CHAPTER TWENTY THREE: When She Loved Me

Whatever remained of us left Rarity's house, hearing the screams of Peter.

“GUYS! I FINALLY FOUND YOU!” David came running towards us, his mane sopping wet and messed up.

“Princess Celestia and Luna teleported the three of us to their bedroom, after a few minutes they got bored and began to pleasure each other! I barley escape! One more thing, I AM GOING TO FUCKING KILL YOU DORCHESTER!” David pounced on me, but was thrown back by King Horus.

“Look, we don't have time to fight. There are hundreds of horny mares looking for us, and we have no idea when or where they might show up.”

Suddenly a mare perched herself on my back.

“JOCKEY!” I yelled as the mare screamed as she grinded my back. I was running everywhere.

“GET IT OFF GET IT OFF GET IT OFF! WHOAA!” I yelled as Silvermoon headbutted my chest, sending me and the mare flying back.

“Don't you dare try to touch my husband!” Silvermoon roared. The mare ran away yelling in terror.

“C'mon, I have a feeling that the two princesses will be coming back any moment now.” But before Lance could finish his sentence, thousands, if not hundreds of mares surrounded us. Followed by the two princesses.

“Gotcha.” Celestia said with a wild giggle, and we were ambushed.

The Next Day...

I woke up in the princesses bedroom with Lance, Frederic, David, and King Horus in the same room, still out cold.

Damn this headache hurts...

I rubbed my head, why did my groin hurt so... oh shit. Frederic is going to kill me if he ever finds out. My member was sticking out in front of Luna's face. Her tongue sticking out.

Damnit boy, find your clothes!

I scattered around, eventually finding my clothes and putting them on.

“Huh...? What...?” Celestia got up drowsily. She gasped and fell on her back when she saw the scene.

“Whoops...” She said, blushing.

“You can't control it. Just... forget about it. Please.” I shuddered, my head still throbbing and my groin aching.

I exited the castle, I needed some time by myself to forget that experience.

“Dorchester!” Silvermoon came walking up to me.

“I'm so sorry I couldn't help you! They just completely ignored me and went on.”

“It's fine.” I replied, slinging my arm around Silvermoon.

We returned to the house where I went into bed to take a nap. I was tired and my headache was a pain in the ass.

“Wake up Dorchester.”

…

“I said WAKE UP!”

“What?” I said yelled out, Silvermoon jerked awake.

“Is everything okay?” She asked me. I glanced outside. Dark.

“I just... I think I just heard something in my sleep that freaked me out.” I waved my hoof. “Forget about it.”

Silvermoon nodded and went back to sleep. I sighed and closed my eyes as I lowered myself back onto my bed.

“Dorchester. I won't leave you until you speak to me.”

I opened my eyes. I was in some sort of tie-die area, floating in midair. The dark purple and blue colors swirled around. I saw a bruised body of a massive golden and white alicorn. It lay there, motionless.

“Ty... Tythol...?”

“I've been waiting for you Dorchester. I may not be able to revive myself to my former glory, but I have gained enough power to bring you here.”

“What do you want from me?”

“I want nothing. At the moment. Actually, come to think of it. I want to talk to you.”

The massive curled body of Tythol didn't move.

“My soul was separated from my body when Lace... defeated me. I've heard you're going to go back in time and stop whatever saved you? What do you suspect it was?”

My eyes continued to stare at the unmoving body.

“I don't know.”

I was suddenly pushed back and fell to the floor.

“LIES! You suspected love.”

“What are you getting at?”

“Make it easier for yourself. Don't go back. If Lace defeated me... why chance do you have against him?”

“What are you talking about?!” I yelled.

“Are you happy?”

“Of course! I am being provided by the castle and have an amazing wife that I love and care for!”

“Is she the one you truly wanted?”

I see now he's mentioning Luna.

“Luna is very happy, and so am I!” I stomped my hoof on the ground.

“Are you sure about that?”

I began to become frustrated. “Of course!”

“I sense denial.”

“Let me go.” I demanded.

“Think about what you've witnessed. You may change your mind later.”

I woke up while the sun rose. I checked the clock beside me, it read 9:37 AM. Silvermoon was still sound asleep. I got out of bed and dressed myself.

After having a small breakfast, I went outside whistling a tune. Little did I know it was one of the saddest songs I had ever heard. I sighed and continued. I eventually found myself singing the lyrics.

“When somebody loved me,

everything was beautiful,

Every hour we spent together,

lives within my heart.

And when she was sad,

I was there to dry her tears,

and when she was happy, so was I,

when she loved me.

Through the summer and the fall,

we had each other, that was all,

just she and I together,

like it was meant to be.

And when she was lonely,

I was there to comfort her,

and I knew that she loved me.

So the years went by,

I stayed the same

and she began to drift away,

I was left alone,

still I waited for the day,

when she'd say:

“I will always love you.”

Lonely and forgotten,

never thought she'd look my way,

she smiled at me and held me,

just like she used to do,

like she loved me...

when she loved me...

When somebody loved me,

everything was beautiful,

every hour we spent together,

lives within my heart,

when she loved me...”

I felt myself feel lightheaded, I knew Tythol was summoning me again. I sat under a nearby tree and lay there.

I appeared in the arena once again.

“You still care for her.”

“I don't want to talk to you.” I said firmly.

“Why not? Maybe I can help you.”

“You can't help me. All you've done is sit around in the deepest waves of the universe! You've already given up!” I had my eyes fixed on the body of Tythol. I just knew it was watching me... somehow...

“That doesn't mean I still can't give you advice.”

“I don't need any advice! I'll go back, and stop love from saving me.”

“Love... so you have figured it out. How do you suppose it saved you?”

“That's what I'm trying to figure out.” I snapped.

“Fine. I'll send you back. But first, tell me this. What do you suppose to do when you go back in time. How will you stop it?”

“I'm trying to figure that out as well...” I said, looking down. I blinked and I was back under the shade of the tree.

Might as well head back.

I agree.

Yeah... let's go. Next Chapter: Nightmare Estimated time remaining: 36 Minutes