In the sequel to "Rarity Tries Out Magic", Magic: The Gathering has become popular at the Ponyville Schoolhouse with everypony going out and buying starter decks. Everypony's having a great time with their cards and battling each other. However, one pony seems to be unstoppable in her quest to defeat each and every single pony in class with her deck combinations. With the rise of this student, can anypony there defeat this player and restore balance to the school?