When lunchtime was over, Fluttershy told the three that the head of the Party Planning Committee is in the gym.

While they were going to the gym, Garfield, Nermal and Arlene asks Jon and Liz 'Is it time for us to get out of your shirts?', and the latter humans both replied 'Yes.'

They, Twilight and Spike reached the gym, and Twilight said to her dragon dog, "Fluttershy said she'd probably be in here."

"Well? Where is she?", asked Garfield, as the eight are looking for her.

As they look for the person responsible for the committee, they are alerted by a voice so loud it scares the eight.

"INCOMING!", a voice yelled.

Looking up at the ceiling, Twilight, Liz, the four Garfield pets and Spike grimace, while Jon gasps as a rain of colourful streamers suddenly covers them. The seven got down except for Jon, who is astonished. Taking off the streamers, they look to a similar person from Equestria too. Pinkie Pie. Pinkie then starts to blow a balloon.

"Hi. My name's Twilight Sparkle, and-", Twilight greeted the person, who she turns around, and Twilight ducked when noticing the balloon she's blowing. She finally recognized the person. "...Pinkie Pie...?"

The air from the balloon blows her face. When Twilight and the six Garfield characters witness this, they are startled by Pinkie Pie once again, behind them while asking if they are psychic.

"Uh, no...I don't think so. Unless, of course, that's something you can do here."

"Not usually.", the party girl responds, starting to blow another balloon.

"Fluttershy said this was where I'd find the head of the Fall Formal Planning Committee.", supposed Twilight.

"Are you that person?", Jon asked Pinkie if she's the head of the Committee.

"Fluttershy, huh?", Pinkie angered, tying the balloon she blew. "Don't let the whole 'shy' thing fool you. She can be a real meanie."

"WHAT?! YOU'RE ENEMIES?", Liz yelled.

"You two ain't friends?", gasped Twilight.

Pinkie Pie mood swings to happiness when she went back to talking about the sign-up. "Waited a bit to get you and your friends' name on the ballot, huh? Dance is day after tomorrow.", she then says, as she offered Odie a little dance, who the latter smiles romantically instead of answering.

"We're brand new here. Twilight's signing up for the princess and we're supporting her as chaperones.", explained Jon.

"Ooh! I thought you didn't look familiar.", dumbfounded Pinkie, who then examines her to make sure she recognizes Twilight. "Though now that I'm really looking at you...", she said, backing up and finished by questioning her: "...do you have a twin sister who lives in the city, has a pet dog named Spike that looks just like that one?", pointing to Spike who is playing with the balloons along with Garfield and the other three animals.

"Uh, maybe?", Twilight considers.

"Thought so."

"Be careful, Jon.", whispers Garfield as he yanks his shirt. "This might be a major foreshadow in the series."

"Anywho, just need to fill this out and you are officially up for the coveted Princess of the Fall Formal crown, along with your chaperones.", instructs Pinkie Pie, pulling out a clipboard and a pen from her hair.

Twilight, in nervous and suspense, uses her teeth to hold the pen. Pinkie Pie doesn't react to this, but still smiling. She then holds the pen with her hands, and writes her "name" on the clipboard. The six characters then writes their names one by one right beside Twilight's name on the clipboard.

As Pinkie Pie turns the clipboard around to see their signatures, she is shocked to see Twilight's handwriting: her signature is scribbly. "Wow! You have really bad handwriting. It's like you've never held a pen before!", she exclaims.

Twilight and the others giggle in embarrassment. The former says, "Is it?"

The eight are interrupted by another person asking them in a familiar voice, "Somebody order a dozen cases of fizzy apple cider?"

Pinkie Pie, Garfield and Odie, the two latter at the sound of 'fizzy apple cider', were eager about this and the person reveals she is the one who ordered the dozen apple ciders because of the upcoming Fall Formal.

It was Applejack, as she places the crate on the table and wipes the sweat from her forehead off.

Twilight and the six Garfield characters' jaws drop as they saw her.

"Can you bring in the rest?", Applejack asks her associate, who arrives at the door with the other crates of fizzy apple cider. Her associate was Big Maclntosh, who is also familiar like the one back at Equestria. Most of the time when someone asks him a question, he symbolically says 'Ee-yup.' or 'Nn-nope.' He answers:

"Ee-yup."

Applejack, while carrying another crate, sees Twilight and the six Garfield characters, who Garfield and Odie already got the apple cider from a crate.

"Hey, I know you guys.", Applejack realized.

"You do?", inquired Twilight curiously.

"Yes! Now it's time for-", Liz cheers, before interrupted by Applejack again.

"Sure! You're the new guys who gave Sunset Shimmer the what-for today.", replied Applejack.

Arlene climbs up on Liz's shoulder and whispered: "So much for us to talk."

Applejack also grabs a apple cider bottle and starts drinking, with Garfield and Odie drinking at the same time.

"Twilight Sparkle, Garfield, Odie, Jon, Liz, Nermal and Arlene here is gonna run against Sunset Shimmer for Princess of the Fall Formal." announced Pinkie blowing a balloon. The announcement causes Applejack, then Garfield and Odie, to spit out the apple cider in shock. Twilight, Jon, Liz, Nermal, Arlene and Spike also react in shock.

"I'd think twice about it. Oh, sure, she'll probably aproach you all friendly-like...", Applejack explains why. She then pulls Pinkie Pie down, who recently is hovering due to the balloon. She grabs the red heart-shaped balloon and begins to write a face of Sunset Shimmer, while Pinkie Pie blows another balloon and writes a face of Twilight.

'I am sure lookin' forward to some friendly competition!', mocked Applejack, acting like Sunset Shimmer while holding the red balloon.

She also acts like Twilight for the yellow balloon, saying: 'It's so good to hear!'

She turns the red balloon around, showing a pin taped.

"But then, here comes the backstabbin'!", Applejack finished explaining, popping the yellow balloon (Twilight).

"Should've said that to her earlier.", Jon realizes, with the others look confused except for Applejack and Pinkie Pie.

"About the only girl at this school you can trust less than Sunset Shimmer is Rainbow Dash.", the country girl tutorials.

"Rainbow Dash?", Liz asked her.

"She's the captain of, like, every team at Canterlot High!", Pinkie Pie reminded them.

"Athletes.", Garfield whispered to Jon, with Odie agreeing with the orange cat.

"She's also the captain of sayin' she's gonna do somethin' for you, and then turnin' around and not even botherin' to show up!", Applejack angered.

"Oh, no. Not you too!", Nermal whispered to himself.

"Thanks for the advice, Applejack. but this is something we really need to do.", Twilight thanked.

"Suit yourself.", Applejack finishes, before she sounded suspicious, asking Twilight: "Hey, how'd you know my name was Applejack?"

Twilight and the others felt nervous and the "princess" asked her, "Didn't you say?", nervously.

"Nn-nope.", Big Mac said to them, answering their question while carrying the rest of the crates.

"Well, uh, sure nice meeting you both! I'm sure I'll be seeing you around!", Jon said to Pinkie and Applejack, as the eight of them moved on.

"Those seven's trying to hide a secret, but I am totally on to her. She's psychic!", she proved Applejack.

Applejack agrees to Pinkie Pie's theory, saying: "Uh-huh. If you say so."

Suddenly, someone opens the doors and reveals to be Sunset Shimmer once again.