one, now make me a mommy, bro.” Twilight replied softly as she locked lips with her brother.

Shining Armor gave a loud grunt into their kiss and that's when Twilight felt it. Her brother's hot, warm, and sticky life-giving seed gushing into her folds.

“That's it shiny, cum for me. Give your sister every last drop of that seed.” Twilight said lustfully after she broke the kiss as she thrust him into her with reckless abandon now feeling her own climax come crashing down on her body moments after she said these words.

Twilight's body seized up, her vaginal muscles clamped down on her brother's member like a vice, and her puffy purple pussy soaked her brother's neither regions and bed in her mare juices. “I love you so much Shiny! Don't stop until you give me every last drop!” Twilight exclaimed at the top of her lungs as she continued to thrust her flower up and down on her brothers member, each time she pulled up, she felt another stream of her brother's seed splash against her inner walls, coating it in his seed, only to slam herself back down on him as deeply as possible.

Each time Twilight slammed herself down on her brother, she felt his seed smear against her inner walls along with fresh streams. Finally, she slammed herself down upon him once more and laid there in place as she felt a few more streams splash against her cervix.

Twilight by now had completely lost all but all of her desire to cum to her brother and past self bucking by now. She was too stunned by the fact that she and her brother mutually consented to having a foal. So many questions now laid in her mind now. However, before she could think on them anymore, the world around seemed to swirl and fade as if somepony had taken a paint brush and began to swirl it along the canvas to mix and blur the colors together.

---------------------------------------------

When the swirling finally stopped, she found herself in another familiar setting. Only this one she couldn't recall at all. Twilight now stared at what could be none other than herself looking at, what Twilight assumed to be at least four months pregnant along with her former mentor as they stood in her royal quarters.

“Twilight, please do not lie to me. I have been your mentor for nearly fifteen years now and you should know by now that I know when you are hiding something from me.” Princess Celestia remarked and sighed before she continued. “Now I will ask once more, who is the father of your foal?”

Twilight watched her past self fidget nervously where she stood, the all too common look of worry that she often wore when she would allow things to get to her upon her past self's face now.

Twilight fidgeted in place for a little longer before she hung her head low and sighed heavily. “Shining... Shining Armor is the father.” She said in a defeated tone which earned a shocked expression from her mentor.

“Y-Your brother?! He's the father?! I'll see to it that he is punished for doing this to you.” Princess Celestia said in a firm tone.

Twilight's expression became panicked as she snapped her head up to look at her mentor. “N-No! It's not like that! I consented!”

Upon hearing this, the Alicorn's became confused. “You consented? Do you mean to tell me that you willingly had sex with your brother and allowed him to impregnate you?” Princess Celestia asked incredulously.

“Y-Yes. We've talked about starting family before but he would always convince me-”

“Wait a second! You mean to tell me that this isn't the first time that you and your brother have had sex?”

“Yes. I know its illegal to have an incestuous relationship in Equestria but I love him, Princess! If you wish to punish anypony for this crime, punish me but please, I beg you not to punish my brother. He has such a great life ahead of him as head of the royal guard and I don't want to see him lose it.” Twilight replied as tears streamed from her eyes now as she looked at her mentor.

Princess Celestia's expression remained firm for a few moments longer before she let out a heavy sigh. “Twilight, what you have done is wrong and under normal circumstances, I would be forced to carry out the punishment for the crime you and your brother have committed...” Princess Celestia replied only to sigh once again.”But that would ruin the wonderful future you and your brother have.”

“P-Princess?” Twilight asked sounding mildly confused as a smile washed over her mentor's face.

“So, I will choose to act as if this conversation never took place but I ask that you allow me to present the day you give birth to your foal, are we clear, Twilight?” Princess Celestia said softly.

“O-Of course Princess! Thank you so much for understanding!” Twilight exclaimed as she rushed up to her mentor and hugged her tightly.

After Princess Celestia said these words, the world once again began to swirl and blur until another she didn't recall beheld her. She was now standing in a hospital room and realized almost immediately that her past self was crying out in pain as Shining Armor stood next to her while Princess Celestia stood at the foot of the hospital bed paying close attention to the mare's vagina.

Almost there Twilight, just one more push!” Princess Celestia exclaimed.

“Ahhhh!” Twilight exclaimed aloud in agony as she pushed with all her might.

Twilight stared slack-jawed as her past self gave a pained cry and moments later an orange filly with a purple mane and tail slowly edged its way from her past self's vagina and out into Princess Celestia's magic.

The infant foal immediately began to cry out as the cold air from the world she was just born into brushed against her body. The Alicorn swiftly used her magic to cut the umbilical cord and wrapped the infant foal in a nearby towel before levitating her into Twilight's hooves.

Twilight held her newborn daughter in her hooves with a tearful smile and looked to her brother. “Look at her Shiny... our daughter.” Twilight remarked as the infant foal quickly calmed down in her mother's embrace and fell a sleep.

Twilight quickly looked to her left and saw a glimpse of pink mane which was barely viable in the crack of the door. However, a few moments later she saw Fluttershy's head pop in to get a better look at the scene.

The Alicorn then gently lifted the now sleeping foal from Twilight's arms. “What will you name her?” She asked softly.

Twilight was silent for a time before she finally spoke. “I'll name her... Scootaloo. It's the name I always told myself I would name my first-born daughter.” Twilight replied as she smiled at her mentor.

“Very well. I will see that she is taken care of.” Celestia said as she began to turn around.

Twilight turned to look in the direction of the door now just in time to see Fluttershy's expression become panicked and duck from the door and out of sight.

“Wh-What?”Twilight asked aloud in a confused tone as though she didn't understand what was happening.

I'm Sorry Twilight but if word got out that this foal was born out of an incestuous relationship between you and your brother... the results would be disastrous for you and your family, I would be forced to dismiss you as my pupil, and Shining Armor would lose his post as head of the royal guard due to the scandal.” Celestia replied though it sounded deeply saddened now.

Do you honestly think that we would let you walk out of here with our daughter only to never see her again?”Shining Armor's voice spoke up, the anger and fury of his words carrying an air of threat to them.

“No, I suppose not. Forgive me.” Celestia replied and in the next moment, A blinding light flashed brightly before Twilight's eyes.

The light was so bright that Twilight herself had to shield her eyes from it. Once the light faded, Twilight lowered her hoof and realized she was standing back in the Canterlot Archives standing dead in the middle of the books and scrolls which were swirling seemingly hours ago.

“So Fluttershy wasn't lying... it's all true.” Twilight remarked aloud as the realization of what this meant settled in her mind. Twilight then looked up to see the same royal guard from earlier staring at her in pure shock.

“P-Princess, are you alright?” The guard asked hesitantly.

“In a matter of speaking.” Twilight muttered to herself dismally before she replied so that the guard could hear her. “I'm fine, why?”

“W-Well, I came here to inform you that Princess Celestia has requested your presence but you weren't here. I was about to leave when you suddenly popped into existence out of nowhere.” The guard replied nervously.

“How long was I gone?” Twilight asked curiously.

“I don't know, less than two minutes at most.” The guard replied with an unsure expression.

Twilight then placed a hoof on her chin looking deep in thought “But it was so much longer than that...just what spell did I cast anyways?” She mused to herself for a short time before she resumed her attention to the guard.

“Very well, there's a matter I wish to discuss with the princess myself. Remove all guards from their posts and leave us in peace until you are informed otherwise.” Twilight said aloud in the most regal voice she could muster.

“But Princess, I can't-”

“This is a royal order. You wouldn't dare disobey a royal order, would you?” Twilight replied, cutting off the guard with a stern expression and tone to match it.

“N-No of course not! As you wish, your highness.” The guard replied, gave a short bow and quickly left Twilight alone.

“Now to have a nice long chat with my former mentor...” Twilight seethed aloud through gritted teeth as she walked towards the royal hall.

-------------------------------------

“Where is Twilight? I certainly hope nothing has happened to her.” Princess Cadance remarked with a worried expression.

“I'm sure she's just fine. In fact I'm sure she'll be showing up any-” Princess Celestia began to say only for a blast of magic to connect with her royal chair, obliterating it in an explosion of splinters and wood.

All three Alicorn's attention was yanked to the source of the attack prepared to defend themselves only to gawk in shock as Twilight stood on the other side of the royal hall, a look of pure rage upon her facial features.

“Why did you do it?! How could you separate a mother from her foal?!” Twilight roared as she walked along the hall growing closer and closer with each rage filled step that echoed throughout the hall.

“Twilight, I'm afraid I don't know what you're-” Princess Celestia began to say only to be cut off as another blast of magic impacted less than a foot away from her head into the wall directly behind her.

“The next one won't miss. NOW ANSWER ME!” Twilight roared as she stepped up to the Alicorn and stood less than five feet from her.

Celestia's expression became sympathetic now as she knew exactly what Twilight was talking about now. “You have to understand, Twilight. I did what I thought was-” Princess Celestia began to say only to go flying into the wall as Twilight blasted her with a shot of Alicorn level magic.

“Twilight! What in Equestria do you think you're doing?! You just assaulted royalty! That's a criminal offense, even for a princess!” Princess Cadance exclaimed as she ran up to Twilight and stood in front of her.

“M-Move aside, Cadance. Twilight's actions are not unwarranted.” Princess Celestia said aloud as she stood to all fours with a soft groan. “Besides, if she really wanted to hurt me, she would have put a lot more magic behind that spell of hers.” She added as she looked past Cadance to Twilight whom continued to glare at her.

“No more excuses, no more lies! How could you do that to me? To Scootaloo?!

“Sister, what is Twilight talking about?” Princess Luna whom was in pure shock up till now finally managed to utter out this question.

“So she didn't even tell you? Then let me! She took my daughter, Scootaloo, away from me and wiped all memories I had of her and any events before I gave birth to her!”

This new set of information caused both Alicorn's to stare in shock at Twilight then to Princess Celestia whom made no attempt to deny these claims.

“Leave us.” Princess Celestia said calmly but firmly.

“But sister-”

“I said, LEAVE US!” Princess Celestia roared in none other than her royal Canterlot voice. “I will explain everything once I've had a chance to discuss this matter with Twilight.” She added in her normal voice though it still sounded firm.

Without another word, Princess Cadance and Luna swiftly left the royal hall. With the two now alone, Princess Celestia sighed heavily as she looked over at her royal chance which was not in tatters then to Twilight whom still continued to glare at her with the same rage filled eyes.

“I did it to protect you and your brother. If you recall everything as I think you do, then you will recall that I explicitly said that an incestuous relationship is illegal in Equestria. What do you think would have happened to you and your brother once word got out?” Celestia said as she looked at her former pupil with a stern gaze.

“But it wouldn't have! You could have made sure of this!” Twilight exclaimed as she stomped a hoof on the floor. “Why Princess? I trusted you! Shining Armor trusted you! How could you betray us like that?” Twilight asked, her anger slowly ebbing away and being replaced with sadness and grief.

“Questions would have arisen Twilight! We hid the fact that you were pregnant from all of Canterlot! Not even your parents knew of it! Or did you not recall?” Celestia exclaimed her temper rising slightly until she realized Twilight was genuinely drawing a blank on this particular set of information.

“I see, so not all of your memories have returned.” Celestia remarked as she sat down on the floor now and sighed. “Twilight, I won't deny that what I did was beyond forgivable but please understand, I had your best intentions at heart.”

Twilight stood there for a few moments longer simply staring at her mentor's saddened face. She wanted to hate her forever, she wanted to stay angry but she also knew that her former mentor wouldn't do something so drastic without a good reason. Eventually, Twilight crumbled to the floor and began to sob loudly. “It's not fair!” She sobbed aloud as Princess Celestia stood up, walked over to her, kneeled down and placed an arm around her.

“I would like to discuss this matter further but there's a more pressing matter I must speak with you about.” Princess Celestia said and sighed.

“Discord has betrayed the ponies of Equestria and joined forces with Tirek. ” Princess Celestia remarked solemnly.

Upon hearing this, Twilight's face snapped up to look at her mentor with a shocked expression.”What?! How could he do this?! I thought our friendship meant something to him! I thought he had changed.” Twilight exclaimed her voice filled with a mixture of shock and anger.

“There is no doubt that Tirek is after Alicorn magic. With Discord by his side, we will not be able to stop him from taking it.”

“Once it is in his possession, his power will know no bounds, and all hope will be lost.” Princess Luna's voice came from behind the two at which point Twilight looked back to see Luna and Cadance walking towards them.

“How much did you hear?” Celestia asked with a stern expression.

A coy grin appeared on Luna's face as she spoke. “I'm sorry sister, but I'm afraid I must have had something in my ears up until a few moments ago. I didn't hear anything until you spoke of Tirek.” Luna replied with a knowing look.

“Same here. I don't know why but I couldn't make out more than a muffle till now.” Cadance added with a similar knowing look.

A smile washed over the Alicorn's face upon hearing this before she allowed it to return to its stern state and sighed. “Getting back to the matter at hoof, there is but one solution. It is only by making this sacrifice that Equestria and the lands beyond it might be saved. We must rid ourselves of our magic before Tirek has the chance to steal it from us.”

Upon hearing this, Twilight gave a shocked gasp as her eyes widened...

Next Chapter: Betrayal(part 1) Estimated time remaining: 1 Hour, 48 Minutes
Return to Story Description
Some Secrets Are Better Left Untold 2...

Mature Rated Fiction

This story has been marked as having adult content. Please click below to confirm you are of legal age to view adult material in your area.

Confirm
Back to Safety

Login

Facebook
Login with
Facebook:
FiMFetch