James woke up in the morning to see Fiddlesticks smiling at him. He couldn’t help but smile back as he leaned in to give her a kiss. She met him halfway as their lips met. He caressed her cheek as they deepened the kiss. They broke the kiss off, still connected by a string of saliva. He got out of bed and picked up the mare. She was surprised by the reaction, but when she saw him smiling down at her, she calmed down. He carried her to the bathroom so they could get cleaned.

Fiddlesticks sat on the bench as he ran his hands over her body. She couldn’t help but moan as he explored her body. As his hands roamed her body she started to tease him with her tail. She enjoyed the grunts that he made as he tried to keep himself under control. He lathered the shampoo in her mane as she hummed happily. He couldn’t help the smile that grew on his face as he tended to the country mare. She was capable of taking care of herself but was nervous when it came to simple things like love.

He felt happy that she was happy with the choice that she made. He finished washing her off and now it was his turn. She still couldn’t help but blush as she washed him. As she washed the human, he gave her tiny kisses on her cheeks and lips. She met every kiss with enthusiasm as she tried to deepen it. They washed their bodies off and then exited the shower. He handed her a towel as he headed into his room. The country mare dried herself off and then entered his room.

He had her clothes ready when she entered. She smiled as she dressed in her comfortable country attire. She picked up her hat and looked at it for a few seconds. She walked up to him and placed the hat on his head. He tried to give her the hat back, but she insisted that he keep it. He gave her one final kiss as he looked out his bedroom door. The coast was clear so he led her to the front door. She gave him a hug as she walked down the path, heading back to her cousin’s farm.

He took a big breath as he grabbed a piece of paper and started writing a note. He put all the mares’ names on it as he walked out of the house. The note stated that he was headed to Canterlot for a bit to get some fresh air. He walked to the train station and boarded the train. He fell asleep on the train as it headed for Canterlot. He was at his destination and started walking around the city. He came across a jewelry store that he hadn’t seen before. He entered the building, intrigued what he might find.

House

The mares waited as they watched the human leave the house. They went to the window to see when he was out of sight. When they couldn’t see him anymore, Spitfire nodded to the others and they headed out. She got all the mares together early in the morning to talk about what happened. The mares were a little less than happy to hear what he did. They agreed that when he would step out they would gather the five mares and have a talk with them. Spitfire sat in a swivel chair that she bought for any occasion that required one. The mares returned with the five mares and she turned in the chair to face them.

She got out of her chair and started walking around the five mares. The mares stared at her as she walked around them. They had no idea what was going on and they were scared out of their mind. Flitter and Cloudchaser were taken from their home by Rainbow Dash and Lightning Dust. Daisy and Lily were put under a quick sleep spell by Vinyl and Lyra. Fiddlesticks was grabbed from the road by Octavia and Pinkie Pie. They could see that the pegasus was angry so they kept their silence, waiting for her to speak.

“Care to explain why you five had sex with our stallion?” Spitfire asked as she leered over them.

The pegasus was steadily getting angrier and her flames were starting to show. Trixie saw that she was starting to get heated so she went to the kitchen. She came out of the kitchen with a fire extinguisher. She looked at Twilight who nodded her head. The azure unicorn pulled the pin and then aimed the nozzle at Spitfire. She squeezed the handle and sprayed her with the cold foam.

Spitfire turned and stared at Trixie, waiting for her to explain why she did that. She made gestures saying that she was getting heated and they didn’t want the house to burn down. The pegasus left the room so she could wipe herself off and change her clothes. She returned and gestured for the mares to explain themselves.

“We had intentions at first to just show that we were sorry for what happened. As we spent time with him we started getting some feelings. We saw how he loved you and we wanted some of that love. We all felt terrible that we tried to hurt him and all of you. He showed us such kindness that we wanted to have it always,” Flitter explained as tears formed in all their eyes.

Rose, Aloe, and Lotus felt bad for the mares. They too were in the same position that they were in. That didn’t still do much for the little amount of anger that they felt towards them. Spitfire walked up to them and continued to stare them down. The mares shrank back trying to hide from her gaze. Before anything else could be said, the human came in through the front door. The mares all looked towards him as he carried something in his hand.

Canterlot

James walked around the jewelry store, impressed with some of the jewels. He was about to leave when he spotted this sparkling prism diamond. He walked up to it and looked it over with interest. He picked the prism up and it quickly flashed. He looked around to see if anything changed and nothing did. He walked up to the front counter to pay for the prism. He rang the bell and waited for the store clerk. The clerk showed up and saw what the human had in his hands.

“Beware, strange man, for that prism has untold powers,” the store clerk warned James.

“Trust me when I say that if it does then I am more than willing to face the consequences,” James told the store clerk.

“Are you the one known as James? The human that saved Canterlot,” the clerk asked as she eyed him up and down.

“Well, I am the only human here in Equestria so, yes I was,” James answered as he smiled at the store clerk.

The mare nodded as she took the prism and put it in a bag. He paid for the prism and left the store. He pulled the prism out of the bag and stared at it. If anything, Rarity probably would like the prism since it is shiny and looks rare. He boarded the train and headed back for Ponyville.

House

He showed the mares the prism and they looked at it with intrigue. Rarity was staring at it completely filled with interest. He asked if she would like to have it and she quickly answered yes. He tossed the prism to the unicorn who had a tiny heart attack. She dove through the air as she caught the diamond prism. She got up from the ground and stared angrily at him. He rubbed the back of his head as he chuckled a little. She looked at the prism and smiled at its brilliance.

The prism started to glow and she got very scared. She panicked and did the only thing that she thought was a good idea at the moment. She tossed the prism over to Twilight. Twilight tossed it to Rainbow who tossed it to Trixie. Trixie held it for a second before tossing it to Aloe. Aloe shoved the prism in Lotus’ face as she stepped far away. The mares tossed the prism back and forth for a couple minutes until James caught it.

He smiled at the mares as he held the prism. The prism then released a bright flash as it sucked him inside of it. The prism floated in the air for a few seconds as the mares stared at it in confusion. There was another flash of light and five beams of light shot out. The prism fell to the ground and broke into five different shards. That isn’t what caught the attention of the mares though. They stared at the five different James’ in front of them.

One James had blue hair and eyes. His clothing was all blue and he wore a cloak. The James next to him had pink eyes and hair. His clothing was all pink and was covered in smiles. The James next to him had green eyes and hair. His clothing was green and he wore some type of futuristic armor and for some reason he had wings on his back. The James next to him had purple eyes and hair. His clothing was purple and it looked like clothes that a demon hunter would wear. The James next to him had orange eyes and hair. His clothing was orange and his eyes were also crossed. He wasn’t standing for long as he fell to the ground asleep.

Once that James was asleep all the other James’ scattered out of the house and ran in every direction. The mares watched in confusion at what happened and then they were filled with worry as they thought that they lost James. The mares quickly got their wits about them and tried to come up with a plan. As they talked, Twilight looked over the prism shard. She looked over at the sleeping James and walked over to him. She poked him a few times but he didn’t stir. She decided to try it the James way and go for it. She touched the lazy James with the shard and he was sucked back into it.

The mares saw this and nodded in understanding at what they needed to do. It was a long shot but if they could capture the other James’ and then bring the pieces together they might be able to get him. The mares split into teams with a mare that was similar to the other James so he would be easy to capture. The team to capture timid James would be Fluttershy as the leader with Rarity, Aloe, and Lotus. The team to capture happy James would be Pinkie Pie as leader with Octavia, Vinyl, and Lyra.

The team that would capture brash James would be Spitfire as leader with Lightning Dust and Rainbow Dash. The team that would capture smart James would be Twilight as leader with Trixie and Rose as her backup. The mares were getting ready to leave when Lightning stopped Spitfire.

“What are we supposed to do with these other mares?” Lightning asked as she stared at the mares.

“You five are coming with us until we decide what to do with you later. Flitter you are going with Fluttershy’s team. Lily and Daisy, you are going with Pinkie’s team. Fiddlesticks you are going with Twilight, Rose, and their partner. Cloudchaer you are with my team,” the mares nodded as they got up and followed the mares outside.

The mares all split up as they chased after the individual James that they were assigned. The other mares sighed as they followed the mares to capture James. They were worried with what would happen to them, but that was pushed aside as they worried for James. The mares nodded to each other as they were going to try and prove themselves that they weren’t a danger to him.

Author's Notes:

Thanks to ErikTheSoulReaper for the help on this chapter. These chapters were made to be this short. They are still canon to my story but it's like this to help set up the part that is going to happen next after these five short parts.