Day 1

As James and Spitfire awoke to the new morning James got dressed and packed for the next mares to watch over him. Spitfire told James that Fluttershy and Rarity would be the next to watch over him. They went downstairs and James sat in the kitchen as Spitfire started up breakfast. James left the table to take a quick shower before he ate anything and especially before Rarity showed up and complained about how he looked. James was finished with his shower and on the way down he saw that Spitfire was finishing up with her cooking. They sat down to a silent breakfast just exchanging glances with each other. After breakfast was over James cleaned the dishes until he heard a knock at the door. Spitfire went to answer and James could hear the sing song voice of the fashionista.

Rarity and Fluttershy were standing outside looking very happy well mainly Rarity was. Fluttershy on the other hand was hiding behind her main and keeping some of her distance. They didn’t know that James wanted to start a harem or that he asked her to be the lead mare. She decided to keep that information to herself as James would be able to tell them about it more easily. Spitfire stepped to the side to let the other two mares inside. When they entered Rarity started looking around and taking note of how the house looked. She seemed somewhat pleased with the way that it looked. Though with Rarity it is really hard to make something look really nice and not have her see something wrong with it.

James came out with his bag and looked at the mares in the living room. When they turned to see James he still looked very bleak and pale. Rarity walked over to the man and gave him a reassuring hug. Fluttershy slowly walked over to James and looked him in the eyes. After several seconds of staring Fluttershy gave James a quick little hug. Once the hugs were finished with James followed the two mares out after he said goodbye to Spitfire. Spitfire locked the door behind her as she needed to head back to Cloudsdale and finish up some paperwork. Sure Soarin could have done it for her but she didn’t want to deal with his lazy ass because he probably left it for the last minute to be done. Before she took for the sky she watched James walk away until she couldn’t see him any more.

“I hope everything goes well James and please stay safe.” Spitfire thought to herself as she took off and headed back to Cloudsdale.

James walked behind the two mares keeping his own little distance from the two. He was far enough away where he could keep his thoughts to himself but not too far that it looked like he was falling behind. James only caught little bits of the conversation that were mainly about some spa treatments and other plans that they had. James didn’t pay much mind to their conversation, as he just wanted to clear his head a bit. Rarity and Fluttershy saw that James was behind them a good few feet but didn’t pull him closer as he wasn’t staying any farther away. So the two of them continued on with their conversation.

“So what do you think Fluttershy? Do you think that would help make James feel better?” Rarity asked her shy pegasus friend who was still hiding behind her mane.

“I don’t know Rarity. Sure we have our weekly spa visits but I’m not so sure that James would like to go. He doesn’t seem like the type to go and relax at a spa as much as you and I do.” Fluttershy replied slightly coming out of mane to look back at James.

“That may be true Fluttershy but we won’t know unless we try. Even then if doesn’t like it then we can just head back to my boutique and do something else. It is completely up to how he feels about it.”

“Well as long as we aren’t forcing him to do it then I guess that it would be okay.” Rarity surprised the pegasus by giving her a hug. Once Rarity let go they all headed for the boutique and to get James started on his physical workout. Rarity didn’t own any exercise equipment but was glad that Spitfire and Twilight helped her make a room where you could do the exercises using simple items. Turns out that you didn’t really need all the fancy equipment to workout. It was just more convenient but using simple house hold items still had the same effect.

The three of them arrived at the boutique and went inside. Rarity lead James to the extra room so he could place his things. Fluttershy went to the kitchen to make James his special drink and plan out the meals for the next few days. James finished putting his stuff up and followed Rarity downstairs. Once at the bottom Fluttershy gave him the drink that he was all too familiar with. James looked at it for a couple of seconds before releasing a sigh and downing the drink. He gave the glass back to Fluttershy and went to the workout room with Rarity. James saw the household items and chuckled slightly that he had taken things for granted but were still very helpful. James entered the room and started his exercises as Rarity and Fluttershy left to go do something else.

Day 2, 3, 4

The past three days have been okay with James. Rarity and Fluttershy have been working very hard to bring James back but haven’t been very successful. James was still being silent but would make some light conversation with them. They had simple meals and James worked out as Fluttershy and Rarity talked about what to do. James went with Fluttershy a couple of times a day to help with her little critters. Fluttershy had been taking care of Lightning Bolt and Brave Heart while he was gone. When James entered the house his pets were very happy. Fluttershy gave them a slight stare but James halted her.

James kneeled down on the ground to pet the little guys. They followed James around the house as he helped feed the other critters. His pets helped him out with the feeding by bringing the food bags or helped round up the critters so they could eat. Fluttershy was starting to come out of her mane and smile at James. She was glad that James was still caring for the animals and didn’t show them any harm. She had been worried that after that everything that happened that he would try to hurt her animals. She felt bad that she would think poorly of James but she wanted to make sure that her animals stayed safe.

As James went around the house feeding the animals and organizing all the food Fluttershy took the time to think to herself. Through the time she thought about what James thought about her. When he first arrived he seemed dangerous and Fluttershy thought of him as a monster. As the times went on the showed his caring side letting her relax a little more. Fluttershy would sometimes think about James during the day where he was just helping around the house and taking care of the animals. During the night though and when she was asleep she would then have naughty thoughts. She would think about him taking her in the night and rutting her like no tomorrow. He would be rough but gentle with her as they would make passionate love with each other. Fluttershy had to change her sheets more often then before because of how intense the dreams were being. As Fluttershy and James got closer to each other she was happy to know about the man. Before she thought that she couldn’t love him but was proven wrong when he was so kind. James always put others before himself and would always be there when he was needed. Fluttershy then decided from then on to be there for him also no matter how bad he was feeling. Fluttershy would relive every moment of everyday if she could if it meant that James would be with her and take care of her.

Fluttershy was now out of her little protective mane shell and Rarity was happy to see her come out of it. Rarity had James help her with designing commissions and simple patch jobs. She would ask his input on how a dress looked and if there was anything that should be changed. James may not have been good at fashion but it was nice that he was there with her. James would offer the little knowledge that he had about fashion and it was slightly helpful. There was a few new things that Rarity learned about fashion from his world and would try to use some of those techniques in some other designs. Rarity was able to make a very good dress but it was nice when James would point out a small flaw that she missed because she kept herself up late at night trying to make sure that James stayed safe. Rarity was very sleepy and her worries weren’t helping to keep her up. When she went down to the kitchen she was James and Fluttershy in the kitchen together cooking. When she went in she saw that most of the dinner was ready and they were just finishing up. After dinner was over Rarity fell asleep on the table having relaxed a bit from all the stress. Fluttershy just giggled a little at her sleeping friend. Fluttershy took her friend back to her bed and James was more than willing to help. Once Rarity was in bed James left and went to his room and went to bed.

Day 5

Rarity woke up in her bed feeling refreshed. She looked around her room and saw that Fluttershy was sleeping on the mattress that she pulled out for her. As Rarity looked around the room she could hear some stumbling from downstairs. She got out of bed and ran quickly down the stairs scared out of her mind that James did another stupid thing again. When she reached the bottom she saw James rubbing the back of his head. James fell down off a ladder because he was trying to get something from the top shelf. Rarity saw where he was trying to grab and walked over to James and helped him up. She pulled down a package that had his name on it and gave it to him. James opened the box and saw that it was filled with bits. Before James could say anything Rarity cut him off.

“These are the contributions that you asked from us for a present. I meant to give it to you but then you had the accident.” Rarity looked at James hoping that he had something to say. He just stared blankly at the bits and didn’t say anything. Rarity was getting worried that James was going to throw the bits away but was surprised when he hugged her. James had a few tears coming down his face and Rarity just rubbed his back.

Rarity was forever known for making outstanding outfits that stood out from all the others. Though when she made the clothes for James she felt happy to make something so simple. Everytime she made the clothes she would imagine James getting dressed and how the clothes was loose fitting on his body but snug enough to show his muscles. Once James was dressed she would then undress him slowly with her mind and imagine his naked body. Then he would come over to her and undress her from one of her best dresses and make sweet love under the moonlight in her bed. Rarity couldn’t control the dreams that she had when she went to bed. Rarity remembered the other stallions that tried to woo her but James did it without even trying. His smile and his caring attitude that he had just made her heart flutter. At first she thought that it was a simple filly crush but as they spent more time together she learned that she was actually falling for the man. Though tradition has a stallion wear something small and practical like a flower to show who he was with. She wanted something that looked better on him and that was when she came up with the shirts. At first the shirts were designed just to look nice but as James wore the different kinds she knew that he did care for them in some way. Rarity would be glad to have James and be able to share him with others if he so chooses. Rarity would let him decide if he wanted to have other mares in his life and be happy. Rarity wouldn’t change his life or her own if it meant that they would be together no matter what.

Once Rarity was done with her little thought train she let go of James so she could cook something. James went upstairs to put the money away and get clean. Rarity finished breakfast and Fluttershy and James came down the stairs and she served all three of them. Rarity was happy to be there in James’ time in need and was glad that Fluttershy was there to relish in the happiness that all of them shared

Day 6

James followed the mares down a road to a surprise that they had for him. James kept asking what it was but they wouldn’t tell him. Everytime that he asked they would look at him then to each other and giggle. James gave up trying to get any answers after his tenth failed attempt. After walking for half an hour James saw a huge building that read ‘Aloe and Lotus Spa Treatment.’ James stared at the building for a few seconds before being pulled inside. Once inside he looked at the front counter to see two mares. One was pink and wearing a blue shirt and blue skirt and a headband with a lotus on it. The other one was blue wearing a pink shirt and pink skirt and a headband that had a lotus on it. Their tails and manes were the color of each other and were very beautiful earth mares. James guessed that they were probably twins if they shared the same cutie mark.

“Good evening Ms. Rarity and Ms. Fluttershy. Are you hear for your regular appointment?” The pink mare asked.

“Yes Aloe me and Fluttershy are but we also brought a guest with us.” Aloe looked over to where Rarity was gesturing and saw the man standing there. Aloe grabbed the blue mare next to her and whispered into her ear about something. James didn’t know about what but he could see the small hint of a blush on their cheeks.

“Then Ms. Rarity and Ms. Fluttershy you may head back and our employees will be with you shortly.” Aloe smiled at Rarity as she opened the door to let the two mares through. She closed the door once they were through and called James over.

“Good evening sir my name is Aloe and this is my sister Lotus. We are the owners of this establishment and are glad to see a new customer. So do you know what kind of treatment that you want?”

“Well I’m not entirely sure because I have never been to a spa before.” James chuckled slightly rubbing the back of his head in nervousness.

“Well then might I suggest the special treatment? It’s a new treatment that we haven’t used before but we would like to try it out today with you if you would like.”

“How much does it cost to have one of those?”

“For you sir since you are friends with Ms. Rarity and Ms. Fluttershy it’s free of charge. You don’t have to worry about paying us either because I think that you will enjoy it more than you think you might.” Lotus said while she looked at her sister with a playful smile. James nodded his head and followed the mares through the door.

“Oh and by the way the name is James and you don’t need to add any surname to it.” Aloe and Lotus brought James with them to the private room so the could give him his treatment. Rarity and Fluttershy saw James go in the private room with Aloe and Lotus and were worried what might be happening in there. They would check on James after they were finished with their treatment to make sure that he was okay.

Once James was inside the room he was assaulted by Aloe that surprised him by giving him a deep kiss. James didn’t resist or stop it but just let the kiss happen. James could feel Lotus rubbing her hands all over his body pulling at his clothes. Aloe broke the kiss with a string of saliva still connecting their lips. Aloe started to take her clothes off and so did Lotus. James was now staring at the two naked mares whose busts were of a well size and very curvy bodies. Lotus pulled James to the bed and the sisters started taking his clothes off.

James didn’t resist their actions and let them do what they wanted. James heard the mares gasp as they saw his member fully erect in front of them. Lotus was the first to grab hold of it and start stroking it. Aloe let her sister have fun with his manhood as she brought herself above James’ face. She presented her marehood to her and lowered herself and he started licking at her folds. Lotus then took James’ cock into her mouth and started bobbing her head up and down. James could feel the pleasure and couldn’t control the hip thrusts that he kept giving trying to go deeper into Lotus’ mouth. Aloe quickly reached her peak as she came all over James’ face. Not too long after James released his seed deep into Lotus’ mouth and she swallowed every drop.

The sisters switched positions and Aloe lined up James manhood with her marehood and set herself down on him. She kept going until he penetrated her hymen and she shivered at the pleasure. Aloe waited a few seconds before she started rocking her hips. Lotus went over to James’ face and did the same thing that Aloe did. James proceeded to lick at her folds while Aloe rode him. Lotus released a loud moan as she came from James’ skilled tongue and he came himself deep into Aloe’s pussy as his seed and her juices mixed. Aloe fell to the bed exhausted but Lotus wasn’t done yet. She went over licked as James’ cock making it erect once again. Lotus slid herself down slowly and she broke through her hymen and was now fully hilted by the man. She started with slow thrusts but quickly started speeding up since she was still sensitive after her last orgasm. It didn’t take long for her and James to cum as she went down one last time she could feel his seed fill her up as she came all over his cock. She fell on the bed and snuggled up next to James. Aloe did the same as her sister but before they could enjoy the quiet the door was flung open.

“WHAT THE BUCK IS GOING ON IN HERE?” The three of them lifted their heads to see an angry Rarity and Fluttershy.

“James get dressed and wait out by the front doors while me and Rarity talk with Aloe and Lotus.” James was going to say something but was stopped cold as Fluttershy stared at him. To keep from angering the pegasus James got dressed and headed for the doors. Once he was gone Rarity went to tell the two spa ponies that he went through.

“So as you can see he is not himself and isn’t feeling very well. We are trying to cheer him up and then you possibly could have bucked this all up by having sex with him.” Rarity stared daggers at the two now dressed spa ponies putting venom into each word. They were about to say something until Fluttershy cut them off.

“If you ever think about doing this to James ever again or even look at him with the intent of doing this then so help me that the others and I will come and kick your asses back to Taurtarus.” Fluttershy looked at them very angrily. Before they could get a reply the two of them left for home with James in between them. Once home Rarity called the other nine mares and told them what happened. They made sure that they would keep a closer eye on James to make sure that he would stay okay. Rarity went to the kitchen and started dinner. There was a knock at the door and Fluttershy answered it.

Standing outside were Aloe and Lotus. They kept their heads down so they wouldn’t look at the pegasus or James who was sitting on one of the couches. Aloe and Lotus spoke at the same time to apologize.

“We would like to apologize for our actions from the spa earlier this evening. We were wrong to take advantage of James the way we did and are very sorry. We hope that you can forgive us and our actions.” Fluttershy only released a small sigh but her glare didn’t let up.

“I’m not sure if Rarity and I can take your apologies just yet but we will talk about it and see if your apologies are enough.” Aloe and Lotus looked at Fluttershy and bowed before leaving back to their homes. Dinner went on in silence as the mares kept an eye on James to make sure that he was okay. After dishes were clean they all went to bed so they could relax a little.

Day 7

Rarity and Fluttershy were still fuming mad at what happened yesterday and James knew that he needed to do something. James needed a way to distract them from what happened so they could relax. James didn’t know how to feel during that night because he just didn’t know what to be feeling. He could understand where they were getting angry from but it wasn’t needed at all. So James did the next best thing he could. He called up to the two mares to come downstairs because he needed to share something with them. Once they were downstairs James gestured towards the couch and they took a seat. James did the one thing that was needed to get their minds on something else.

“Rarity and Fluttershy I know that you are still angry at Aloe and Lotus but I need you two to know this before I leave with whoever tomorrow morning.” Rarity was about to say something but before she could James stopped her by pressing a finger to her mouth.

“Just listen for now and think about what I am going to say because it is more important. I knew about the date challenge that you all had and wanted to say that all of you lost. What I wanted was not a herd but a harem. I want this because I love every single one of you and can’t stand to let you be sad over me. So what I want to know is do you or do you not want to be a part of this? I will not be hurt by your decision if you don’t stay. If you do join then I want you to know that Spitfire is already the lead mare and she gives the final say. So just think this over for a while and then talk to her about it.” James then got up and walked away from the two mares and headed for his bedroom to just lay on his bed and relax. James was glad to get this out in the open now after hiding it for so long and was hoping that they would join.

Author's Notes:

Thanks to ErikTheSoulReaper for the chapter idea and order for all of this.