It was a beautiful day in Ponyville. The sun was shining, the birds were chirping, and everypony was in a delightful mood. All that is…except for Pinkie Pie. She mopped around Ponyville, trying to look a little bit cheerful. “Pinkie Pie!” Twilight Sparkle said. “You look horrible! What’s wrong?” “Nothing that you would understand, Twilight.” Pinkie said. “I’m just tired.” “Okay, Pinkie. I wanted to ask you if you wanted to come look for Rainbow Dash with me and Applejack. I havent seen her all day.” Pinkie said: “She’s probably in the clouds, flying. I gotta go home and get some rest. “”Bye, Pinkie! I hope you feel better!” Twilight called after her. As Pinkie stopped in front of Sugar Cube Corner, she sighed. “I wish I could tell them, but I know that I can’t.” She walked into her secret cellar. She drawed a number from the drawing. “Looks like Amethyst Star is up next. But I’ll do that tomorrow.” So Pinkie took some pills, trudged over to her bed, and fell asleep.

“Welcome, Amethyst! I’ve been waiting for you ALLLLL DAY!” Pinkie chirped, trying to be as cheerful as possible. “It’s such a pleasant treat to be invited here, Pinkie!” Amethyst said. “So, what fun things do you having planned for us today?” Pinkie gave Amethyst a cupcake. “I want you to taste test this!” So Amethyst ate the rainbow-colored cupcake. “Okay, now what?” “Now,” Pinkie said. “You take a nap!” Ametyst began to feel very wozy, and soon fell to the ground, out cold. Pinkie dragged her into the cellar, clipped her onto the iron holder, cut her horn off, and patiently waited until she got up. Amethyst got up, finding that her horn was gone. “Pinkie! What are you doing?!” Amethyst yelled. Pinkie was not in the mood for talking, so she just began her work without saying anything. She slowly cut off Amethyst’s two cutie marks. She had always thought that her cutie marks were pretty. They were three Amethysts, each one with a blue color.

She couldn’t hear Amethyst's screaming. She had bought earplugs from the dollar store earlier this morning. After she had her cutie marks, she nailed her onto the iron board, making her hooves stained in blood. “Boy, Amethyst has a lot of blood in her body.” Pinkie thought. She flipped a switch. Amethyst whole body was devoured in sparks from being electrocuted. Pinkie unclipped her, and placed the blood stained nails on the stove. She cut open her stomach, making a slab of gooey flesh fall off of Amethysts body. Pinkie carefully placed Amethysts liver, kidneys, heart, and stomach into a bucket. Amethyst finally closed her eyes, the last thing she seeing be Pinkie take her heart out of her body.