“Oh boy! This is gonna be lots of fun, Gummy! Oh how I wish you could come, but Rarity said it was a “special” kind of get together. I didn't even know she swung that way!” Pinkie was skipping about her house, getting supplies, such as flour and other cupcake ingredients. “What did you think I meant Gummy? Something dirty? Oh no, not dirty like that, silly billy!” She gave Gummy a kiss goodbye as she skipped over to Rarity's house. She said hello to everypony, greeted a few new faces, and promised them a party later. She thought it was weird that Fluttershy hadn't been at the pet store, this was her usual time to buy birdseed for the wild birds she cares for. She giggled and thought nothing of it, maybe she decided to go earlier. Pinkie finally bounced to Rarity's door, and before she could knock, the door swung open, causing Pinkie to fall in as she leaned to knock.

“Oh, Hey Rarity! Are you excited? I am, I didn't think you would get your hooves dirty with me, but wanting to make cupcakes with me? This is gonna be fun! I wrote a song about this!” Rarity interrupted her before she sung her song, and asked her to go pick up a letter from her desk. Pinkie thought nothing of it, and felt a slight prick in her neck as she turned around, then fell unconscious. Rarity had used a syringe full of tranquilizer that Discord had left her. He was watching from the sidelines. “Well, are you just going to sit there, or are you going to help me get this thing up to the bath?” Discord sighed, and helped Rarity bring the pink pony to the upstairs. Suddenly a burst of cool water woke the earth pony up. “Oh..Rarity, what happened..and why am I tied up? Wait..Is this what you meant by a special day? Oh..I didn't know you went that way, I thought we were going to make cupcakes!” Pinkie takes a deep breath, preparing to sing her Cupcakes song, when Rarity drove her hoof into the pony's throat, shutting her up, and causing tears to form.

“Oh god, why must all you ponies have such annoying eyes when you cry. If I didn't want you to see what I am about to do, I'd cut them out right now. But there is no fun in that. Simply put, my dear, you were right, we were going to make cupcakes, not partake in that BDSM fetish of yours. You did save me a few bits on supplies, and I thank you. Your reward is a front row seat of a once in a lifetime event, for you at least.” Rarity was laughing manically at the end of her speech. She had Discord Soundproof the room this time, so she could hear the cries of torment, without the possibility of detection. She called to the closet, which confused Pinkie. Suddenly Discord himself appeared, with a few needles, and a sewing kit. “Oh, my dear Pinkamena Diane Pie, you just had to hold the element of Laughter, didn't you?”Discord spoke, “Otherwise, you would be out there, living it up. But you see, Rarity here, she thinks of you as a thief. One she wants to kill, brutally. But you can rest easy, this is a fun game!” Discord laughed as the pony started to cry. “Oh no no no Pinkie, we can't have you shutting your eyes now!” Discord pulled out the needle and thread, and proceeded to sew her eyelids open, and fixes her vision to her body, and tells Rarity to proceed with the festivities, he would mix the cupcake batter while the fun was underway.

“So, Pinkie darling, did you know that a Pony can live without their skin? Well, as long as they stay in a clean environment, such as this. It also helps if the one skinning you wanted you to live, of course.” Rarity let out her sinister laugh she had developed from the fun. Pinkie was scared, that she lost control of her bladder. Rarity shook her head at the sight of this. “Oh now darling, you ruined a small part of the special ingredient, I would never make anypony eat a urine soaked piece of Pinkie. Now I have to punish you before the fun starts!” Rarity trots over to her tools, pulling out a hatchet, a knife, and a nail gun. “Hmm, the hatchet will come in handy afterward, Really don't need to nail you down, so the Knife will be just fine for this.” Rarity takes the knife in her mouth, and trots over to Pinkies flank, looking at her urine stained nether region. “Oh, if we were brought together on happier terms, I might of partook in the sexual fun, but you had to soak it in urine, now to waste this meat.” Rarity used her telekinesis to lift the knife, and proceeded to carve out the soiled chunk of flesh, causing Pinkie to pass out. Discord slithered over next to her.

“Rarity, wait a second, she cannot experience this, just a shot of my special brew, and she won't be able to pass out!” Discord inserted the syringe full fo a mysterious fluid into Pinkies arm, who awoke to the sight of Rarity carving out her flesh. “Rar..Rarity, why are you cutting those off, how will I go to the bathroom now?” Pinkie was trying to make the best of this situation, playing it off as a dream. Discord found this hilarious, and told Rarity to continue with it. Rarity finally got the ruined chunk of meat off of Pinkie, and walked over, forcing her mouth open. “Now now Darling, if you hadn't ruiend this, I wouldn't have to force feed it to you.” With that, she shoved the chunk of flesh down into her mouth, when Pinkie cired out, trying to spit it out, the feel of a dream soon faded back into fear. Rarity had used her magic to force the chunk down her throat, and had made sure it had reached her stomach.

“Oh darling, it would have been wonderful had you thought it was all a dream still. But now you had gone and ruined that too!” Rarity used a hoof to strike Pinkie across the face, causing Pinkie to cry out. Discord had grown annoyed with the pink one's voice, and told Rarity to silence her. She sighed, and proceeded to carefully cut at her throat, where she carefully removed her vocal box, hoping not to kill her play toy before the fun begun. Pinkie tried to move her body to cause the knife to end her suffering right now, but the magical fluid Discord injected her with caused her to lose all control of her body, yet still allowed her to feel each nerve, even more so than usual. Rarity managed to silence the pony, without ruining the fun, and threw the vocal chords into the tub below. It was filled with a mixture of urine and blood from her newest victim. Yellow, blood stained feathers still littered the tub, from her last victim. Rarity used her magic to lift a few, causing Pinkie's eyes to stream tears at a rapid rate.

“That is right darling, Fluttershy was killed, much like you were. She made a lovely roast, and her skin made these lovely pot holders.” She proceeded to get a larger knife, and slowly made an incision from the pink pony's chest, to the spot where the ruined flesh was cut out. She got out a bizarre looking tool, it was a flat piece of steel. Rarity knew what Discord had given it to her for. She slid the flat metal into the incision, lifting the skin up off the body. What felt like days of excruciating pain to Pinkie finally ended. Rarity pulled the skin off slowly, Pinkie had seen it, what laid protected under her flesh was exposed. Rarity was almost done, but before, she kissed Pinkie on the cheek. “I just want to thank you for the fun you gave me today, darling. But now it must come to an end.” With that, Rarity had used her magic to bring the Hatchet up, and she kept bringing it down, cutting the body from the below the stomach off, spilling out the entrails into the tub below. Pinkie had tried to let out a loud sound as she was slowly dying then and there. The pain had gotten to be so much, Pinkie couldn't feel pain anymore. Discord then handed her the nail gun.”It isn't fun if she can't feel it, be a dear and put her out of her misery.” Rarity had placed the nail gun in between Pinkie's eyes, and pulled the trigger, killing the pink pony then and there, a tear of joy running down her cheek.

“Ahh, Rarity, a job well done!” Discord commended her, “And these cupcakes are so wonderful!” Rarity chuckled, as she took a bite. “Why of course, Discord, and this rug is lovely! I must thank you for bringing this fun to me!” She gave him a hug, and retired to her chambers for the night.