James woke up on the couch in a bit of pain. He got up from the couch and started stretching and popping his bones into place. James headed his room for a needed shower since he was covered in cheese powder from the cheese puffs. It felt like home to him all over again. He got in the shower and let the water run over him. James looked at the symbols on his hands. Now that his magic was out in the open there was no point hiding them. James got out of the shower and dried himself off. He got dressed and headed for the kitchen to grab some orange juice.

The mares woke up in the huge bed and saw their clothes on the dresser. Fiddlesticks was quick to change out of her sleeping clothes. The others couldn’t help but laugh at the way Fiddlesticks was flustered. She shot them a glare but the just continued to laugh. The mares got dressed and headed for the kitchen to see if James was up yet. They reached the kitchen and saw that James was grabbing himself a glass of orange juice. They don’t know why but they hid behind a corner so he wouldn’t see them.

They thought back to the conversation that they had last night. They looked at each other and nodded their heads. Cloudchaser and Flitter would be the first to ask James out for a night dinner. James startled them when he came out of the kitchen and said hello to them. They turned around and saw that James was smiling at them. They said good morning and then went into the kitchen to get something to drink. Cloudchaser and Flitter were pushed out so they could speak with James. James could see they had something to say and waited for them to speak.

“James if it isn’t too much trouble my sister and I would like to take you out to dinner later tonight.” Cloudchaser looked at the ground trying to avoid James’ gaze.

“You don’t have to take me out to dinner as some sort of payment. I just did what I do best and that was it.” James placed a hand on their shoulders and smiled.

The mares looked back at him and he could see the determination in their eyes that they wanted to do this. James nodded his head in agreement and the mares gave him a hug. They ran out the front door and took to the sky so they could be ready for the night. Daisy and Lily were the next to come out of the kitchen and they asked the same thing. James agreed to be taken out to dinner the next day. The mares giggled as they left the house excited for the future events. James went back into the kitchen and saw Fiddlesticks. Probably taking on a good guess he said yes to the possible question. Fiddlesticks could feel her face burning when James said yes. She did the only thing that she could do in this situation. She grabbed a cookie sheet and knocked James unconscious.

When James hit the floor she ran out of the house before the other mares showed up. She was mentally slapping herself for hitting James. She didn’t know what came over her. She had never been in that position before so she did what she could. She would apologize to James later when she had the chance. These short conversations didn’t go unnoticed by the five mares that were watching them. Vinyl had to shut Pinkie’s mouth before she gave them away. They headed back to their rooms to get their supplies.

James grabbed the side of his head where Fiddlesticks hit him. There was no blood or a bruise so he just shrugged it off. That was the first time that a mare reacted so weirdly to him. James couldn’t help but laugh at it though since he did kind of put her on the spot. James got off the kitchen floor and headed for the void room. James went inside and saw that Twilight was busy getting the place cleaned up. She looked over at James and smiled at him. James offered to help her clean up and she accepted it.

Twilight made the room smaller so that it would be easier to clean. As they were cleaning James found the two books and picked them up. Twilight was looking at him a little angry saying that he better not open those books. For the sake of messing with the bookworm James opened the book. There was a bright flash and James felt a bolt of electricity shoot up his arm. Twilight couldn’t help but laugh when James dropped the book and started rubbing his arms. James looked over at Twilight who just shrugged. She did tell him not to open the book but he didn’t listen. James really hoped that Twilight gave the books back soon.

The void room was finally clean and Twilight gave James a big hug. James gave her a hug back and kissed her horn. She pushed James back waving her finger in front of him. She said that he cannot do that with her or the others since he was still in trouble. James groaned as he went back upstairs to see Rarity digging through the exotic wines. James quietly walked up behind her and tapped her shoulder. Rarity jumped at the touch and almost dropped the wine. James was quick enough to catch the bottle and handed it back to her.

Rarity was able to calm her beating heart after she saw that it was James that tapped her shoulder. She was fine as long it was James or any of the other mares but a random stranger would have been hurt. Rarity always acted like a proper lady but if you got on her bad side then you were in trouble. She may not have looked it but she was capable to hold her own in a fight. James asked what she was doing with the wine. She said that she wanted to see what Berry Punch gave them and was quite surprised. Many of the wines were a rare find and were to be top quality. James just shrugged his shoulders since he didn’t know much about wine.

Rarity stopped trying to explain it since James wasn’t going to get it anytime soon. She took the bottle that she was holding and headed for her room. James asked what she wanted with the wine. She said that she needed something to drink while she worked. James asked if she needed any help but she said that she was fine. James walked around the house and found the Wonderbolt jacket. James picked up the jacket and went for Rainbow’s room. James opened the door and he wished that he knocked first before entering.

Rainbow was coming out of the shower with a towel over head. She saw James standing in her doorway and she wasn’t happy. Before she could do anything James put the jacket on the dresser. Once the jacket was placed James went back to staring at Rainbow. She picked up a box and threw it at James. James was hit in the face and it hurt like hell. He asked if there was lead in the box and Rainbow said yes. James looked at her quizzically to see if she was messing with him. She didn’t budge so he checked the box. Inside the box was a big piece of lead.

James grabbed a couple of tissues and wiped the blood from his nose. It seemed that these mares were getting a little more emotional than before. James just shrugged and headed for Trixie’s room so she could take a look at him. He knocked on the door and Trixie answered it. She was smiling at James but stopped when she saw the tissues in his nose. She stepped aside and let him in. James took a seat as she began to look him over. Nothing was broken and he was just bleeding slightly from the nose. Trixie used her magic and healed his nose.

James pulled out the tissues and thanked Trixie for taking a look at him. She gave James a slight bow and asked if there was anything else. James took a few seconds to think and couldn’t come up with anything. James walked out of her room and went to the kitchen. It was nearing lunch time so James got to cooking. The mares all showed up when James was finished cooking. They all ate in silence as they sat at the table. When lunch was over James cleaned up his plate and then headed for the entertainment room as he waited for night to come.

Night finally came and James was dressed casually for the dinner. He told his mares that he would be going out and some of them were a little less than pleased. Lotus on the other hand seemed fine with it but that was probably because she knew that James would behave. There was a knock at the door and James answered it. Cloudchaser and Flitter were dressed casually but spruced themselves up a bit. James gave a smile to the two mares who blushed. James waved goodbye to his mares and left with the two pegasi.

The two pegasi sat with James in a booth as they waited for somepony to take their order. They were nervous as they sat with James. They don’t know what it was but as they stayed around James they didn’t want to leave. There was no explanation for how they were feeling. The only word that came to mind as they were around James was comfort. They felt safe around James and they didn’t want to mess this up. The waiter came by and took their orders. They know about James being an omnivore so they said that he could order whatever he wanted. James didn’t want to make them uncomfortable so he ordered some simple foods.

When the waiter was gone they had a conversation. Not much was said in the beginning but as time went on they were having longer conversations. As they talked they could see that James was a really nice guy. James asked if they were doing okay after everything that happened to them. They nodded their heads showing they were fine. James was more interested in their health than his own especially since he was in a coma for two months. They asked if James was alright and he said that he had worse.

The mares couldn’t help but laugh at his little comment. James couldn’t help but laugh also since he never actually had something put him in a coma. Their food finally arrived and they ate in silence. Cloudchaser and Flitter could feel their faces slightly burn as their blushes started to slowly creep up on them. James noticed that they were looking a little uncomfortable and asked if they were okay. The answered quickly that they were okay and left for the bathroom.

Once they were inside the bathroom they splashed cold water on their faces. As the cool water dripped from their face they took a few breaths. They dried off their faces and went back to join James. As they walked they were certain that they saw Pinkie Pie out in the distance. There was a slight pink blur but they shrugged thinking that it was just Pinkie being herself. They joined James back at the booth and continued their conversation. When the waiter showed up James put the money down on the bill and got up.

The mares looked at James confused at what he did and he just said that it was only fair. He didn’t mind being taken out for dinner but he wanted to be the one to at least make some kind of contribution. The mare’s faces went flush at James’ kindness. This was supposed to be a simple dinner to show their apology but now it became something more. During this time they got to see what James was truly like and they couldn’t help it. The mares did the only thing that seemed right at the moment. They both leaned in close to James and kissed him.

Spitfire, Vinyl, Rose, Octavia, and Pinkie got up from their dinner and headed out. They kept their distance from James so they could spy on him. They followed him to a restaurant and they hid up on a hill. They watched as James and the two pegasi ate their food and had a general conversation. Pinkie was about to yell something at James but Octavia tackled her to the ground and told her to be quiet. Pinkie gave a slight nod of the head and Octavia got off of her. They continued to watch until something happened.

Dinner was over and James paid the bill for their dinner. They were getting up to leave but before they stepped out the door Cloudchaser and Flitter gave him a kiss. Spitfire and the gang saw what happened and were ready to charge down there to show the mares what they did wrong. The only thing that stopped them was how they were going to explain to James why they were spying on him. Frustrated the mares left back to the house since they couldn’t do anything. Pinkie had to be dragged since she wanted to go bother James about what he was going to do.

When the mares were back home Octavia grabbed a bottle of wine and took it to Spitfire’s room so they could all have a drink. They were slamming back glasses full of the wine. As they drank the wine they were talking about what they were going to do. There was two more dinner dates that were coming up and there is a possibility that this could happen again. As they talked there was only a couple things that they could do. They could either talk to James to see how he felt about the mares and if he wanted them to join the harem or if they should scare them off. The conversation ended when they heard the front door open and close. They saw the two mares follow James into his room and felt their anger spike. They were going to let James have it in the morning when they slept off the alcohol in their body.

When the mares were gone they didn’t see Cloudchaser and Flitter were still with James. They were still kissing James but doing something extra. During the kiss they slightly rubbed their bodies up against his. James fought back against their advances but it was really hard. They were very persistent and didn’t back down. James walked back home with the two mares in tow. Once inside they headed for James’ room and locked the door. When James turned around the two mares were already out of their clothes and looking at James seductively.

James gave a slight chuckle as he took his clothes off and the mares tackled him to the bed. Cloudchaser was already over his mouth presenting her marehood to him. James took a slow lick causing a shiver to run down her spine. Flitter took James’ cock in her mouth and started to suck. James stuck his tongue down deeper into Cloudchaser and that sent her over the edge. She came all over James’ face and happily licked up her juices. James came into Flitter’s mouth and she swallowed every drop of his cum.

Flitter and Cloudchaser switched places so that Flitter was above James’ face and Cloudchaser was near his cock. James grabbed Flitter’s flanks and pulled her down. She gave a slight yelp at the sudden action but that was soon replaced with moans. Cloudchaser smiled at her sister whose face was contorted into pure bliss. Cloudchaser took James’ manhood into her mouth and started bobbing her head. James licked all over Flitter’s marehood and she couldn’t control the moans that were escaping her mouth. Flitter soon came and James drank her juices wanting to savor every drop. James then came into Cloudchaser’s mouth and she moaned happily as she swallowed his seed.

The two pegasi moved around so that their marehoods were presented to him. James took Flitter first and slowly entered her first. She gave a slight whimper as James broke through her hymen. James waited a few seconds for her to adjust and then he would get started. She nodded her head and James started thrusting into her. Cloudchaser played with herself as she waited her turn. James could feel his peak rising and he tried to pull out. Flitter pushed back keeping him inside of her and he couldn’t take it. She came hard all over James’ cock covering it in her juices and making it shine.

James filled her insides with his seed as she moaned into the bed sheets. James pulled out and looked over to Cloudchaser. Cloudchaser smiled as she moved closer to James and lined herself up with his member. She gently lowered herself onto him and whimpered as her hymen was broken through. She was able to calm down and James thrusted into her. James felt his peak rising and looked at her. She nodded her head as she wrapped her legs around him holding her in place. James released his seed inside of her and she went limp. Her juices mixed with her sister’s as they fell asleep happy. James pulled the sheets over the three of them so they would be comfortable.

James fell to the bed tired and glad that his room was sound proofed. Before he fell asleep he was struck with two ideas. The first was that there was a possibility that the other dinner dates would end up like this. The second idea was that his mares were going to kill him when they find out that he had sex with the five mares. If he was lucky maybe they would want to join his harem and Spitfire would be fine with that. James nodded his head as he fell asleep planning to cross that bridge when it came time to.

Author's Notes:

Thanks to ErikTheSoulReaper for the help on this chapter.