Mistress Do Well: Fractured Elements
by milesprower06

Indecision

Rainbow began to stir, and rolled onto her back with a stretch. She opened her eyes, and noticed that she was not in the library. Tilting her head to the right, she saw she was laying on a mattress, and the cinder block wall five feet away immediately felt familiar.

Rarity's basement.

Rainbow shot to her hooves, eyes still acclimating to the dark. Panic turned to confusion when she realized she wasn't restrained in any way. Then she heard the rattling of chains. She pinpointed the sound to the back wall, but couldn't see anything due to the darkness. As she squinted to try and make out the source of the noise, a single light on the ceiling came on, and shone down on the captive chained to the wall.

"Twilight?" Rainbow asked, confused, getting off of the mattress and walking over to her.

"What's going on here?"

"We're waiting for you to decide." Twilight answered. Her eyes were hidden by a blindfold, a magic limiter, or 'sap cap', had been fastened to the tip of her horn, and a bridle was strapped around her head.

"We?"

"Yeah, the two ponies whom you can't decide if you love."

This new voice came from behind. Rainbow Dash whipped her head around, and from the darkness, walked in another Twilight; this one clad in black leather. In the purple aura of her magical grasp was a quill, parchment, and whip.

"M-Mistress..." the chained, captive, submissive Twilight greeted nervously.

Her greeting was replied to with a lash from the whip on her right thigh. She cried out in pain.

"Stop it!" Rainbow said, charging at the leather-clad alicorn. With a flash, she simply winked out and reappeared out of Rainbow's path, giving her a smirk.

"N-not until you decide..." the captive Twilight whimpered.

"Decide what?"

"If you love me or not..."

"I... I don't know!"

'Mistress' Twilight turned to Rainbow, and lashed out with the whip, the tip cracking the ground inches in front of her hooves, causing Rainbow to jump back in fear. Twilight winked out again, reappearing directly in the pegasus' face.

"Exactly. You don't know because you're afraid."

A piercing gun appeared in Twilight's magical grip, which she waved in front of Rainbow's face.

"More than that, you're terrified that you might love one of the ponies that tortured you."

"But also the pony that freed you," submissive Twilight finished.

Without warning, Mistress Twilight turned her attention back to her slave, stuck the gun in her nostrils, and pulled the trigger.

Submissive Twilight screamed in pain, as her Mistress removed the gun, and fit a steel ring to the piercing.

"Stop hurting her!!" Rainbow yelled, trying to catch her off guard as she was focused on finishing fastening the nose ring, but Mistress Twilight once again winked out and back, away from Rainbow's tackle.

"Silly Dashie, we're one and the same. I'm not hurting her, you are."

She lashed out with the whip again, catching her slave on the opposite thigh, getting a yelp in response.

"This is in your head; you want to do to her what she did to you."

"No, never!" Rainbow objected.

"Join me Dash, Mistress loves me... She can love you too."

"But she's already joined me. Your place is as Twilight's mistress, and you've been an excellent one so far. You're torturing her; living with her, sleeping across from her, teasing her, but never committing. She doesn't deserve you, she is boring without you and you have to remind her of that."

"She loves me, I don't have to worry or take care of myself, Mistress rewards my good behavior. We love each other. Please love me, Mistress."

"Look at her groveling, begging. She has no right to love you. You need to punish her, make her beg you for the privilege of licking your hooves clean."

"I want to clean Mistress' hooves, I want to prove I love her every way I can."

Mistress Twilight lashed out with the whip again, her angle much higher on this swing, and it cracked across Twilight's right cheek, and she let out another scream. Rainbow wanted to charge at her again, but stayed her hooves, knowing she would wink out again.

"Stop! Please!" she begged instead.

"She is nothing but an object to serve you, to take out your anger on or sate your lust by eating out your throbbing slit."

"The... The pain reminds me how lucky I am to have my Mistress..." the slave Twilight whimpered, shuddering, a bruise starting to form on her cheek.

Rainbow stared helplessly at her friend hanging on the wall from chains. She felt magic grip her front right hoof as it was lifted off the ground, and the whip was placed in it.

"Go on. You know you want to. Make her love you. Show her how lucky she is that you're even considering forgiving her. Remind her what she did."

"Please... I've been naughty. I did horrible things and you need to punish me so I know you love me and want to fix me."

"Make her bleed and grovel, force her to apologize until her throat is too hoarse to spell. Only then, will you make her jam her muzzle in your marehood like a good slave and eat you out."

Rainbow's hooof trembled. She somehow knew that Twilight's eyes were pleading through the blindfold as she squirmed in the chains... She did want it. Mistress Twilight came to her side.

"Remember the first night you came back?" she began, whispering in her ear. "You pretty much raped her. You made her yours...and she loved it."

"Yes, it feels so good to have a pony take charge, and give me exactly what I deserve..."

"Your slave is begging for her punishment. It's how she knows you love her. Are you going to give it to her?"

"No," Dash protested. "I don't want to hurt her."

"Please... Do it for me."

"Why would you want me to hurt you?"

"To show me you love me."

"That doesn't make any sense! I'm better than her! I'm better than Rarity!"

"Then why are you still holding the whip?" Mistress Twilight asked.

She looked down, and discovered that she had not immediately dropped the whip when it was handed to her.

"Here, perhaps you need some help."

Rainbow felt her grip on the whip tighten as it was surrounded by Twilight's magical grasp. Her muscles acting against her will, she raised the whip up, and brought it down, the end cracking down on submissive Twilight's stomach, and she responded with a cry.

"Stop!" Dash protested, her foreleg rearing back again, and striking the whip again lower down Twilight's stomach, inching closer against her moist marehood.

"Stop it!" she pleaded. She brought it back one last time, and swung it out even harder, and time, caught Twilight right on her swollen clit.

"STOP!!!" she screamed, but couldn't hear herself over the shriek of pain that Twilight gave out.

"STOP!!!" Rainbow screamed, shooting up from a laying position, taking in a gasping breath as she realized the location had changed again. She was half underneath a twin bed comforter.

"Rainbow, are you alright?" she heard Twilight ask. She looked over to her, sitting on the edge of her bed in the library, having tried to wake her. "You were thrashing about pretty bad there."

Dash felt an increasing pressure in her stomach, and she threw herself at the alicorn, wrapping her forelegs around her as she burst into tears. Twilight returned the embrace.

"Please... I don't want to hurt you... I won't hurt you..." she whimpered through her sobs.

"You haven't hurt me at all. It was just a nightmare."

Twilight tried to soothe Rainbow by continuing to hug her and rub her back as she cried it out. After a few minutes, she figured something to drink would help.

"Wait here, I'll be right back."

She went downstairs to the kitchen and quickly brewed up some tea. Returning upstairs, she offered the lightly steaming cup to her roommate, who sniffled, and accepted it with her two front hooves.

"I'm sorry, Twilight," she said, taking a sip of the hot, honey-flavored drink.

"Rainbow, you have nothing to be sorry for, alright?"

"I do..." the pegasus answered, taking another drink. "I never should have encouraged you to drink with me and AJ last night. I never should have written that letter to you before I left. I was so hurt, so angry... I wasn't thinking clearly."

"Justifiably so."

"Still... I could have just left that one letter for all of you. But no, I had to do another one just for you, rejecting you... And you still waited here for me for a year, when everypony else left."

Twilight didn't reply to this, not entirely sure how to respond.

"You had a point last night, after you kicked AJ out... I told you we should take it one day at a time, and we haven't been. It's been a standstill. I'm sorry. I guess I was just stalling while I figured out if I really wanted..."

Rainbow took another sip of tea while she searched for the right words.

"I want to return your affection, Twilight. But... My heart just won't let me. Something is missing, some piece to all this isn't here, and I have to find out what it is."

Twilight slid closer to Rainbow as she sipped at her tea.

"Rainbow, the cider got the better of my tongue last night. Do you know how grateful I am that you came back? The fact that you're here, living with me is more than enough for now, and certainly more than I deserve. Don't let my short bouts of impatience convince you otherwise, okay? So you take as long as you need, to find out what you need to do to bury this. I promise I'll wait for as long as it takes."

Rainbow nodded, and took another sip. Halfway through her drink, her ears perked up, as she came to a realization.

"That's it. That's it! That's what I need to do!" she exclaimed to herself quietly.

"What...?" Twilight asked, noticing the metaphorical light bulb had come on above Rainbow's head.

"Can I get a quill, ink, and parchment? I need to write a letter to the Princess."

"Alright, but Spike isn't here, so..."

"We'll send it by Royal Air in the morning, I've got the bits."

Twilight walked over to her desk while Rainbow made herself comfortable on the floor. She returned with a roll of parchment, a quill, ink, and a lit candlestick for her to work by. As Rainbow began to write the letter, Twilight went to get the teapot, and set it gently down next to her cup. Wanting to respect Rainbow's privacy, she returned to bed, letting Rainbow write in peace, wondering what it was that she was going to try next.