The next day:

“You think you’re smart? HUH? YOU THINK YOU KNOW ME? YOU DON’T KNOW ME AT ALL!” Star screamed.

Pabu let out a squeak.

“Oh you think begging will save you now?” Star said to Pabu.

Pabu stood on his legs, staring at Star curiously.

J watched them from the stairway his eyebrow cocked.

Star aimed his finger at Pabu before saying “Bang!”

Pabu let out a squeal before falling over, playing dead.

J shook his head a little bit before slowly descending the stairs. He kept staring at Star. “What are you doing?” He questioned.

“Reenactment.” Star said.

“Of what?” J questioned.

“Never you mind that.” Star said quickly. “Come Pabu we have… Ah never mind I’m bored.”

“Okay… do you know what day it is?” J asked.

“Why?” Star asked.

“Just wondering.” J said. “So do you?”

“February 14th.” Star said.

“Oka-” J stopped mid sentence.

“What is it?” Star asked.

J smiled a little bit, “Don’t you worry your pretty little head one bit.” He said. “Well you might want to in a few minutes… once everyone IS awake.”

“J… You’re making me nervous.” Star said.

“Star! I’m surprised you don’t know what today is!” J said with a gasp of surprise.

Star squinted, “Elaborate…” He said.

J smiled, “Well it’s a holiday today…” He said.

Star thought for a moment, “Which o-” He froze, his eyes widening.

“Hey Star…” Fluttershy said.

“Oh god…” Star mumbled.

“Hey Star…” Pinkamena said.

“Oh… God.” Star mumbled louder.

“Hey Dad.” Sarah and Serena said.

“Nope!” Star yelped running downstairs and into the kitchen.

J laughed a little bit as he walked into living room, “I’m heading out I have one last thing I need to pick up.” He said approaching the front door.

“Sure you don’t wanna stay for breakfast?” Star asked as the scent of bacon wafted through the morning air.

J shrugged, “Sure I can stay…” He said turning around. “I… oh… fuck I forgot about Rarity…”

“I’m sure we can find a diamond somewhere to give her.” Star laughed.

“Yeah… I’m sure we can…” J said. “I’m hoping everyone likes what I got…”

“Well I’ll count this as my gift.” Star said as he lined several plates of food on the table, “Breakfast lunch and dinner. For breakfast we have… Bacon, eggs, french toast, pancakes, some sugary cereal, orange juice, some grilled cheese, and fuck it… Might as well throw in the chocolate strawberries.”

“Awww… I knew you loved me…” J said with a smile.

“Feel free to pig o-” Star was cut off as Fluttershy bolted through the air and tackled him.

“I smelled chocolate strawberries…” Fluttershy said jumping off of him and staring at the table of food.

“One down…” Star grunted.

There was a flash as Sarah and Serena teleported into the kitchen, landing on top of Star.

“We smelled pancakes.” The two of them said simultaneously.

“T...Three…” Star mumbled painfully.

Pinkamena dove through the window, “I SMELL BACON!” She screamed.

“Well… That wasn’t as bad as I expected…” Star said quietly standing up. He noticed J was gone, seeing his phone on the table. He picked it up and noticed a text message from Cadence. “I’ve decided to come see you today… It’s been too long since we’ve done ANYTHING! Come pick me up at the train station Joe Joe!”

“Kay.” Pinkamena mumbled.

“Well what do you think about that Flutt-” Star paused as he glanced at Fluttershy, who was staring at him, a strawberry between her teeth.

Star smiled, “Let me help you with that.” He said walking over and kissing her.

“Dad.” Sarah said elbowing Star in the side.

Star nearly choked on the strawberry in his mouth before looking at Sarah, “Yes?” He said.

“J got us gifts.” Serena said pointing into the living room.

“Well merry Christmas.” Star laughed as the five of them headed out into the living room. Fluttershy took hers first.

“I wonder what it is…” Fluttershy said.

All of them heard a little bark from the inside the present.

Everyone in the room looked at the present as Fluttershy opened it.

The paper fell away to reveal a medium sized dog crate with a little note attached to the door. The note was half eaten as a little puppy looked up at everyone expectantly, his tail wagging happily.

Fluttershy squealed before taking the puppy out and hugging it, “Oh my god he’s so cuuute!” She said.

Sarah and Serena walked over to Fluttershy and stared at the puppy intently.

“Daww…” Pinkamena and Star said.

The puppy barked happily a few more times.

Inside the crate there were a few strange sounds.

“I think you have more gifts.” Star motioned to the crate.

Fluttershy picked up what was left of the note, “I’ve decided to give one of my puppies to each of you! Enjoy!”

Sarah and Serena lit up before rushing over to the crate and taking out one of the previous unnoticed puppies. The two of them giggled uncontrollably as the puppies licked their faces.

Pinkamena picked one up and stared at it, “Hm…” She mumbled.

“Pinkamena?” Star said.

“He’s okay.” Pinkamena shrugged.

Star walked over to the crate and noticed a larger mass of black fur resting in the back corner. The puppy sitting there was a bit larger than the others. Star reached down to pick it up.

The puppy looked up at Star’s hands before looking up at him.

“Well aren’t you just adorable.” Star smiled.

The puppy licked his hand and it’s tail wagged a little bit.

Star laughed and hugged the puppy close, “Okay… This is a pretty cool gift.” He said.

Fluttershy was on the floor with hers, Sarah’s, Serena’s and Pinkamena’s puppies. They were all climbing over and licking her.

“Stop it! It tickles!” Fluttershy squealed and giggled.

Star put his down, “Why don’t you go join your friends.” He said. The puppy looked up at him curiously before running back and sitting next to Star’s foot. “You really like me don’t you boy… I guess I’ll have to think of a name then won’t I?”

The puppy’s tail started wagging as he licked Star’s foot.

Star smiled again before Pabu ran up to the puppy, tilting his head curiously. The puppy licked Pabu, causing him to jump back.

“Well… I know just the name for you now.” Star said picking up the puppy. “Naga.”

The puppy barked before licking Star’s face.

“Seems fitting… Except for one thing.” Chrysalis said appearing at the bottom of the stairs before casting a spell.

“What are…” Star mumbled.

“Nothing.” Chrysalis said taking a seat on the couch and watching TV.

“Okay…” Star said. Star’s attention was snapped back to Fluttershy as the puppies started to chew on her hair.

“This is the best day ever!” Fluttershy said hugging all the puppies together.

“Oh yes… Fluttershy I have a present for you.” Chrysalis said motioning her over with her finger.

Fluttershy stood up and walked over.

Chrysalis placed a hand on Fluttershy’s chest. Fluttershy immediately let out a pained scream.

“Chrysalis what the hell?” Star said in a worried tone, rushing over.

Chrysalis took her hand off. There was a burn mark on Fluttershy’s chest in the shape of Chrysalis’ hand. A few moments later the mark started to move and shape into what seemed like a spider before disappearing.

“What…” Fluttershy mumbled.

“Think of it as a gift to both you and Star.” Chrysalis smiled before disappearing.

“You okay?” Star asked.

“I’m fine I guess…” Fluttershy shrugged.

“Well… I can only hope J is having as much fun as us.” Star smiled looking back at the puppies climbing over Sarah, who was laughing as they licked her.

----------------------------

J ran over to Cadence and picked her up in his arms, “I missed you so much!” He said nuzzling her affectionately.

“Oh really?” Cadence said teasingly. “How much did you miss me?”

“I’ve been feeling so alone without you nearby…” He said looking at her expectantly.

“Well that just won’t do.” Cadence smiled and placed her hand on his cheek.

J kissed her as his grip on her tightened.

Cadence moaned softly into his mouth before pulling away, “So… Why don’t we catch up a bit?” She suggested.

“I’d love that…” J said, “But today is about you… not me…” He gently rubbed her back.

“Oh I see. Well if its about me… Then you do as I say. Correct?” She asked raising an eyebrow.

“Yes… I do.” He said. “What is your first… command?”

Cadence smile increased in size as she stared at J. “Well first off… you can take me out for breakfast…” She said.

“As you wish.” He said kissing her cheek.

“So what are you feeling like?” Cadence asked. “Besides mexican.” She giggled.

J looked down at her, “How did you know about that?” He asked.

“Star keeps me up to date about the situation when I’m not around. It’s rather sweet. You two are like two peas in a pod…” She smiled.

J bit his lip and looked a little saddened, “Oh… well that’s great!” He said.

“I’m sorry… Did I say something wrong?” Cadence asked.

“No. You didn’t.” J said as he kissed her. “I’m just too worried for my own good right now.” His smile returning in full.

“Well today we relax… At least… For a little while.” She smiled coyly before giggling.

He laughed a little, “You must be really tired after that long train ride…” He said.

“More than you think. Now… What are we going to do about it?” Cadence smiled.

J smiled, “We can do a lot about it… but I feel the best thing for you now… is to rest…” He said snuggling her closer against his chest.

“Sounds good.” Cadence said softly, resting her head against his chest and closing her eyes.

“I’ll wake you up when we get there…” He said kissing her forehead. “Sleep well Caddie…”

------------------------------------

When J sat down at the table he gently rubbed Cadence’s shoulder.

“Mm… I’ve missed you too…” Cadence sighed.

“I can see that you did…” He smiled.

“Oh hi J!” Derpy waved entering the door to the diner.

“Hi Derpy.” J said looking back at her.

Cadence looked up at Derpy before sliding off J’s lap into the chair beside him.

“How’s it going?” Derpy said quickly taking a seat next to J and Cadence.

“Great!” J said wrapping an arm around the both of them pulling them both closer, “Now if you’re both going to stay it can only get better…”

Cadence smiled brightly and laid her head on his shoulder.

Derpy saw this and immediately copied, placing her head on his other shoulder. Cadence and Derpy both glared at each other.

J looked between the two of them he rubbed both their shoulders lightly, “Are you both hungry?” He asked.

“Yes… I am…” Cadence said her hand sliding slowly up his leg.

“Very.” Derpy said pulling her blouse down slightly, revealing her breasts a bit more.

J sighed. “I’ll have the breakfast special…” He said looking up at the waiter. He looked back down at the girls, “And what are you two going to be having?”

“That depends… What are you having?” Derpy asked.

“Yes… what ARE you having?” Cadence said coyly.

The two of them stared intently at J, waiting an answer.

J smirked as his hands slid further down their backs. “I don’t know girls… what am I having?” He said as he grasped their butts and squeezed a little bit.

The two let out a soft moan.

“How about… Something… Very meaty.” Derpy said, sliding her hand onto his crotch, “Maybe some sausage.”

“Not enough… How about some chicken breast…” Cadence said sliding J’s hand to her chest.

“Or maybe a nice lasagna?” Derpy asked sliding J’s other hand into her pants.

“I think I’ll get a combo plate…” J said as he squeezed Cadence’s breast and pushed a finger into Derpy. They both let out a muffled moan as they clamped their mouths shut. They both slid a hand into J’s pants and started stroking him off.

“To go if you’d please…” J said without looking up.

“But J… I’m tired remember?” Cadence smirked.

“Yeah… And I’m hungry now.” Derpy said squeezing his balls gently.

“Girls… I didn’t say we wouldn’t… I was talking to our patient waiter…” J said, “You two started this… so we’re not leaving until it’s finished…”

“Good.” Cadence said moving onto J’s lap.

Derpy shoved her off and jumped onto his lap, “Yeah, really good.” She said. Cadence grabbed her and shoved her off, repeating it. Derpy grabbed Cadence and pulled the two of them to the floor.

J smiled a little bit and pulled his pants fully off.

“He’s mine!” Derpy yelled yanking on Cadence’s hair.

“I bet you don’t even know how to kiss properly.” Cadence said angrily.

“OH really?” Derpy said pressing her lips to Cadence’s.

J smiled even more starting to stroke himself a little.

“That’s… Good.” Cadence said, her tone softening a bit but still commanding. “But more like this…” She kissed Derpy, her tongue darting into her mouth.

Derpy pulled away a few moments later, climbing on top of Cadence, “I… See…” Derpy panted lightly, kissing her again and sliding a hand under her shirt, squeezing Cadence’s breast. Cadence moaned into her mouth and placed her hands around Derpy’s head. The two of their faces were flushed bright red.

J groaned as he got up. He got over top of the two of them, “I don’t give a damn if I’m interrupting… I’m not getting left out…” He said commandingly as he pressed his dick between the two of their faces.

“Oh… Hey Cadence…” Derpy said.

“Mmhm?” Cadence mumbled.

“I think he wants a kiss too.” Derpy said as she licked the tip of J’s dick.

“I think so too…” Cadence said running her tongue across the base of his shaft.

“I’ve been waiting for this…” He moaned. “Now we can really start OUR Valentine’s Day…” He place a hand on each of their cheeks, “And what better way to spend it then with the two of you?”

Cadence’s horn lit up and forced J to the floor and onto his back. “Shut up and stay there. You’ll do as I say remember?” She said forcefully.

“Nngh… I…” J mumbled.

“I think I love you.” Derpy said as her and Cadence started making out over top of J, occasionally brushing against his dick.

J scooted back and sat up watching them carefully as he started stroking himself again.

Derpy and Cadence stood up and started stripping slowly, glancing down at J with a giggle after each ornament of clothing.

J smirked as he watched them.

After they stripped, Derpy straddled J, sliding his dick between her ass cheeks as Cadence started to lick it.

J stopped Derpy, “Ah ah ah… I didn’t get my kiss from you…” He said.

Derpy smiled, leaning down and pressing her lips to J’s, moaning at J’s throbbing member sliding between her cheeks.

J grasped her wings and slowly massaged them.

Derpy bit her lip before turning around, pressing her pussy to his face as she helped Cadence. The two of them placed his dick between their breasts, pushing theirs against each other as they took turns licking and playing with his head.

J grasped Derpy’s ass as he pushed his tongue against her pussy, he started licking and playing with her clit.

Derpy let out a loud moan that was quickly silenced by Cadence’s mouth. Her horn lit up and her magic engulfed J’s cock, massaging and squeezing it.

J moaned into Derpy, he started nibbling on her lips as his tongue continued playing with her clit.

Cadence’s eyes shot open, a tear sliding down her face. As Derpy came she bit down on Cadence’s tongue.

Derpy quickly pulled away, “I’m sorry!” She said.

“It’s okay… You didn’t mean it.” Cadence said.

Derpy placed her hands on Cadence’s cheeks before pulling her into another kiss. Cadence’s pussy had started rubbing against J’s dick as she sat up more. Derpy’s pussy had slid off J’s mouth and was grinding against J’s dick on the other side.

“Ah… this is good…” J moaned.

The two grinded harder against J, placing their hands around his dick and rubbing softly.

“J… We’re really hungry.” Derpy said looking back at J innocently.

“Pwetty pwease feed us Joe Joe Bear?” Cadence said.

His knot which had been growing slowly suddenly expanded instantly reaching full size.

“Don’t you love us J?” Derpy asked innocently.

“Come on Joeley woely… Give us all that pent up need you’ve been holding just for us.” Cadence said.

J grunted and his dick twitched violently. “Nnng… not too much… more…” He groaned.

“Joel…” Derpy and Cadence moaned, their voices intertwining as they stared back at J, their faces bright red as they panted.

J grunted one final time as he came, splattering his cum all over the them.

They both started licking the cum off each other, occasionally glancing back at J.

His dick hardened almost instantly.

A smirk returned to his face, “So… girls…” He said looking up at them.

“Yeah?” Derpy asked.

“Who’s first?” He asked the smirk never leaving his face.

“I feel bad for hurting you… You go first.” Derpy said.

“No no I started the fight earlier you go…” Cadence said.

“No… You go.” Derpy said, her tone rising in irritance.

J placed his hands under his head, his smile growing bigger.

Cadence pushed Derpy back, now having her lying on top of J as she pressed the tip of J’s dick to her entrance. She immediately kissed Derpy. Derpy’s expression changing back to relaxed as Cadence pushed J inside her.

J moaned, “Ah… I’ve been needing this for so long…” He said as he grabbed Derpy’s breasts and started playing with them, “The three of us getting together… and having a relaxing day…”

Cadence grabbed her own breasts as Derpy’s hands wandered down to her own pussy.

J kissed Derpy’s cheek and looked expectantly at Cadence.

Cadence moaned as she finally started moving her hips, taking J in and out of her.

J seemed to be content as he went back to nibbling and licking Derpy’s neck. His hands started pressing and kneading Derpy’s breasts.

Derpy moaned into Cadence’s mouth.

J started thrusting in time with Cadence’s movements causing them both to shiver and moan.

“Nnng…” J groaned, “I love the both of you so much…”

Derpy rubbed her back against J’s chest in response as she and Cadence continued making out.

Cadence’s horn lit up and she magically started massaging his entire dick.

J moaned and stared up at her lovingly.

She returned the look and started moving her hips a little faster.

Their eyes remained locked on each other for a few more moments, when they broke eye contact J thrust up violently lodging his dick in her.

Cadence yelped into Derpy’s mouth.

J’s knot flared outward violently causing Cadence to squirm on top of him.

J grunted and twisted around a little causing his knot to move around inside of Cadence.

His hot baby batter flooded into her causing her stomach to swell out slightly.

Cadence panted heavily as she was racked with multiple orgasms. Her body shook more with everyone that occurred.

J smiled and nuzzled Derpy, “Sweetie you’re next…” He whispered.

“I can’t wait…” Derpy mumbled.

As J’s knot slowly shrank he pulled out of Cadence. She slipped off to the side a blissful smile on her face.

Derpy rolled over on top of J. She placed her hands on his shoulders.

J kissed her as he thrust up into her. His dick was still covered in his hot sperm and caused her entire body to shiver in pleasure.

Derpy moaned into his mouth. “I really m… missed y… you J…” She stammered as he started bouncing her hips against his own.

“We… we… need to spend… more together…” He whispered grabbing ahold of her ass.

“Ah… yes…” Derpy moaned.

J grunted as he started massaging her ass.

She moaned loudly and began working her hips in time with his. Each time their hips met they gasped and moaned together.

Derpy shook violently as she came, her pussy tightening around J.

Cadence’s horn lit up and J suddenly felt a warmth growing in his balls. The warmth turned to pleasure as it continued to get hotter. The heat spread slowly up his shaft and stopped just under the head. Derpy let out a yelp as she started to feel it more and more each thrust.

J panted heavily and a smile formed on his face, “Ahhh…. yeah…” He moaned.

Derpy gripped him more tightly as a second orgasm rocked through her.

J started thrusting harder as he approached the beginning of his orgasm. His knot started forming and it grew in size with every thrust. He let on hand go from Derpy’s ass and he reached over and grabbed Cadence pulling her closer. His hand quickly moved to her breast and he started massaging it. “After… this… I’m going to be… really… thirsty…” He grunted.

“Why… Wait?” Cadence asked scooting closer and hovering her breasts close to his mouth.

J started sucking on it right away, his hand was still hard at work squeezing and kneading it. His thrusting into Derpy became erratic as he tried to lodge his knot in her.

Derpy was moaning loudly as she bounced on his dick.

After a few more violent thrusts his knot slammed into Derpy locking them together.

Derpy laid on J’s chest panting heavily as she began to recover her strength.

Her composure was lost after he started pumping her full. His hot cum drenching her interior. Derpy was turned instantly into a moaning and shivering mess as she reveled in the feelings tearing through her body. She collapsed forward onto him.

J let Cadence’s breast leave his mouth, “Mmm…” He mumbled looking around at the patrons and staff who were staring at them, “What?” He said loudly, “Are we not allowed to express our love however we want to now?” He groaned, “Some people have no decency anymore…”