It was probably hours until Rarity let them out. Each one of them had an article of clothing. Castiel had a trench coat, Dean had a leather jacket, while Sam got a plaid jacket. By now the sun was setting and it was time to go back to the library where they were told to go. Once they reached there destination, they walked right in and was greeted with blinding light and a loud cheer. The light dimmed down and there, standing before them, was most of the ponies in PonyVille.

"Welcome!" Most of them greeted and erupted in cheers again.

"Dean, I don't understand. What's happening?" Castiel asked Dean.

"It looks like a welcoming party." He answered.

Pinkie Pie bounced towards them with some of her friends. The three recognized Rarity, Apple Jack, and Twilight Sparkle.

"Hello again." Twilight greeted.

"Oh! You met! That's so great!" Pinkie Pie exclaimed bouncing around them.

"Hey! So you're the new ponies that Pinkie Pie been talking about." A pegasus spoke up. She had a rainbow mane and blue fur. Her cutie mark was a rainbow lightning bolt. "I'm Rainbow Dash, for your information."

"I… I'm Fluttershy." Another pegasus introduced. Her voice was barely audible. She had a long pink mane and yellow fur. Her cutie mark was three butterflies. Fluttershy crouched down a bit shyly.

"I'm Sam." Sam introduced.

"The names Dean."

"My name is Castiel."

"Oh my gosh! I love this song!" Pinkie Pie suddenly said in excitement. "Come on! Enjoy your welcoming party!"

"Oh…but we probably won't stay that long here."

"WHAT?!" Pinkie Pie stared at them in shock.

"Pinkie Pie, they are travelers." Twilight tried to explain.

"Oh. Well, where are you traveling from? It seems like you're from a different world where you aren't ponies and found someone that transported you here. So now that you're here, the only way to go back is to find this gypsy's pony, or whatnot."

The three travelers deadpanned. Is she physic?

"Oh come one. That story doesn't make sense." Apple Jack argued.

"Actually, you're right." Sam said. The group of ponies looked at them. Bewilderment clear on their faces.

"Really?" They asked simultaneously.

"That's so cool!" Rainbow Dashed cheered.

"So, how do you plan to get back?" Twilight asked.

"We wait for an odd occurrence," Dean started. There was a loud boom outside. "Like that."