Next Day – 10:00 PM
Fluttershy’s Cottage

Twilight walked up the cobblestone path that led to Fluttershy’s front door. As she walked, she briefly went over the day’s events in her head. After waking up cuddling with Applejack, the two had showered together and then eaten breakfast, before AJ then headed out to return to her home and tackle her morning duties. The rest of Twilight’s day had been fairly normal, almost dull, though the anticipation of tonight was always in the back of her mind. Around 8:30 at night, however, Pinkie Pie had showed up with her odd flying machine, requesting that Twilight cast two spells on her: the penis spell, and a Cloud-Walking spell strong enough to last until at least 10 AM the next morning. Upon being granted her request, Pinkie had hurriedly climbed aboard her machine and pedaled her way up towards Rainbow Dash’s cloud-house; Twilight couldn’t quite yet understand why she felt slight disappointment that Pinkie had taken off before Twilight could have a look at her new ‘equipment’.

Twilight’s thoughts came back to the present as she reached the front door and knocked. After a few seconds, the door opened, and Fluttershy’s expression of nervous curiosity changed to one of recognition and joy.

“Oh, Twilight!” she said. “I was afraid it was someone else. Please, come in!”

Twilight followed her in, instantly feeling comfortable in the cozy abode that Fluttershy called home. They made their way into the living room, and Fluttershy then leaned against Twilight, nuzzling her.

“I’ve… been thinking about tonight almost all day” she confessed. “At first I was nervous, but then I remembered that I’m going to be doing this with you, one of the ponies I trust most in the world.”

She walked forward a bit, and Twilight realized she now had Fluttershy’s long, silky-soft tail draped over her shoulders and neck. “Even though I still feel a little nervous… more than that, I can’t wait to get started! I even have a few of my favorite toys that I’d just love to share with you! …I mean, if that’s okay with you.”

“It’s f-fine…” Twilight replied with a blush as Fluttershy’s tail ran across her cheek in a caress. Fluttershy couldn’t help but giggle a little at the sight, as well as blush that she, of all ponies, could get such a reaction from anyone.

“Follow me, please” she said, as she led Twilight through her cottage and into her bedroom, where a bedside lamp provided illumination.

Twilight, following Fluttershy’s unspoken gesture, hopped up on the bed, and was amazed by how soft it was. Seconds later, Fluttershy was up with her, sitting very close. Fluttershy smiled at her and then kissed her tenderly, and Twilight couldn’t help but think of how soft her lips were, even as Fluttershy gently but insistently pushed her down onto her back, laying on top of her and deepening the kiss. Fluttershy let out a cute little moan as her tongue slipped into Twilight’s mouth, feeling a little thrill at how Twilight instantly submitted to her. Twilight’s forelimbs came up around Fluttershy’s body to hold her, slipping under her wings which were now unfolding upwards.

After a few minutes of making out like this, they broke the kiss, both of them panting lightly from arousal. Fluttershy had to admit: Twilight looked really cute right now, eyes half-open with a blush on her cheeks and her mouth open just a little bit. Fluttershy sat back, and a quick look down confirmed that both she and Twilight were turned on. She then crawled over to her bedside nightstand/drawer, opening the top-most drawer and rummaging around until she pulled out something. Twilight looked; it was a shiny metallic purple, cylindrical with a rounded tip on one end and a flat bottom with a little switch on the other. It wasn’t very long or big around.

“This is the one I usually start with” Fluttershy said. “Just lie back and let me introduce you to a whole new type of pleasure~…”

Fluttershy gripped the inactive vibrator with her hoof (unlike their hard-hoofed distant ancestors, modern ponies’ hooves were different and more flexible in structure, enabling them to grip some objects, though they lacked the opposable thumbs found in gryphons and dragons). She flicked the ‘ON’ switch, and it began buzzing and vibrating. She grinned as she then rubbed it against Twilight’s pussy. Twilight gasped, her hips lifting a bit off the bed in surprise, as the strange new sensation hit her. The buzzing, vibrating object that was slowly being slid up and down her slit caused a brand-new feeling that was both weird and really good. She moaned as Fluttershy pressed it against her a little harder.

Fluttershy smiled as she continued her ministrations, watching Twilight twitch and wriggle, hearing her squeaks and gasps and moans. She never once actually slid it into Twilight, simply rubbing it around and along her pussy, occasionally teasing her entrance. She pressed the vibrating head against Twilight’s clit, and Twilight squealed as her hips came up off the bed, trying to push back. After a few seconds she moved it down and continued what she’d been doing before, gradually picking up the pace. Twilight’s vocalizations slowly increased in pitch and volume over the next minute or so, the coiled-spring tension of an incoming orgasm building inside her. Sensing that she was close to the edge, Fluttershy positioned the vibrator so it was parallel to Twilight’s slit, and then pressed it inward, providing stimulation to the entire thing from bottom to clit.

Twilight cried out as her orgasm hit her, pulses of pleasure being magnified slightly by the vibrator pressed against her pussy. Fluttershy began slowly running the vibrator up and down, stimulating different parts as Twilight’s climax continued. She pulled away when Twilight’s climax finally faded, leaving the unicorn panting for breath, splayed out on the bed. After 30 seconds or so of recovery, she propped herself up on her elbows, staring in wonder at the vibrator Fluttershy still held, which was now turned off.

“That thing…” she panted “is amazing…”

Fluttershy giggled. “We’ve still got lots more to do, Twilight” she said.

“Should I cast the spell now?”

“Um… Sure.”

Twilight sat up, and focused her magic, concentrating on Fluttershy. Fluttershy gasped as she felt Twilight’s magical energy envelop her, focusing in between her legs. After a few seconds, there was a burst of magenta light. When it faded, Fluttershy looked down to find a penis standing erect from just above her clitoris. She touched it, and then shuddered from the feeling. Twilight took a good look; it was slightly toward the small end of ‘average’, having the girth of Rarity’s and the length of Applejack’s. But she knew that it would still feel nice and big inside her.

Twilight sat up and moved forward as Fluttershy leaned back against the bed’s footboard. Twilight gave Fluttershy’s new dick a few light licks, earning some cute little squeaks from the other girl, and then began taking it into her mouth, and Fluttershy let out a shuddering moan from the new pleasure. Then Twilight started bobbing her head up and down, taking it in and out, and Fluttershy cried out and arched her back a little bit. Twilight let out her own little happy moan as she worked; from what she’d gathered in those magazines she’d read, some mares didn’t like giving blowjobs, seeing it as a chore or a means to an end to ‘get to the good stuff’, but she had quickly realized that she liked – nay, loved – doing this. It was like her whole mouth – lips, tongue, palate, all of it – became a rather sensitive erogenous zone whenever she was using it to pleasure one of her friends’ cocks, providing her with almost as much pleasure as she was giving to them. Part of her suspected that, provided the right circumstances, she could maybe get off just from doing this.

Fluttershy continued to moan and squeak as Twilight tended to her. Her wings were sticking straight out, twitching slightly, and she reached a trembling hoof out and softly petted Twilight’s head. Twilight made a happy little noise, almost a purr, in response, so Fluttershy kept doing that. After a little while, Twilight started deepening her motions, taking Fluttershy’s dick all the way in her mouth with each downward movement and creating a little suction with each upward one. Fluttershy’s pleasured noises became a little louder as the sensations intensified, both fore-hooves lightly grabbing hold of Twilight’s head. Fluttershy felt her release coming quickly, and when she looked down Twilight made eye contact with her, staring into her eyes as she kept up her work. That was enough to push Fluttershy over the edge.

Fluttershy cried out and thrusted her hips forward as she came, filling Twilight’s mouth with cum that she gladly swallowed. Twilight kept making little up-and-down motions as Fluttershy came, adding a little extra to the sensations. After a while, the orgasm came to its end, and Fluttershy’s body relaxed, leaning her weight against the footboard as she let out a sigh, a smile on her face. Twilight let go and moved up to snuggle against her, kissing her neck a few times. She then reached behind and started stroking Fluttershy’s wings, making the other girl moan and coo. Before long, thanks to the fast-recovery function of the spell, she was hard again.

“How would you like to do me?” Twilight asked.

“Um…” Fluttershy considered her options. “H-How about from behind?”

Twilight blushed and smiled, and then got into position, lifting her tail so Fluttershy could see everything. A few seconds later, she felt the growing anticipation as Fluttershy mounted her, and then the wonderful feeling of the beautiful pegasus’ cock sliding inside her. Both girls moaned from the sensations, Fluttershy gripping Twilight’s body with her forehooves and bucking her hips forward a little to get all the way in. Twilight let out a happy little coo as Fluttershy bottomed out inside her, grinding her hips back against Fluttershy’s and reveling in the moment.

“S-So… good…” Fluttershy squeaked out. “Twilight… It feels so wonderful inside you… Aah~… C-Can I start moving now?”

“Yes” Twilight gasped out. “Please.”

Fluttershy nodded, and then pulled almost all the way out before thrusting back in again, causing both of them to cry out. She started thrusting, enraptured by the new pleasures it gave her, and the noises Twilight was making were a lovely extra turn-on. Twilight started pushing her hips back a little each time Fluttershy moved in, deepening the thrusts and increasing the pleasure a bit for both of them. After a little while, Fluttershy changed the angle of her thrusts a little, enough to start hitting Twilight’s g-spot; Twilight squealed in pleasure, her fore-hooves gripping the sheets.

It wasn’t very long before Twilight’s climax approached, her cries and moans getting louder and higher. Fluttershy was on the verge too, so to hurry things along she bent over Twilight’s back, gripped that one part of her mane coming from the back of her skull, and pulled. Twilight let out a squeal that became a scream as her orgasm hit, with Fluttershy’s joining her a second later. The girls’ cries of pleasure blended together, Fluttershy still thrusting inward a little with each spurt, while Twilight’s lower body quivered and twitched beneath her. When it was finished, Twilight collapsed onto her front, while Fluttershy pulled out and then lay on top of her, nibbling her ear.

“One more?” Fluttershy asked after a few minutes of cuddling.

“What do you have in mind?” Twilight replied.

“I’ve got another special toy that I’d like to share with you” Fluttershy said as she crawled over to the edge of her bed, reaching into the still-open drawer. “Lie on your back, please” she said as she searched.

Twilight flipped over onto her back, enjoying the close view of Fluttershy’s soft yet toned ass moving back and forth ever so slightly as she searched. After a few more seconds, the pegasus emerged, holding three pink vibrators, one larger than the other two, all connected via cords to a single control remote; on the remote was a sliding switch with positions marked ‘OFF’ (which it was currently on), ‘LOW’, ‘MED’, ‘HI’, and ‘MAX’. Fluttershy let out a little giggle as she saw Twilight’s expression. Then she rubbed the two smaller ones against her pussy for several seconds, getting them wet.

“Twilight?” she said in a voice like honey. “Could you be a dear and cast, on me and on yourself, the rectal contaminant-purge spell that Rarity told me she used on you during her night with you?”

Twilight, curious as to where this would go (and remembering that anal sex had felt unexpectedly good…), nodded and focused her magic. She and Fluttershy both jumped a little from the ensuing tiny split-second tingle in their behinds.

“Thank you” Fluttershy said. “Now…” she turned around, sticking her butt and privates up and lifting her tail, looking over her shoulder at Twilight with a blush. “Could you please insert these two vibrators into me up to the dark-red stripes toward their bases? This bigger one in my pussy, and one of these two smaller ones in my butt?”

“S-Sure” Twilight replied, telekinetically grabbing hold of the two devices. She slowly, carefully inserted the one into Fluttershy’s vagina, hearing the pegasus let out little squeaking moans, and then a content sigh as it reached its target depth. Then the other one was just as carefully slid into her anus, and Fluttershy shivered a little from pleasure. When it was done, she turned around to face Twilight, a hungry look in her eyes as she grabbed the last remaining vibrator. She bade Twilight to open and raise her hind-legs, and then she pressed the tip against Twilight’s sphincter, slowly pushing it in.

Twilight gasped as it slid in. It wasn’t as big as Rarity’s cock had been, and it felt different from an actual, live penis as well. But it still felt that odd combination of ‘strange’ and ‘good’ that she liked quite a bit. She let out a soft moan as it slid in up to the dark-red stripe toward the base. Fluttershy gently lowered Twilight’s legs a little, and the unicorn whimpered as she felt the vibrator shift slightly inside her ass. Then, Fluttershy climbed atop her, their chests touching and Fluttershy’s dick brushing against Twilight’s pussy, still holding the control in her hoof. She gave Twilight a seductive grin, and then slid the switch up to ‘LOW’.

Twilight’s breath caught in her throat and her eyes went wide open as the vibrator began buzzing inside her butt. She moaned from the combination of that and from Fluttershy lightly grinding her hips against her, her dick sliding along Twilight’s slit as she panted from arousal and pleasure as the two vibrators inside her did their work. Then, Fluttershy lined her cock up with Twilight’s pussy and pushed in, sliding in all the way to the base. Before Twilight could fully get used to it all, Fluttershy then flicked the switch up to ‘MED’. Both girls moaned aloud as the vibrators inside them increased in strength, combining with the feelings of one being hilt-deep inside the other to form a wonderful blend of pleasure.

Fluttershy started moving, sliding in & out of Twilight at a moderate pace while the vibrators buzzed inside them, both girls moaning and gasping from the sensations. Fluttershy bent down to kiss Twilight, tongue slipping inside of Twilight’s mouth and coiling around her tongue, the girls’ moans muffled by each others’ mouths until they broke away. Fluttershy started thrusting a little harder and faster, and Twilight’s moans got a little louder. Somehow, she discovered, Fluttershy maintaining eye contact with her through all this made it feel a little more intense, and more… intimate. The look of lust, desire, and love in Fluttershy’s beautiful eyes made Twilight feel even warmer inside, and she found herself smiling even as moans and gasps continued to spill from her lips. Likewise, the same look in Twilight’s eyes drove Fluttershy onward, strengthening her desire to make Twilight feel good.

After a little while of this, Fluttershy grabbed the control and slid the switch up to ‘HI’. Both girls gasped and moaned from the increased sensation, and when Fluttershy thrusted all the way in, Twilight squealed from that and the high-power vibrator in her butt. Fluttershy continued thrusting like that, letting out her own adorable-sexy moans and squeaks that melded with Twilight’s. Before long, she could feel her climax beginning its approach.

So she flicked the switch to ‘MAX’.

Fluttershy let out a squealing moan from the powerful vibrations of pleasure inside both her holes, and then she started thrusting into Twilight as hard as she could. Between the full-power vibrator in her ass and Fluttershy’s sudden intensity, Twilight was letting out screams of pleasure, forelimbs holding onto Fluttershy for dear life as the normally-gentle mare fucked her senseless. Not that she was complaining about Fluttershy’s uncharacteristic ‘aggression’; on the contrary, combined with the vibrator it was driving her wild, and she could feel her climax approaching very quickly, and it was gonna be a big one.

It only took a matter of seconds before both girls came, and came hard. Twilight wrapped all four of her limbs around Fluttershy, feeling the intensity of the hot, thick ejaculations hitting deep inside her. Fluttershy’s eyes were rolled back, tongue hanging out a little, as her pussy came so hard that her hips jerked with each contraction, while at the same time experiencing a similarly powerful male orgasm. Her entire body jerked and quivered with each pulse of pleasure, made even better as Twilight’s vagina contracted and squeezed her cock, wringing more out of her, and all the while the frantically-buzzing vibrators in her pussy and ass provided even more strong stimulation, as the one in Twilight’s ass did for her.

As the powerful synchronized climaxes finally came down, Fluttershy reached out with a shaking hoof and slid the switch down to ‘OFF’, and then collapsed atop Twilight, both girls panting hard. Twilight used the last of her strength to gently telekinetically remove the vibrators from herself and Fluttershy, both girls moaning lightly from the feeling of them being pulled out. Fluttershy reached out a wingtip and flicked the off switch on her bedside lamp, plunging the room into comforting darkness. They were soon asleep, in each other’s embrace.

-----SCENE BREAK-----

Next Morning – 7:40 AM

“Twiiiliiight~” a beautiful voice called to her in a sing-song tone. “Wake up, sweetheart~.”

Twilight groaned, opening her eyes to see Fluttershy looking down on her with a loving smile. She blushed lightly as the events of last night came back to her, and then returned Fluttershy’s smile, which resulted in the pegasus giggling and then nuzzling her. That nuzzle then turned into a trail of kisses down Twilight’s neck.

“It’s a little early,” Fluttershy said softly, “but I want to get you awake and aroused. There’s one toy that I didn’t get to use on you last night, since we both fell asleep before I could.”

Fluttershy then lay on top of Twilight, front to front, and continued kissing and licking along her neck and ears. Twilight gave a little moan as she felt Fluttershy’s thigh rub between her legs, and before long she could feel that now-familiar heat building in her lower belly. After a little while, Twilight was ready, so Fluttershy got up and rummaged through her bedside drawer one more time, coming out with a new and odd-looking device.

Twilight stared, a blush on her cheeks, at the thing Fluttershy had pulled out. It was obviously a vibrator, the phallic shape and the cord connected from the base to a control remote. If she had to guess by looking, it was as long as Rarity’s and as big around as Applejack’s. It had a slight curve to it, and it had little bumps and ridges here and there. But there were three odd protrusions to it – one a hump along the top, and the other two odd-looking parts that stuck out from near the base.

“This one is my absolute favorite” Fluttershy cooed, holding it up almost reverently in both hooves and nuzzling it with her cheek. “It’s the biggest one I’ve got. It has four power settings, just like the ones we used last night, but it also has additional portions for simultaneous g-spot, clitoral, and anal stimulation. …You’d best brace yourself, Twilight, because I’m gonna make you cum so hard with this baby…”

Twilight gulped, feeling a combination of nervousness and anticipation, the latter quickly overshadowing the former. Fluttershy gave her a look that was somehow both cute and seductive as she made her way down near Twilight’s loins, holding her favorite toy at the ready. Positioning it just right, she began to push it in, the sight of Twilight’s pussy swallowing it up turning her on. Twilight moaned and shuddered lightly as the toy entered her, going deep, stretching and filling her. She felt the ‘hump’ go inside, and soon she could feel it pressing against her g-spot. Just before the toy stopped going in, she felt something soft and curved come into contact with her clitoris, sorta cradling it, while another protrusion poked into her anus. Seconds later, her vision was again filled with Fluttershy, standing over her, holding the control in one hoof as she smiled down at her.

“I can’t wait to see how good this’ll make you feel” she said in a low, sultry tone. “Here we go~.”

She slid the switch up to ‘Low’, and Twilight squeaked as it began to buzz. The main body of the thing, vibrating throughout a significant portion of her pussy, was pleasure enough. But add to that the vibrating pressure against her g-spot, the buzzing ‘peg’ in her anus, and the ‘cradle’ holding her clit, and even on a low-power setting it was enough to make her hooves curl. She whimpered and moaned and panted, eyes half-open and filled with the sight of Fluttershy’s blushing smile.

“I’m glad you like it” Fluttershy said with a little giggle, and then slid the switch up to ‘Medium’.

Twilight moaned, her lower body trembling as the vibrations increased. Fluttershy lay down atop her and gently caressed her cheek, giving her a few kisses on her neck. Twilight felt as Fluttershy entwined their tails together, and then licked and sucked a spot on Twilight’s neck that drew a throaty moan from her and made her pussy squeeze the vibrator a little tighter. After a little of this, Fluttershy raised her head to look down at Twilight’s face, almost nose-to-nose, and with a big happy smile on her face.

“You’re so pretty when you’re in ecstasy, Twilight” she said softly, kissing the tip of her nose and then moving back down to kiss the front of her throat. Then, she grabbed the remote and slid the switch up to ‘High’.

Twilight squealed, her hips bucking a little, the further-intensified stimulation of her pussy, ass, and clit driving her wild. She panted and moaned and muttered nonsensical syllables, her hips gyrating a little bit, grinding against Fluttershy, who now looked even happier as she watched Twilight’s face intently, looking into her eyes (whenever they weren’t squeezed shut, that is). Fluttershy kept the setting on ‘High’ for another half a minute or so, feeling Twilight’s body beginning to tense up, readying for release. She leaned in close.

“Now, Twilight…” she spoke in a near-whisper, “my adorable… sexy… beautiful mare…” And she leaned in close to whisper into Twilight’s ear, drawing out every syllable. “Cum for me~…”

And then she flicked the switch up to ‘Maximum’. Twilight’s back arched, eyes wide and breath caught in her throat, as the stimulation of her vagina, g-spot, clitoris, and anus quickly overwhelmed her. Within a manner of seconds, she came, screaming out in pleasure as her hips convulsed, a frighteningly, wonderfully powerful orgasm ripping through her, her cry of ecstasy stopping only long enough for her to draw in breath for more. Her eyes rolled back a little from it all, and she was aware of Fluttershy grinding against her a little through it all.

When it ended after what felt like an eternity, Fluttershy switched the vibrator to ‘Off’, and Twilight went totally limp beneath her. Twilight took in deep gasps for air, panting in an attempt to cool her body off, the ‘aftershocks’ of heat and pleasure still moving through her. She lay like that for quite a while, and when she finally worked up the strength to open her eyes, Fluttershy’s pretty blue-green eyes filled her vision, sparkling with mirth and happiness.

“You’re beautiful when you cum” Fluttershy said. She briefly sat up and back to gently pull the toy out of Twilight, earning a whimpered moan from the girl, before lying back down on top of her.

“In a little while,” the pegasus said, “we’ll get up. I’ll bathe you and then make us breakfast. But for now, I just want to snuggle you, to hold you tight and feel your warmth.”

Twilight nodded; that sounded like a very, very good idea right now. She wrapped her shaking forelimbs around Fluttershy, hugging and being hugged by her as they lay together in the exquisitely soft bed. Twilight nuzzled against Shy’s face, and she giggled and kissed Twilight on the forehead, the two of them letting out a content sigh. Tonight, Twilight would be having fun with Rainbow Dash. But right now, she was with - she belonged - to Fluttershy.

Author's Notes:

I unexpectedly had the day off, and have finished my ME3 playthrough, thus I had plenty of time to work this chapter out. There may be another multi-day wait for the next one, sadly.