Fluttershy’s mind was flooding with horrific thoughts of how he could make her torture any worse. She thought she could deal with pretty much anything as long as he could just finish her aching vagina. She stared at him intently when he returned. She then looked down at what he was holding, a mirror. She had no idea what it could be for.

He placed the mirror in front of her so she was looking at herself. Her flanks were blushed red from all the smacking he had done. Her face was surprisingly only a bit bruised up. She thought her face would be a mess.

“Aren’t you just the cutest little thing, Fluttershy?”

The pony stared at her in the mirror for a few long moments, waiting for her response.

“Oh right, permission to speak.” he added.

Fluttershy wasn't sure what he wanted her to say.

“I... I guess so,” she squeaked. That little squeak, made the pony’s cock come to attention again. Fluttershy stared at it and noticed she was drooling, she wanted it so bad.

“Oh Fluttershy,” he laughed. “You’re the cutest thing I have ever seen, that’s why I did all this”.

“Are... Are... you ever going to let me go?” she whispered. Her voice was trembling even worse.

“Not likely, Fluttershy.” He shook his head. “You are going to be my property forever. I own you”.

“You can’t just take a pony as your property!” She said a bit louder and with some of her rarely seen anger.

“Well that’s obviously wrong, because I just did.” he said while grinning.

Fluttershy’s head sank down, but didn’t go far before the spikes on the collar caught her neck. A terrifying thought crossed her mind. She was ashamed of how selfish she was being. She suddenly squealed loud.

“My animals! Oh please, what will happen to all my animals!” She started breathing heavily until she saw him give her a sympathetic smile and patted her lightly on the head.

“Don’t worry Fluttershy, I love animals too. I’ll take care of them”. He continued to explain. “That’s another thing I love about you Flutters. I may even let them visit you, if you’re good. I may even let you have some room to move if you are extra good,”

Fluttershy felt relieved for her animals. Without thinking she said something that surprised her.

“Thank you,”

Fluttershy immediately felt sick, she actually thanked a pony that kidnapped, hit and raped her. Then to make it worse he tormented her for hours by making her drink an aphrodisiac and getting her close to climax, but kept refusing to finish her off. This pony didn’t deserve her thanks.

The pony smiled, “Awww, now that’s being a good pony. I think you deserve a reward”.

Fluttershy’s eyes opened wide.

“Oh ye... yes, please can you please let me cum,”she gasped desperately.

The pony nodded. “I think I can allow that, but next time you don’t do as you are told, it will last twice as long.” He kept talking and Fluttershy was getting impatient.

“There is just more thing I want to do to you first.”

If Fluttershy could have moved her legs she would have stomped in frustration. The pony went behind her and finally touched her slit with his tongue again, but then moved away to speak again.

“By the way, you are not allowed to close your eyes; I want you to watch yourself enjoying this, that’s what the mirror is for.”

Fluttershy looked at the disgusted expression that appeared on her face, as she realized that she didn’t want to know what her face looked like, it made her feel embarrassed at herself.

The pony teased her slit again, this time going a bit harder on her clit. Fluttershy saw her face make some expressions that she had to admit made her look adorable, it made her look happy. She didn’t like that she was having fun.

After he ravaged her vagina, getting Fluttershy really close again, he moved his muzzle away from her. ‘not again.’ Fluttershy thought angrily. But then she felt him put his hooves on her flanks and brought his rock hard cock up behind her. She saw herself smile in the mirror. Her face started perspiring and the pony was very happy he could see her face in the mirror; he was not planning on closing his eyes either. He lined up behind her and got ready to penetrate.

He thrusted as hard and fast as he could the first time, making Fluttershy “eeep!” in surprise. He broke right through her hymen roughly and filled her up with his entire ten inch cock in one fell swoop, making his balls slap loudly against her arse. He felt her vaginal wall welcoming him and hugging his cock tightly and blood started pouring out of her vagina and dripping on the floor. He saw her face as she experienced both pain and pleasure at the same time.

She had a puzzled look that showed she wasn’t sure if she liked what she was feeling. But as he pulled back to the tip of his cock and slammed into her again and again and again, the pain started subsiding and now it was just pure pleasure for her. He tried to go as hard as he could; he wanted to be as rough as physically possible. Fluttershy’s mouth was now wide open and was drooling; with each pump from behind her, she made a little adorable squeak, like she was a rubber duck.

Fluttershy’s vagina held his cock tightly and it was getting harder to pull out. It felt great; all he could think about was how his penis never wanted to leave its warm new home, that it had ached for as ever since he first saw Fluttershy singing an amazing song while playing with her animals.

His pace slowed down a bit as his initial burst of energy started running out. His testicles were starting to hurt from how hard they were slapping against her ass. He started shouting out loud. Each time he pumped into her he shouted a new word.

“Ahhhh! fuck! yes! you! naughty! little! filly! I! fucking! love! you! so! much!"

Fluttershy finally came, she felt something spray out of her vagina like a sprinkler and she felt her canal convulsing and squeezing hard on the cock that was inside her. She screamed louder than she ever had in her life and she saw her eyes and mouth open as wide as they could, as she felt the most amazing feeling she had ever experienced in her life between her legs.

When Fluttershy came the pony’s cock felt her vagina convulse around it and squeeze it as hard as it could. This sent him over the edge he felt what seemed like the largest load he ever shot go inside her. Her vagina held him there as it tried to pull every tiny drop of semen out of him and then her walls relaxed. All the while he watched the mirror as Fluttershy made the cutest face he had ever seen.

He collapsed on her and just stayed there. He didn’t want to leave her, but his cock shrunk and popped out. In relief Fluttershy closed her eyes and let her head drop. Getting her neck poked again by the spiked collar. She realized her neck now had blood trickling down.

“Thank you so much!” Fluttershy said with a big smile. Then it turned upside down, because she just thanked her kidnapper again.

“See Fluttershy, life will be good as my slave, as long as you behave you will get to feel that very very often.”

The pony grinned at her in the mirror and saw her frown about the prospect. “Don’t lie to yourself Fluttershy, I know you enjoyed yourself”.

He then put his muzzle down to her vagina to lick up the liquid that was leaking out of her. Fluttershy closed her eyes in anticipation. She actually already wanted to do it again. He moved away after he cleaned her out as best he could.

“Now,” he said with a tone as if he was conducting business. “Since we are now so well acquainted, I should introduce myself. I would like us to be friends as well as master and slave, if that’s okay with you.”

Fluttershy knew she didn’t have a choice so she just tried starting idle conversation.

“Who are you?” she asked.

“I guess I’ll start with my name,” he started cheerfully.