When they arrived at Tooth Palace, it was not a pretty sight. The nightmare horses were everywhere, taking every little fairy and tooth boxes they can catch.

"What is this?" North asked. "They're taking the fairies." said Jack. "They're stealing all of the teeth." said Bunny. When a nightmare horse flew by, Twilight zapped it with her magic causing black sand to go everywhere. "Black sand." she muttered. Sandy looked at it and gave her a worried look on his face.

The horses were making the sleigh so bumpy that Applejack accidentally fell off. "Applejack!" Jack shouted as he flew down and caught her. Once she was saved, her head was already dizzy. "Are you okay?" Jack asked. "What is it with me falling down a lot?" Applejack asked herself. "Just hang on. We're almost there." said Jack as he holds her while flying to the others.

Once the sleigh was landed, they saw a panicked Tooth flying over the place. "Tooth! Down here!" North shouted. Tooth saw her friends and flew to them in grief and sorrow. "Are you alright?" Rarity asked. "No. They took all of the teeth. They took all of my fairies. Everything is gone. Everything." Tooth replied in sorrow. "I'm so sorry, Tooth. We'll get them back, don't you worry." said Rarity as she comforts the fairy.

"I have to say. This is very very exciting. The Big Four, all together. A little star struck." said Pitch as he appears out of nowhere. "Pitch!" Twilight shouted. "Hello, Twilight Sparkle. So glad to see you again, and you brought your friends. How charming." said Pitch. "Save it, Pitch! You've got thirty seconds to return my fairies!" Tooth shouted. "Or what? You'll stick a quarter under my pillow?" Pitch teased. "You heard her! Give them back or else you'll be very sorry!" Rarity shouted as she prepares to use her magic. "I already am." said Pitch as he disappears.

"Where'd he go?" Jack asked. "Right behind you, Jack Frost. I can see you have joined a group. I thought it would never happen." said Pitch. "Will you stop teasing him like that?! He's had enough of your evil schemes!" Pinkie shouted. "I don't think so. Jack is too fun to mess with, and I'm going to continue that for a really long time." Pitch replied with a chuckle. "You wish." said Jack.

"Why are you doing this?" North asked. "Maybe I want what you have. To be believed in. Maybe I'm tired of hiding under beds!" Pitch explained. "Maybe that's where you belong." said Bunny. "Oh, go suck an egg rabbit." said Pitch. "Let me guess. You want to turn Equestria into a living nightmare." said Twilight. "Very good. But, I never told you why." said Pitch. "Why?" Twilight asked. "Don't worry. No one has been afraid of him since the Dark Ages." said Bunny.

"Oh, the Dark Ages. Everyone frightened and miserable, such happy times for me. Then, The Man in the Moon chose you to give them hope and dreams. While I was forced to be stuck in the shadows, not being seen by anyone. They always say I'm just a bad dream or there's no such thing as the Boogeyman! But, that's all about to change." Pitch explained. "So that's it? You're just jealous of the Guardians?" Applejack asked. "Yes, I am. But, I also want them to be destroyed. Forgotten by the ponies forever and the only thing they will believe in is me!" Pitch replied.

Tooth was so angry at this that she took one of Bunny's boomerangs and tries to attack Pitch. But, he summoned his nightmare horse which startled her. Pinkie screamed and shouted, "It's the nightmare horse!" "That's right. I use these wonderful creatures to turn dreams into nightmares. Took a while to use that trick." said Pitch. "That explains the black sand." said Fluttershy.

Then all of the sudden, Tooth Palace was starting to collapse. "Oh, it's happening already." said Pitch. "What is?" Jack asked. "All of the little fillies are waking up, realizing that the Tooth Fairy never came." Pitch replied. Tooth was shocked at on what the Boogeyman has done to her. "What's going on?" Jack asked. "They don't believe in me anymore." Tooth replied in sadness. "You can't do that to the Guardians!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "Oh, yes I can. Just watch." said Pitch. "You have a holiday too. Halloween." said Pinkie. "Halloween is just a silly joke that people use fear for fun. I want to use fear for real." said Pitch.

"No matter what you do, my friends and I will still believe in the Guardians!" Twilight shouted. "Are you sure? Little by little, everyone in Equestria will stop believing in them. No Christmas or Easter or little fairies coming in the night. It will be nothing but fear and darkness, and me. Now, it's their turn not to be believed in." Pitch explained. Twilight got so angry that she zapped him with her magic, but Pitch blocked it and went straight towards her. He grabs her and tries to kidnap her.

"Let me go, Pitch!" Twilight shouted. "I don't think so. Since you're afraid of me, I'm going to use your fear to gain my powers and your friends will be surrounded by nothing by fear." Pitch replied as he takes off with Twilight. But the Guardians are on his tail to rescue her. Jack uses his staff to freeze Pitch's arm, causing him to let go of the princess as she starts to fall. "Twilight!" Rainbow Dash shouted as she and Jack caught her. "Twilight, are you ok? Speak to me!" said Jack.

Twilight wasn't talking. The only thing that came out of her mouth was heavy breathing. Jack sets her down and tries to calm her. "Twilight, it's ok. Don't listen to what Pitch says. It's ok." he said. "What did Pitch do to her?" Bunny asked. "I don't know. All he did was trying to kidnap her." Jack replied. Sandy came in to help by sprinkling some of his golden sand onto her, and it worked. "Oh my gosh." said Twilight. "Are you ok?" Jack asked. "Does it look like I'm ok? Pitch is going to destroy you guys. He must be stopped right now." Twilight replied in fear.

"Speaking of Pitch, he's gone." said Rainbow Dash. "Oh, pony feathers. I was so close to bucking him in the face." said Applejack. "And look what he did to Tooth." said Rarity. "I'm okay, girls. Really." said Tooth. "So, why was the teeth so important?" Fluttershy asked. "It's not just the teeth, it's the memories they hold." Tooth replied. "Teeth can give you memories? I didn't know that." said Pinkie. "Maybe we could get some more teeth. That way Tooth will be believed in again." said Fluttershy.

North liked her idea and said, "That's it! We will get more teeth and we'll get believed in again." "Now, you're talking!" Rainbow Dash shouted. "Oh, that's makes me feel so much better." said Twilight. "Hey Jack, care to join us?" Applejack asked.

"I'm in." Jack replied.

...

So the mane six and the Guardians went all over Equestria to get teeth. They went from Canterlot to Appleloosa to The Crystal Empire.

"There's one here and one other there! They're everywhere! This is so exciting!" Tooth shouted as she accidentally bumped into a sign. "You okay?" Jack asked. "Yes. It's been a while since I've been out in the fields." said Tooth. "And how long is that?" Rainbow Dash asked. "Four hundred and forty years, give or take." Tooth replied. "That does not surprise me since this one is three hundred years old." Rainbow Dash said as she gestures Jack. Jack laughed at her comment.

As they went from house to house, they each found a tooth underneath the pillow. And surprisingly, they competed each other to see who gets the most teeth and who gets the tooth first. Especially Jack and Bunny. "Wanna see who's the fastest?" Bunny asked. "I'm pretty fast, alright. Are you challenging me?" Jack asked. "You don't want to race with a rabbit, mate." Bunny replied as he went faster than ever before.

Once everyone got every tooth they can, they showed it to Tooth and she was very impressed. "Wow, that's a lot of teeth. But, did you leave any gifts? You gotta leave some gifts." she said. Everyone had worried looks on their faces, meaning they forgot to bring gifts to the ponies.

So, they went back and gave any pony who lost their tooth gifts. North gave out candy canes, Bunny gave out his Easter eggs, Tooth gave out coins, Applejack gave out apples, Twilight gave out books, Pinkie gave out confetti and balloons, Rarity gave out jewels, Fluttershy gave out stuffed animals, and Rainbow Dash gave out trophies.

During the tooth hunt, North accidentally dropped his teleportation snowglobe which falls into their hands of Twilight's niece Flurry Heart. She looked at it funny and began to play with it. She shook it and it showed Easter eggs, but dropped it. The globe turned into a portal and Flurry went right in.