The next day:

J groaned a little as he sat down on the couch.

“You okay? Still sore from last night?” Star asked.

“Yeah… still sore all over.” J said. “I’m guessing you didn’t have as active a Valentine’s as I did…”

“You could say that. Everyone here was too full to do anything. I’d say the breakfast lunch and dinner gift was the best idea ever!” Star smiled.

“Great… I only actually ate anything for lunch… you saw my ‘dinner’. Breakfast wasn’t any different… just a public threesome…” J said. “Though it was great. Derpy and Cadence are really getting along…”

“Well that’s good.” Star said as he started to massage J’s back. “This feel good?”

“Yeah… really good…” J sighed.

“Anything else special happen?” Star asked.

“Not really… just them fighting over me…” J said.

“That’s a first.” Star laughed rubbing a bit harder.

“Yes… it was… but it got really hot…” J said as he shifted a little bit.

“Yes I felt it last night.” Star smirked.

“No… not just that… them fighting was a really… big turn on…” J sighed. “Seeing them rolling on the ground… getting scratched up… and then going to making out… ahh it was a great time.”

“Well it sounds like you could use a day to relax.” Star said moving up to J’s shoulders.

“Aaahhhh… so good…” J moaned.

“Just let me squeeze out all your tension.” Star’s smile grew. “Pun fully intended.”

J sighed again and a smile spread across his face.

“Am I interrupti- Oh.” Luna said noticing the bulge in J’s pants as she walked into the room.

“Not at all. What’s up?” Star asked.

Luna just smiled and walked back out of the room.

“So… I didn’t get you anything for Valentines Day.” Star smiled, “It’s only right that I make up for it a bit.”

“And… how are you planning on doing… that…” J mumbled.

“However you want.” Star said as several new arms grew and massaged his shoulders and back.

“Oh… god… yes…” J moaned.

“I missed you yesterday… But I don’t plan on going anywhere, and neither are you.” Star said kissing J’s cheek.

“Not… for a while at least…” J said.

“Whenever you get hungry just say so.” Star said.

“Food… would be nice…” J said.

“Great! What would you like.” Star asked excitedly jumping up.

“Eggs… would be great.” J said.

Star ran into the kitchen, leaving J alone.

Luna peeked back into the room before quickly running over and sitting next to J, “Hello.” She said.

J smiled as he looked at her, “Hello to you too…” He said placing an arm around her. “Don’t… we have some unfinished business?”

Luna smiled coyly, “Why don’t you refresh my memory…” She said.

J pulled her in closer, “I’d love too…” He said as he kissed her.

“Mmm…” Luna moaned before pulling back slightly, “Now I’m starting to remember.”

“Maybe this will help a little too…” J said as he pulled her onto his lap. “Or… this…” He pulled her head down and pressed his lips to hers again. His tongue gently prodded her lips.

“Oh…” Luna said feeling the hard-on in his pants. “I think I’m remembering more than what actually happened.” She joked.

“I am too…” J said.

“Should the food wait?” Star asked peeking out of the kitchen with a raised eyebrow.

J looked up at Luna, “Do you want to wait a little longer?” He asked leaning up a little bit to kiss her neck.

Luna quickly put a finger to his mouth and slowly pushed him back, “Soon. But not now.” She whispered teasingly before standing up.

“I can’t wait…” J smiled. He stood up and walked into the kitchen shooting a smile back at Luna.

--------------------

“Thanks for making breakfast.” J said as he leaned back on the couch.

“Anytime. Well… Everytime.” Star smiled.

“So anything special planned for today?” J asked.

“Not really why?” Star said.

“Just wondering.” J said as he pulled Star closer.

Star smiled wider, “So… I never asked what ‘you’ wanted to do.” He said.

“Well… there are a few things.” J smiled.

“Do tell.” Star said.

J leaned in closer, “I’ve been thinking a lot about this… and I’ve finally decided…” He whispered.

“Yeah?” Star asked.

“Yes…” J said.

“J?” Star raised an eyebrow.

“Oh don’t chicken out now that I’ve said yes.” J said leaning back, “That’s just cruel.”

“I’m just surprised is all.” Star shrugged.

“Well I’m surprised… I decided on it too…” J said, “Though… I can say I’m at least a little happy about it.”

“Well… Where do you want to start?” Star asked.

“Well… that’s the thing… the only other times… it’s happened…” J said quietly.

“Let’s start with the basics… Then work our way down.” Star said gently pulling him into a kiss.

J lightly placed a hand on Star’s cheek and pushed his tongue forward into Star’s mouth.

Star’s eyes shifted, noticing Chrysalis and Cadence at the top of the stairs peeking down at them. “I think we have some guests.” Star smiled.

J bit his lip a little bit.

“We can stop if you want… Unless you don’t mind.” Star said running his hand down J’s arm, stopping once he reached the wrist and grasped J’s.

“N… no… it’s fine…” J said a little shakily.

“Hey…” Star said quickly, placing a hand on J’s cheek and slowly pulling his attention back, “Don’t look at them… Look at me.” He said kissing J again.

J closed his eyes and pushed deeper into the kiss.

Star slid his hand under J’s shirt, feeling J’s skin on his and giving off a small shiver.

J grabbed Star’s back and held him tightly, “When… we do get there… nothing… beyond normal… not yet… at least…” He said quietly.

“Of course… I wouldn’t ever think of hurting you… Or doing anything you wouldn’t want me to do.” Star said softly.

J smiled a little bit more, “I… just wanted to make sure.” He said kissing Star again, “I love you Star…”

“I love you too Joel.” Star whispered before resting his head on J’s shoulder, bathing in his embrace.

J smiled, “All this clothing…” He whispered, “It’s too constricting…”

“And what are you going to do about it?” Star asked rhetorically.

J reached under Star’s shirt, “The question isn’t about you… or me… it’s about us… What are we going to do about it?” He said.

Star stood up and faced J, slowly taking his own shirt off to reveal his sculpted abs. He threw his shirt on J’s head before taking off his pants.

J grabbed the shirt and took a deep breath in through his nose, inhaling the smell, “Mmmm…” He mumbled.

Star tossed his pants to the side, his dick already poking out from the top of his underwear. “I think I’m going to need a little help with the last part…” He smiled.

J threw Star’s shirt to the side, “I’m happy to help…” He said as he stood up and pushed Star back onto the couch.

Star waited patiently, his heart increasing in pace as J approached.

J got on his knees in front of Star. He smiled as he slowly pulled down Star’s underwear.

There was a noise in the kitchen. J and Star looked in it’s direction to see Fluttershy and Twilight bolt around the corner, occasionally peeking out at the two.

J’s eyes darted up and he seemed to get a little more nervous.

“J relax… We’re all friends here. Who cares if we give them a little show?” Star smiled, trying to reassure him.

“Y...yeah… j… just some bad memories… with… other watching…” J mumbled quietly as he focused on Star again. He slid Star’s underwear the rest of the way off. His hand slowly wrapped around Star’s dick.

Star’s eyes were fixed on J as he felt pleasure begin to radiate through him, “Do… Whatever’s comfortable.” He said.

J started stroking Star’s dick, his other hand grasping his balls.

Star’s arm started to lose its consistency, melting slowly before Star snapped back his attention and reformed it.

J smiled a little bit, a small blush became noticeable on his face. “Oh… you like it that much? I haven’t even truly started yet…” He said with a small chuckle.

Star panted softly, leaning back against the couch as the slightest bit of sweat formed around his face.

J moved both his hands to Star’s dick, one rolling the tip against his palm, while the other massaged the shaft. J moved his face closer and breathed in the scent around Star’s dick, his hot breath rushing over the shaft.

“You haven’t even started and… Look what you’re doing to me…” Star moaned softly as more sweat seeped down his face, occasionally having to reform a limb or two.

J leaned closer and rubbed Star’s dick with his face, giving him a teasing lick against the head.

Star grunted, gripping the side of the couch tightly.

J smiled a little more as he licked Star again this time slowly winding his tongue around Star’s dick. He slowly pulled his tongue back unwinding it from Star’s shaft. He then slowly pulled Star’s dick into his mouth. Both his hands moved down to Star’s balls and started massaging them.

Star’s dick twitched and his mouth dropped open a little, “Joel…” He mumbled.

J looked up a smile spreading across his face. He slowly moved his head down sliding Star’s length into his throat. J’s tongue circling around it the entire time.

Star reached his arms down and placed his hands on J’s shoulders, gripping them and started to massage them.

J moaned slightly. He closed his eyes and started bobbing his head up and down.

“J I’m…” Star grunted, his dick beginning to twitch violently.

J grasped Star’s knot and gently pressured it. He looked up at Star and smiled widely as he moved a little faster.

Star’s head slammed back against the couch before his pleasure peaked, sending a torrent of his seed from his dick.

J’s eyes shut tightly as he started gulping it down.

Star groaned, putting his hands on the back of J’s head and forcing his entire length down his throat.

“Holy shit…” Dash whispered.

“Shut it.” Twilight whispered, elbowing Dash before the two shot back into the kitchen.

J looked up before gulping even more down.

A few more moments passed before relaxing, his arms falling back to his side. “Sorry…” Star said.

J pulled back and coughed out a little bit of cum, “No worries…” He said, “I enjoy doing that too…”

“I think it’s your turn now.” Star grinned. His horn lit up and flashed as J’s clothes disintegrated. “Woops…”

“Well that’s not to much of a problem… they were getting really uncomfortable…” J said with a smile.

“What next?” Star asked.

“Well now it’s up to you…” J said.

“I see… Well don’t let me stop you if you have any ideas…” Star said turning over and shaking his ass slowly in front of J, “Any ideas at all.” He smiled.

J smiled a little bit. He got up behind Star. “Well if you insist…” He whispered as he rubbed his dick against Star’s ass.

“I have no idea what you’re talking about.” Star said sarcastically and pushed his ass back against the tip of J’s dick, “I didn’t say anything.”

J pressed a little bit into Star’s ass, “Oh… god…” He grunted. “Not… expecting this…” He panted onto Star’s neck as he pushed two more inches into him. “How… how are you doing?”

“Gr...Great… Keep going.” Star said in a half strained tone.

J pushed another inch in. “G… God…” He mumbled, “A… at this rate… I won’t… be able to… last… too long…”

“Just… A bit further…” Star moaned.

J pushed even more in and moaned loudly, “So… tight…” He said.

“All for… You… Joel.” Star smiled, glancing back up at J, Star’s face bright red. “Nngh… Shit…” He grunted, pressing his face into the couch as he came again, his orgasm splashin the floor under them. “I love you… So much…”

J leaned closer and wrapped his arms around Star’s stomach, “I… can’t… even begin to tell you… just… how much… I love you…” He moaned.

“Pu… Push it all in… I want you…” Star begged as J’s body bent forward. Star reached back and placed a hand on J’s cheek, both their faces nearly side by side.

J thrust in hilting himself fully inside of Star.

“Nngod!” Star sputtered, slamming his face hard into the seat of the couch. “Gh… Fuck…”

“Oh… fuuu…” J groaned, “Nnng… going… to start… moving… soon…”

The inside of Star’s ass started to get slick, lubricating J’s dick. “There…” Star sighed.

J kissed Star’s cheek, “Here… I go…” He grunted as he started to pull out.

Star nodded, biting his lip slightly as he stared back at him.

J placed a hand on Star’s cheek and kissed him as he thrust back in.

Star slowly ground his hips in circles, pushing his tongue into J’s mouth this time.

J started pistoning his hips slowly. He wrapped his tongue around Star’s and played with it. He moaned into Star’s mouth.

“Faster… I want ‘you’... Show me what you got…” Star smirked.

“Nnng…” J groaned as he slammed forward into Star.

“Fuck… That’s better…” Star moaned.

J picked up in speed shaking them both a little bit with every thrust. He grasped at Star’s chest holding on tightly.

Star panted faster, tightening his ass around J.

“Ho…” J grunted as he started thrusting harder into Star. “N… not… m… much longer…” He moaned.

Star moved his hips faster, “Don’t you dare… Stop… Until… You’re done.” He laughed weakly.

“I… wouldn’t… dream… of stopping…” J panted. He started thrusting harder and faster as he kept going.

Star tightened even more. His horn lit up and an aura flowed around J’s balls, kneading them gently.

J’s panting got heavier as he got closer to cumming, “N… not… much… more…” He moaned. “Just… a… little… l… longer…”

Star’s eyes snapped shut as he came a second time, pooling more of his semen onto the floor.

J’s dick twitched deep inside of Star as he came, flooding Star’s ass with his hot cum.

“I… So warm…” Star mumbled, drooling a little onto the couch as it seeped onto the floor, mixing with his own cum.

“Holy shit…” Twilight mumbled.

“Shut up.” Dash said elbowing Twilight.

“Hell- Oh my…” Rarity said walking in through the front door.

“Morning… I think… What time is it?” Star asked groggily.

“Wow…” Applejack mumbled.

“Good to know… We’re not the only ones enjoying this eh J?” Star joked.

J had slid off to the side and drool slid down his face. He was panting heavily and a large blissful smile ran across his face.

Ethan peeked in through the door and stared wide eyed at them before blushing brightly.

“Hey Ethan… How’s… Your day been?” Star grunted slightly as he shifted around to a more comfortable spot.

“G… good…” Ethan said quietly.

“That’s good… I’m Ha- Oh god…” Star grunted, pressing his face back into the couch as he hit a third orgasm, “So… Fuck…” The cum pooling on the floor reached Ethan’s feet.

“Oh… god… felt… so good…” J muttered coming down slowly from his blissful haze.

Star pulled J out and stood up, wobbling slightly before catching himself on the edge of the couch. J’s cum leaked from his ass as he tried to catch his breath.

“Where… where do you think your going?” J questioned looking up at Star.

“W...Wherever… You want me… To go.” Star stopped falling onto the couch and reclining back, “And where… Do YOU want to go?” He smiled as his dick began to re-harden.

“You know where… this was more for you… then for me…” J said. He bit his lip a little bit as he slowly glanced around the room at everyone who was watching.

“Don’t let us stop you…” Dash said quietly, still half-disbelieving what she was seeing.

“We could um… Leave if you want.” Cadence said glancing over at Luna.

“When did you two get here?” Star questioned.

J looked back down at the ground seeming a little scared.

“Joel… You know I love you. We don’t have to do this.” Star said, extending his leg and poking J with his foot.

“N… no… I want to…” He said quietly.

“Well… There’s no rush. Take your time.” Star said with a reassuring smile.

J looked up at Star, “J… just take it slow alright?” He said quietly.

Star nodded, sitting up on the couch and waiting.

J slowly propped himself up on the couch his ass sticking out, “Go… ahead…” He said.

Star shook his head, staying in his sitting position, “If we’re doing this… I want to see you.” He said motioning J to straddle him.

J nodded a small smile crossing his face. “You know… I wanted to too…” He said as he got on Star’s lap.

Star’s dick slid between J’s ass cheeks. Star reached up and pulled J forward into a kiss.

J leaned in and opened up for the kiss.

Star’s dick poked at the entrance to J’s ass, “You ready?” He asked softly.

J nodded, “Yeah…” He said.

The first bit of Star’s dick slid into J easily as the outside of it began to produce a slick liquid. Star pressed J’s lips to his immediately.

J’s eyes shut tightly and his entire body shivered. Pre started leaking out of J’s dick in torrents.

Star’s hands went down to J’s dick and started to stroke it as he pushed more of himself inside. Two more arms grew out and began to massage J’s shoulders again. “Is… This okay?” Star asked.

J nodded. “Y… yeah…” He panted, “So… much… of… you… oh… god…”

“You… Feel so good Joel… H… Here I go.” Star said and started to thrust slowly.

J gritted his teeth together for a few seconds before letting out a low moan. “Yes…” He grunted, “L… like that…” He wrapped his arms around Star and squeezed him tightly.

Star’s hot breath escaped onto J’s neck with every pant, now starting to jerk off J a little faster.

J moaned a little louder, “Ah… th… the double… tr… treatment…” He stammered jokingly.

“Only the best… For the… Best…” Star smiled pressing his face into J’s neck.

“W… with that sort of… t… talk… you’re… making me… want to… transform… j… just s… so I… can give… you s… something… s… special…” J moaned.

“In a… Bit… Right now I just… I want to see you… The friend I grew up with… And loved… And still love…” Star said as a few tears slid down his face and onto J’s shoulder, “I love you…”

“I… love you too Star… a… and I always… have… and… always will…” J said as he hugged Star more tightly, “A… and… I… I wouldn’t… g… give this up… for… anything… I… wouldn’t give… you up… for anything...”

“Don’t… Don’t ever leave me Joel… Please…” Star said gripping J tighter.

“W… why was… that never… guaranteed?” J asked as he started crying a little.

Star’s thrusts sped up as he gripped J’s dick tighter.

J’s pants grew hotter, “C… close…” He mumbled.

Star’s knot began to swell. He gripped J’s balls and squeezed before his magic engulfed J’s shaft and started massaging it.

J screamed as he came spraying both of them in his cum, his grip on Star never loosening.

Star immediately pushed his knot into J, quickly silencing him with a kiss.

J shivered even more on top of Star as he pushed the kiss deeper.

Star moaned into J’s mouth, his nails digging into J’s shoulders as his cum flooded into him.

J moaned into Star’s mouth, his face turned a bright red.

The two of them pulled away, panting heavily. Star smiled, “H...Hi…” He chuckled.

“So… fucking… hot…” J moaned.

Star looked down at his dick, still pumping J full, “I could say the same… Thing.” He panted. “I still have a… Lot more left… I can pull out if you want…”

“E… either way… the floors getting stained…” J joked.

Star laughed, resting his head on J’s chest.

“Hey… I’m… supposed to be doing that…” J said with a smile.

“Wait your turn.” Star smiled and closed his eyes, drifting to sleep.